Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 57, Issue 4, pp 311–326 | Cite as

Can Ethical Organizational Character Be Stimulated and Enabled?: “Upbuilding” Dialog As Crisis Management Method

Article

Abstract

Crisis management can be simultaneously a content specific problem solving process and an opportunity for stimulating and enabling an organization’s ethical tradition. Crisis can be an opportunity for ethical organizational development. Kierkegaardian “upbuilding” dialog method builds from within the internal ethical tradition of an organization to respond to crises while simultaneously adapting and protecting the organization’s tradition. The crisis itself may not be a directly ethical crisis, but the method of responding to the crisis is built upon the ethical foundations of an organization’s tradition. A limitation of this method is that it may be less applicable to organizations with questionably ethical traditions. The concept of “upbuilding” dialog is derived from Kierkegaard, but here is applied to organizational crisis management. The method is illustrated and discussed in the context of a wrongful death crisis of the Dana- Farber Cancer Institute, a nonprofit organization, and an economic survival crisis at Ben and Jerry’s, a business organization.

Keywords

Ethics organizational character crisis Kierkegaard 
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Argyris, C., Schon, D. A. 1974Theory in PracticeJossey-BassSan FranciscoGoogle Scholar
  2. Argyris, C. and D. A. Schon: 1988, Reciprocal Integrity: Creating Conditions that Encourage Personal and Organizational integrity, in S. Srivastva and Associates (ed.), Executive Integrity: The Search for High Human Values in Organizational Life. Jossey-Bass Publishers, San Francisco, pp. 197–222.Google Scholar
  3. Argyris, C., Putnam, R., Mc Lain, S. D. 1985Action ScienceJossey-Bass PublishersSan FranciscoGoogle Scholar
  4. Argyris, D. 1985Action ScienceArgyris, C.Putnam, R.Smith, D. M. eds. ‘The Ethnographic Approach to Intervention and Fundamental Change’Jossey-Bass PublishersSan Francisco158189Google Scholar
  5. Aristotle,  1955EthicsPenguin ClassicsNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  6. Audia, P. G., Locke, E. A., Smith, K. G. 2000’ The Paradox of Success: An Archival and a Laboratory Study of Strategic Persistence Following Radical Environmental Change’Academy of Management Journal43837853Google Scholar
  7. Bates, S. and C. W. Hall: 1994, ‘Tylenol Verdict puts Spotlight on Drug Labels’, Washington Post, October 22, p. A1.Google Scholar
  8. Bateson, G. 1972Steps to an Ecology of MindBallantine BooksNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  9. Bernstein, R. J. 1971Praxis and ActionUniversity of Pennsylvania PressPhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
  10. Buono, A. F., Bowditch, J. L. 1989The Human Side of Mergers and AcquisitionsJossey-BassSan FranciscoGoogle Scholar
  11. Carlzon, J. 1987Moments of TruthBallinger Publishing CompanyCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  12. Chanin, M. N., Shapiro, H. J. 1985‘Dialectical Inquiry in Strategic Planning: Extending the Boundaries’Academy of Management Review10663675Google Scholar
  13. Chappell, T. 1993‘The Soul of a Business: Managing for Profit and the Common Good’Bantam BooksNYGoogle Scholar
  14. Churchman, C. W.: 1966, Hegelian Inquiring Systems. Working paper No. 49, University of California, Berkeley, Space Sciences Laboratory, Social Sciences Project.Google Scholar
