Environmental and Resource Economics

, Volume 29, Issue 3, pp 257–283 | Cite as

Wealth, Natural Capital, and Sustainable Development: Contrasting Examples from Botswana and Namibia

  • Glenn-marie Lange
Article

Abstract

Theoretical work has demonstrated that sustainable development requires non-declining per capita wealth, where wealth is defined to include produced, natural, human and social capital. Several studies have attempted to measure total national wealth or changes in wealth, but have been seriously hampered by a lack of data, especially for natural and human capital. To address this problem, the UN and other international statistical agencies developed a standardized framework for environmental accounts, the System of integrated Environmental and Economic Accounts (SEEA). Using the newly available asset accounts for natural capital, national wealth accounts are constructed and used to assess the contrasting development paths of Botswana and Namibia. Botswana, with an explicit policy of reinvestment of resource rents, has roughly tripled per capita wealth and national income over the past two decades. Namibia, with no explicit policy to use natural capita to build wealth, has seen per capita wealth and income decline.

Botswana environmental accounting Namibia natural capital sustainable development wealth 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Arntzen, J.(2002),'Review of Agricultural Subsidies ',report to Ministry of Agriculture: Gaborone,Botswana.Google Scholar
  2. Arrow, K.J.,P.Dasgupta and K.-G. M€aler (2003),'Evaluating Projects and Assessing Sustainable Development in Imperfect Economies '.Environmental and Resource Economics 26,647-685.Google Scholar
  3. Australian Bureau of Statistics (2001),Australian System of National Accounts.Consolidated Balance Sheet.Canberra:ABS.Google Scholar
  4. Auty, R.M.(1993),Sustaining Development in Mineral Economies:The Resource Curse ThesisLondon: Routledge.Google Scholar
  5. Auty, R.M.and R. Mikesell (1998),Sustainable Development in Mineral Economies.Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  6. Bank of Botswana (2001a),Annual Report 2000.Gaborone,Botswana.Google Scholar
  7. Bank of Botswana (2001b),Unpublished Time Series of Net Foreign Financial Assets. Gaborone,Botswana.Google Scholar
  8. Bank of Namibia (1995),Annual Report 1994.Windhoek,Namibia: Bank of Namibia.Google Scholar
  9. Bank of Namibia (2001),Annual Report 2000.Windhoek,Namibia: Bank of Namibia.Google Scholar
  10. Barnes, J.I.(1999),'Economic Potential for Biodiversity Use in Southern Africa:Empirical Evidence'.Environment and Development Economics 4,215-220.Google Scholar
  11. Barnes, J.I.(2001),'Economic Returns and Allocation of Resources in the Wildlife Sector of Botswana'.South African Journal of Wildlife Research 31,141-153.Google Scholar
  12. Barnes, J.I.,J. Cannon and K. Morrison (2001),'Economic Returns to Selected Land Uses in Ngamiland,Botswana ',Report to Conservation International,Washington,DC.Google Scholar
  13. Barnes, J.and P. Lindeque (2003),'A Study to Value the Natural Asset Portfolio of the Ministry of Environment and Tourism (MET):Wildlife Stocks,Tourism Land,and Forests ',unpublished report to the Directorate of Environmental Affairs,Ministry of Tourism and Environment. Windhoek,Namibia.Google Scholar
  14. Bell, C.,S. Devarajan and H. Gersbach (2003),'The Long-Run Economic Impact of AIDS: Theory and an Application to South Africa '.World Bank paper (unpublished).Washington,DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  15. BIDPA (Botswana Institute for Development Policy Analysis)(2000),'Macroeconomic Impacts of the HIV/AIDS Epidemic in Botswana'.Gaborone,Botswana: BIDPA.Google Scholar
  16. Central Bureau of Statistics (1999),National Accounts 1998.Windhoek,Namibia: National Planning Commission.Google Scholar
  17. Central Bureau of Statistics (2001),National Accounts 2000.Windhoek,Namibia: National Planning Commission.Google Scholar
