Social disparities and prostate cancer: mapping the gaps in our knowledge
Article Received: 19 May 2004 Accepted: 11 July 2004 Abstract
To evaluate the current state of our knowledge regarding social disparities and prostate cancer and to map the domains where substantial knowledge has been acquired as well as those where little is known, with the purpose of identifying important areas for future research.
A Medline research was conducted to identify published papers regarding social disparities in prostate cancer since 1990. The results of this review are presented in a social disparities and prostate cancer grid designed to highlight which domains of social disparities have been researched and which neglected.
The major social disparity in prostate cancer concerns the extremely high prostate cancer incidence and mortality seen among black Americans. This is also the area where the most research has been performed. Low socioeconomic position is associated with poorer prostate cancer outcomes but not with higher prostate cancer incidence. It remains poorly defined to what extent racial/ethnic differences in prostate cancer result from differences in socioeconomic position (SEP). Understanding the causes of the high prostate cancer mortality seen among black men remains the major challenge in the area of social disparities and prostate cancer.
Keywords cancer disparities health disparities prostate cancer race review article References
Ries LAG, Eisner MP, Kosary CL
, et al.
(2003) SEER Cancer Statistics Review, 1975–2000. Bethesda, MD: National Cancer Institute, http://seer.cancer.gov/csr/1975_2000/, Section 22.
Krieger N (2004) Defining and investigating social disparities in cancer. Cancer Causes Control (in press).
Krieger N, Emmons KE, Burns-White K (2004) Cancer disparities: developing a multidisciplinary research agenda. Cancer Causes Control (in press).
Google Scholar Robbins, AS, Whittemore, AS, Thom, DH 2000 Differences in socioeconomic status and survival among white and black men with prostate cancer Am J Epidemiol 151 409 416 PubMed Google Scholar Robbins, AS, Whittemore, AS, Eeden, SK 1998 Race, prostate cancer survival, and membership in a large health maintenance organization J Natl Cancer Inst 90 986 990 PubMed Google Scholar Roach, M, 3rd, Forte, D, Alexander, M 1999 Re: race, prostate cancer survival, and membership in a large health maintenance organization J Natl Cancer Inst 91 801 803 PubMed Google Scholar Kaufman, JS, Millikan, R, Poole, C, et al. 2000 Re: differences in socioeconomic status and survival among white and black men with prostate cancer Am J Epidemiol 493 152 Google Scholar Freedland, SJ, Sutter, ME, Naitoh, J, Dorey, F, Csathy, GS, Aronson, WJ 2000 Clinical characteristics in black and white men with prostate cancer in an equal access medical center Urology 55 387 390 PubMed Google Scholar Optenberg, SA, Thompson, IM, Friedrichs, P, Wojcik, B, Stein, CR, Kramer, B 1995 Race, treatment, and long-term survival from prostate cancer in an equal-access medical care delivery system JAMA 1995 1599 1605 Google Scholar Polednak, AP 2003 Black-white differences in survival from latestage prostate cancer Ethni Dis 13 220 225 Google Scholar Polednak, AP 1998 Prostate cancer treatment in black and white men: the need to consider both stage at diagnosis and socioeconomic status J Natl Med Assoc 90 101 104 PubMed Google Scholar Montie, JE, Pienta, KJ 