Advertisement

Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 128, Issue 3, pp 585–601 | Cite as

Two Forms of Virtue Ethics: Two Sets of Virtuous Action in the Fire Service Dispute?

  • David DawsonEmail author
Article

Abstract

There has been increasing interest in the relevance of virtue approaches to ethics over the past 15 years. However, debate surrounding the virtue approach in the business, management and organisational studies literature has lacked progress. First, this literature focuses on a narrow range of philosophers, and, second, it has failed to analyse properly the consequences of virtue theory for action in practical settings other than in abstract terms. In order to begin addressing these issues, this paper compares what two virtue frameworks—one focused on virtue in the context of community and the other on individuals as virtuous agents—lead to when evaluating the actions of parties to the 2002–2004 UK Fire Service dispute. The analysis argues that the virtue frameworks proposed by MacIntyre and Slote offer different but complimentary evaluations. Both not only point to potential problems with industrial disputes, but also recognise the legitimacy of action that is based in good motivations and carried out with regard for the virtues. It seems that fire fighters and their immediate supervisors, on the whole, met the conditions of virtue, but that it is open to question if the leaders of the Fire Brigades Union and the Government did the same. The analysis goes on to suggest which modes of negotiation would be acceptable under the virtue frameworks, and the implications for those involved in industrial dispute.

Keywords

Business ethics Employee relations Fire fighters Industrial action MacIntyre Negotiation Slote Strike Virtue ethics 

