Advertisement

Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 80, Issue 4, pp 727–743 | Cite as

Women’s Careers at the Start of the 21st Century: Patterns and Paradoxes

  • Deborah A. O’Neil
  • Margaret M. Hopkins
  • Diana BilimoriaEmail author
Article

Abstract

In this article we assess the extant literature on women’s careers appearing in selected career, management and psychology journals from 1990 to the present to determine what is currently known about the state of women’s careers at the dawn of the 21st century. Based on this review, we identify four patterns that cumulatively contribute to the current state of the literature on women’s careers: women’s careers are embedded in women’s larger-life contexts, families and careers are central to women’s lives, women’s career paths reflect a wide range and variety of patterns, and human and social capital are critical factors for women’s careers. We also identify paradoxes that highlight the disconnection between organizational practice and scholarly research associated with each of the identified patterns. Our overall conclusion is that male-defined constructions of work and career success continue to dominate organizational research and practice.

We provide direction for a research agenda on women’s careers that addresses the development of integrative career theories relevant for women’s contemporary lives in hopes of providing fresh avenues for conceptualizing career success for women. Propositions are identified for more strongly connecting career scholarship to organizational practice in support of women’s continued career advancement.

Keywords

women’s career development career success gender career theories 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Arthur M. B. (1994), The Boundaryless Career: A New Perspective for Organizational Inquiry, Journal of Organizational Behavior, 15, 295–306CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bateson M. C. (1990), Composing a Life. Plume Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  3. Belkin, L.: 2003, ‹The Opt-Out Revolution’, New York Times Magazine, October 26th, 42Google Scholar
  4. Betz N. (1993), Women’s Career Development In F. L. Denmark, M. A. Paludi, (eds) Psychology of Women. Greenwood Press, Westport, CT 627–679Google Scholar
  5. Betz N. E., Fitzgerald L. F. (1987), The Career Psychology of Women. Academic Press, NYGoogle Scholar
  6. Braynion P. (2004), Power and Leadership, Journal of Health, Organization, and Management, 18(6), 447–463CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Brett J. M., Stroh L. K. (1999), Women in Management: How Far Have We Come and What Needs to be Done as We Approach (2000)?, Journal of Management Inquiry 8(4), 392–398CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Burke R. J. (1997), Are Families Damaging to Careers?, Women in Management Review, 13(8), 320–324CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Burke R. J. (1999), Are Families a Career Liability?, Women in Management Review, 14(5), 159–163CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Burke R. J. (2002), Career Development of Managerial Women In Burke R. J., Nelson D. L. (eds.), Advancing Women’s Careers, Blackwell Publishing, Malden, MA, 139–160Google Scholar
  11. Burke R. J., McKeen C. A. (1996), Do Women at the Top Make a Difference? Gender Proportions and the Experiences of Managerial and Professional Women, Human Relations, 49(8), 1093–1098CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Catalyst: 2007, ‹Facts About Working Women’, http://www.catalystwomen.org/files/tid/tidbits04.pdf, retrieved 4/25/07
  13. Drew E., Murtagh E. M.: 2005, Work/Life Balance: Senior Management Champions or Laggards?, Women in Management Review, 20(4), 262–278CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Fagenson E. (1990), At the Heart of Women in Management Research: Theoretical and Methodological Approaches and Their Biases, Journal of Business Ethics 9, 267–274CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Fagenson-Eland E., G. Baugh (2000), Career Paths, Networking, and Mentoring In Smith D. (ed.), Women at Work – Leadership for the Next Century. Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 145–161Google Scholar
  16. Fels A. (2004), Do Women Lack Ambition?. Harvard Business Review, Harvard Business School Publishing Corporation, Boston, MAGoogle Scholar