1999 A unifying model to explain the increased incidence and higher mortality of prostate cancer in black men Urology 53 1073 1076 PubMed Google Scholar Powell, IJ, Schwartz, K, Hussain, M 1995 Removal of the financial barrier to health care: does it impact on prostate cancer at presentation and survival? A comparative study between black and white men in a Veterans Affairs system. Urology 46 825 830 PubMed Google Scholar Freedland, SJ, Jalkut, M, Dorey, F, Sutter, ME, Aronson, WJ 2000 Race is not an independent predictor of biochemical recurrence after radical prostatectomy in an equal access medical center Urology 56 87 91 PubMed Google Scholar Freedland, SJ, Sutter, ME, Naitoh, J, Dorey, F, Csathy, GS, Aronson, WJ 2000 Clinical characteristics in black and white men with prostate cancer in an equal access medical center Urology 55 387 390 PubMed Google Scholar Freeman, VL, Leszczak, J, Cooper, RS 1997 Race and the histologic grade of prostate cancer Prostate 30 79 84 PubMed Google Scholar Fowler, JE, Jr, Terrell, F 1996 Survival in blacks and whites after treatment for localized prostate cancer J Urol 156 133 136 PubMed Google Scholar Thompson, IM, Goodman, PJ, Tangen, CM, et al. 2003 The influence of finasteride on the development of prostate cancer N Engl J Med 349 215 224 PubMed Google Scholar Duffield-Lillico, AJ, Dalkin, BL, Reid, ME, et al. 2003 Selenium supplementation, baseline plasma selenium status and incidence of prostate cancer: an analysis of the complete treatment period of the Nutritional Prevention of Cancer Trial BJU Int 91 608 612 PubMed Google Scholar Heinonen, OP, Albanes, D, Virtamo, J, et al. 1998 Prostate cancer and supplementation with alpha-tocopherol and beta-carotene: incidence and mortality in a controlled trial J Natl Cancer Inst 90 440 446 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Schmitz-Drager, BJ, Eichholzer, M, Beiche, B, Ebert, T 2001 Nutrition and prostate cancer Urol Int 67 1 11 PubMed Google Scholar Blumenfeld, AJ, Fleshner, N, Casselman, B, Trachtenberg, J 2000 Nutritional aspects of prostate cancer: a review Can J Urol 7 927 935 PubMed Google Scholar Kolonel, LN, Hankin, JH, Whittemore, AS, et al. 2000 Vegetables, fruits, legumes and prostate cancer: a multiethnic case-control study Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 9 795 804 PubMed Google Scholar Whittemore, AS, Kolonel, LN, Wu, AH, et al. 1995 Prostate cancer in relation to diet, physical activity, and body size in blacks, whites, and Asians in the United States and Canada J Natl Cancer Inst 87 652 661 PubMed Google Scholar Hayes, RB, Ziegler, RG, Gridley, G, et al. 1999 Dietary factors and risks for prostate cancer among blacks and whites in the United States Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 8 25 34 PubMed Google Scholar Ross, RK, Shimizu, H, Paganini-Hill, A, Honda, G, Henderson, BE 1987 Case–control studies of prostate cancer in blacks and whites in southern California J Natl Cancer Inst 78 869 874 PubMed Google Scholar Popkin, BM, Siega-Riz, AM, Haines, PS 1996 A comparison of dietary trends among racial and socioeconomic groups in the United States N Engl J Med 335 716 720 PubMed Google Scholar
Gilligan T, Wang PS, Levin R, Kantoff PW, Avorn JA (2003) Racial disparities in prostate cancer (CaP) screening among Medicare beneficiaries in New Jersey. Proceedings of the American Society of Clinical Oncology 22.