  15. Churchman, C. W. 1968The Systems ApproachDell PublishingNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  16. Churchman, C. W. 1971The Design of Inquiring Systems: Basic Concepts of Systems and OrganizationBasic BooksNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  17. Cohen, B. G. and M. Meredith: 1997, Ben and Jerry’s Double-Dip: How to Run a Values-led Business and Make Money Too. Fireside.Google Scholar
  18. Collins, J. C., Porras, J. I. 1994Built to Last: Successful Habits of Visionary CompaniesHarper CollinsNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  19. Cosier, R. A. 1981‘Dialectical Inquiry in Strategic Planning: A Case of Premature Acceptance?’Academy of Management Review6643648Google Scholar
  20. Cosier, R. A. 1981b‘Further Thoughts on Dialectical Inquiry: A Rejoinder to Mitroff and Mason’Academy of Management Review6653654Google Scholar
  21. Czarniawska, B. 1997Narrating the Organization: Drama of Institutional IdentityThe University of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  22. Deephouse, D. L. 1996‘Does Isomorphism legitimate?’Academy of Management Journal3910241039Google Scholar
  23. Derrida, J.: 1977, Limited inc. (Northwestern University Press, Evanston, IL). See especially, Afterword: Toward an Ethic of Discussion, pp. 111–154.Google Scholar
  24. Derrida, J. 1981‘Three Questions to Hans-Georg Gadamer. Interpreting Signatures (Nietzsche/Heidegger): Two Questions’Michelfelder, D. P.Palmer, R. E. eds. Dialogue and Deconstruction: The Gadamer-Derrida EncounterState University of New York PressAlbanyGoogle Scholar
  25. di Lampedusa, G.: 1958, Il Gattopardo. Milano, Italy (1961). The Leopard (Signet, New York).Google Scholar
  26. DiMaggfio, P. J., Powell, W. W. 1983‘The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields’American Sociological Review48147160Google Scholar
  27. Ewing, D. W. 1989Justice on the JobHarvard Business School PressBostonGoogle Scholar
  28. Feldman, S. P. 2002Memory as a Moral Decision: The Role of Ethics in Organizational CultureTransaction PublishersNew BrunswickGoogle Scholar
  29. Fiano, A.: 2000, Unilever’s Hefty Tab for Ben and Jerry and Slim-Fast, Barron’s, April 17, p. MW13.Google Scholar
  30. Fiol, C. M. 2002‘Capitalizing on Paradox: The Role of Language in Transforming Organizational Identities’Organization Science13653666Google Scholar
  31. Fleischacker, S. 1994The Ethics of CultureCornell University PressIthacaGoogle Scholar
  32. Gadamer, H.-G. 1960Truth and MethodCrossroadNew York1989Google Scholar
  33. Gilmour, D. 1988The Last Leopard: A Life of Giuseppe Tomasi di LampedusaPantheonNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  34. Grady, D.: 1997, ‘Tylenol Overdoes Linked to Acute Failure of Liver’, New York Times, October 16, Section A, p. 18.Google Scholar
  35. Haverman, H. A. 1992‘Between a Rock and a Hard Place: Organizational Change and Performance Under Conditions of Fundamental Environmental Transformation’Administrative Science Quarterly374875Google Scholar
  36. Hechinger J., Pereira J. (2000). ‘Sympathizers Scramble to Rid Ben and Jerry’s of Two Unwanted Suitors’. The Wall Street Journal, February 4, p. 1, A20.Google Scholar
  37. Hill, Charles W. L., Rothaermel, F. T. 2003‘The Performance of Incumbent Firms in the Face of Radical Technological Innovation’The Academy of Management Review28257274CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hooper, L. and M. W. Miller: 1992, ‘IBM Shares Fall 11 as Firm Says It Will Cut 25,000 Jobs and May Trim Dividend’, Wall Street Journal, December 16, 1992, 3.Google Scholar
  39. Kearney, Richard 1998‘The wake of imagination’University of Minnesota PressMinneapolisGoogle Scholar
  40. Kierkegaard S. 1843, 1944, Either/Or(David F. and Lillian Swenson, Walter Lowrie, Translators). (Princeton University Press, Princeton).Google Scholar
