Smoking and alcohol drinking increased the risk of esophageal cancer among Chinese men but not women in a high-risk population
Although the association for esophageal cancer with tobacco smoking and alcohol drinking has been well established, the risk appears to be less strong in China. To provide more evidence on the effect of smoking and alcohol consumption with esophageal cancer in China, particularly among Chinese women, a population-based case–control study has been conducted in Jiangsu, China, from 2003 to 2007. A total of 1,520 cases and 3,879 controls were recruited. Unconditional multivariate logistic regression analysis was applied. Results showed that the odds ratio (OR) and confidence interval (CI) for ever smoking and alcohol drinking were 1.57 (95% CI: 1.34–1.83) and 1.50 (95% CI: 1.29–1.74). Dose–response relationships were observed with increased intensity and longer duration of smoking/drinking. Risk of smoking and alcohol drinking at the highest joint level was 7.32 (95% CI: 4.58–11.7), when compared to those never smoked and never drank alcohol. Stratifying by genders, smoking and alcohol drinking increased the risk among men with an OR of 1.74 (95% CI: 1.44–2.09) and 1.76 (95% CI: 1.48–2.09); however, neither smoking nor alcohol consumption showed a significant association among women. In conclusion, smoking and alcohol drinking were associated with esophageal cancer risk among Chinese men, but not among Chinese women.
KeywordsEsophageal cancer Smoking Alcohol Case–control studies China
Esophageal cancer remains one of the most fatal malignancies in the world. In 2005, about 497,700 new cases occurred worldwide, and the prevalence is expected to increase by approximately 140% by 2025 . The actual etiology of esophageal cancer remains unclear, but extensive evidence in the past decades has demonstrated that tobacco smoking and alcohol drinking are prominent risk factors of this disease [2, 3, 4, 5, 6]. The risk of esophageal cancer among smokers is 2–5 fold in general when compared to non-smokers, while for heavy smokers, the risk may exceed tenfold . The average risk of esophageal cancer with alcohol drinking is estimated to be 1.04-fold per drink/week , and the risk ratio may also over tenfold among heavy drinkers . Some previous studies reported that the associations significantly increased when alcohol and smoking coexist, their joint effects are approximately multiplicative and may increase 130-fold in the highest joint level .
Although the association for esophageal cancer with tobacco smoking and alcohol drinking has been well established in many areas of the world, some striking variation between regions does exist . In Western countries, smoking and alcohol consumption seem to be the primary risk factors of esophageal squamous cell cancer, the population attributable fraction (PAF) of smoking and alcohol was estimated to be 71 and 41%, respectively . China is an area with one of the highest incidence of esophageal cancer worldwide, about half of the cases that occur in the world each year are estimated to be in this country . Whereas, the strong association of smoking and alcohol as well as their multiplicative joint effects were observed considerably weaker or even absent according to some previous studies [9, 10, 11, 12]. The proportion of esophageal cancer attributed to smoking and alcohol in China was estimated to be only 23 and 16%, respectively . Previous studies showed that smoking and alcohol are strong and important risk factors in both genders in Western populations [5, 14, 15, 16]; however, because of the rather low prevalence of smoking and alcohol drinking in Chinese women, very few studies explored the etiology of these two risk factors among women in this country.
During 2003–2007, a large population-based case–control study on esophageal cancer has been carried out in Jiangsu province, an area with the third highest esophageal cancer mortality in China . The study design has previously been described in detail [18, 19]. In brief, this study was conducted in two counties, Dafeng and Ganyu. Both of these counties are less-developed rural areas in northern Jiangsu, and farming remains the main occupation of the local population. The annual average age-standardized incidence during 2006–2008 by China standard population was 36 and 24 per 100,000 in Dafeng and Ganyu, respectively. In this present analysis, we analyzed the overall and gender-specific effects of smoking and alcohol drinking on esophageal cancer in this high-risk Chinese population. It aims to provide further data on the independent and joint effects of these two well-known risk factors in China, especially among Chinese women.
Materials and methods
Subject recruitment and data collection
Eligible subjects were restricted to local inhabitants who have lived in the study area for at least 5 years. Newly diagnosed primary esophageal cancer patients were recruited as cases, using the data from local population-based cancer registries. From 2003 to 2007, 68 and 75% of all newly registered patients were recruited and interviewed in Dafeng and Ganyu, respectively. Because of the low proportion of pathological examination in the less-developed rural areas (39%), patients who were diagnosed by other sophisticated methods such as endoscopic examination (40%) or radiology (11%) were also included.