Google Scholar Etzioni, R, Berry, KM, Legler, JM, Shaw, P 2002 Prostate-specific antigen testing in black and white men: an analysis of medicare claims from 1991 to 1998 Urology 59 251 255 PubMed Google Scholar Steele, CB, Miller, DS, Maylahn, C, Uhler, RJ, Baker, CT 2000 Knowledge, attitudes, and screening practices among older men regarding prostate cancer Am J Public Health 90 1595 1600 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Polednak, AP, Flannery, JT 1992 Black versus white racial differences in clinical stage at diagnosis and treatment of prostatic cancer in Connecticut Cancer 70 2152 2158 PubMed Google Scholar Roetzheim, RG, Pal, N, Tennant, C, et al. 1999 Effects of health insurance and race on early detection of cancer J Natl Cancer Inst 91 1409 1415 PubMed Google Scholar Oakley-Girvan, I, Kolonel, LN, Gallagher, RP, Wu, AH, Felberg, A, Whittemore, AS 2003 Stage at diagnosis and survival in a multiethnic cohort of prostate cancer patients Am J Public Health 93 1753 1759 PubMed Google Scholar deVere White, RW, Deitch, AD, Jackson, AG, et al. 1998 Racial differences in clinically localized prostate cancers of black and white men. J Urol 159 1979 1982 PubMed Google Scholar Merrill, RM, Lyon, JL 2000 Explaining the difference in prostate cancer mortality rates between white and black men in the United States Urology 55 730 735 PubMed Google Scholar Polednak, AP 2002 Black-white differences in tumor grade (aggressiveness) at diagnosis of prostate cancer, 1992–1998 Ethn Dis 12 536 540 PubMed Google Scholar Powell, IJ 1998 Prostate cancer in the African American: is this a different disease? Semin Urol Oncol 16 221 226 PubMed Google Scholar Pettaway, CA, Troncoso, P, Ramirez, EI, Johnston, DA, Steelhammer, L, Babaian, RJ 1998 Prostate specific antigen and pathological features of prostate cancer in black and white patients: a comparative study based on radical prostatectomy specimens J Urol 160 437 442 PubMed Google Scholar Polednak, AP 1997 Stage at diagnosis of prostate cancer in Connecticut by poverty and race Ethn Dis 7 215 220 PubMed Google Scholar Ndubuisi, SC, Kofie, VY, Andoh, JY, Schwartz, EM 1995 Black-white differences in the stage at presentation of prostate cancer in the District of Columbia Urology 46 71 77 PubMed Google Scholar Powell, IJ, Dey, J, Dudley, A, et al. 2002 Disease-free survival difference between African Americans and whites after radical prostatectomy for local prostate cancer: a multivariable analysis Urology 59 907 912 PubMed Google Scholar Zeliadt, SB, Penson, DF, Albertsen, PC, Concato, J, Etzioni, RD 2003 Race independently predicts prostate specific antigen testing frequency following a prostate carcinoma diagnosis Cancer 98 496 503 PubMed Google Scholar Underwood, W, Monner, S, Ubel, P, Fagerlin, A, Sanda, MG, Wei, JT 2004 Racial/ethnic disparities in the treatment of localized/regional prostate cancer J Urol 171 1504 1507 PubMed Google Scholar Horner, RD 1998 Racial variation in cancer care: a case study of prostate cancer Cancer Treat Res 97 99 114 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Imperato, PJ, Nenner, RP, Will, TO 1996 Radical prostatectomy: lower rates among African-American men J Natl Med Assoc 88 589 594 PubMed Google Scholar Schapira, MM, McAuliffe, TL, Nattinger, AB 1995 Treatment of localized prostate cancer in African-American compared with Caucasian men. Less use of aggressive therapy for comparable disease Med Care 33 1079 1088 PubMed Google Scholar Desch, CE, Penberthy, L, Newschaffer, CJ, et al. 1996 Factors that determine the treatment for local and regional prostate cancer Med Care 34 152 162 PubMed Google Scholar Harlan, L, Brawley, O, Pommerenke, F, Wali, P, Kramer, B 1995 Geographic, age, and racial variation in the treatment of