  41. Kierkegaard, S.: 1845, 1967, Stages on Life’s Way (Walter Lowrie, Translator). Schocken Books, New York.Google Scholar
  42. Kierkegaard, S.: 1846a, 1968 Concluding Unscientific Postscript to the Philosophical Fragments (David F. Swenson, Translator). Princeton University Press, Princeton.Google Scholar
  43. Kierkegaard, S.: 1846b, 1962. The Present Age (Alexander Dru, Translator). Harper Torchbook, New York.Google Scholar
  44. Kierkegaard, S.: 1847a, 1946, Works of Love (David F. Swenson, Trans.). Princeton University Press, Princeton.Google Scholar
  45. Kierkegaard, S.: 1847b, 1948, Purity of Heart (D. Steere, Trans.) Harper and Row, NY.Google Scholar
  46. Knox, R. A.: 1995a, Overdoses Still Weigh Heavy at Dana-Farber More than Year After Tragedy, Cancer Institute Works to Balance Research Mission, Crucial Details of Patient Care. Boston Globe, December 26, p. 1, 6.Google Scholar
  47. Knox, R. A.: 1995b, New Dana-Farber Head Vows “Never again.” Boston Globe, September, 16, p.1, 9.Google Scholar
  48. Knox, R. A.: 1995c, President of Troubled Dana-Farber Steps Down. Boston Globe, September 13, p. 1, 7.Google Scholar
  49. Knox, R. A.: 1995d, Dana-Farber Head Quits 2nd Post, Vows Changes. Boston Globe, p. 1, 11.Google Scholar
  50. Knox, R. A.: 1995e, Dana-Farber on Probation: Agency Downgrades Accreditation. Boston Globe, April 15, p. 17.Google Scholar
  51. Knox, R. A.: 1995f, Doctor’s Orders Killed Cancer Patient: Dana-Farber Admits Drug Overdose Caused Death of Globe Columnist, Damage to Second Woman. March 23, p. 1, 6.Google Scholar
  52. Knox, R. A. and K. Blanton: 1995, Overdose Cloud Dana-Farber Bonds. Boston Globe, March 24, p. 77.Google Scholar
  53. Kong, D.: 1995a, State Faults Dana-Farber. Boston Globe, March 24, pp. 1, 12.Google Scholar
  54. Kong, D.: 1995b, Safeguards Failed at Dana-Farber. Boston Globe, March 25, pp. 1, 8.Google Scholar
  55. Kostova, T., Zaheer, S. 1999‘Organizational Legitimacy Under Conditions of Complexity’Academy of Management Review246481Google Scholar
  56. Lager, F., Loger, F. C. 1995Ben and Jerry’s: The Inside Scoop: How Two Guys Build A Business With a Social Conscience and A Sense of HumorCrown PublishingNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  57. Lawrence, F. 1984‘Language as horizon’Lawrence, F. eds. The Beginning and The BeyondThe Scholars PressChico, CA)Google Scholar
  58. Lewin, K. 1951Field Theory in Social ScienceHarperNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  59. Lowrie, W. 1970A Short Life of KierkegaardPrinceton University PressPrincetonGoogle Scholar
  60. Mirvis, P. (1999). Electronic Mail Conversation, October 25.Google Scholar
  61. Mirvis, P. H., Karen Ayas, G. R. 2003To the Desert and BackJossey-BassSan FranciscoGoogle Scholar
  62. Mitroff, I. I., Mason, R. O. 1981‘The Metaphysics of Policy and Planning: A Reply to Cosier’Academy of Management Review6649651Google Scholar
  63. Mitroff, I., Pauchant, T., Shrivastava, P. 1988‘Conceptual and Empirical Issues in the Development of a General Theory of Crisis Management’Technological Forecasting and Social Change3383107Google Scholar
  64. Morgenson G. (2002). ‘Analyze This: What Those Analysts said in Private’, New York Times, September 15, section 3, p. 1.Google Scholar
  65. Nielsen, R. P. 2005‘Systematic Corruption in Financial Services, Types of Capitalism, and Ethics Intervention Methods’Business and Professional Ethics Journal23131Google Scholar
  66. Nielsen, R. P. 2004‘Ethics and Organizational Theory: Varieties and Dynamics of Constrained Optimization in Different Types of Capitalism’Tsoukas, H.Knudsen, C. eds. The Oxford Handbook of Organizational Theory: Meta-Theoretical PerspectivesOxford University PressLondon476501Google Scholar
