Presumed Consent: A Potential Tool for Countries Experiencing an Organ Donation Crisis
- 17 Downloads
There is currently an inadequate supply of allografts to meet the number of transplant candidates worldwide. A number of controversial policies, including implementation of a presumed consent organ donation system, have been considered to rectify the organ donation crisis.
A secondary retrospective data analysis aimed to assess the impact of switching to a presumed consent organ donation model on organ donation rates.
Deceased organ donation rates were compared before and after countries adopted presumed consent.
Six countries met entry criteria. All six countries had an increase in liver donation rates, while 4 out of the six countries had an increase in kidney donation rates. The overall mean (± SD) liver donation rate was 3.23 (± 0.97) per million population (pmp) before the transition and 6.46 (± 1.81) pmp after the transition (p < 0.0001). The overall mean (± SD) kidney donation rate was 17.94 (± 3.34) pmp before the transition and 26.58 (± 4.23) pmp after the transition (p < 0.0001). The percentage increase in liver and kidney donation rates varied among countries, ranging from 28 to 1186%.
The transition from explicit to presumed consent was associated with a significant increase in liver donation rates in all countries that met our criteria, while the effect on kidney donation rates was partially realized. Although presumed consent alone is unlikely to explain the increase in donation rates, the adoption of such a policy may prove to be a worthwhile risk for countries experiencing consistently low organ donation rates.
KeywordsPresumed consent Liver transplantation Kidney transplantation Organ procurement Waiting lists
World Health Organization
Gross domestic product
Intensive care unit
- R. Catholic
Per million population
International Registry in Organ Donation and Transplantation
Donation after cardiac death
United Arab Emirates
Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development
Institutional review board
Central Intelligence Agency
United Nations Development Program
- Slovak R
Per million population
Male or female
Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network
Global Observatory on Donation and Transplantation
SS and SSS were involved in study concept and design, analysis and interpretation of data; SSS and MA contributed to acquisition of data; SS, SSS and MA were involved in drafting of the manuscript; SS and GC contributed to critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content; SSS contributed to statistical analysis; SS was involved in study supervision.
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The authors of this manuscript have no conflicts of interest to disclose.
- 1.Sheldon T. Dutch to start presumed consent for organ donation in 2020. BMJ. 2018;16:360.Google Scholar
- 3.English V. Is presumed consent the answer to organ shortages? Yes. BMJ. 2007;26:334.Google Scholar
- 10.Crespo G, Trota N, Londoño MC, Mauro E, Baliellas C, Castells L, Castellote J, Tort J, Forns X, Navasa M. The efficacy of direct anti-HCV drugs improves early post-liver transplant survival and induces significant changes in wait-list composition. J Hepatol. 2018 in press.Google Scholar
- 30.World Health Organization guiding principles on human cell, tissue, and organ transplantation. 2008;1:1.Google Scholar
- 31.International Registry of Organ Donation and Transplantation. http://www.irodat.org/. Accessed March 25, 2018.
- 32.Law 26,066 Transfer of Organ and Tissues, Argentina. http://servicios.infoleg.gob.ar/infolegInternet/anexos/110000-114999/112375/norma.htm. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 34.Hughes JA. Rethinking U.S. organ procurement policy. Vanderbilt J Transnatl Law. 2009;42:351–379.Google Scholar
- 35.Yordanova T. Ways to apply behavioral economics into organ donation and transplant system in Bulgaria. Manag Sustain Dev. 2014;45:52–58.Google Scholar
- 37.Willsher K. France introduces opt-out policy on organ donation. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/jan/02/france-organ-donation-law. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 40.Italy: provisions for organ harvesting and transplantation of organs and tissues, implementation of the requirements related to the declaration of citizens’ wishes on organ donation for transplantation purposes. http://www.trovanorme.salute.gov.it/norme/dettaglioAtto?id=17738&articolo=3. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 42.Laurenco JS, Ciriolo E, Almeida SR, Troussard X. Behavioral insights applied to policy. Eur Rep. 2016;1:1–51.Google Scholar
- 43.Reilly K. Dutch bill would make everyone an organ donor unless they opt out. http://time.com/4490016/netherlands-organ-donation-bill/. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 44.Norway Law No. 6 of 9 February 1973. http://www.lovdata.no/cgi-wift/wiftldles?doc¼/usr/www/lovdata/all/nl-19730209-006.html&emne¼transplantasjonslov*&&. Accessed April 2, 2018.
