Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 101, Issue 1, pp 143–162 | Cite as

Socially Responsible Investment and Fiduciary Duty: Putting the Freshfields Report into Perspective

Article

Abstract

A critical issue for the future growth and impact of socially responsible investment (SRI) is whether institutional investors are legally permitted to engage in it – in particular whether it is compatible with the fiduciary duties of trustees. An ambitious report from the United Nations Environment Programme’s Finance Initiative (UNEP FI), commonly referred to as the ‘Freshfields report’, has recently given rise to considerable optimism on this issue among proponents of SRI. The present article puts the arguments of the Freshfields report into some further both empirical and critical perspective, however, and suggests that its findings do not call for very much optimism. The general argument is that while the understanding of fiduciary duty outlined by the Freshfields report seems to allow institutional investors to at least sometimes take some social or environmental considerations into account, the support it gives for SRI is notably contingent and, furthermore, it rules out exactly the kind of SRI which proponents of social responsibility and environmental sustainability should hold in highest regard – proactive cases and socially effective investment strategies. If SRI is to become an important force for corporate social responsibility through its adoption by institutional investors, then, it is suggested that legal reform is needed.

Keywords

ethical investment fiduciary duty Fresh-fields report institutional investors legal reform prudent investor rule social effectiveness socially responsible investment United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Ali, Paul A.U. and Kanako Yano. 2004. Eco-Finance: The Legal Design and Regulation of Market-Based Environmental Instruments. The Hague: Kluwer Law International.Google Scholar
  2. Anand, Paul and Christopher J. Cowton. 1993. The ethical investor: Exploring dimensions of investment behaviour, Journal of Economic Psychology 14, 377-385.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Aviva Investors: 2008, ‘Investment Tutor Training Guide: An Introduction to Sustainable and Responsible Investment for institutional trustees’, http://www.investmenttutor.com.
  4. Baue, W.: 2005, ‘Fiduciary Duty Redefined to Allow (and Sometimes Require) Environmental, Social and Governance Considerations’, SocialFunds.com, November 3.Google Scholar
  5. Beal, D. J. and M. Goyen. 1998. ‘Putting your money where your mouth is’ a profile of ethical investors, Financial Services Review 7(2), pp. 129-43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Domini, A. L.: 2001, Socially Responsible Investing: Making a Difference and Making Money (Dearborn Trade, Chicago)Google Scholar
  7. Eurosif. 2008. 2008 European SRI Study. Paris: Eurosif.Google Scholar
  8. Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer: 2005, A Legal Framework for the Integration of Environmental, Social and Governance Issues into Institutional Investment. Report produced for the Asset Management Working Group of the UNEP Finance Initiative.Google Scholar
  9. Gay, George R. and Johann A. Klaassen. 2005. Retirement Investment, Fiduciary Obligations, and Socially Responsible Investing, Journal of Deferred Compensation 10(4), 34-49.Google Scholar
  10. Getzner, M. and S. Grabner-Kräuter. 2004. Consumer Preferences and Marketing Strategies for ‘‘Green Shares’’. Specifics of the Austrian Market, International Journal of Bank Marketing 22(4), 260–279.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Haigh, Matthew and James Hazelton. 2004. Financial Markets: A Tool for Social Responsibility? Journal of Business Ethics 52, 59-71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Hawley, James P. and Andrew T. Williams. 2000. The Rise of Fiduciary Capitalism. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
  13. Hawley, James P. and Andrew T. Williams. 2002. Can Universal Owners Be Socially Responsible Investors? In Camejo, Peter (ed.), The SRI Advantage: Why Socially Responsible Investing Has Outperformed Financially, Gabriola Island, BC: New Society Publishers.Google Scholar
  14. Hebb, Tessa. 2008. No Small Change: Pension Funds and Corporate Engagement. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
