Iα to Iβ mechano-conversion and amorphization in native cellulose simulated by crystal bending
The bending of rod-like native cellulose crystals with degree of polymerization 40 and 160 using molecular dynamics simulations resulted in a deformation-induced local amorphization at the kinking point and allomorphic interconversion between cellulose Iα and Iβ in the unbent segments. The transformation mechanism involves a longitudinal chain slippage of the hydrogen-bonded sheets by the length of one anhydroglucose residue (~ 0.5 nm), which alters the chain stacking from the monotonic (Iα) form to the alternating Iβ one or vice versa. This mechanical deformation converts the Iα form progressively to the Iβ form, as has been experimentally observed for ultrasonication of microfibrils. Iβ is also able to partially convert to Iα-like organization but this conversion is only transitory. The qualitative agreement between the behavior of ultrasonicated microfibrils and in silico observed Iα → Iβ conversion suggests that shear deformation and chain slippage under bending deformation is a general process when cellulose fibrils experience lateral mechanical stress.
KeywordsBending Chain slippage Kink Molecular dynamics simulation Allomorphic conversion
In recent years, cellulose nanofibers (CNF) and nanocrystals (CNC) have received increased interest in materials science (Habibi et al. 2010; Grishkewich et al. 2017). These cellulose nanomaterials are obtained by disintegrating cellulosic fibers in the plant cell wall through chemical or mechanochemical treatments. These materials may experience various stress conditions in industrial processes and in use that may alter the inner structure of the cellulose nanocrystals through dislocations (Hidayat et al. 2012) and allomorphic transitions. Understanding the mechanical response of crystalline cellulose to various external forces is important for fundamental understanding and for development of more effective processing.
Processing cellulose by ultrasound is a scalable process currently used in many laboratories. It is often observed that sonicated cellulose fibrils have a tortuous morphology, showing numerous kinks and can be accompanied by an allomorphic transformation (Briois et al. 2013) from the triclinic cellulose Iα to the monoclinic Iβ form.
We recently carried out molecular modeling to mimic a 3-point bending test of cellulose Iβ crystals (Chen et al. 2016). Upon bending, the crystal developed a sharp kink identical to that observed experimentally for processed celluloses (Kekaelaeinen et al. 2012; Wang et al. 2012; Zeng et al. 2012; Martoia et al. 2016). We found shear deformations are very important when the bending load is applied on the hydrophobic face, for which the bending rigidity is also the lowest.
In this study, we applied this bending protocol to produce kinks in molecular models of pure Iα and pure Iβ cellulose crystals on their hydrophobic face. We followed the evolution of the internal atomic structure to investigate the molecular details of allomorphic transition and morphological changes. Results obtained on short crystals (about 20 nm in length) of Iα and Iβ will be shown first, followed by results obtained on a long crystal (about 80 nm in length) of Iα.
Each crystal model was energy minimized (EM) and then equilibrated by molecular dynamics (MD). EM was performed using the steepest descent method followed by the conjugated gradient method, with the convergence criterion being a maximum force of 10 kJ mol−1 nm−1. In the dynamics process, the temperature was slowly increased from 0 to 300 K over 6 ns, followed by a 94 ns equilibration period.
The bending was carried out as described in a previous paper (Chen et al. 2016). Briefly, the equilibrated crystals were rotated to align their long axes with the z-axis and their respective hydrophobic surfaces (the 110 surface for Iα and the 100 surface for Iβ) parallel to the yz plane, as shown in Fig. 1. They were then bent normal to their hydrophobic surface by displacing bridge oxygen atoms at the center of the top surface to a fixed x coordinate. Constraints were also applied on the glycosidic oxygen atoms at the two ends of the bottom layers of cellulose chains, with the x coordinate constrained at the reducing end and the x and z coordinates constrained at the non-reducing end. The crystal was bent by gradually moving the x coordinate of the constrained atoms at the center of the microfibril. A stepwise displacement of −0.015 nm was applied, followed by either 1 or 3 ns of MD simulation, which was enough for the energy to converge (Chen et al. 2016).