- 46.New Peru law permits removal of organs for transplant without kin’s consent. http://articles.latimes.com/1987-11-01/news/mn-17716_1_organ-removal. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 47.The need for a soft opt-out plus approach to the proposed change in organ donor consent in Ireland. https://www.cfireland.ie/pdf/Joint_Submission_on_Organ_Donor_Consent.pdf. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 48.Uruguay: modification of law 14.005 on organs and tissues. Global Observatory on Donation and Transplantation. http://www.transplant-observatory.org/download/ley-no-17-668-trasplantes-de-organos-y-tejidos-modificacion-de-la-ley-no-14-005-law-on-organs-and-tissues-2003-uruguay/. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 49.Cruz PD. The Swedish law on transplantation. Comp Healthc Law. 2013;1:568.Google Scholar
- 50.Ministry of foreign affairs of Denmark. http://um.dk/en/. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 51.Moy C. Improving Australia’s organ donation rates. https://ama.com.au/ausmed/improving-australia%E2%80%99s-organ-donation-rates. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 53.Living donor liver transplantation: donor manual 2017. http://www.uhn.ca/MOT/Living_Donor_Program/Pages/living_liver_donor.aspx. Accessed February 20, 2017.
- 54.Reed GA. Organ donation and transplants in Cuba: promising results, challenges ahead. MEDICC Rev. 2016;18:11–14.Google Scholar
- 55.Li J, Nikolka T. The effect of presumed consent defaults on organ donation. CESifo DICE Report 2016; 4.Google Scholar
- 56.Organ donation in Hong Kong. Res Brief. 2016; 5:15–16.Google Scholar
- 57.Organ Donation - Introducing an opt-out system of consent, Ireland 2014. http://health.gov.ie/blog/policy/o/introducing-an-opt-out-system-of-consent-for-organ-donation/. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 58.National organization for organ and tissue donation and transplantation Lebanese legislation historical overview. https://www.nodlb.org/en/support-my-decision/lebanese-legistlation/historical-overview. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 60.Puerto Rico (government): Act No.296 Section 27. http://www.oslpr.org/download/en/2011/A-0026-2011.pdf. Accessed April 2, 2018.
- 61.Etheredge H, Penn C, Watermeyer J. Opt-in or opt-out to increase organ donation in South Africa? Appraising proposed strategies using an empirical ethics analysis. Dev World Bioethics. 2017;00:1–7.Google Scholar
- 62.Hsiao A. Most misinformed on organ donation: data. http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiwan/archives/2013/08/06/2003569051. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 63.Organ procurement and transplantation network policies. https://optn.transplant.hrsa.gov/governance/policies/. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 64.Need to improve the identification of potential organ donors. http://stm.fi/en/artikkeli/-/asset_publisher/need-to-improve-the-identification-of-potential-organ-donors. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 65.Myerson B. Should families have the final say on organ donation? http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/the-question/should-families-have-the-final-say-on-organ-donation-20111209-1onde.html. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 66.Venezuela enforces law on default organ donation. http://venezuela.um.dk/en/about-venezuela/news/newsdisplaypage/?newsid=dd59c17c-c27d-4bec-bc49-72b10c52d534. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 67.Honduras: law for human organ and tissue donation and transplantation. http://www.transplant-observatory.org/download/ley-de-trasplante-y-extraccion-de-organos-y-tejidos-humanos-1982-law-for-human-organ-and-tissue-donation-and-transplantation-honduras/. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 68.Dutch OK law: everyone is organ donor unless they opt out. Associated Press. http://www.businessinsider.com/ap-dutch-ok-law-everyone-is-organ-donor-unless-they-opt-out-2018-2. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 70.Bengali, Mostaghim. Kidney for sale’: Iran has a legal market for the organs, but the system doesn’t always work. http://www.latimes.com/world/middleeast/la-fg-iran-kidney-20171015-story.html. Accessed April 2, 2018.
- 72.Cacciatore R. Costa Rica organ trafficking trial links illicit transplant network to Ukraine. http://qcostarica.com/costa-rica-organ-trafficking-trial-links-illicit-transplant-network-to-ukraine/0/. Accessed April 2, 2018.
- 73.United Nations Office on Drugs and Crimes. Global Report on Trafficking in Persons. 2017.Google Scholar
- 74.Central intelligence agency world factbook. https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/fields/2103.html. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 75.Baller S, Dutta S, Lanvin B. The global information technology report 2016. http://www3.weforum.org/docs/GITR2016/WEF_GITR_Full_Report.pdf. Accessed February 20, 2018.
- 78.Gavriluta C. Theoretical and practical premises in building up the health policies in the field of transplant. Transylvanian Review of Administrative Sciences 2013; S50.Google Scholar