  15. Heinkel, Robert, Alan Kraus and Josef Zechner. 2001. The Effect of Green Investment on Corporate Behavior, The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 36(4), 431-449.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Hess, D.: 2007, Public Pensions and the Promise of Shareholder Activism for the Next Frontier of Corporate Governance: Sustainable Economic Development. Working Paper, Ross School of Business, University of Michigan.Google Scholar
  17. Hesse, A.: 2008, Long-Term and Sustainable Pension Investments: A Study of Leading European Pension Funds. Report Prepared for Asset4 and the German Federal Environment Ministry.Google Scholar
  18. Hoffman, W. Michael, Robert Frederick and Edward S. Petry, Jr. 1990. Business, Ethics, and the Environment: The Public Policy Debate. Westport, CT: Quorum Books.Google Scholar
  19. Hudson, Richard. 2005. Ethical Investing: Ethical Investors and Managers, Business Ethics Quarterly 15(4), 641-57.Google Scholar
  20. Hutchinson, James D. and Charles G. Cole. 1980. Legal Standards Governing Investment of Pension Assets for Social and Political Goals, University of Pennsylvania Law Review 128(4), 1340-1388.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. International Decision Strategies: 2009, Environmental, Social and Governance Investing in Europe: A Review and Analysis. Report Prepared for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Financial Market Incentives Workgroup.Google Scholar
  22. Juravle, C. and A. Lewis: 2008, `Identifying Impediments to SRI in Europe: A Review of the Practitioner and Academic Literature', Business Ethics: A European Review 17(3), 285–310.Google Scholar
  23. Kanzer, Adam M. 2009. The Use of Shareholder Proposals to Address Corporate Human Rights Performance. In de Bettignies, Henri-Claude and Francois Lépineux (eds.), Finance for a Better World: The Shift toward Sustainability, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  24. Kiernan, Matthew. 2002. SRI: From the Margins to the Mainstream. In Camejo, Peter (ed.), The SRI Advantage: Why Socially Responsible Investing Has Outperformed Financially, Gabriola Island, BC: New Society Publishers.Google Scholar
  25. Kiernan, Matthew. 2009. Investing in a Sustainable World. Why GREEN is the New Color of Money on Wall Street. New York: Amacom.Google Scholar
  26. Knoll, Michael S. 2002. Ethical Screening in Modern Financial Markets: The Conflicting Claims Underlying Socially Responsible Investment, The Business Lawyer 57, 681-726.Google Scholar
  27. Krosinsky, Cary and Nick Robins (eds.). 2008. Sustainable Investing: The Art of Long-Term Performance. London: Earthscan.Google Scholar
  28. Langbein, John H. and Richard A. Posner. 1980. Social Investing and the Law of Trusts, Michigan Law Review 79(1), pp. 72-112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Lanoff, Ian D. 1980. The Social Investment of Private Pension Plan Assets: May It Be Done Lawfully under ERISA? Labor Law Journal 31(7), 387-392.Google Scholar
  30. Lewis, A. and C. Juravle (2009) Morals, Markets and Sustainable Investments: A Qualitative Study of ‘Champions. Journal of Business Ethics 93: 483-494CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Lewis, Alan and Craig Mackenzie. 2000a. Support for investor activism among UK ethical investors, Journal of Business Ethics, 24 (3), pp. 215-22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Lewis, Alan and Craig Mackenzie. 2000b. Morals, money, ethical investing and economic psychology, Human Relations 53(2), 179-191.Google Scholar
  33. Lewis, Alan and P. Webley. 1994. Social and ethical investing. In Lewis, A. and Wärneryd, K-E. (eds), Ethics and Economic Affairs, Routledge, London, pp. 171-82.Google Scholar
  34. Logsdon, Jeanne M. and Harry J. Van Buren III. 2009. Beyond the Proxy Vote: Dialogues Between Shareholder Activists and Corporations, Journal of Business Ethics 87, 353-365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Mackenzie, C.: 1997, Ethical Investment and the Challenge of Corporate Reform. PhD Thesis, University of Bath.Google Scholar
  36. Mackenzie, Craig and Alan Lewis. 1999. Morals and markets: the case of ethical investing, Business Ethics Quarterly 9(3), pp. 439-52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Mallin, Christine A. 2007. Corporate Governance, 2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  38. Margolis, J. D., H. A. Elfenbein and J. P. Walsh: 2007. Does it Pay to be Good? A Meta-Analysis and Redirection of Research on the Relationship Between Corporate Social and Financial Performance. Working Paper, Harvard Business School.Google Scholar