All simulations have been performed with GROMACS version 4.6 for cellulose chains with degree of polymerization 40 and version 2016.3 for the fibril with degree of polymerization 160 (Hess et al. 2008). The cellulose fibril was modelled using the GROMOS 56Acarbo force field, which is a mostly explicit-atom force field, although carbons bonded to a single hydrogen atom are replaced by a CH1 united atom (Hansen and Huenenberger 2011) whose Lennard–Jones parameters have been subsequently optimized (Chen et al. 2014). MD simulations were performed in the NVT ensemble using a 2 fs integration time step. The stochastic velocity-rescaling algorithm of Bussi et al. (2007) was used to control the temperature at 300 K. Bonds involving explicit hydrogen atoms were constrained using the LINCS algorithm (Hess et al. 1997). Electrostatic and Lennard–Jones interactions were both truncated with a cut-off radius of 1.2 nm; no long-range electrostatic or Lennard–Jones interactions were computed.
Local structures: amorphous kinks surrounded by crystalline straight segments
Figures 2 and 3 show that the linear segments remain highly organized for the entire range of studied deflections. The hydroxymethyl groups keep the initial tg conformation (Fig. 2) and the pyran rings adopt exclusively the 4C1 conformation (Fig. 3). The regular organization of the linear portions of the crystals can be visualized in the snapshots shown in Fig. 1. Near the loading point, however, the structure becomes disorganized. The appearance of the gg and gt conformers of the hydroxymethyl groups, together with the appearance of the unconventional forms of the pyran rings accompanying the kinking, is perceptible for deflections beyond 2–3 nm. The disorganized portion of the micro-fibril propagates progressively and symmetrically on both sides of the kink as deflection increases.
Diffractograms predicted for Iα and Iβ at various levels of deflection are superimposed in Fig. 4c. As expected, at small deflections, the most intense diffraction peak of Iβ (200) appears at a larger 2 − θ value than that for Iα (110). In contrast, the two diffractograms predicted from the strongly kinked Iα and Iβ become almost identical, indicating that the straight domains of the two kinked crystals undergo ultrastructural reorganizations and converge to a similar structure.
Discontinuities in the potential energy curves
The energy-deflection curves show several discontinuities where small increases in deflection are accompanied by energy drops of up to 1.5 kJ/(mol cellobiose). Such energy drops are specific to bending at the hydrophobic surfaces of native cellulose crystals, as they are not observed in the other directions (Chen et al. 2016). For deflections larger than 5 nm, the energy of the kinked Iα microfibril is lower than that of its initial equilibrated crystal, suggesting that the structural rearrangements for this allomorph are favorable, and probably irreversible, despite the presence of a significant amount of amorphous phase that has a higher energy than the crystals (Mazeau and Heux 2003). In contrast, no such behavior is observed for the Iβ form, where the energies of the kinked Iβ crystal are always higher than that of the initial straight form.
Torsional entropy compensation
The potential energy increase due to bending is accompanied by larger torsional freedom in the kinked region, resulting in a much smaller net increase in free energy, between 2 and 4 kJ/(mol cellobiose) less than the potential energy for cellulose Iα and Iβ, respectively (Fig. 5). Thus, under ambient conditions, cellulose chains should kink more easily than what the potential energy increase or the theoretical bending rigidity would imply.
Chain slippage at the origin of the energy drops
The initial organization of the cellulose chains in the crystal influences the number and location of the allomorphic transitions (Figs. 1, 6). For the Iα system, the first transition takes place at a deflection of 1.8 nm, where Dslip between layers 3 and 4 on the reducing end side varies suddenly by + 0.5 nm (Fig. 5). Just after the transition (Fig. 1c), the reducing side of the microfibril is composed of two triclinic blocks separated by a monoclinic interface between layers 3 and 4. This structural event is repeated at each energy drop and, after each new sliding event, the total amount of the monoclinic form increases. This accumulation of the Iβ-like form can be observed in Fig. 1g where the microfibril is strongly bent after three energy drops corresponding to six sliding events, and the vast majority of the crystal is in Iβ-like organization, except for the amorphous kink. Note that, at this bending level, the non-reducing end side of the microfibril (to the right of the kink in Fig. 1e, g) is also affected by the structural reorganization. Interestingly, the 5 kJ/(mol cellobiose) energy drop between tags f and g is due to three concerted sliding events on the non-reducing end side of the microfibril (Fig. 6). Finally, under extreme bending, at a deflection of 7.5 nm (Fig. 1g right), the organization is mainly Iβ-like on both sides of the kink, showing that the allomorphic transformation is almost complete. This progressive transformation from triclinic form to a monoclinic form leads to the stabilization of the kinked state after being displaced 5 nm compared to its initial form (Fig. 5).
