Rekindling Union Democracy Through the Use of Sortition
There is a long-standing and growing interest in democratizing labor unions. Union democracy is important for many reasons, including fostering greater member voice in the workplace and society, improving the internal effectiveness of unions, building members’ capacities to engage in democracy in other contexts, and helping foster union renewal. Despite these benefits, democracy in unions as practiced today is characterized by several problems. In this paper, I analyze several of the remedies to increase union democracy proposed to date by scholars and practitioners, finding that despite their potential positive impacts, many of them may have inherent limitations. I then argue that sortition—the use of lotteries in selecting leaders—shows potential in helping address many of the problems facing union democracy and overcoming the limitations of recent remedies. An important democratic tool in Ancient Athens and other city-states, sortition has a long history in political theory and practice, yet application to unions is in its infancy. I conclude by developing and evaluating several ways in which sortition could be used as a tool in union governance structures, and by discussing the implications of my theorizing for ongoing work on union democracy and union renewal.
KeywordsUnion democracy Union governance Workplace democracy Demarchy Sortition Union renewal
I would like to thank the editor, Edmund Byrne, and the three anonymous reviewers for their very thoughtful and constructive engagement with this paper. I would also like to thank Adam Cronkright, Tao Wang, Brandon Froh, Armando Martins, Francisco Brahm, and participants at the 2017 Sustainability, Ethics, and Entrepreneurship Conference for their feedback on earlier versions of this paper.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of interest
- Alexander, R. (2006). “Unity, democracy, militancy”: New trade union initiative launched in India. Labor Notes. 2006/09/%E2%80%98unity-democracy-militancy%E2%80%99-new-trade-union-initiative-launched-india. Accessed 17 March 2017.Google Scholar
- Barling, J., Fullager, C., & Kelloway, E. K. (1992). The union and its members: A psychological approach. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Benson, H. (1986). The fight for union democracy. In S. M. Lipset (Ed.), Unions in transition: Entering the second century (pp. 323–370). San Francisco, CA: Institute for Contemporary Studies.Google Scholar
- Brown, E. (2015). Two teachers explain why they want to take down their union. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/education/wp/2015/08/11/two-teachers-explain-why-they-want-to-take-down-their-union/. Accessed 8 April 2016.
- Burnheim, J. (1985). Is democracy possible?. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Can Public Employees be Forced to Pay Union Dues? (2016). The economist. http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2016/01/labour-pains. Accessed 8 April 2016.
- Carson, L., & Martin, B. (1999). Random selection in politics. Westport, CT: Praeger.Google Scholar
- City of Toronto. (2016). Introducing the inaugural Toronto planning review panel. https://www1.toronto.ca/City%20Of%20Toronto/City%20Planning/Planning%20Review%20Panel/Downloads/TPRP_Guiding%20Values_Web.pdf. Accessed 21 April 2016.
- de Jong, G., & van Witteloostuijn, A. (2004). Successful corporate democracy: Sustainable cooperation of capital and labor in the Dutch Breman Group. The Academy of Management Executive (1993–2005), 18(3), 54–66.Google Scholar
- Dibben, P. (2004). Social movement unionism. In M. Harcourt & G. Wood (Eds.), Trade unions and democracy: Strategies and perspectives (pp. 280–302). Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
- Eisenscher, M. (1999). Critical juncture: Unionism at the crossroads. In B. Nissen (Ed.), Which direction for organized labor? Essays on organizing, outreach, and internal transformations. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.Google Scholar
- Emery, F. E. (1989). Toward real democracy and toward real democracy: Further problems. Toronto, ON: Ontario Quality of Working Life Centre.Google Scholar
- Fairbrother, P., & Yates, C. A. B. (2003). Unions in crisis, unions in renewal? In P. Fairbrother & C. A. B. Yates (Eds.), Trade unions in renewal: A comparative study (pp. 1–31). London: Continuum.Google Scholar
- Flynn, M., Brewster, C., Smith, R., & Rigby, M. (2004). Trade union democracy: The dynamics of different forms. In M. Harcourt & G. Wood (Eds.), Trade unions and democracy: Strategies and perspectives (pp. 319–351). Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
- Freeman, R. B., & Rogers, J. (2006). What workers want (2nd ed.). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
- Frey, B. S., & Steiner, L. (2014). God does not play dice, but people should: Random selection in politics, science and society. Working paper. University of Zurich. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2407896. Accessed 9 April 2016.
