Climatic Change

, Volume 85, Issue 1–2, pp 33–69 | Cite as

Robustness of the Mann, Bradley, Hughes reconstruction of Northern Hemisphere surface temperatures: Examination of criticisms based on the nature and processing of proxy climate evidence

Article

Abstract

The Mann et al. (1998) Northern Hemisphere annual temperature reconstruction over 1400–1980 is examined in light of recent criticisms concerning the nature and processing of included climate proxy data. A systematic sequence of analyses is presented that examine issues concerning the proxy evidence, utilizing both indirect analyses via exclusion of proxies and processing steps subject to criticism, and direct analyses of principal component (PC) processing methods in question. Altogether new reconstructions over 1400–1980 are developed in both the indirect and direct analyses, which demonstrate that the Mann et al. reconstruction is robust against the proxy-based criticisms addressed. In particular, reconstructed hemispheric temperatures are demonstrated to be largely unaffected by the use or non-use of PCs to summarize proxy evidence from the data-rich North American region. When proxy PCs are employed, neither the time period used to “center” the data before PC calculation nor the way the PC calculations are performed significantly affects the results, as long as the full extent of the climate information actually in the proxy data is represented by the PC time series. Clear convergence of the resulting climate reconstructions is a strong indicator for achieving this criterion. Also, recent “corrections” to the Mann et al. reconstruction that suggest 15th century temperatures could have been as high as those of the late-20th century are shown to be without statistical and climatological merit. Our examination does suggest that a slight modification to the original Mann et al. reconstruction is justifiable for the first half of the 15th century (∼+0.05), which leaves entirely unaltered the primary conclusion of Mann et al. (as well as many other reconstructions) that both the 20th century upward trend and high late-20th century hemispheric surface temperatures are anomalous over at least the last 600 years. Our results are also used to evaluate the separate criticism of reduced amplitude in the Mann et al. reconstructions over significant portions of 1400–1900, in relation to some other climate reconstructions and model-based examinations. We find that, from the perspective of the proxy data themselves, such losses probably exist, but they may be smaller than those reported in other recent work.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Ammann CM, Wahl ER (2007) The importance of the geophysical context in statistical evaluations of climate reconstruction procedures. Clim Change (volume)Google Scholar
  2. Bradley RS, Jones PD (1993) “Little Ice age” summer temperature variations: their nature and relevance to recent global warming trends. Holocene 3(4):367–376Google Scholar
  3. Briffa KR, Osborn TJ, Schweingruber FH, Harris IC, Jones PD, Shiyatov SG, Vaganov EA (2001) Low-frequency temperature variations from a northern tree ring density network. J Geophys Res 106:2929–2941CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Cane MA, Clement AC, Kaplan A, Kushnir Y, Pozdnyakov D, Seager R, Zebiak SE, Murtugudde R (1997) Twentieth-century sea surface temperature trends. Science 275:957–960CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Chapman DS, Bartlett MG, Harris RN (2004) Comment on “Ground vs. surface air temperature trends: implications for borehole surface temperature reconstructions by” M. Mann and G. Schmidt. Geophys Res Lett 31, doi: 10.1029/2003GL019054Google Scholar
  6. Cole JE, Cook ER (1998) The changing relationship between ENSO variability and moisture balance in the continental United States. Geophys Res Lett 25(24):4529–4532CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Cook ER, Briffa KR, Jones PD (1994) Spatial regression methods in dendroclimatology: a review and comparison of two techniques. Int J Clim 14:379–402CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Cook ER, Esper J, D'Arrigo RD (2004) Extra-tropical Northern Hemisphere land temperature variability over the past 1000 years. Quat Sci Rev 23:2063–2074CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Crowley TJ, Lowery T (2000) How warm was the Medieval Warm Period? A comment on “man-made versus natural climate change”. Ambio 29:51–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Crowley TJ, Baum SK, Kim K-Y, Hegerl GC, Hyde WT (2003) Modeling ocean heat content changes during the last millennium. Geophys Res Lett 30(18):1932, doi:10.1029/2003GL017801Google Scholar
  11. Esper J, Cook ER, Schweingruber FH (2002) Low frequency signals in long tree-ring chronologies for reconstructing past temperature variability. Science 295:2250–2253CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Evans MN, Kaplan A, Cane MA (2002) Pacific sea surface temperature field reconstruction from coral d18O data using reduced space objective analysis. Paleoceanography 17:7, 1–7, 13Google Scholar
  13. Folland CK, Karl TR, Christy JR, Clarke RA, Gruza GV, Jouzel J, Mann ME, Oerlemans J, Salinger MJ, Wang S-W (2001) Observed climate variability and change. In: Houghton JT et al. (eds) Climate change 2001: the scientific basis. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 99–181Google Scholar