local/regional carcinoma of the prostate J Clin Oncol 13 93 100 PubMed Google Scholar Lai, S, Lai, H, Krongrad, A, Lamm, S, Schwade, J, Roos, BA 2000 Radical prostatectomy: geographic and demographic variation Urology 56 108 115 PubMed Google Scholar Klabunde, CN, Potosky, AL, Harlan, LC, Kramer, BS 1998 Trends and black/white differences in treatment for nonmetastatic prostate cancer Med Care 36 1337 1348 PubMed Google Scholar Jenkins, R, Schover, LR, Fouladi, RT, et al. 2004 Sexuality and health-related quality of life after prostate cancer in African-American and white men treated for localized disease J Sex Marital Ther 30 79 93 PubMed Google Scholar Hu, JC, Elkin, EP, Pasta, DJ, et al. 2004 Predicting quality of life after radical prostatectomy: results from CaPSURE J Urol 171 703 707 PubMed Google Scholar Gotay, CC, Holup, JL, Pagano, I 2002 Ethnic differences in quality of life among early breast and prostate cancer survivors Psychoncology 11 103 113 Google Scholar Eton, DT, Lepore, SJ, Helgeson, VS 2001 Early quality of life in patients with localized prostate carcinoma: an examination of treatment-related, demographic, and psychosocial factors Cancer 92 1451 1459 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Lubeck, DP, Kim, H, Grossfeld, G, et al. 2001 Health related quality of life differences between black and white men with prostate cancer: data from the cancer of the prostate strategic urologic research endeavor J Urol 166 2281 2285 PubMed Google Scholar Thompson, I, Tangen, C, Tolcher, A, Crawford, E, Eisenberger, M, Moinpour, C 2001 Association of African-American ethnic background with survival in men with metastatic prostate cancer J Natl Cancer Inst 93 219 225 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Moul, JW, Douglas, TH, McCarthy, WF, McLeod, DG 1996 Black race is an adverse prognostic factor for prostate cancer recurrence following radical prostatectomy in an equal access health care setting J Urol 155 1667 1673 PubMed Google Scholar Pienta, KJ, Demers, R, Hoff, M, Kau, TY, Montie, JE, Severson, RK 1995 Effect of age and race on the survival of men with prostate cancer in the metropolitan Detroit tricountry area, 1973–1987 Urology 45 93 101 PubMed Google Scholar Godley, PA, Schenck, AP, Amamoo, MA, et al. 2003 Racial differences in mortality among Medicare recipients after treatment for localized prostate cancer J Natl Cancer Inst 95 1702 1710 PubMed Google Scholar Roach, M, 3rd, Lu, J, Pilepich, MV, Asbell, SO, Mohiuddin, M, Grignon, D 2003 Race and survival of men treated for prostate cancer on radiation therapy oncology group phase III randomized trials J Urol 169 245 250 PubMed Google Scholar
Halabi S, Gilligan T, Vogelzang N, Barrier R, George S, Small E (2004) The Impact of Race On Survival in Men With Metastatic Hormone Refractory Prostate Cancer. J Urol (in press).
Google Scholar Liu, L, Cozen, W, Bernstein, L, Ross, RK, Deapen, D 2001 Changing relationship between socioeconomic status and prostate cancer incidence J Natl Cancer Inst 93 705 709 PubMed Google Scholar Lund Nilsen, TI, Johnsen, R, Vatten, LJ 2000 Socioeconomic and lifestyle factors associated with the risk of prostate cancer Br J Cancer 82 1358 1363 PubMed Google Scholar Hemminki, K, Li, X 2003 Level of education and the risk of cancer in Sweden Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 12 796 802 PubMed Google Scholar Krstev, S, Baris, D, Stewart, PA, Hayes, RB, Blair, A, Dosemeci, M 1998 Risk for prostate cancer by occupation and industry: a 24-state death certificate study Am J Ind Med 34 413 420 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar
Gilligan T, Wang P, Levin R, Kantoff PW, Avorn J (2004) Racial differences in screening for prostate cancer in the elderly. Arch Internal Med (in Press).