- Goldberg, M. J. (2002). Derailing union democracy: Why deregulation would be a mistake. Berkeley Journal of Employment and Labor Law, 23, 137–148.Google Scholar
- Goldberg, M. J. (2008). In the cause of union democracy. Suffolk University Law Review, 41, 8–69.Google Scholar
- Goodall, A. H., & Osterloh, M. (2015). Women have to enter the leadership race to win: Using random selection to increase the supply of women into senior positions. Working paper. Institute for the Study of Labor. Accessed 7 May 2015.Google Scholar
- Hansen, M. H. (1991). The Athenian democracy in the age of Demosthenes: Structure, principles, and ideology. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
- Hochner, A., Koziara, K., & Schmidt, S. (1980). Thinking about democracy and participation in unions. In Proceedings of the 32nd annual meeting of the industrial relations research association. Madison, WI: Industrial Relations Research Association.Google Scholar
- Hyman, R. (1994). Changing trade union identities and strategies. In R. Hyman & A. Ferner (Eds.), New frontiers in European industrial relations (pp. 108–139). Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
- Kohler, T. C. (1995). Civic virtue at work: Unions as seedbeds of the civic virtues. Boston College Law Review, 36, 279.Google Scholar
- Langford, T. (2015). Union democracy as a foundation for a participatory society: A theoretical elaboration and historical example. Labour/Le Travail, 76, 79–108.Google Scholar
- Lévesque, C., & Murray, G. (2002). Local versus global: Activating local union power in the global economy. Labor Studies Journal, 27(3), 39–65.Google Scholar
- Lipset, S. M. (1986). Labor unions in the public mind. In S. M. Lipset (Ed.), Unions in transition: Entering the second century (pp. 287–321). San Francisco, CA: Institute for Contemporary Studies.Google Scholar
- Oxenbridge, S. (2003). A story of crisis and change: The Service and Food workers Union of Aotearoa. In P. Fairbrother & C. A. B. Yates (Eds.), Trade unions in renewal: A comparative study (pp. 135–157). London: Continuum.Google Scholar
- Peetz, D., & Ollett, N. (2004). Union growth and reversal in newly industrialized countries: The case of South Korea and peripheral Workers. In M. Harcourt & G. Wood (Eds.), Trade unions and democracy: Strategies and perspectives (pp. 211–240). Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
- Petruska, B. (2003). Choosing competition: A proposal to modify article XX of the AFL-CIO constitution. Hofstra Labor and Employment Law Journal, 21, 1–60.Google Scholar
- Powley, E. H., Fry, R. E., Barrett, F. J., & Bright, D. S. (2004). Dialogic democracy meets command and control: Transformation through the appreciative inquiry summit. The Academy of Management Executive, 18(3), 67–80.Google Scholar
- Schenk, C. (2003). Social movement unionism: Beyond the organizing model. In P. Fairbrother & C. A. B. Yates (Eds.), Trade unions in renewal: A comparative study (pp. 244–262). London: Continuum.Google Scholar
- Snider, J. H. (2007). From Dahl to O’Leary: 36 Years of the “Yale School of Democratic Reform”. Journal of Public Deliberation, 3(1), 9.Google Scholar
- Summers, C. W. (1984). Democracy in a one-party state: Perspectives from Landrum-Griffin. Maryland Law Review, 43, 93.Google Scholar
- Tattersall, A. (2010). Power in coalition: Strategies for strong unions and social change. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Accessed 6 March 2017.Google Scholar
- Thompson, G. (2006, May 6). Mexican mine disaster brings charges of collusion. The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2006/05/06/world/americas/06mexico.html. Accessed 27 March 2017.
- UAW. (2015). UAW constitution. UAW. https://uaw.org/uaw-constitution/. Accessed 17 March 2017.
- Vergne, A. (2010). A brief survey of the literature of sortition: Is the age of sortition upon us? In G. Delannoi & O. Dowlen (Eds.), Sortition: Theory and pactice (pp. 69–87). Exeter: Imprint Academic.Google Scholar
- Voss, K., & Sherman, R. (2003). You just can’t do it automatically: The transition to social movement unionism in the United States. In P. Fairbrother & C. A. B. Yates (Eds.), Trade unions in renewal: A comparative study (pp. 51–77). London: Continuum.Google Scholar
- Wood, G. (2004). Trade unions and theories of democracy. In M. Harcourt & G. Wood (Eds.), Trade unions and democracy (pp. 19–39). Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar