Sustainable Consumption Research as Democratic Expertise Article DOI:
Cite this article as: Cohen, M.J. J Consum Policy (2006) 29: 67. doi:10.1007/s10603-005-6050-1 Abstract
Academic proponents of sustainable consumption have marshaled considerable evidence over the past decade to support calls for more efficacious lifeways among residents of the world’s developed countries. Policymakers continue, however, to resist these recommendations because sustainable consumption runs counter to dominant tenets of neo-liberal economics and conventional political objectives. Unless investigators in the field can identify a cadre of clients that is interested in forming tacit partnerships, the concept of sustainable consumption is likely to remain little more than a prospective pursuit. This article suggests that there are some nascent indications that these kinds of alliances are developing. For sustainable consumption to take root in the policy sphere, it will be necessary to more actively foster these relationships and to cast this form of knowledge as a form of democratic counterexpertise that challenges elite economic and political institutions that regularly appropriate and deploy consumer science to advance their own interests.
References Arkenstette, M. 2005 Reorientation in consumer policy: Challenges and prospects from the perspective of practical consumer advice work Journal of Consumer Policy 28 361 370 CrossRef Google Scholar Berman, R. 2004Anti-Americanism in Europe: A cultural problem Hoover Institution Press Stanford, CA Google Scholar Blickstein, S., Hanson, S. 2001 Critical mass: Forging a politics of sustainable mobility in the information age Transportation 28 347 362 CrossRef Google Scholar Bocking, S. 1997Ecologists and environmental politics: A history of contemporary ecology Yale University New Haven Google Scholar Bordwell, M. 2002 Jamming culture: Adbusters’ hip media campaign against consumerism Princen, T. Maniates, M. Conca, K. eds. Confronting consumption MIT Press Cambridge 237 253 Google Scholar
Cohen, M. (2005a). Consumer credit, household financial management, and sustainable consumption.
International Journal of Consumer Studies, (in press). Cohen, M. 2005b Sustainable consumption American style: Nutrition education, active living, and financial literacy International Journal of Sustainable Development & World Ecology 12 407 418 Google Scholar
Cohen, M. (2006). A social problems framework for the critical appraisal of automobility and sustainable systems innovation.
Mobilities, 1(1), (in press). Cohen, M., Comrov, A., Hofner, B. 2005 The new politics of consumption: Promoting sustainability in the American marketplace Sustainability: Science, Practice, & Policy 1 58 76 Google Scholar Cohen, M., Howard, J. 2006 Success and its price: The institutionalization and political relevance of industrial ecology Journal of Industrial Ecology 10 (79–88) CrossRef Google Scholar Cohen, M. Murphy, J. eds. 2001Exploring sustainable consumption: Environmental policy and the social sciences Elsevier New York Google Scholar Fabbrini, S. 2002 The domestic sources of European anti-Americanism Government & Opposition 37 3 14 CrossRef Google Scholar Fischer, F. 1990Technocracy and the politics of expertise Sage Newbury Park, CA Google Scholar Fuchs, D., Lorek, S. 2005 Sustainable consumption governance: A history of promises and failures Journal of Consumer Policy 28 361 370 CrossRef Google Scholar Furlough, E., Strikwerda, C. 1999Consumers against capitalism? Consumer cooperation in Europe, America, and Japan Rowman and Littlefield Lanham, MD 1840 1990 Google Scholar Gatersleben, B. 2001 Sustainable household consumption and quality of life: The acceptability of sustainable consumption patterns and consumer policy strategies International Journal of Environment & Pollution 15 200 216 Google Scholar Golley, F. 1993A history of the ecosystem concept in ecology: More than the sum of its parts Yale University Press New Haven, CT Google Scholar Hagen, J. 1992An entangled bank: The origins of ecosystem ecology Rutgers University Press New Brunswick, NJ Google Scholar Hilton, M. 2003Consumerism in twentieth-century Britain: The search for a historical movement Cambridge University Press New York Google Scholar Hoppe, R. 2005 Rethinking the science-policy nexus: From knowledge utilization and science technology studies to types of boundary arrangements Poiesis & Praxis 3 199 215 CrossRef Google Scholar Jackson, T. 2005 Live better by consuming less? Is there a “double-dividend” in sustainable consumption? Journal of Industrial Ecology 9 19 36 Google Scholar Johansson, J. 2004 In your face: How American marketing excess fuels anti-Americanism Prentice-Hall Upper Saddle River, NJ Google Scholar Kozinets, R., Handelman, J. 2004 Adversaries of consumption: Consumer movements, activism, and ideology Journal of Consumer Research 31 691 704 Google Scholar Littler, J. 2005 Beyond the boycott: Anti-consumerism, cultural change, and the limits of reflexivity Cultural Studies 19 227 252 Google Scholar Maniates, M. 2002 In search of consumptive resistance? The voluntary simplicity movement Princen, T. Maniates, M. Conca, K. eds. Confronting consumption MIT Press Cambridge 199 235 Google Scholar Martens, S., Spaargaren, G. 2005 The politics of sustainable consumption: The case of the Netherlands Sustainability: Science, Practice, & Policy 1 29 42 Google Scholar Mayer, R. 1989The consumer movement: Guardians of the marketplace Twyane Publishers Boston Google Scholar Micheletti, M. 2003Political virtue and shopping: Individuals, consumerism and collective action Palgrave Macmillan New York Google Scholar Micheletti, M. Follesdal, A. Stolle, D. eds. 2004Politics, products, and markets: Exploring political consumerism past and present Transaction Publishers New Brunswick, NJ Google Scholar
Müller, E. (2005).
