Advertisement

Children's Literature in Education

, Volume 45, Issue 3, pp 179–196 | Cite as

The Columbus Myth: Power and Ideology in Picturebooks About Christopher Columbus

  • Christina M. Desai
Original Paper
First Online:

Abstract

In 1992, the 500th anniversary of Columbus’s landing in the Bahamas was simultaneously celebrated and denounced in the US. Damaging facts about Columbus and the impact of his voyages were aired along with demands for truth and change. This study analyzes the power relationships and political ideology of picturebooks about Columbus published in the US in the 20 years since that anniversary to determine what messages and attitudes young readers are likely to absorb from them and whether the picturebook image of Columbus has evolved. It draws on the ideas of progressive educator Herbert Kohl, who demonstrates how the analysis of power relationships in stories reveals their political stance (Should We Burn Babar?, 1995), and on the tradition of progressive librarianship, which seeks to promote intellectual freedom and positive images in children’s literature of all peoples. The study finds extensive use of certain narrative techniques, including patterns of assumptions, avoidance, event selection, and omission. Patterns in illustration and sentence structure (use of passive voice, etc.) as well as stereotyping and Eurocentrism also abound. Finally, mild historical revisionism is introduced in more “balanced” titles, though the definition of balance is problematic. This article finds that the Columbus myth persists with little change, and that few titles present child readers with alternative perspectives.

Keywords

Christopher Columbus Power Ideology Picturebooks Illustration Native Americans 
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