References

  1. Abelson, J., & Gouvin, F. (2006). Assessing the impacts of public participation: Concepts, evidence and policy implications. Ottawa: Canadian Policy Research Networks.Google Scholar
  2. Ackers, P., & Payne, J. (1998). British trade unions and social partnership: Rhetoric, reality and strategy. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 9(3), 529–550.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Addley, E. (2002, October 18). Real lives: Feeling the heat. The Guardian (London), p. 4.Google Scholar
  4. Athanassoulis, N. (2000). A response to Harman: Virtue ethics and character traits. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 100, 215–222.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Audi, R. (2012). Virtue ethics as a resource in business. Business Ethics Quarterly, 22(2), 273–291.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bacon, N., & Storey, J. (2000). New employee relations strategies in Britain: Towards individualism or partnership? British Journal of Industrial Relations., 38(3), 407–427.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bain, G., Lyons, M., & Young, A. (2002). The future of the fire service reducing risk, saving lives: The independent review of the fire service december 2002. London: Office of the Deputy Prime Minister.Google Scholar
  8. BBC. (2003). Firefighters’ mixed emotions. Retrieved July 28, 2004 from www.BBC.co.uk 12 July.
  9. Beadle, R. (2001). MacIntyre and the amorality of management. Paper presented at the second international conference of critical management studies. Manchester: UMIST.Google Scholar
  10. Beadle, R. (2002). The misappropriation of MacIntyre. Reason in Practice, 2(2), 45–54.Google Scholar
  11. Beadle, R. (2013). Managerial work in a practice-embodying institution: The role of calling, the virtue of constancy. Journal of Business Ethics, 113, 679–690.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Bertland, A. (2009). Virtue ethics in business and the capabilities approach. Journal of Business Ethics, 84, 25–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Bouvaird, T. (2007). Beyond engagement and participation: User and community coproduction of public services. Public Administration Review, 67(5), 846–860.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Brennan, J. (2012). For-profit business as civic virtue. Journal of Business Ethics, 106(3), 313–324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Bull, C., & Adam, A. (2011). Virtue ethics and customer relationship management: Towards a more holistic approach for the development of ‘best practice’. Business Ethics: A European Review, 20(2), 121–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Burchill, F. (2004). The UK Fire Service Dispute. Employee Relations, 26(4), 404–421.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Charter, D., Hurst, G., & Buckley, C. (2002, October 24). Fire union in all-night talks on strike. The Times (London), p. 1.Google Scholar
  18. Chun, R. (2005). Ethical character and virtue of organizations: An empirical assessment and strategic implications. Journal of Business Ethics, 57, 269–284.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Clarke, S. G., & Simpson, E. (1989). Anti-theory in ethics and moral conservatism. New York: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
  20. Collett, B. (2003). Behind the scenes of the fire dispute. Retrieved July 26, 2004, from www.findarticles.com.
  21. Darley, J. (1973). From Jerusalem to Jericho: A study of situational and dispositional variables in helping behaviour. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  22. Dawson, D., & Bartholomew, C. (2003). Virtues, managers and business people: Finding a place for MacIntyre in a business context. Journal of Business Ethics, 48, 127–138.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Dobson, J. (1997). Virtue ethics as a foundation for business ethics: A MacIntyre based critique. Unpublished paper presented at the second international symposium on Catholic Social Thought and Management Education, University of Antwerp, Belgium.Google Scholar
  24. Doris, J. (1998). Persons, situations, and virtue ethics. Nous, 32(4), 504–530.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Dunlop, J. (1958). Industrial relations systems. New York: Holt Dryden.Google Scholar
  26. Dunn, J. (2003). Arguing for teaching as practice: A reply to Alasdair MacIntyre. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 37(2), 353–369.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Fire Brigades Union. (2003a). Strike dates. Retrieved July 26, 2004, from www.fbu.org.uk.
  28. Fire Brigades Union. (2003b). Recall conference news. Retrieved July 26, 2004, from www.fbu.org.uk 12 June.
  29. Fire Brigades Union (2004a). Press release: FBU recommend ballot for industrial action over continued refusal to honour pay deal. Retrieved July 26, 2004, from www.fbu.org.uk 9 June.
  30. Fire Service Pay and Conditions Agreement 2003.Google Scholar
  31. Fitzgerald, I., & Stirling, J. (1999). A slow burning flame? Organisational change and industrial relations in the fire service. Industrial Relations Journal, 30(1), 46–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Foot, P. (2001). Natural goodness. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Foot, P. (2002a). Virtues and vices and other essays in moral philosophy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  34. Foot, P. (2002b). Moral dilemmas. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Gastil, J. (2000). By popular demand. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  36. Gillan, A. (2002, September 7). Fires, chemicals, road crashes, water rescues, terrorism—all for £22,400 a year: Why blue watch is hot enough under the collar to strike. The Guardian (London), p. 9.Google Scholar
  37. Harman, G. (2000). The nonexistence of character traits. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 100, 223–226.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Harman, G. (2003). No character or personality. Business Ethics Quarterly, 13(1), 87–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Haynes, P., & Allen, M. (2001). Partnership as union strategy: A preliminary evaluation. Employee Relations, 23(2), 164–187.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Howell, C. (2004). Is there a third way for industrial relations? British Journal of Industrial Relations, 42(1), 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Hursthouse, R. (1999). On virtue ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  42. Income Data Services. (2003). Pay Report 893, November.Google Scholar
  43. Johnstone, S., Ackers, P., & Wilkinson., A. (2009). The British partnership phenomenon: A ten year review. Human Resource Management Journal, 19(3), 260–279.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Johnstone, S., Wilkinson, A., & Ackers, P. (2010). Critical incidents of partnership: Five years’ experience at NatBank. Industrial Relations Journal, 41(4), 382–398.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Koehn, D. (1998). Virtue ethics, the firm, and moral psychology. Business Ethics Quarterly, 8(3), 497–513.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Louden, R. B. (1984). On some vices of virtue ethics. American Philosophical Quarterly, 21(3), 227–236.Google Scholar
  47. MacIntyre, A. (1985). After virtue. London: Duckworth.Google Scholar
  48. MacIntyre, A. (1988). Whose justice? Which rationality?. London: Duckworth.Google Scholar