  14. Fritts HC (1976) Tree rings and climate. Academic Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  15. Goosse H, Crowley TJ, Zorita E, Ammann CM, Renssen H, Driesschaert E (2005) Modeling the climate of the last millennium: what causes the differences between simulations? Geophys Res Lett 32:L06710, doi: 10.1029/2005GL022368Google Scholar
  16. Graybill D, Idso S (1993) Detecting the aerial fertilization effect of atmospheric CO2 enrichment in tree-ring cohronologies. Global Biogeochemical Cycles 7:81–95CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Green DM, Swets JA (1988) Signal detection theory and psychophysics. Peninsula Publishing, Los Altos, CA 0. Harris RN, Chapman DS (2001) Mid-latitude (30–60N) climatic warming inferred by combining borehole temperatures with surface air temperatures. Geophys Res Lett 28:747–750Google Scholar
  18. Huang S, Pollack HN, Shen P-Y (2000) Temperature trends over the past five centuries reconstructed from borehole temperatures. Nature 403:756–758CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Huang S (2004) Merging information from different resources for new insight into climate change in the past and future. Geophys Res Lett 31:L13205Google Scholar
  20. Hughes MK, Funkhouser G (2003) Frequency-dependent climate signal in upper and lower forest border trees in the mountains of the Great Basin. Clim Change 59:233–244CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Huybers P (2005) Comment on “Hockey sticks, principal components, and spurious significance” by S. McIntyre and R. McKitrick (eds). Geophys Res Lett 32:L20705, doi:10.1029/2005GL023395Google Scholar
  22. Jones PD, Briffa KR (1992) Global surface temperature variations during the 20th century: Part 1: Spatial, temporal and seasonal details. Holocene 1:165–179Google Scholar
  23. Jones PD, Briffa KR, Barnett TP, Tett SFB (1998) High-resolution paleoclimatic records for the last millennium: Interpretation, integration and comparison with circulation model control-run temperatures. Holocene 8:455–471CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Jones PD, Mann ME (2004) Climate over past millennia. Rev Geophys 42:RG2002, doi: 10.1029/2003RG000143Google Scholar
  25. Jones PD, Moberg A (2003) Hemispheric and large-scale surface air temperature variations: an extensive revision and an update to 2001. J Climate 16:206–223CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Jones PD, Osborn TJ, Briffa KB (2001) The evolution of climate over the last millennium. Science 292:662–667CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Kaplan A, Kushnir Y, Cane MA, Blumenthal MB (1997) Reduced space optimal analysis for historical data sets: 136 years of Atlantic sea surface temperatures. J Geophys Res 102(C13):27,835–860CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Lytle D, Wahl E (2005) Paleoenvironmental reconstructions using the modern analog technique: the effects of sample size and decision rules. Holocene 15:554–566CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Luterbacher J, Dietrich D, Xoplaki E, Grosjean M, Wanner H (2004) European seasonal and annual temperature variability, trends and extremes since1500. Science 303:1499–1503CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Mann ME, Bradley RS, Hughes MK (1998) Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries. Nature 392:779–787CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Mann ME, Bradley RS, Hughes MK (1999) Northern hemisphere temperatures during the past millennium: inferences, uncertainties, limitations. Geophys Res Lett 26:759–762CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Mann ME, Bradley RS, Hughes MK (2000) Long-term variability in the El Nino Southern Oscillation and associated teleconnections. In: Diaz HF, Markgraf V (eds) El Nino and the Southern Oscillation: multiscale variability and its impacts on natural ecosystems and society. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, pp 357–412Google Scholar
  33. Mann ME, Bradley RS, Hughes MK (2004) Corrigendum: global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries. Nature 430:105Google Scholar
  34. Mann ME, Jones PD (2003) Global surface temperatures over the past two millennia. Geophys Res Lett 30:1820, doi: 10.1029/2003GL017814Google Scholar
  35. Mann ME, Jones PD (2003) Global surface temperatures over the past two millennia. Geophys Res Lett 30:1820, doi: 10.1029/2003GL017814Google Scholar
  36. Mann ME, Rutherford S (2002) Climate reconstruction using “pseudoproxies”. Geophys Res Lett 29:139, 1–139, 4CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Mann ME, Rutherford S, Bradley RS, Hughes MK, Keimig FT (2004) Optimal surface temperature reconstructions using terrestrial borehole data. J Geophys Res 108(D7):4203, doi: 10.1029/2002JD002532Google Scholar
  38. Mann ME, Rutherford S, Wahl E, Ammann C (2005) Testing the fidelity of methods used in “proxy”-base reconstructions of past climate. J Climate 18:4097–4107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Mann ME, Schmidt GA (2003) Ground vs. surface air temperature trends: implications for borehole surface temperature reconstructions. Geophys Res Lett 30(12):1607, doi: 10.1029/2003GL017170Google Scholar
