Roche’s Clinical Trials with Organs from Prisoners: Does Profit Trump Morals?
- 819 Downloads
This case study discusses the economic, legal, and ethical considerations for conducting clinical trials in a controversial context. In 2010, pharmaceutical giant Roche received a shame award by the Swiss non-governmental organization Berne Declaration and Greenpeace for conducting clinical trials with organs taken from executed prisoners in China. The company respected local regulations and industry ethical standards. However, medical associations condemned organs from executed prisoners on moral grounds. Human rights organizations demanded that Roche ended its clinical trials in China immediately. Students are expected to review the economic and ethical issues regarding the outsourcing of clinical trials to controversial human rights contexts, and discuss how to make business decisions when there are conflicts between making profit and ethical considerations. Was Roche complicit in the human rights violations that were related to its clinical trials? Future patients might benefit from these clinical trials. Do profit and the greater good, in general, trump morals?
KeywordsHuman rights Roche China Clinical trials Organ transplantation
The author wishes to thank Guido Palazzo for his invaluable assistance in the case study, and members of the Berne Declaration and Amnesty International for their support during the work on the case study.
- Actares. (2008a). ACTARES befragt Roche zu menschenrechtswidrigen Transplantationen in China [ACTARES asks Roche about human rights violations related to transplantations in China]. http://www.actares.ch/de/index.php/news/article/transplants-against-the-human-rights-in-china/. Retrieved 19 December 2012.
- Actares. (2008b). Transplantationen in China unter Verdacht [Transplantations in China under scrutiny]. ACTARES – Info, 17, 5.Google Scholar
- Amnesty International. (2010a). Annual Report: China 2010. Retrieved 9 December 2011, from http://www.amnestyusa.org/research/reports/annual-report-china-2010.
- Amnesty International. (2010b). Death sentences and executions 2009. Retrieved 10 December 2011, from http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/ACT50/001/2010/en/17348b70-3fc7-40b2-a258-af92778c73e5/act500012010en.pdf.
- Amnesty International. (2011). Annual Report: China 2011. Retrieved 18 December 2012, from http://www.amnestyusa.org/research/reports/annual-report-china-2011?page=show.
- ASN Bank. (2010). Annual Report 2010.Google Scholar
- Bradsher, K. (2012, March 24). China moves to stop transplants of organs after executions. The New York Times, A7.Google Scholar
- Bryskine, S. (2012). Governments Must End Organ Harvesting, Says Nobel Prize Nominee. The Epoch Times. Retrieved 18 December, 2012, from http://www.theepochtimes.com/n2/australia/governments-must-end-organ-harvesting-says-nobel-prize-nominee-314866.html.
- Clapham, A., & Jerbi, S. (2001). Categories of corporate complicity in human rights abuses. Hastings International and Comparative Law Review, 24, 339–349.Google Scholar
- Einhorn, B., & Arndt, M. (2008). The rush to test drugs in China, Business Week. Retrieved 7 December 2011, from http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/07_22/b4036076.htm.
- European Medicines Agency. (2002). ICH Topic E 6 (R1) Guideline for Good Clinical Practice. Retrieved 9 December 2011, from http://www.emea.europa.eu/docs/en_GB/document_library/Scientific_guideline/2009/09/WC500002874.pdf.
- Harney, A. (2009). The China price. The true cost of Chinese competitive advantage. London: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
- International Conference on Harmonization. (2002). Guideline for Good Clinical Practice. Retrieved 10 December 2011, from http://www.emea.europa.eu/pdfs/human/ich/013595en.pdf.
- Keller, M. (2010). Transplanation. Woher stammen die Organe? [Transplantation. Where do the organs come from?]. Zeit Online. Retrieved 18 December 2012, from http://www.zeit.de/2010/04/Pharmakonzern-Roche.
- Kilgour, D. (2012). Ending organ pillaging in China. Retrieved 18 December 2012, from www.david-kilgour.com/2012/David_speech_10252012.pdf.
- Koller, F. (2010). Appel à clarifier les prélèvements d’organes sur des prisonniers en Chine [Call to clarify harvesting organs from prisoners in China]. Le Temps. Retrieved 21 December 2012, from http://www.letemps.ch/Page/Uuid/72759116-a71a-11df-aeb8-0c7af7c72949/Appel_%C3%A0_clarifier_les_pr%C3%A9l%C3%A8vements_dorganes_sur_des_prisonniers_en_Chine#.UNTLsLY1bmY.
- Matas, D. (2008). Organ harvesting of Falun gong practitioners in china: An update. Retrieved 10 December 2011, from www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/cat/docs/ngos/II_China_41.pdf.
- Matas, D. (2012). Anti-rejection drug trials and sales in China. Retrieved 18 December 2012, from www.david-kilgour.com/2012/Matas_07082012.pdf.
- Matas, D. & Kilgour, D. (2006). Report into allegations of organ harvesting of Falun Gong practitioners in China. Retrieved 18 December 2012, from http://organharvestinvestigation.net/report20060706.htm.