  18. Central Bureau of Statistics (2003),Population Census 2001.Windhoek,Namibia: National Planning Commission.Google Scholar
  19. Central Statistics Office (1998),'National Accounts Statistics-Capital Stock.'Stats Brief No. 98/7,June,Gaborone,Botswana: CSO.Google Scholar
  20. Central Statistics Office (2000),Environment Statistics.Gaborone,Botswana: CSO.Google Scholar
  21. Central Statistics Office (2003),Population Census 2001,Gaborone,Botswana: CSO.Google Scholar
  22. Central Statistics Office (annual),Statistical Bulletin.Gaborone,Botswana: CSO.Google Scholar
  23. Dasgupta,P.(2001).Human Well-Being and the Natural Environment.Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  24. Dasgupta, P.(2002),'Economic Development, Environmental Degradation and the Persistence of Deprivation in Poor Countries '.Paper presented at the World Bank,May.Google Scholar
  25. Dasgupta, P.and K. M € aler (2000),'Net National Product,Wealth,and Social Well-Being'. Environment and Development Economics 5,69-94.Google Scholar
  26. Dasgupta, P.and K. M € aler (2001),'Wealth as a Criterion for Sustainable Development '.Beijer Institute Discussion Paper Series No.140.Google Scholar
  27. Department of Mines (annual),Annual Report.Gaborone,Botswana:Ministry of Mines, Energy and Water Resources.Google Scholar
  28. Food and Agriculture Organization (2002),'AIDS-a Threat to Rural Africa:Fact Sheet '. Rome: FAO.Google Scholar
  29. Green, J.,P. Akatu, M. Mfunwa, T. Poddar and S. Ding (2002),'Botswana:Selected Issues and Statistical Appendix '.IMF Country Report No.02/243Google Scholar
  30. Gylfason, T.(1999),'Exports,Inflation and Growth '.World Development 27(6),1031-1057.Google Scholar
  31. Haacker, M.(2002),'The Economic Consequences of HIV/AIDS in Southern Africa '.IMF Working Paper,African Department WP/02/38.Google Scholar
  32. Hamilton, K.(2002),'Sustainable per Capita Welfare with Growing Population:Theory and Measurement '.Paper presented at the Second World Congress of Environmental and Resource Economists,Monterey,California,23-27 June.Google Scholar
  33. Hamilton, K.and M. Clemmens (1999),'Genuine Savings Rates in Developing Countries '.World Bank Economic Review 13(2),336-356.Google Scholar
  34. Hartwick, J.(1977),'Intergenerational Equity and the Investing of Rents from Exhaustible Resources '.American Economic Review 67(5),972-974.Google Scholar
  35. Heal, G.and B. Kristrom (2001)'National Income and the Environment,'draft of a chapter forthcoming in T. Tietenberg and H.Folmer,eds.,International Yearbook of Environmental and Resource Economics.Cheltenham,UK: Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
  36. International Monetary Fund (2001),International Financial Statistics Yearbook.Washington, DC: IMF.Google Scholar
  37. Kunte, A.,K. Hamilton, J. Dixon and M. Clemens (1998),'Estimating National Wealth: Methodology and Results '.Environment Department Papers,Environmental Economics Series No.57,Washington,DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  38. Lange, G.(2001),'The Contribution of Minerals to Sustainable Development in Botswana:Natural Resource Accounts for Minerals.'Final Report to the Botswana Natural Resource Accounting Programme.Gaborone,Botswana.Google Scholar
  39. Lange, G.(2002)'Alternative Measures of the Value of Natural Capital in Constant Prices'.Paper presented at the workshop,Putting Theory to Work:The Measurement of Genuine Wealth,25-26 May 2002,Stanford University.Google Scholar
  40. Lange, G.(2003a),'Fisheries Accounts:Managing a Recovering Fishery ',in G.Lange,R.Google Scholar
  41. Hassan and K. Hamilton,eds.,Environmental Accounting in Action:Case Studies from Southern Africa.Cheltenham,UK: Edward Elgar Publishers.Google Scholar
  42. Lange, G.(2003b)'The Value of Namibia 's Commercial Fisheries.'Research Discussion Paper Number 55.Ministry of Environment and Tourism,Directorate of Environmental Affairs,Windhoek,Namibia,February 2003.Google Scholar