  40. McIntyre S, McKitrick R (2003) Corrections to the Mann et al. (1998) proxy data based and Northern Hemispheric average temperature series. Energy and Environment 14:751–771CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. McIntyre S, McKitrick R (2005a) Hockey sticks, principal components, and spurious significance. Geophys Res Lett 32:L03710, doi: 10.1029/2004GL021750Google Scholar
  42. McIntyre S, McKitrick R (2005b) The M&M critique of the MBH98 Northern Hemisphere climate index: update and implications. Energy and Environment 16:69–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. McIntyre S, McKitrick R (2005c) Reply to comment by Huybers on “Hockey sticks, principal components, and spurious significance”. Geophys Res Lett 32:L20713, doi: 10.1029/2005GL023586Google Scholar
  44. Moberg A, Sonechkin D, Holmgren K, Datsenko N, Karlén W (2005) Highly variable Northern Hemisphere temperatures reconstructed from low- and high-resolution proxy data. Nature 433:613–617CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Oerlemans J (2005) Extracting a climate signal from 169 glacier records. Science 308:675–677CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Osborn TJ, Briffa KR (2006) The spatial extent of 20th-Century warmth in the context of the past 1200 years. Science 311:841–844CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Prentice IC, Bartlein PJ, Webb TI III (1991) Vegetation and climate change in eastern North America since the last glacial maximum. Ecology 72:2038–2056CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Raible C, Casty C, Luterbacher J, Pauling A, Esper J, Frank D, Buntgen U, Roesch A, Tschuck P, Wild M, Vidale P-L, Schar C, Wanner H (2006) Climate variability - observations, reconstructions, and model simulations for the Atlantic-European and Alpine region from 1500–2100 AD. Clim Change 79:9–29Google Scholar
  49. Rajagopalan B, Cook ER, Lall U, Ray BK (2000) Spatiotemporal variability of ENSO and SST teleconnections to summer drought over the United States during the twentieth century. J Climate 13:4244–4255CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Rutherford S, Mann ME, Osborn TJ, Bradley RS, Briffa KR, Hughes MK, Jones PD (2005) Proxy-based Northern Hemisphere surface temperature reconstructions: sensitivity to method, predictor network, target season, and target domain. J Climate 18:2308–2329CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Rutherford S, Mann ME (2004) Correction to Optimal surface temperature reconstructions using terrestrial borehole data. J Geophys Res 109(D11107) doi:10.1029/2003JD004290Google Scholar
  52. Schmidt GA, Mann ME (2004) Reply to comment on “Ground vs. surface air temperature trends: implications for borehole surface temperature reconstructions” by D. Chapman et al. Geophys Res Lett 31:L07206, doi: 10.1029/2003GL0119144Google Scholar
  53. Shindell DT, Schmidt GA, Mann ME, Rind D, Waple A (2001) Solar forcing of regional climate change during the Maunder Minimum. Science 294:2149–2152CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Shindell DT, Schmidt GA, Miller RL, Mann ME (2003) Volcanic and solar forcing of climate change during the preindustrial era. J Climate 16:4094–4107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Schneider T (2001) Analysis of incomplete climate data: estimation of mean values and covariance matrices and imputation of missing values. J Climate 14:853–887CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Von Storch H, Zorita E, Jones JM, Dimitriev Y, Gonzalez-Rouco F, Tett SFB (2004) Reconstructing past climate from noisy data. Science 306:679–682CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Xoplaki E, Luterbacher J, Paeth H, Dietrich D, Steiner N, Grosjean M, Wanner H (2005) European spring and autumn temperature variability and change of extremes over the last half millennium. Geophys Res Lett 32:L15713Google Scholar
  58. Wahl E (2004) A general framework for determining cut-off values to select pollen analogues with dissimilarity metrics in the modern analogue technique. Rev Palaeobot Palyno 128:263–280CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Waple A, Mann ME, Bradley RS (2002) Long-term patterns of solar irradiance forcing in model experiments and proxy-based surface temperature reconstructions. Clim Dyn 18:563–578Google Scholar
  60. Waple A, Mann ME, Bradley RS (2002) Long-term patterns of solar irradiance forcing in model experiments and proxy-based surface temperature reconstructions. Clim Dyn 18:563–578Google Scholar
  61. Wonnacott R, Wonnacott T (1979) Econometrics, 2nd edn. John Wiley and Sons, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  62. Zorita E, Gonzalez-Rouco F, Legutke S (2003) Testing the Mann et al. (1998) approach to paleoclimate reconstructions in the context of a 1000-yr control simulation with the ECHO-G coupled climate model. J Climate 16:1378–1390CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Environmental Studies and Geology DivisionAlfred UniversityAlfredUSA
  2. 2.Climate and Global Dynamics DivisionNational Center for Atmospheric Research BoulderColoradoU.S.A.

Personalised recommendations