  39. Meakin, Robert. 2005. Socially Responsible Investment by Charities. In Scanlan, Charles (ed.), Socially Responsible Investment: A Guide for Pension Schemes and Charities, London: Key Haven.Google Scholar
  40. Michelson, Grant, Nick Wailes, Sandra van der Laan, and Geoff Frost. 2004. Ethical Investment Processes and Outcomes, Journal of Business Ethics 52, 1-10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Miller, G. Daniel and Carol V. Calhoun. 2000. Analysis of Legal Issues Concerning Tobacco Divestment and Socially Screened Investments. In Cogan, Doug (ed.), Tobacco Divestment and Fiduciary Responsibility: A Legal and Financial Analysis, Washington, DC: Investor Responsibility Research Center.Google Scholar
  42. Munnell, A. H: 2007. Should Public Pension Plans Engage in Social Investing? Brief Prepared for the Centre for Retirement Research at Boston College.Google Scholar
  43. Munnell, Alicia H. and Annika Sundén. 2005. Social Investing: Pension plans should just say “No”. In J. Entine (ed.), Pension Fund Politics: The Dangers of Socially Responsible Investing, Washington, D.C.: AEI Press.Google Scholar
  44. National Round Table on the Environment and the Economy (NRTEE). 2007. Capital Markets and Sustainability: Investing in a sustainable future. Ottawa: NRTEE.Google Scholar
  45. Nilsson, Jonas. 2008. Investment with a Conscience: Examining the Impact of Pro-Social Attitudes and Perceived Financial Performance on Socially Responsible Investment Behavior, Journal of Business Ethics 83, 307-325.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Nilsson, Jonas. 2009. Segmenting socially responsible mutual fund investors: The influence of financial return and social responsibility. International Journal of Bank Marketing 27(1): 5-31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Office for National Statistics. 2007. Share Ownership: A Report on Ownership of UK Shares as at 31 st December 2006. Newport: Office for National Statistics.Google Scholar
  48. Oxford Business Knowledge: 2007, Recent Trends and Regulatory Implications in Socially Responsible Investment for Pension Funds. Report Prepared for the OECD Roundtable on Corporate Responsibility.Google Scholar
  49. Pearce, Robert and John Stevens. 2006. The Law of Trusts and Equitable Obligations, 4th ed. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  50. Powers, Charles W. 1971. Social Responsibility & Investments. Nashville: Abingdon Press.Google Scholar
  51. Richardson, Benjamin J. 2007. Do the Fiduciary Duties of Pension Funds Hinder Socially Responsible Investment? Banking and Finance Law Review 22(2), 145-201.Google Scholar
  52. Richardson, Benjamin J. 2008a. Socially Responsible Investment Law: Regulating the Unseen Polluters. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Richardson, Benjamin J. 2008b. Putting Ethics into Environmental Law: Fiduciary Duties for Ethical Investment, Osgoode Hall Law Journal 46(2), 243-91.Google Scholar
  54. Richardson, Benjamin J. 2009. Keeping Ethical Investment Ethical: Regulatory Issues for Investing in Sustainability, Journal of Business Ethics 87(4), 555-572.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Rivoli, Pietra. 2003. Making a Difference or Making a Statement? Finance Research and Socially Responsible Investment, Business Ethics Quarterly 13(3), 271-87.Google Scholar
  56. Rosen, B. N., D. M. Sandler and D. Shani. 1991. Social Issues and Socially Responsible Investment Behavior: A Preliminary Investigation, The Journal of Consumer Affairs 25(2), 221–234.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Sandberg, J.: 2008, The Ethics of Investing. Making Money or Making a Difference Gothenburg: Acta Universitatis Gothoburgensis.Google Scholar
  58. Sandberg, J. and J. Nilsson: 2010, Conflicting Intuitions about Ethical Investment: A Survey Among Individual Investors, Sustainable Investment and Corporate Governance Working Papers 2010/16, Sustainable Investment Research Platform.Google Scholar
  59. Satz, Debra. 2003. Child Labor: A Normative Perspective, The World Bank Economic Review 17(2), 297-309.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Scanlan, Charles. 2005. Socially Responsible Investment by Pension Schemes. In Scanlan, Charles (ed.), Socially Responsible Investment: A Guide for Pension Schemes and Charities, London: Key Haven.Google Scholar