  17. Fitzgerald L. F., J. O. Crites (1980), Toward a Career Psychology of Women: What do We Know? What do We Need to Know?, Journal of Counseling Psychology, 27(1), 44–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Fitzgerald L. F., Fassinger R. E., Betz N. E. (1995), Theoretical Advances in the Study of Women’s Career Development In Walsh W. B., Osipow S. H. (eds.), Handbook of Vocational Psychology, 2nd Edition. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc., Mahwah, NJ, 67–110Google Scholar
  19. Fletcher J. K. (1998), Relational Practice, Journal of Management Inquiry, 7(2), 163–186CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Fondas N. (1997), Feminization Unveiled: Management Qualities in Contemporary Writings, Academy of Management Review, 22(1), 257–282CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Gallos J. (1989), Exploring Women’s Development: Implications for Career Theory, Practice, and Research In Arthur M. B., Hall D. T., Lawrence B. S. (eds.) Handbook of Career Theory. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 110–132Google Scholar
  22. Gersick C., Kram K. (2002), High Achieving Women at Midlife: An Exploratory Study, Journal of Management Inquiry, 11(2), 104–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Gordon J. R., Whelan K. S. (1998), Successful Professional Women in Midlife: How Organizations Can More Effectively Understand and Respond to the Challenges, The Academy of Management Executive, 12(1), 8–27Google Scholar
  24. Gordon J. R., Beatty J. E., Whelan-Berry K. S. (2002), The Midlife Transition of Professional Women with Children, Women in Management Review, 17(7), 328–341CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Hackett G. (1997), Promise and Problems in Theory and Research on Women’s Career Development, Journal of Counseling Psychology, 44(2), 184–188CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Hall D. T. (1996). The Career is Dead, Long Live the Career. Jossey-Bass, San FranciscoGoogle Scholar
  27. Hall D. T. (2004), The Protean Career: A Quarter Century Journey, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 65(1), 1–13CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Hall D. T., Mirvis P. H. (1995), The New Career Contract: Developing the Whole Person at Midlife and Beyond, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 47(3), 269–289CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hamilton E. A., Gordon J. R., Whelan-Berry K. S. (2006), Understanding the Work–Life Conflict of Never Married Women Without Children, Women in Management Review, 21(5), 393–415CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Hearn J., Parkin P. W. (1986), Women, Men and Leadership: A Critical Review of Assumptions, Practices, and Change in the Industrialized Nations, International Studies of Management and Organization, 16(3/4), 33–60Google Scholar
  31. Helfat C. E., Harris D., Wolfson P. J. (2006), The Pipeline to the Top: Women and Men in the Top Executive Ranks of U.S. Corporations, Academy of Management Perspectives, 20(4), 42–64Google Scholar
  32. Hewlett S. A. (2002), Executive Women and the Myth of Having it All, Harvard Business Review, 80(4), 66–73Google Scholar
  33. Hewlett S. A., Luce C. B. (2005), Off-Ramps and On-Ramps: Keeping Talented Women on the Road to Success, Harvard Business Review, 83(3), 43–54Google Scholar
  34. Hopkins M. M., O’Neil D. A. (2007), Women and Success: Dilemmas and Opportunities In Bilimoria D., Piderit S. K. (eds.) Handbook on Women in Business and Management. Edwin Elgar Publishing Limited, Cheltenham, UK, 132–153Google Scholar
  35. Huang Q., Sverke M. (2007), Women’s Occupational Career Patterns Over 27 Years: Relations to Family of Origin, Life Careers, and Wellness, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 70, 369–397CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Hurley A. E., Sonnenfeld J. A. (1997), A Study of the Tournament Model With Female Managers, Women in Management Review, 12(3), 91–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Ibarra H. (1993), Personal Networks of Women and Minorities in Management: A Conceptual Framework, Academy of Management Review, 18(1), 56–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Jacobson S. W., Aaltio-Marjosola I. (2001), Strong Objectivity and the Use of Q-Methodology in Cross-cultural Research, Journal of Management Inquiry, 10(3), 228–248CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Judiesch, M. K., Lyness K. S. (1999), Left Behind? The Impact of Leaves of Absence on Managers’ Career Success, Academy of Management Journal, 42(6), 