  49. MacIntyre, A. (1990). Three rival versions of moral enquiry. London: Duckworth.Google Scholar
  50. MacIntyre, A. (1999). Dependant rational animals. Chicago: Open Court.Google Scholar
  51. MacIntyre, A., & Dunne, J. (2002). Alisdair MacIntyre on education: In dialogue with Joseph Dunne. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 36(1), 1–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Maguire, K. (2002a, April 18). Fire union to end no-strike accord: Winter of industrial turmoil threatened over pay claim. The Guardian (London), p. 5.Google Scholar
  53. Maguire, K. (2002b, October 19). Fire crews in 36 days of strikes: Nine to one vote backs action for 40% pay rise. The Guardian (London), p. 1.Google Scholar
  54. Maguire, K. (2002c, November 14). Bitter start to fire strike: Night watch at 6 pm yesterday walked out for first time in 25 years. The Guardian (London), p. 1.Google Scholar
  55. Maguire, K., & White M. (2002, December 3). Fire strike off for new peace talks: Union denies weakened resolve after shock move. The Guardian (London), p. 1.Google Scholar
  56. Maguire, K. (2003a, March 18). Fire walkout on hold as train strikes loom: Union reconsiders stoppages fearing tabloid backlash. The Guardian (London), p. 15.Google Scholar
  57. Maguire, K. (2003b, March 19). Fire union chiefs back new offer: Strike due to start tomorrow called off. The Guardian (London), p. 12.Google Scholar
  58. Maguire, K. (2004a, May 20). Strike threat as fire crews take action: Many brigades turn out for emergency calls only after greater Manchester colleagues suspended in lingering pay and duties dispute. The Guardian (London), p. 6.Google Scholar
  59. Maguire, K. (2004b, August 26). Two-year fire dispute ends. The Guardian (London), p. 5.Google Scholar
  60. Maitland, I. (1997). Virtuous markets: The market as school of the virtues. Business Ethics Quarterly, 7(1), 17–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. McPherson, D. (2013). Vocational virtue ethics: Prospects for a virtue ethic approach to business. Journal of Business Ethics, 116, 283–296.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Milgram, S. (1974). Obedience and Authority. New York: Harper Row.Google Scholar
  63. Moore, G. (2002). On the implications of the practice institution distinction: MacIntyre and the application of modern virtue ethics to business. Business Ethics Quarterly, 12(1), 19–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Moore, G. (2003). Hives and horseshoes, Mintzberg or MacIntyre: What future for corporate social responsibility. Business Ethics: A European Review, 12(1), 41–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Moore, G. (2005). Humanizing business: A modern virtue ethics approach. Business Ethics Quarterly, 15(2), 237–255.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Moore, G. (2012). The virtue of governance, the governance of virtue. Business Ethics Quarterly, 22(2), 293–318.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Moore, G. (2013). Re-imagining the morality of management: A modern virtue ethics approach. In H. Harris, G. Wijesinghe, & S. McKenzie (Eds.), The heart of the good institution: Virtue ethics as a framework for responsible management. Netherlands: Springer.Google Scholar
  68. Morse, J. (1999). The missing link between virtue theory and business ethics. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 16(1), 47–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Provis, C. (2013). Judgement, virtue and social practice. In H. Harris, G. Wijesinghe, & S. McKenzie (Eds.), The heart of the good institution: Virtue ethics as a framework for responsible management. Netherlands: Springer.Google Scholar
  70. Randels, G. (1998). The contingency of business: Narrative, metaphor, and ethics. Journal of Business Ethics, 17, 1299–1310.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Robbins, M., Simonsen, B., & Feldman, B. (2008). Citizens and resource allocation: Improving decision making with interactive web-based citizen participation. Public Administration Review, 68(3), 564–575.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Robinson, B., Stey, P., & Alfano, M. (2013). Virtue and vice attributions in the business context: An experimental investigation. Journal of Business Ethics, 113, 649–661.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Schneewind, J. B. (1990). The misfortunes of virtue. Ethics, 101, 42–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Scott, K. (2003, November 5). Fears of full-Scale fire strike grow: Wildcat action spreads over plan to pay only half of agreed rise. The Guardian (London), p. 2.Google Scholar
  75. Shaw, B. (1997). Sources of virtue: The market and the community. Business Ethics Quarterly, 7(1), 33–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Sherman, J. (2002, September 5). Fire safety campaign may breach strike ballot rules. The Times (London), p. 12.Google Scholar
  77. Sherman, J. (2003, January 28) Fire strikes have cost Prescott’s department £70 million. The Times (London), p. 10.Google Scholar
  78. Sherman, J., Buckley, C., & Webster, P. (2002, December 3). Fire strike is suspended as union’s hard line crumbles. The Times (London), p. 1.Google Scholar
  79. Slote, M. (1996). From morality to virtue. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  80. Slote, M. (2001). Morals from motives. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Solomon, R. (1992). Ethics and excellence: Co-operation and integrity in business. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  82. Solomon, R. (2003). Victims of circumstances. Business Ethics Quarterly, 13(1), 43–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Sreenivasan, G. (2002). Errors about errors: Virtue theory and trait attribution. Mind, 110(441), 47–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Sundman, P. (2000). The good manager—a moral manager? Journal of Business Ethics, 27, 247–254.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Swanton, C. (2001). A virtue ethical account of right action. Ethics, 112(1), 32–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Swanton, C. (2003). Virtue ethics: A pluralistic view. London: Clarendon Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. The Guardian (2003, January 13). Comment and analysis—do not play with fire: Fresh strikes are in no ones interest. The Guardian (London), p. 19. Google Scholar
  88. Undy, R. (1999). Annual review article: New labour’s industrial relations settlement: The third way? British Journal of Industrial Relations, 37(2), 315–336.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Warren, R. (1996). The empty company: Morality and job security. Personnel Review, 25(6), 41–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Whetstone, J. T. (2003). The language of managerial excellence: Virtues as understood and applied. Journal of Business Ethics, 44(4), 343–357.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. White, M., & Maguire, K. (2002, December 2). Minister raises heat in fire strike: Troops ‘modernised’ role angers union. The Guardian (London), p. 1.Google Scholar
  92. Yang, K., & Pandey, S. (2011). Further dissecting the black box of citizen participation: When does citizen involvement lead to good outcomes? Public Administration Review, 71(6), 880–892.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.The Business SchoolUniversity of GloucestershireCheltenhamUK

Personalised recommendations