Controls were derived from the same county as cases, randomly selected from the county demographic database. Controls were frequency matched with cases by gender and age (±5 years). The participation rate of controls was 87% in Dafeng and 85% in Ganyu, respectively.
With written informed consent, epidemiological data were obtained by face-to-face interviews using a pre-tested standardized questionnaire. The questionnaire included detailed information on factors known or suspected to be associated with esophageal cancer, including demographic information, socio-economic status, living conditions, environmental exposures, and dietary habits. Details on lifetime smoking and alcohol drinking habits were collected, questions included age at starting smoking/drinking, years of consumption, the average number of cigarettes smoked per day, weekly frequency, and the amount of drinking different types of alcohol beverages (e.g., beer, wine, and liquor). If the subject had quit smoking/drinking habit at time of interview, the duration of cessation was also recorded. This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Jiangsu Provincial Health Department.
In the present analysis, never smokers were defined as having smoked fewer than 100 cigarettes in their lifetime; while never drinkers were those who drank less than once per month. Current smokers and current drinkers were defined as those who had the habit at the time of interview or stopped the habit within 1 year before interview. Pack-years of smoking and weekly consumption of pure ethanol (grams/week) on average were calculated. Since no marked difference was observed regarding the effect of smoking and alcohol drinking between the two counties, data were pooled to improve statistical power.
Confounders were selected based on the previous knowledge on esophageal cancer and our preliminary results , including age, gender, education level, previous income, body mass index (using Chinese recommendation standard) , family history of cancer in first-degree relatives (any malignancy), and study area. After adjusting for confounders, the overall and gender-specific effects for smoking and alcohol drinking were evaluated by unconditional logistic regression. The strength was quantified as odds ratios (OR), and 95% confidence intervals (CI) around the OR were used to quantify precision. The trend test of ordered variables was performed by assigning scores to different exposure levels and treating the categorical variable as a continuous variable in the logistic regression model. Effect modifications were evaluated by stratification, statistical interaction was assessed by including main effect variables and their product terms in the logistic regression model.
Data were entered into the computer by Epidata 3.0, cleaned and analyzed using SAS v9.1 software (SAS Institute, Inc., Cary, NC).
The demographic information and socio-economic status of cases and controls
Case (%) (n = 1,191)
Control (%) (n = 2,916)
Case (%) (n = 329)
Control (%) (n = 963)
Middle school and above
Previous income (RMB)a
Body mass index (BMI)a,b
18.5 ~ 23.9
24 ~ 27.9
Family history of cancer
The OR and 95% CI for smoking-related variables with esophageal cancer among men and women
The OR and 95% CI for alcohol-related variables with esophageal cancer among men and women
The joint effects of smoking and alcohol drinking on esophageal cancer among men and women
OR (95% CI)a
OR (95% CI)b
OR (95% CI)b
P for interaction
The overall OR and 95% CI for independent and joint effects of smoking and alcohol drinking on esophageal cancer risk
Ethanol intake (ml/week)
P for trend
P for trend
P for interaction
In this large population-based case–control study, we confirmed that tobacco smoking and alcohol drinking were associated with esophageal cancer development in a high-risk Chinese population and found the positive dose–response trends with both intensity and duration of consumption during lifetime. In agreement with some previous studies in China, their independent and joint effects seem to be less strong when compared to that of Western countries [9, 10, 11, 12, 13]. Whereas, neither smoking nor alcohol drinking was found to be associated with esophageal cancer among Chinese women in the present analysis.
Tobacco smoking and alcohol have been claimed as strong risk factors of esophageal cancer for a long time, both of them have been categorized into group I carcinogens (carcinogenic to human) by the working group of International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) . Strong associations for smoking and alcohol consumption with esophageal cancer were observed in Western countries (including South-American and African populations); however, the risks appear to be much lower in China, especially in some high incidence regions [9, 10, 11]. In a large prospective study in Linxian China, one of the highest esophageal cancer risk areas in the world, Tran et al.  only found modest elevations in the risk of esophageal cancer among current smokers (OR = 1.3), while alcohol drinking was not associated with esophageal cancer (OR = 0.86). In a meta-analysis of seven Chinese studies, the pooled OR for smoking and alcohol drinking on esophageal cancer was estimated to be 1.84 and 1.50, respectively . Similarly, we observed a moderate increased risk of smoking (OR = 1.57) and alcohol drinking (OR = 1.50) in our study, supporting that the risks of these two well-known risk factors are less strong in China.
