Immigrant Therapists’ Unresolved Identity Problems and Countertransference
Article
- 217 Downloads
- 2 Citations
Abstract
The difficult task of identify formation is greatly complicated by immigration in childhood or adolescence. This paper shows how the unresolved identity problems stemming from their immigration to Israel in childhood or early adolescence of three young therapists, two from Ethiopia and one from Russia, affected their countertransference in their treatment of their adolescent clients from their own countries of origin. The three examples are based on art works produced by the therapists and their clients in the framework of workshops on the integration of art therapy techniques into verbally based diagnosis and treatment. The paper highlights the need to help immigrant therapists recognize their own identity conflicts and resulting countertransference, as well as the identity issues of their immigrant clients.
Keywords
immigrants countertransference art therapyPreview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
- Arlow, Y. M. 1985Some technical problems of countertransferencePsychoanalytic Quarterly54164174PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ben-Ezer, G. 1992“Yegan Mevralht”: Migration and Absorption of Ethiopian Jews in IsraelMass PressJerusalem[Hebrew]Google Scholar
- Berger, R. 1999Immigrants from the former Soviet Union: characteristics, needs and treatment principlesRabin, C. eds. Being Different in Israel: Ethnicity, Gender and TherapyRamot Tel Aviv UniversityTel Aviv97119[Hebrew]Google Scholar
- Berger, R. 2002Adolescent immigrants: Advantages and principles of group workKasan, L.Lev-Wiesel, R. eds. Group Work with Multicultural SocietyCherikoverTel-Aviv117128[Hebrew]Google Scholar
- Berry, J. W., Kim, V., Munde, T. 1987Comparative studies of acculturation stressInternational Migration Review21491511Google Scholar
- Blanck, G., Blanck, R. 1979Ego psychology: Psychoanalytic developmental PsychologyColombbia University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
- Blos, P. 1979The Adolescent PassageInternational Universities PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
- Blos, P. 1967The Second Individuation Process of AdolescenceThe Psychoanalytic Study of the Child2216287PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Buck, D., Provancher, M. 1972Magazine picture collage as an evaluation techniqueAmerican Journal of Occupational Therapy263639PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Dotan, T. 1998Adolescence in transition: Ethiopian immigrant youth in IsraelGolan, M.Duacker-Vajunsky, B.Yaakov, M.Nodelman, A. eds. HaKesher el hakesher: Family, Community and Boarding School IssuesMinistry of Education, Culture and Sport, haMinhal le Hinuch Hityachvuti v’ Aliyat haNoarState of Israel3148[Hebrew]Google Scholar
- Erickson, E. H. 1968Identity, Youth and CrisisNortonNew YorkGoogle Scholar
- Freud, S. (1910) Future prospects of psychoanalytic psychotherapy. In J. Strachey (Ed.), (1959). The standard edition of the complete works of Sigmund Freud (Vol. 11, pp. 139–151). London: Hogarth.Google Scholar
- Hammer, E. 1958The Clinical Application of Projective DrawingsCharles. C. ThomasSpringfieldGoogle Scholar
- Hays, R. E., Lyons, S. J. 1981The bridge drawing: A projective technique for assessment in art therapyThe Arts in Psychotherapy8207217CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Hillel, N., Haiman, A. 1999Group Therapy for Ethiopian ImmigrantsJoint IsraelJerusalem[Hebrew]Google Scholar
- Horowitz, T. R. (1989). The Soviet man in an open society: An overview. In T. R. Horowitz (Ed.), The Soviet man in an open society (pp. 5–18) Lanham, MD.Google Scholar
- Izikovitz, R. & Back R. (1991). Guiding models in education of immigrant children in Israel. Studies in Education, 33–50.Google Scholar
- Lerner, C., Ross, G. 1977The magazine picture collageAmerican Journal of Occupational Therapy31156161PubMedGoogle Scholar
- McNiff, S. 1997Art therapy: A spectrum of partnershipsThe arts in Psychotherapy243744CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- McNiff, S. 1989Depth Psychology of ArtCharles C. ThomasSpringfieldGoogle Scholar
- Mirsky, J. 1990Individuation through immigration to Israel: Psychotherapy with immigrant adolescentsJournal of Contemporary Psychotherapy204761CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Mirsky, J., Prawer, L. 1992To Immigrate as an Adolescent: Immigrant Youth from the Former Soviet Union in IsraelElka & the Van Leer InstituteJerusalem[Hebrew]Google Scholar
- Oaklander, V. 1997The Therapeutic process with children and adolescentsGestalt Review1292317Google Scholar
- Ogden, T. H. 1989The Primitive Edge of ExperienceJason AronsonNew YorkGoogle Scholar
- Reich, A. 1960Further remarks on countertransferenceInternational Journal of Psychoanalysis41389395PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sere, M. (2000) SRQ-A Culturally Sensitive Psychiatric Screening Instrument for Ethiopian immigrants in Israel. M.A. Thesis, School of Social Work, Bar Ilan University [Hebrew].Google Scholar
- Shabtai, M. 1995The experience of Ethiopian jewish soldiers in the Israeli army: The process of identity formation in the military contextIsrael Social Science Research106980[Hebrew]Google Scholar
- Shabtai, M. 1996“The melting pot works externally” -Dynamics of identification with Ethiopian culture: a glance at the military serviceHevrah v’ Revacha16199216[Hebrew]Google Scholar
- Winnicott, D. W. 1953Transitional objects and transitional phenomena: A study of the first “not me” positionInternational Journal of Psychoanalysis348997PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yaron, U. 1985Identity crisis and impaired self-image among Ethiopian immigrant youthAlim, Youth Aliya1919[Hebrew]Google Scholar
- Yedidia, T. (1993). Developing diagnostic tools from expressive therapy for diagnosing youth in distress. Doctoral Dissertation. Cincinnati, Ohio: The Union Institute UniversityGoogle Scholar
- Yerushalmi, H., Yedidia, T. 1997The family albumAmerican Journal of Family Therapy25261269Google Scholar
- Young, A. 1976Internalizing and externalizing medical belief systemsAn Ethiopian example. Social Science and Medicine10147156CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Copyright information
© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2005