- Matas, D., & Kilgour, D. (2009). Bloody harvest: Organ harvesting of Falun Gong practitioners in China. Woodstock: Seraphim Editions.Google Scholar
- Novartis. (2011). Clinical trials in developing countries. Retrieved 20 December, 2012, from www.novartis.com/.../clinical-trials-developing-markets.pdf.
- Phillips, T. (2012). Chinese organ trafficking ring dismantled. The Telegraph. Retrieved 20 December 2012, from http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/china/9453357/Chinese-organ-trafficking-ring-dismantled.html.
- Recht ohne Grenzen, (2010). Fallbeispiel: Roche [Case: Roche]. Retrieved 18 December 2012, from www.rechtohnegrenzen.ch/media/medialibrary/2011/11/fallbsp_4_roche_111010.pdf.
- Roberts, D. (2009). Novartis Unveils $1.25 Billion China Investment. Businessweek. Retrieved 18 December 2012, from http://www.businessweek.com/globalbiz/content/nov2009/gb2009113_520982.htm.
- Roche. (2008a). Roche clinical trials policy in low and middle income developing countries. Retrieved 20 December 2012, from www.roche.com/clinical_trials_policy_in_low_and_middle_income_developing_countries.pdf.
- Roche. (2008b). Minutes of the 90th Annual General Meeting of the Shareholders of Roche Holding Ltd., Basel. Retrieved 18 December 2012, from www.roche.com/annual_general_meeting_2008_en.pdf.
- Roche. (2010a). A study of CellCept (Mycophenolate Mofetil) in combination therapy in heart transplant patients. Retrieved 10 December 2011, from http://www.roche-trials.com/trialDetailsGet.action?studyNumber=ML20055. .
- Roche. (2010b). Minutes of the 92 nd Annual General Meeting of the Shareholders of Roche Holding Ltd., Basel. Retrieved 18 December, 2012, from www.roche.com/annual_general_meeting_2010_en.pdf. .
- Roche. (2010c). Annual Report. Retrieved 20 December 2012, from www.roche.com/gb10e.pdf.
- Roche. (2011a). Annual Results 2010. Retrieved 7 December 2011, from http://www.roche.com/gb10e.pdf.
- Roche. (2011b). Corporate responsibility: Patients. Retrieved 8 December 2011, from http://www.roche.com/corporate_responsibility/patients.htm.
- Roche. (2011c). Pharmaceuticals. Retrieved 8 December 2011, from http://www.roche.com/about_roche/business_fields/disease_areas.htm.
- Roche. (2011d). Pharmaceuticals Pipeline. Retrieved 8 December 2011, from http://www.roche.com/research_and_development/pipeline/roche_pharma_pipeline.htm.
- Roche. (2011e). A study of CellCept (Mycophenolate Mofetil) combined with Calcineurin inhibitors in liver transplant patients. Retrieved 10 December 2011, from http://www.roche-trials.com/trialDetailsGet.action?studyNumber=ML21241&diseaseCategoryId=51&byLocation=true.
- Roche. (2011f). Minutes of the 93rd annual general meeting of the Shareholders of Roche Holding Ltd, Basel. Retrieved 21 December 2012, from www.roche.com/annual_general_meeting_2011_en.pdf.
- Roche. (2012). Roche position on clinical research. Retrieved 20 December 2012, from www.roche.com/roche_position_on_clinical_research.pdf.
- Roche Historical Archive. (2008). Traditionally ahead of time. Retrieved 6 December 2011, from http://www.roche.com/histb2008_e.pdf.
- Ruggie, J. (2008a). Promotion and protection of all human rights, civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, including the right to development. Clarifying the concepts of “sphere of influence” and “complicity”.Google Scholar
- Santoro, M. A. (2009). China 2020: How western business can and should influence social and political change in the coming decade. New York: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
- Simons, C. (2005, April 11). Meds and miracles: China’s medical system is straining to accommodate a flood of Western firms testing new medicines. Newsweek International, 85.Google Scholar
- Strassheim, I. (2011, September 10). Roche wegen China weiter in der Kritik [Roche because of China again under scrutiny]. Basler Zeitung, 19.Google Scholar
- The Public Eye Awards. (2010). Nominated for the Public Eye Swiss Award 2010 by the Berne Declaration: Roche. Retrieved 7 December 2011, from http://www.publiceye.ch/media/medialibrary/2010/01/Roche_en.pdf. .
- The Transplantation Society. (2011). Homepage. Retrieved 9 December 2011, from http://www.tts.org/.
- The World Health Organization. (2004). WHO Guiding Principles on human cell, tissue and organ transplantation. Retrieved 10 December 2011, from http://www.who.int/entity/transplantation/Guiding_PrinciplesTransplantation_WHA63.22en.pdf.
- Triodos Bank. (2010). Pharmaceutical giant removed from investment universe. Retrieved 18 December 2012, from http://www.triodos.com/en/investment-management/who-we-are/news/newsletter-sustainability-research/pharmaceutical-company/.