The reasons for the weaker association could be partly explained by the short exposure history and considerably low prevalence among Chinese women . Although China is currently the largest producer and consumer of tobacco in the world and there is evidence of a striking increase in alcohol consumption, tobacco, and alcohol use became more prevalent in China just from 1980s, and traditionally, it is more acceptable for Chinese men to smoke and drink than for women. It has been reported that about 66.9% of men but only 4.2% of women are smokers in China, whereas the prevalence of smoking among men and women was estimated to be 35 and 22% in developed countries, 50 and 9% in developing countries [23, 24]. The annual ethanol consumption among Chinese adults was also reported much lower than in industrialized countries, and men drink 13.4 times more than women . Another explanation for the weak association is that there might be some other strong risks factors that account for the majority of cases in those high-risk areas; thus, the effect of smoking and alcohol drinking is diluted . For instance, nutrition deficiency, exposure to N-nitrosamines, and fungi toxins have been summarized as the major causative factors in some high-risk areas of China .
Several studies have indicated that smoking and alcohol consumption are strong risk factors for both men and women in Western populations [5, 14, 15, 16], but very few studies explored their effects among Chinese women because of the considerably low prevalence. Gao et al.  reported that the risk of smoking among women was 1.6 (95% CI: 1.0–2.4) in a case–control study (902 cases and 1,552 controls), but no elevated risk was observed among female alcohol drinkers. Another case–control study (355 cases and 408 controls) found no association between alcohol drinking and esophageal cancer among women (OR = 0.83, 95% CI: 0.22–3.09); given the limited number of female smokers, the author did not estimate the effect of smoking among women . In this present analysis, we found that neither smoking nor alcohol drinking was associated with the risk of esophageal cancer among women in a Chinese population.
Some quantitative aspects of tobacco and alcohol use were demonstrated to be dose-dependently related to the risk of esophageal cancer, such as the intensity and years of consumption [2, 3, 4, 5, 6]. It has been suggested that the risk of smoking depends mainly on the duration of tobacco consumption rather than smoking intensity; on the contrary, the duration of alcohol drinking is less important than the weekly or daily dose of ethanol intake . In our analysis, the risk of esophageal cancer was observed not only positively related to smoking duration and weekly amount of ethanol intake but also associated with smoking intensity and drinking years. Results are similar to the findings of Castellsague et al. and Fan et al. [5, 31]. The association between esophageal cancer and age at starting smoking or drinking alcohol remains inconsistent [5, 6, 31, 32], and we observed that an earlier age at starting smoking or drinking elevated the risk when compared to those who began to smoke or drink later than 30-year old, but no trend was apparent for age and cancer risk among early smokers.
In our analysis, an increased risk was observed in men both for smoking among non-drinkers and for drinking alcohol among non-smokers, confirmed that smoking and alcohol alone may play independent role in the etiology of esophageal cancer. We also found that light alcohol drinking without smoking has relatively low effect on esophageal cancer risk, whereas smoking among never drinkers increased the occurrence of esophageal cancer significantly, suggesting smoking is more strongly related to esophageal cancer than alcohol in China. The synergistic interaction when alcohol and smoking coexist has been reported previously, their joint effects are approximately multiplicative and risk in the highest consumption level may increase 130-fold [2, 5, 6]. Although a statistical interaction between smoking and alcohol drinking was observed in the present analysis, exposure to the highest joint level caused a 7.32-fold risk compared to those who neither smoke nor drink alcohol, indicating less strong effects of these two well-known factors in the high-risk Chinese population.
A beneficial reduction in the risk of esophageal cancer after cessation of smoking and alcohol consumption was observed by some previous studies, but it may take decades to decrease the risk to the level as never exposed individuals [33, 34, 35, 36, 37]. Several case–control studies reported that those who had stopped smoking for less than 10 years had an OR similar to that of current smokers, while quitting for 10 years or more dropped risk to that of never smokers [33, 34, 35]. Similarly, we observed that quitting smoking for less than 5 years has a similar OR (OR = 1.64) compared to current smokers (OR = 1.54), while quitting more than 10 years decreased the OR to the level of never smokers (OR = 0.90). Different from smoking, significantly elevated ORs were observed among former alcohol drinkers, even for quitting drinking for more than 10 years (OR = 1.80). The consequences of drinking cessation has been studied less frequently than smoking cessation, results are more controversial, and beneficial effect has been found in some studies particularly 10 years after giving up drinking [36, 37], whereas other studies have shown either a non-beneficial effect or a higher risk among former drinkers [6, 32, 33, 38, 39]. It is possible that cases were more prone to quit drinking because of digestive tract symptoms long before cancer occurrence; thus, the higher proportion of former drinkers among cases may cause an inflated OR in this group. Another reason is that some heavy drinker cases may underreport their habit, declaring no consumption when in fact they were still drinking and consequently exhibited a higher risk than never drinkers . These two reasons could also explain the increased OR among former smokers.