641–651CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Kanter R. M. (1977), Men and Women of the Corporation. BasicBooks, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  41. Kirchmeyer C. (1998), Determinants of Managerial Career Success: Evidence and Explanation of Male/Female Differences, Journal of Management, 24(6), 673–692CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Kirchmeyer C. (2002), Gender Differences in Managerial Careers: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow, Journal of Business Ethics, 37(1), 5–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Larwood L., Gutek B. A. (1987), Working Towards a Theory of Women’s Career Development In Gutek B. A., Larwood L. (eds.) Women’s Career Development, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CAGoogle Scholar
  44. Lefkowitz J. (1994), Sex-Related Differences in Job Attitudes and Dispositional Variables: Now You See them… Academy of Management Journal, 37(2), 323–349CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Lepine I. (1992), Making Their Way in the Organization: Women Managers in Quebec, Women in Management Review, 7(3), 17–21Google Scholar
  46. Lyness K. S., Thompson D. E. (1997), Above the Glass Ceiling? A Comparison of Matched Samples of Female and Male Executives, Journal of Applied Psychology, 82(3), 359–375CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Lyness K. S., Thompson D. E. (2000), Climbing the Corporate Ladder: Do Female and Male Executives Follow the Same Route? Journal of Applied Psychology, 85(1), 86–101CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Mainiero L. A. (1994), Getting Anointed for Advancement: The Case of Executive Women, The Academy of Management Executive, 8(2), 53–67Google Scholar
  49. Mainiero L. A., Sullivan S. E. (2005), Kaleidoscope Careers: An Alternate Explanation for the Opt-Out Revolution, The Academy of Management Executive, 19(1), 106–123Google Scholar
  50. Marshall J. (1995), Women Managers Moving on: Exploring Career and Life Choices. Routledge, London and New YorkGoogle Scholar
  51. Martins L. L., Eddleston K. A., Veiga J. F. (2002), Moderators of the Relationship Between Work–Family Conflict and Career Satisfaction Academy of Management Journal, 45(2), 399–409CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Mattis M. C. (2004), Women Entrepreneurs: Out from Under the Glass Ceiling, Women in Management Review, 19(3), 154–163CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Mavin S. (2001), Women’s Careers in Theory & Practice: Time for Change? Women in Management Review, 16(4), 183–192CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. McDonald P., Brown K., Bradley L. (2005), Have Traditional Career Paths Given Way to Protean Ones? Career Development International, 10(2), 109–129CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Melamed T. (1995), Career Success: The Moderating Effect of Gender, Journal of Vocational Behavior 47, 35–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Moore D. P., Buttner E. H. (1997), Women Entrepreneurs: Moving Beyond the Glass Ceiling. Sage, Thousand Oaks, CAGoogle Scholar
  57. Moore D. P. (2000), Careerpreneurs. Davies-Black Publishing, Palo Alto, CAGoogle Scholar
  58. Morrison, A. M., R. P. White, E. Van Velsor and the Center for Creative Leadership: 1992, Breaking the Glass Ceiling: Can Women Reach the Top of America’s Largest Corporations? (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA)Google Scholar
  59. Netemeyer R. G., Boles J. S., McMurrian R. (1996), Development and Validation of Work–Family Conflict and Family-work Conflict Scales Journal of Applied Psychology, 81(4), 400–410CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Oakley J. G. (2000), Gender-Based Barriers to Senior Management Positions: Understanding the Scarcity of Female CEOs, Journal of Business Ethics, 27, 321–334CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Osterman P. (1995), Work/family Programs and the Employment Relationship, Administrative Science Quarterly, 40, 681–700CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. O’Leary, J. (1997), Developing a New Mindset: The ‹Career Ambitious’ Individual, Women in Management Review, 12(3), 91–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. O’Neil, D. A.: 2003, ‹Working in Context: Understanding the Career-In-Life Experiences of Women’, Dissertation Abstracts International, UMI 3097354Google Scholar