References

  1. Abnett, Dan. (2007). Christopher Columbus and the Voyage of 1492. New York: Power Kids Press.Google Scholar
  2. Aller, Susan. (2003). Christopher Columbus. Minneapolis: Lerner Publications.Google Scholar
  3. Aloian, Molly. (2010). Columbus Day. New York: Crabtree.Google Scholar
  4. Alter, Judy. (2003). Christopher Columbus: Explorer. Chanhassen, MN: Child’s World.Google Scholar
  5. Ansary, Mir Tamim. (1999). Columbus Day. Des Plaines, IL: Heinemann.Google Scholar
  6. Bailey, Gerry, Foster, Karen, and Noyes, Leighton. (2008). Columbus’s Chart. New York: Crabtree.Google Scholar
  7. Bauer, Marion, and Dubois, Liz Goulet. (Illus.). (2009). Christopher Columbus. New York: Scholastic.Google Scholar
  8. Bello, Manuel, and Shaver, Annis N. (2011). The Representation of Christopher Columbus in High School History Textbooks: A Content Analysis. In Eugene F. Provenzo, Jr. (Ed.), The Textbook as Discourse: Sociocultural Dimensions of American Schoolbooks (pp. 140–161). New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  9. Bigelow, Bill. (1989). Discovering Columbus: Rereading the Past. Language Arts, 66(6), 635–643.Google Scholar
  10. Bigelow, William. (1992). Once upon a Genocide: Christopher Columbus in Children’s Literature. Language Arts, 69(2), 112–120.Google Scholar
  11. Cohen, J.M. (Ed.). (1969). The Four Voyages of Christopher Columbus. London: Penguin.Google Scholar
  12. Craats, Rennay. (2011). Columbus Day. New York: AV2 by Weigl.Google Scholar
  13. Crosby, Alfred W. (1972). The Columbian Exchange: Biological and Cultural Consequences of 1492. Westport, CT: Greenwood.Google Scholar
  14. Davidson, Miles H. (1997). Columbus Then and Now: A Life Reexamined. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.Google Scholar
  15. D’Aulaire, Edgar, and D’Aulaire, Ingri. (1955). Columbus. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.Google Scholar
  16. deRubertis, Barbara. (1992). Columbus Day: Let’s Meet Christopher Columbus. New York: Phoenix Learning Resources.Google Scholar
  17. DeVillier, Christy. (2001). Christopher Columbus. Edina, MN: Abdo.Google Scholar
  18. Gardeski, Christina. (2001). Columbus Day. New York: Children’s Press.Google Scholar
  19. Gardner, Susan. (1991). My First Rhetoric of Domination: The Columbian Encounter in Children’s Biographies. Children’s Literature in Education, 22(2), 275–290.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Gleiter, Jan, Thompson, Kathleen, and Whipple, Rick. (Illus.). (1995). Christopher Columbus. Austin: Raintree Steck-Vaughn.Google Scholar
  21. Halpin, David. (2010). Heroism and Pedagogy. Pedagogies: An International Journal, 5(4), 265–274.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Hill, Rebecca A. (2011). The Color of Authenticity in Multicultural Children’s Literature. Voice of Youth Advocates, 34(5), 445–447.Google Scholar
  23. Ingber, Bonnie Verbung. (1992). The Writing of “Encounter”: The Editor’s Perspective. New Advocate, 5(4), 241–245.Google Scholar
  24. King, Thomas. (2007). A Coyote Columbus Story. Toronto: Groundwood Books.Google Scholar
  25. Kline, Trish. (2002). Christopher Columbus. Vero Beach, FL: Rourke.Google Scholar
  26. Kohl, Herbert R. (1995). Should We Burn Babar? Essays on Children’s Literature and the Power of Stories. New York: New Press.Google Scholar
  27. Koning, Hans. (1991). Columbus: His Enterprise: Exploding the Myth. New York: Monthly Review Press.Google Scholar
  28. Krensky, Stephen, and Green, Norman. (Illus.). (2003, 1991). Christopher Columbus. New York: Random House.Google Scholar
  29. Kurtz, Jane, and Billin-Frye, Paige. (Illus.). (2007). What Columbus Found: It Was Orange, It Was Round. New York: Aladdin.Google Scholar
  30. Landau, Elaine. (2012, 2001). Celebrating Columbus Day. Berkeley Heights, NJ: Enslow.Google Scholar
  31. Liestman, Vicki. (1991). Columbus Day. Minneapolis, MN: Carolrhoda Books.Google Scholar
  32. Lowe, Steve, Columbus, Christopher, and Sabuda, Robert. (Illus.). (1992). The Log of Christopher Columbus. New York: Philomel.Google Scholar
  33. Macdonald, Fiona, and Antram, David. (Illus.). (2004). You Wouldn’t Want to Sail with Christopher Columbus! Uncharted Waters You’d Rather Not Cross. New York: Franklin Watts.Google Scholar
  34. Markle, Sandra, and Akib, Jamel. (Illus.). (2008). Animals Christopher Columbus Saw. San Francisco: Chronicle.Google Scholar
  35. McCormick, Lisa Wade. (2005). Christopher Columbus. New York: Children’s Press.Google Scholar
  36. Molzahn, Arlene. (2003). Christopher Columbus: Famous Explorer. Berkeley Heights, NJ: Enslow.Google Scholar
  37. Morganelli, Adrianna. (2005). Christopher Columbus: Sailing to a New World. New York: Crabtree.Google Scholar
  38. Nussbaum, Martha C. (2010). Not for Profit: Why Democracy Needs the Humanities. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  39. Phelan, Carolyn. (1991). [Review of Christopher Columbus by Steven Krensky]. Booklist, 88(7), 709.Google Scholar
  40. Phillips, Carla R., and Phillips, William D. (1991). The Textbook Columbus: Examining the Myth. Humanities, 12(5), 27–30.Google Scholar
  41. Sanchez, Rebecca M. (2010). The Six Remaining Facts: Social Studies Content Knowledge and Elementary Preservice Teachers. Action in Teacher Education, 32(3), 66–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Schaefer, Lola. (2002). Christopher Columbus. Mankato, MN: Pebble Books.Google Scholar
  43. Schwarcz, Joseph H. (1982). Ways of the Illustrator: Visual Communication in Children’s Literature. Chicago: American Library Association.Google Scholar
  44. Sheyahshe, Michael. (2008). Native Americans in Comic Books: A Critical Study. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.Google Scholar
  45. Smith, Barry. (1992). The First Voyage of Christopher Columbus 1492. New York: Viking.Google Scholar
  46. Spencer, Eve. (1993). Three Ships for Columbus. Austin, TX: Raintree Steck-Vaugh.Google Scholar
  47. Stephens, John. (2012). Editorial. International Research in Children’s Literature, 5(1), v–viii.Google Scholar
  48. Stone, Edward T. (1978). Columbus’ La Navidad. American Heritage, 29(3), 82–91.Google Scholar
  49. Taxel, Joel. (1993). The Politics of Children’s Literature: Reflections on Multiculturalism and Christopher Columbus. In Violet J. Harris (Ed.), Teaching Multicultural Literature in Grades K-8 (pp. 1–36). Norwood, MA: Christopher-Gordon.Google Scholar
  50. Taxel, Joel. (1997). The Analysis of Power in Children’s Literature. The Lion and the Unicorn, 21(2), 299–303.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Wade, Mary Dodson. (2003). Christopher Columbus. New York: Children’s Press.Google Scholar
  52. Wade, Mary Dodson. (2007). Christopher Columbus: Famous Explorer. Mankato, MN: Capstone Press.Google Scholar
  53. Whittemore, Richard. (1972). “The Heroes of Defeat”: Biography and American Indian History. Social Education, 36(5), 520–525.Google Scholar
  54. Wyatt, Valerie. (2008). Who Discovered America?. Toronto: Kids Can Press.Google Scholar
  55. Yolen, Jane, and Shannon, David. (Illus.). (1992). Encounter. San Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of New MexicoAlbuquerqueUSA

Personalised recommendations

Cite article

Buy options