  43. Lange, G.,J.I. Barnes and J.Motinga (1998),'Cattle Numbers,Herd Productivity,and Land Degradation in Namibia.'Development Southern Africa 15(4),555-572.Google Scholar
  44. Lange, G.,R. Hassan and K. Hamilton (2003),Environmental Accounting in Action:Case Studies from Southern Africa.Cheltenham,UK: Edward Elgar Publishers.Google Scholar
  45. Lange, G.and M. Wright (2004),'Sustainable Development in Mineral Economies:The Example of Botswana.'Environment and Development Economics 9(4),485-505.Google Scholar
  46. M € aler, K.(1991),'National Accounts and Environmental Resources '.Environmental and Resource Economics 1(1),1-15.Google Scholar
  47. Marine Research and Information Centre (2001),Unpublished Database of Fish Stocks, Catch and TAC,MRIC,Swakopmund,Namibia.Google Scholar
  48. Office of National Statistics (2003)'Asset Value of Petroleum and Natural Gas Reserves ', available from website of the UK 's ONS:www.statistics.gov.uk.Google Scholar
  49. Pearce, D.and G. Atkinson (1993),'Capital Theory and the Measurement of Sustainable Development:An Indicator of Weak Sustainability'.Ecological Economics 8,103-108.Google Scholar
  50. Pezzey, J.(1992),'Sustainable Development Concepts:An Economic Analysis '.World Bank Environment Paper No.2.Google Scholar
  51. Ryan, L.,R. Thomson and A. Sincock (2003),'Accounting for Subsoil Assets in the National Accounts.'Paper presented at the London Group Meeting,Rome,5-7 November.Google Scholar
  52. Sachs, J.and A. Warner (2001),'The Curse of Natural Resources '.European Economic Review 45,827-838.Google Scholar
  53. Sala-i-Martin, X.and A. Subramaniam (2003),'Addressing the Natural Resource Curse:An Illustration from Nigeria.'IMF Working Paper No 03/139.Washington,DC: IMF.Google Scholar
  54. Sherbourne, R.(2003),'A Rich Man 's Hobby,'Institute for Public Policy Research Opinion Paper Number 11.Windhoek,Namibia: IPPR.Google Scholar
  55. Smith, R.and C. Simard (2001),'A Proposed Approach to Sustainable Development Indicators Based on Capital.'Paper presented by Statistics Canada at the National Conference of Sustainable Development Indicators,March 27,Ottawa,Canada.Google Scholar
  56. Solow, R.(1974),'Intergenerational Equity and Exhaustible Resources '.Review of Economic Studies 41,29-45.Google Scholar
  57. Solow, R.(1986),'On the Intergenerational Allocation of Natural Resources'.Scandinavian Journal of Economics 88,141-149.Google Scholar
  58. Solow, R.(2003)'Population Estimates and Projections:Data Online'.Retrieved from http:// www.un.org/esa/population/unpop.htm in January 2004.Google Scholar
  59. United Nations,European Commission,International Monetary Fund,Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development,and World Bank (1993)System of National Accounts.New York: UN.Google Scholar
  60. United Nations,European Commission,International Monetary Fund,Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development,and World Bank (2003)Integrated Environmental and Economic Accounting 2003.New York: UN.Available on the UN website: www:un:orgGoogle Scholar
  61. World Bank (1995),Namibia Public Expenditure Review.Washington,DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  62. World Bank (1997),'Expanding the Measure of Wealth:Indicators of Sustainable Development '.ESD Studies and Monographs Series No.17,Washington,DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  63. World Bank (2001),Namibia:Selected Development Impact of HIV/AIDS.Washington,DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  64. World Bank (2002),World Development Report.Washington,DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  65. World Bank (2003),World Development Indicators.EdStat online database available at www:worldbank:orgGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Glenn-marie Lange
    • 1
  1. 1.Center for Economy, Environment and SocietyThe Earth Institute at Columbia UniversityNew York

Personalised recommendations