  64. O’Neil D. A., Bilimoria D. (2005), Women’s Career Development Phases: Idealism, Endurance, and Reinvention, Career Development International, 10(3), 168–189CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. O’Neil D. A., Bilimoria D., Saatcioglu A. (2004), Women’s Career Types: Attributions of Satisfaction with Career Success, Career Development International, 9(5), 478–500CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Osipow S. H., Fitzgerald L. H. (1996), Theories of Career Development 4th Edition. Allyn & Bacon, Needham Heights, MAGoogle Scholar
  67. Pinchot G. (1985), Intrapreneuring: Why You Don’t have to Leave the Corporation to Become an Entrepreneur. Harper and Row, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  68. Poole, M. E., Langan-Fox J., Ciavarella M., Omodei M. (1991), A Contextualist Model of Professional Attainment: Results of a Longitudinal Study of Career Paths of Men and Women, The Counseling Psychologist, 19(4), 603–624CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Porter L. W., Steers R. M., Mowday R. T., Boultian P. V. (1974), Organizational Commitment, Job Satisfaction, and Turnover among Psychiatric Technicians, Journal of Applied Psychology, 59(5), 603–609CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Powell G. N., Mainiero L. A. (1992), Cross-Currents in the River of Time: Conceptualizing the Complexities of Women’s Careers, Journal of Management, 18(2), 215–237CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Powell G. N., Butterfield D. A., Parent J. D. (2002), Gender and Managerial Stereotypes: Have the Time Changed? Journal of Management, 28, 177–193CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Pringle J. K., Dixon K. M. (2003), Re-Incarnating Life in the Careers of Women, Career Development International, 8(6), 291–300CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Ragins B. R., Townsend B., Mattis M. (1998), Gender Gap in the Executive Suite: CEOs and Female Executives Report on Breaking the Glass Ceiling, The Academy of Management Executive, 12(1) 28–42Google Scholar
  74. Richardson C. (1996), Snakes and Ladders? The Differing Career Patterns of Male & Female Accountants, Women in Management Review, 11(4), 13–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Richie B. S., Fassinger R. E., Linn S. G., Johnson J., Prosser J., Robinson S. (1997), Persistence, Connection and Passion: A Qualitative Study of the Career Development of Highly Achieving African-American-Black and White Women Journal of Counseling Psychology, 44(2), 133–148CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Ridgeway C. L. (2001), Gender, Status and Leadership, Journal of Social Issues, 57(4), 637–655CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Rindfleish J., Sheridan A. (2003), No Change from Within: Senior Women Managers’ Response to Gendered Organizational Structures, Women in Management Review, 18(6), 299–310CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Rosin, H. and K. Korabik: 1995, ‹Organizational Experiences and Propensity to Leave: A Multivariate Investigation of Men and Women Managers’, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 46Google Scholar
  79. Rothbard N. P. (2001), Enriching or Depleting? The Dynamics of Engagement in Work and Family Roles, Administrative Science Quarterly, 46, 655–684CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Ruderman M. N., Ohlott P. J., Panzer K., King S. N. (2002), Benefits of Multiple Roles for Managerial Women, The Academy of Management Journal, 45(2), 369–386CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Ryan M. K., S. A. Haslam (2005), The Glass Cliff: Evidence that Women are Over-Represented in Precarious Leadership Positions, British Journal of Management, 16, 81–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Schein V. E. (1993), The Work–Family Interface: Challenging Corporate Convenient, Women in Management Review, 8(4), 22–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Schein V. E. (2007), Women in Management: Reflections and Projections, Women in Management Review, 22(1), 6–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Schneer J. A., Reitman F. (1995), The Impact of Gender as Managerial Careers Unfold, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 47, 290–315CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Schneer J. A., Reitman F. (2002), Managerial Life Without a Wife: Family Structure and Managerial Career Success, Journal of Business Ethics, 37, 25–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Schwartz D. B. (1996), The Impact of Work–Family Policies on Women’s Career Development: Boon or Bust? Women in Management Review, 11(1), 5–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. Schwartz F. N. (1992), Women as a Business Imperative, Harvard Business Review, 70(2), 105–114Google Scholar