Similar relaxations by sliding exists for the Iβ form, with the energy drops accompanying ~ 0.5 nm longitudinal displacements of the sheets (Fig. 5) resulting in local Iβ → Iα allomorphic transitions (Fig. 1c, e, g). The first transition occurs at a deflection of 2.5 nm between layers 4 and 5 on the non-reducing (right) end of the fibril, which, at tag c, is organized in two monoclinic blocks separated by a triclinic-like interface between layers 4 and 5). However, layers 4 and 5 in the Iβ system undergo several successive transitions on the non-reducing side, converting the interface into Iα at 2.5 nm of deflection, before reverting to Iβ at 3.5 nm and transforming again into Iα at 6.5 nm. This suggests that the Iβ to Iα-like conversion in Iβ is transitory; after each new sliding event, the organization within the microfibril alternates between pure Iβ and a Iα/Iβ mixture. It is only for extreme curvatures greater than approximately 6 nm of deflection, that a significant portion of the non-reducing side of the microfibril transforms into Iα.
We note that the reducing end side of the microfibril is unaffected by bending and keeps its initial monoclinic organization. This asymmetry of the deformation with respect to the reducing end might come from the sight ratchet-like morphology of cellulose chains, which results in asymmetric shear compliance.
Effect of the crystal length
To keep the computational demands of our simulations reasonable, we first opted to study relatively short crystal segments to study the effect of bending on the local structural transformation in vacuum. Experimentally, the allomorphic transition and creation of kinks by sonication is observed on long microfibrils but not on short fragments of crystals, and in aqueous media (Briois et al. 2013).
Overall, the evolution with kinking of the morphology, the local internal organization (amorphous or crystalline) as well as the allomorphic transitions are independent of size effects. This concordance of structural behavior between the short and long model suggests that the molecular mechanism of response to a lateral force by phase transition is general.
Experimentally sonicated microfibrils showed numerous kinks when observed in TEM, with a 20% decrease in crystallinity and an increase in gg and gt conformers of the hydroxylmethyl groups as estimated by solid-state CP-MAS NMR spectroscopy (Briois et al. 2013). Our models qualitatively agree with these experimental observations. The simulation also suggests that crystallinity degrades only at the kinking point and the linear segments remain crystalline.
We also reported that cellulose microfibrils from Glaucocystis, mostly in Iα, partly transformed into Iβ by ultrasonication (Briois et al. 2013). Kinking the Iα microfibril model agree with this observation. It has been recently measured that the maximum of the distribution of the kink angle is 60° (Usov et al. 2015), which corresponds to a deflection of 5 nm in our model. To reach this level of deflection, the Iα crystal model underwent two transitions on the reducing end and three on the non-reducing end (Figs. 1, 6), leading to an accumulation of the maximal possible amount of Iβ.
In contrast, the cellulose microfibrils from tunicate, dominated by the Iβ phase, remain unchanged when they are sonicated. Our models show that the reducing end of Iβ can undergo some transitions to Iα during kinking, but at the observed kink angle of 60° the two straight segments surrounding the kink are entirely monoclinic (Iβ), corroborating that transitory Iβ → Iα conversions are undetected.
Thermal treatment transforms Iα into Iβ (Horii et al. 1987; Yamamoto et al. 1989; Debzi et al. 1991; Yamamoto and Horii 1993). The high thermal expansion perpendicular to the pyranose plane upon heating measured by in situ X-ray diffraction suggests the thermally induced phase transition is also due to mutual sliding at these hydrophobic interfaces.
We have performed molecular dynamics simulations of cellulose crystals of length 20 nm and 80 nm to study their behavior under bending deformations. Comparable to experimental observations, when bent on the hydrophobic plane, cellulose crystals tend to create kink zones with loss of crystalline order. while the two linear segments on each side of the kink remain crystalline. The creation of kinks is accompanied by translations of the hydrogen-bonded sheets of the crystalline segments, corresponding to partial allomorphic transitions. The Iα → Iβ conversions accumulate with increasing bending deflection, while Iβ → Iα conversions are only transitory.
This work was supported by the Wallenberg Wood Science Center (WWSC) funded by the Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation. This work was performed as part of the Cluster of Excellence “Tailor-Made Fuels from Biomass”, which is funded by the Excellence Initiative by the German federal and state government to promote science and research at German universities. We acknowledge the computational resource from the Centre d'Expérimentaion et de Calcul Intensif (CECIC).
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.