Google Scholar Conlisk, EA, Lengerich, EJ, Demark-Wahnefried, W, Schildkraut, JM, Aldrich, TE 1999 Prostate cancer: demographic and behavioral correlates of stage at diagnosis among blacks and whites in North Carolina Urology 53 1194 1199 PubMed Google Scholar Tarman, GJ, Kane, CJ, Moul, JW, et al. 2000 Impact of socioeconomic status and race on clinical parameters of patients undergoing radical prostatectomy in an equal access health care system Urology 56 1016 1020 PubMed Google Scholar Harvei, S, Kravdal, O 1997 The importance of marital and socioeconomic status in incidence and survival of prostate cancer. An analysis of complete Norwegian birth cohorts Prev Med 26 623 632 PubMed Google Scholar Gorey, KM, Holowaty, EJ, Fehringer, G, Laukkanen, E, Richter, NL, Meyer, CM 2000 An international comparison of cancer survival: metropolitan Toronto, Ontario, and Honolulu, Hawaii Am J Public Health 90 1866 1872 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Penson, DF, Stoddard, ML, Pasta, DJ, Lubeck, DP, Flanders, SC, Litwin, MS 2001 The association between socioeconomic status, health insurance coverage, and quality of life in men with prostate cancer J Clin Epidemiol 54 350 358 PubMed Google Scholar Penson, DF, Litwin, MS, Lubeck, DP, Flanders, S, Pasta, DJ, Carroll, PR 1998 Transitions in health-related quality of life during the first nine months after diagnosis with prostate cancer Prostate Cancer Prostatic Dis 1 134 143 PubMed Google Scholar Polednak, AP 1990 Cancer mortality in a higher-income black population in New York State. Comparison with rates in the United States as a whole Cancer 66 1654 1660 PubMed Google Scholar Swan, J, Breen, N, Coates, RJ, Rimer, BK, Lee, NC 2003 Progress in cancer screening practices in the United States: results from the 2000 National Health Interview Survey Cancer 97 1528 1540 PubMed Google Scholar Moinpour, CM, Lovato, LC, Thompson, IM, et al. Jr, 2000 Profile of men randomized to the prostate cancer prevention trial: baseline health-related quality of life, urinary and sexual functioning, and health behaviors J Clin Oncol 18 1942 1953 PubMed Google Scholar Feychting, M, Osterlund, B, Ahlbom, A 1998 Reduced cancer incidence among the blind Epidemiology 9 490 494 PubMed Google Scholar Kiss, A, Meryn, S 2001 Effect of sex and gender on psychosocial aspects of prostate and breast cancer BMJ 323 1055 1058 PubMed Google Scholar Stansbury, JP, Mathewson-Chapman, M, Grant, KE 2003 Gender schema and prostate cancer: veterans’ cultural model of masculinity Med Anthropol 22 175 204 PubMed Google Scholar Shimizu, H, Ross, RK, Bernstein, L, Yatani, R, Henderson, BE, Mack, TM 1991 Cancers of the prostate and breast among Japanese and white immigrants in Los Angeles Country Br J Cancer 63 963 966 PubMed Google Scholar Moradi, T, Delfino, RJ, Bergstrom, SR, Yu, ES, Adami, HO, Yuen, J 1998 Cancer risk among Scandinavian immigrants in the US and Scandinavian residents compared with US whites, 1973–1989 Eur J Cancer Prev 7 117 125 PubMed Google Scholar Singh, GK, Siahpush, M 2001 All-cause and cause-specific mortality of immigrants and native born in the United States Am J Public Health 91 392 399 PubMed Google Scholar Merrill, RM 2001 Demographics and health-related factors of men receiving prostate-specific antigen screening in Utah Prev Med 33 646 652 PubMed Google Scholar Moran, WP, Cohen, SJ, Preisser, JS, Wofford, JL, Shelton, BJ, McClatchey, MW 2000 Factors influencing use of the prostate-specific antigen screening test in primary care Am J Manag Care 6 315 324 PubMed Google Scholar McWilliams, JM, Zaslavsky, AM, Meara, E, Ayanian, JZ 2003 Impact of Medicare coverage on basic clinical services for previously uninsured adults JAMA 290 757 764 PubMed Google Scholar McDavid, K, Tucker, TC, Sloggett, A, Coleman, MP 2003 Cancer survival in Kentucky and health insurance coverage Arch Intern Med 163 2135 2144 PubMed Google Scholar Kane, CJ, Lubeck, DP, Knight, SJ, et