Sustainable consumption: The need for a strong consumer policy. Paper presented at the Sixth Open Meeting of the Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change Research Community, University of Bonn, 9–13 October 2005. Bonn/Berlin: Unpublished Manuscript. Myers, N. 1997 Consumption: Challenge to sustainable development Science 276 53 55 CrossRef Google Scholar National Research Council 1986Population growth and economic development: Policy questions National Academies Press Washington, DC Google Scholar Princen, T. Maniates, M. Conca, K. eds. 2002Confronting consumption MIT Press Cambridge, MA Google Scholar Reisch, L. 2001 Time and wealth: The role of time and temporalities for sustainable patterns of consumption Time & Society 10 367 385 Google Scholar Reisch, L. 2004 Principles and visions of a new consumer policy Journal of Consumer Policy 27 1 42 CrossRef Google Scholar Rifkin, J. 2004The European dream: How Europe’s vision of the future is quietly eclipsing the American dream Tarcher New York Google Scholar Royal Society & National Academy of Sciences 1992Joint statement: Population growth, resource consumption and a sustainable world National Academy of Sciences Washington, DC Google Scholar Rumbo, J. 2002 Consumer resistance in a world of advertising clutter: The case of Adbusters Psychology & Marketing 19 127 148 CrossRef Google Scholar Sanches, S. 2005 Sustainable consumption à la francaise? Conventional, innovative, and alternative approaches to sustainability and consumption in France Sustainability: Science, Practice, & Policy 1 43 57 Google Scholar Sanne, C. 2005 The consumption of our discontent Business Strategy & the Environment 14 315 323 Google Scholar Sarewitz, D. 1996Frontiers of illusion: Science, technology, and the politics of progress Temple University Press Philadelphia Google Scholar Schor, J. 2004Born to buy: The commercialized child and the new consumer culture Scribner New York Google Scholar Schor, J. 2005 Sustainable consumption and worktime reduction Journal of Industrial Ecology 9 37 50 Google Scholar Shove, E. 2003Comfort, cleanliness, and convenience: The social organization of normality Berg New York Google Scholar Schwartz, B. 2004The paradox of choice: Why more is less Harper Collins New York Google Scholar Southerton, D. Chappells, H. Vliet, B. eds. 2005Sustainable consumption: The implications of changing infrastructures of provision Edward Elgar Northhampton, MA Google Scholar Spaargaren, G., Vliet, B. 2000 Lifestyles, consumption, and the environment: The␣ecological modernisation of domestic consumption Environmental Politics 9 50 76 Google Scholar Spangenberg, J. 2004 A great step further, but still more to go Environment 46 42 45 Google Scholar Stolle, D., Hooghe, M., Micheletti, M. 2005 Politics in the supermarket: Political consumerism as a form of political participation International Political Science Review 26 245 269 Google Scholar Sustainable Development Commission (United Kingdom) 2004Shows promise, but must try harder Sustainable Development Commission London Google Scholar Vigar, G. 2002The politics of mobility: Transport, the environment, and public policy Spon New York Google Scholar Woodhouse, E., Nieusma, D. 1997 When expert advice works, and when it does not IEEE Technology & Society Magazine 16 23 29 Google Scholar Woodhouse, E., Nieusma, D. 2001 Democratic expertise: Integrating knowledge, power, and participation Hisschemöller, M. Hoppe, R. Dunn, W. Ravetz, J. eds. Knowledge, power, and participation in environmental policy analysis Transaction Publishers New Brunswick, NJ 73 96 Google Scholar Worster, D. 1994Nature’s economy: A history of ecological ideas,2 Cambridge University Press New York Google Scholar