  61. Sebastian, Vicente. 1997. Child Labour, Business Ethics: A European Review 6(4), 208-212.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Sethi, S. Prakash. 2005. Investing in Socially Responsible Companies is a Must for Public Pension Funds – Because There is no Better Alternative, Journal of Business Ethics 56, 99-129.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Simon, John G., Charles W. Powers and Jon P. Gunnemann. 1972. The Ethical Investor: Universities and Corporate Responsibility. London: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  64. Social Investment Forum. 2008. 2007 Report on Socially Responsible Investing Trends in the United States. Washington, DC: Social Investment Forum.Google Scholar
  65. Sparkes, Russell. 2002. Socially Responsible Investment: A Global Revolution. New York: John Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
  66. Sparkes, Russell and Christopher J. Cowton. 2004. The Maturing of Socially Responsible Investment: A Review of the Developing Link with Corporate Social Responsibility, Journal of Business Ethics 52(1), 45-57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Statman, Meir. 2000. Socially Responsible Mutual Funds, Financial Analysts Journal 56(3), 30-9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Strätling, Rebecca. 2003. General Meetings: a dispensable tool for corporate governance of listed companies? Corporate Governance: An International Review 11(1), 74-82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. The Conference Board. 2007. 2007 Institutional Investment Report. New York: The Conference Board.Google Scholar
  70. Thornton, Rosy. 2008. Ethical Investments: A Case of Disjointed Thinking, Cambridge Law Journal 67(2), pp. 396-422.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative (UNEP FI). 2004. The Materiality of Social, Environmental and Corporate Governance Issues to Equity Pricing. Geneva: UNEP FI.Google Scholar
  72. United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative (UNEP FI). 2006. Show Me The Money: Linking Environmental, Social and Governance Issues to Company Value. Geneva: UNEP FI.Google Scholar
  73. United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative (UNEP FI) 2009. Fiduciary responsibility: Legal and practical aspects of integrating environmental, social and governance issues into institutional investment. Geneva: UNEP FI.Google Scholar
  74. UNEP FI and Mercer. 2007. Demystifying Responsible Investment Performance: A review of key academic and broker research on ESG factors. Paris: UNEP FI and Mercer.Google Scholar
  75. Viederman, Stephen. 2008. Fiduciary Duty. In Krosinsky, Cary and Nick Robins (eds.), Sustainable Investing: The Art of Long-Term Performance, London: Earthscan.Google Scholar
  76. Wall, Larry D. 1995. Some Lessons from Basic Finance for Effective Socially Responsible Investing, Economic Review of the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta 80(1), 1-12.Google Scholar
  77. Watchman, Paul Q., Jane Anstee-Wedderburn and Lucas Shipway. 2005. Fiduciary duties in the 21st century: a UK perspective, Trust Law International 19(3), 127-148.Google Scholar
  78. Watt, Gary. 2006. Trusts and Equity, 2nd ed. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  79. Webley, Paul, Alan Lewis, and Craig Mackenzie. 2001. Commitment among ethical investors: An experimental approach, Journal of Economic Psychology 22 (1), 27-42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Wen, Shuangge. 2009. Institutional investor activism on socially responsible investment: effects and expectations, Business Ethics: A European Review 18(3), 308-333.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Whitfield, Jane. 2005. Trustees’ Investment Duties. In Scanlan, Charles (ed.), Socially Responsible Investment: A Guide for Pension Schemes and Charities, London: Key Haven.Google Scholar
  82. Woods, C.: 2009. Funding Climate Change: How Pension Fund Fiduciary Duty Masks a Collective (In)Action Problem. Working Paper, School of Geography and the Environment, Oxford University.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Philosophy, Linguistics and Theory of ScienceUniversity of GothenburgGothenburgSweden

Personalised recommendations