al. 2003 Impact of patient educational level on treatment for patients with prostate cancer: data from CaPSURE Urology 62 1035 1039 PubMed Google Scholar Bennett, CL, Ferreira, MR, Davis, TC, et al. 1998 Relation between literacy, race, and stage of presentation among low-income patients with prostate cancer J Clin Oncol 16 3101 3104 PubMed Google Scholar Steenland, K, Henley, J, Thun, M 2002 All-cause and cause-specific death rates by educational status for two million people in two American Cancer Society cohorts, 1959–1996 Am J Epidemiol 156 11 21 PubMed Google Scholar Settimi, L, Comba, P, Bosia, S, et al. 2001 Cancer risk among male farmers: a multi-site case–control study Int J Occupational Med Environ health 14 339 347 Google Scholar Andersson, SO, Baron, J, Wolk, A, Lindgren, C, Bergstrom, R, Adami, HO 1995 Early life risk factors for prostate cancer: a population-based case-control study in Sweden Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 4 187 192 PubMed Google Scholar Gulden, JW, Kolk, JJ, Verbeek, AL 1994 Socioeconomic status, urbanization grade, and prostate cancer Prostate 25 59 65 PubMed Google Scholar Liff, JM, Chow, WH, Greenberg, RS 1991 Rural-urban differences in stage at diagnosis. Possible relationship to cancer screening. Cancer 67 1454 1459 PubMed Google Scholar Harlan, L, Brawley, O, Pommerenke, F, Wali, P, Kramer, B 1995 Geographic, age, and racial variation in the treatment of local/regional carcinoma of the prostate J Clinical Oncology 13 93 100 Google Scholar Powell, TM, Thompsen, JP, Virgo, KS, et al. 2000 Geographic variation in patient surveillance after radical prostatectomy Ann Surg Oncol 7 339 345 PubMed Google Scholar Lai, S, Lai, H, Krongrad, A, Roos, BA 2001 Overall and disease-specific survival after radical prostatectomy: geographic uniformity Urology 57 504 509 PubMed Google Scholar Yang, CY, Hsieh, YL 1998 The relationship between population density and cancer mortality in Taiwan Japanese J Cancer Res 89 355 360 Google Scholar Sakr, WA, Grignon, DJ, Crissman, JD, et al. 1994 High grade prostatic intraepithelial neoplasia (HGPIN) and prostatic adenocarcinoma between the ages of 20-69: an autopsy study of 249 cases In Vivo 8 439 443 PubMed Google Scholar Sanchez-Chapado, M, Olmedilla, G, Cabeza, M, Donat, E, Ruiz, A 2003 Prevalence of prostate cancer and prostatic intraepithelial neoplasia in Caucasian Mediterranean males: an autopsy study Prostate 54 238 247 PubMed Google Scholar Lu-Yao, G, Stukel, TA, Yao, SL 2003 Prostate-specific antigen screening in elderly men J Natl Cancer Inst 95 1792 1797 PubMed Google Scholar Schwartz, KL, Alibhai, SM, Tomlinson, G, Naglie, G, Krahn, MD 2003 Continued undertreatment of older men with localized prostate cancer Urology 62 860 865 PubMed Google Scholar Neulander, EZ, Duncan, RC, Tiguert, R, Posey, JT, Soloway, MS 2000 Deferred treatment of localized prostate cancer in the elderly: the impact of the age and stage at the time of diagnosis on the treatment decision BJU Int 85 699 704 PubMed Google Scholar Huguenin, PU, Bitterli, M, Lutolf, UM, Bernhard, J, Glanzmann, C 1999 Localized prostate cancer in elderly patients. Outcome after radiation therapy compared to matched younger patients Strahlentherapie und Onkologie 175 554 558 PubMed Google Scholar Eapen, L, Villeneuve, PJ, Levy, IG, Morrison, HI 1998 Comorbid survival among elderly male participants of the Canada health survey: relevance to prostate cancer screening and treatment Chronic Diseases in Canada 19 84 90 PubMed Google Scholar Alibhai, SM, Naglie, G, Nam, R, Trachtenberg, J, Krahn, MD 2003 Do older men benefit from curative therapy of localized prostate cancer J Clin Oncol 21 3318 3327 PubMed Google Scholar Etzioni, R, Penson, DF, Legler, JM, et al. 2002 Overdiagnosis due to prostate-specific antigen screening: lessons from US prostate cancer incidence trends J Natl Cancer Inst 94 981 990 PubMed Google Scholar