There are several limitations to this present analysis. Firstly, although the questionnaire had been pre-tested in some previous studies and all interviewers had been trained to explain questions to participants more clearly, the exposure level of smoking and alcohol drinking was reported by study participants without accurate measurements, and thus, subjective judgement and recall bias may exist and cause non-differential misclassification of exposures. However, the strength of the associations for esophageal cancer with smoking and alcohol consumption, particularly the dose–response trends, indicate good validity and sensitivity of our study. Secondly, when evaluating the risk of intensity and duration of smoking/drinking, the same cutoff point was used for both men and women. Given the relatively smaller number in some categories among women, it may cause an unstable OR. However, similar results were observed when gender-specific cutoff points were used separately (data not shown). Thirdly, we were not able to determine the pathological type for all cases in this population-based study because of the low proportion of histological confirmed cases in less-developed rural areas; however, more than 95% of esophageal cancer in China are esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC) according to previous reports [40, 41].
In conclusion, our study indicates that smoking and alcohol drinking are associated with the risk of esophageal cancer among Chinese men but not among Chinese women in a high-risk population, with less strong independent and joint effects when compared with that in Western countries. Nevertheless, the elimination of these modifiable lifestyle risk factors should be part of the primary prevention strategy and control activities on esophageal cancer in China.
The authors would like to thank the subjects for their voluntary participation, as well as the staff of local Health Bureaus and local CDCs in Dafeng and Ganyu for their assistance in fieldwork. This study is funded by Jiangsu Provincial Health Department (RC 2003090), the Graduate School VLAG at Wageningen University is also acknowledged for their financial supporting on a study fellowship.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
- 2.Munoz N, Day NE (1996) Esophagus. In: Schottenfeld D, Fraumeni JF (eds) Cancer epidemiology and prevention. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 681–706Google Scholar
- 4.World Cancer Research Fund/American Institute for Cancer Research (2007) Food, nutrition, physical activity, and the prevention of cancer: a global perspective. AICR, Washington, DC, pp 60–195Google Scholar
- 13.Yu HP, Shi LY, Yao HY (2003) Meta-analysis on the association of esophageal cancer with smoking and alcohol drinking [Chinese]. Zhongguo Manxingbing Yufang Kongzhi Zazhi 11:1–2Google Scholar
- 17.Chen Z (2008) Report of the third national mortality retrospective sampling survey [Chinese]. Peking Union Medical College Press, BeijingGoogle Scholar
- 19.Wu M, Zhang ZF, Kampman E et al. (2010) Does family history of cancer modify the effects of lifestyle risk factors on esophageal cancer? A population-based case-control study in China. Int J Cancer. doi:10.1002/ijc.25532
- 21.Zhou B (2002) Predictive values of body mass index and waist circumference to risk factors of related diseases in Chinese adult population [Chinese]. Zhonghua Liuxing Bingxue Zazhi 23:5–10Google Scholar
- 22.IARC. Agents classified by the IARC monographs, vols 1–100. http://monographs.iarc.fr/ENG/Classification/ClassificationsAlphaOrder.pdf. Accessed 10 Sep 2010
- 24.Mackay J, Eriksen M (2002) The tobacco atlas. World Health Organization, GenevaGoogle Scholar
- 26.Kamangar F, Chow WH, Abnet CC, Dawsey SM (2009) Environmental causes of esophageal cancer. Gastroenterol Clin North Am 38:27–57, viiGoogle Scholar
- 27.Dong Z, Tang P, Li L, Wang G (2002) The strategy for esophageal cancer control in high-risk areas of China. Jpn J Clin Oncol 32(Suppl):S10–S12Google Scholar
- 40.Liu ZH (2006) The identification, regulation and function study of the differentially expressed genes in human esophageal squamous cell carcinoma. In: Kinner HK (ed) Esophageal cancer research developments. Nova Science Publishers Inc, New York, pp 1–97Google Scholar
- 41.Guo M, Zhao YD, Yang HJ, Yan XF (2008) Analysis of clinicopathological characteristics for 5406 cases of esophageal neoplasm [Chinese]. Zhonghua Zhongliu Fangzhi Zazhi 1:54–56Google Scholar