  88. Simpson R. (1997), Have Times Changed? Career Barriers and the Token Women Manager, British Journal of Management, 8, S121–S130CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Simpson R. (2000), Gender Mix and Organizational Fit: How Gender Imbalance at Different Levels of the Organization Impacts on Women Managers Women in Management Review, 15(1), 5–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Singh V., Vinnicombe S., Kumra S. (2006), Women in Formal Corporate Networks: An Organisational Citizenship Perspective, Women in Management Review, 21(6), 458–482CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Smart R. M. (1998), Career Stages in Australian Professional Women: A Test of Super’s Model, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 52, 379–395CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Still L., Timms W. (1998), Career Barriers and the Older Women Manager, Women in Management Review, 13(4), 143–155CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Stroh L. K., Brett J. M., Reilly A. H. (1992), All the Right Stuff: A Comparison of Female and Male Managers’ Career Progression, Journal of Applied Psychology, 77(3), 251–260CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Stroh L. K., Brett J. M., Reilly A. H. (1996), Family Structure, Glass Ceiling, and Traditional Explanations for the Differential Rate of Turnover of Female and Male Managers, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 49, 99–118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  95. Sturges J. (1999), What it Means to Succeed: Personal Conceptions of Career Success Held by Male and Female Managers at Different Ages, British Journal of Management, 10, 239–252CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  96. Sullivan S. E. (1999), The Changing Nature of Careers: A Review and Research Agenda, Journal of Management, 25(3), 457–484CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  97. Sullivan S. E., Arthur, M. (2006), The Evolution of the Boundaryless Career Concept: Examining Physical and Psychological Mobility, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 69(1), 19–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Tenbrusel A. E., Brett J. M., Maoz E., Stroh L. K., Reilly A. H. (1995), Dynamic and Static Work–Family Relationships, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 63(3), 233–246CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  99. Tharenou P. (2001), Going Up? Do Traits and Informal Social Processes Predict Advancing in Management? Academy of Management Journal, 44(5), 1005–1017CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  100. Tharenou P., Latimer S., Conroy D. (1994), How do You Make it to the Top? An Examination of the Influences on Women’s and Men’s Managerial Advancement, Academy of Management Journal, 37(4), 899–921CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Thompson C. A., Beauvais L. L., Lyness K.S. (1999), When Work–Family Benefits are Not Enough: The Influence of Work–Family Culture on Benefit Utilization, Organizational Attachment, and Work–Family Conflict, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 54, 392–415CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  102. Tomlinson J. (2004), Perceptions and Negotiations of the ‹Business Case’ for Flexible Careers and the Integration of Part Time Work, Women in Management Review, 19(8), 413–420CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  103. U.S. Department of Labor – Women’s Bureau: “Quick Stats”, http://www.dol.gov/wb/stats/main.htm, retrieved 4/25/07
  104. White B. (1995), The Career Development of Successful Women, Women in Management Review, 10(3) 4–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  105. Winsor R. D., Ensher E. A. (2002), Choices Made in Balancing Work and Family: Following Two Women on a 16-Year Journey, Journal of Management, 9(2), 218–231Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  • Deborah A. O’Neil
    • 1
  • Margaret M. Hopkins
    • 2
  • Diana Bilimoria
    • 1
    Email author
  1. 1.Department of ManagementCollege of Business Administration, Bowling Green State UniversityBowling GreenU.S.A
  2. 2.Department of Management College of Business AdministrationUniversity of ToledoToledoU.S.A

Personalised recommendations