  67. Nielsen, R. P. 2003‘Corruption Networks and Implications For Ethical Corruption Reform’Journal of Business Ethics42125149Google Scholar
  68. Nielsen, R. P. 1998‘Can Ethical Character be Stimulated and Enabled?’Business Ethics Quarterly8581604Google Scholar
  69. Nielsen, R. P. 1996aThe Politics of Ethics: Methods For Acting, Learning, and Sometimes Fighting, With Others in Addressing Ethics Problems in Organizational LifeThe Ruffin Series in Business Ethics, Oxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  70. Nielsen, P. R. 1996‘Varieties of Dialectic Change Processes’Journal of Management Inquiry5276292Google Scholar
  71. Nielsen,  1989‘Changing Unethical Organizational Behavior’Academy of Management Executive3123130Google Scholar
  72. Nielsen, R. P. 1993‘Woolman’s “I Am We” Triple-loop, Action-Learning: Origin and Application in Organization ethics’Journal of Applied Behavioral Science29117138Google Scholar
  73. Nielsen, R. P.: 1988, Personal Conversation with Douglas Steere.Google Scholar
  74. O’Brien, T. L. and T. Landon: 2004, ‘It’s Cleanup Time at Citi: A New C.E.O. Aims to Overhaul the Superbank’s Culture’, New York Times, Nov. 7, 2004, section 3, pp. 1–7.Google Scholar
  75. Oliver, C. 1991‘Strategic Responses to Institutional Processes’Academy of Management Review16145179Google Scholar
  76. Oxford English Dictionary: 1971, (Oxford University Press, New York)Google Scholar
  77. Pearson, C. M., Clair, J. A. 1998‘Rethinking Crisis Management’Academy of Management Review235976Google Scholar
  78. Pearson, C. M., J. A. Clair, S. Kovoor-Misra and I. I. Mitroff: 1997, ‘Managing the Unthinkable’. Organizational Dynamics, Autumn, 51–64.Google Scholar
  79. Pfeiffer, S.: 1999, Court Protects Anonymity of Globe Sources in Dana-Farber Case. The Boston Globe, February 27, p. B4.Google Scholar
  80. Rogers, B. 1986The IBM wayHarper and RowNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  81. Sapsford J. (2004). Citigrop’s Weill Received Bonus of $29 Million in Cash for 2003, Wall Street Journal, March 17, C3.Google Scholar
  82. Schrivastava, P. 1993‘Crisis Theory/Practice: Towards a Sustainable Future’Industrial and Environmental Crisis Quarterly72342Google Scholar
  83. Schweiger, D. M., Sandberg, W. R., Ragan, J. W. 1986‘Group Approaches for Improving Strategic Decision Making: A Comparative Analysis of Dialectical Inquiry, Devil’s Advocacy, and Consensus’Academy of Management Journal295171Google Scholar
  84. Schweiger, D. M., Sandberg, W. R. 1989‘The Utilization of Individual Capabilities in Group Approaches to Strategic Decision Making’Strategic Management Journal103143Google Scholar
  85. Schweiger, D. M., Sandberg, W. R., Rechner, P. L. 1989‘Experiential Effects of Dialectical Inquiry, Devil’s Advocacy, and Consensus Approaches to Strategic Decision Making’Academy of Management Journal32745722Google Scholar
  86. Senge, P. 1990The Fifth DisciplineDoubledayNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  87. Smith, C., Child, J., Rowlinson, M. 1990Reshaping Work: The Cadbury ExperienceCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  88. Smith, R., C. Susanne and S. Deborah: 2003, Wall Street Firms to Pay $1.4 Billion to End Inquiry, Wall Street Journal, April 29, p. 1, 6.Google Scholar
  89. Steere, D. 1938Translator’s introduction to Soren Kierkegaard’s Purity of HeartHarper and RowNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  90. Steere, D. 1949Introduction to Soren Kierkegaard’s Works of LovePrinceton University PressPrincetonGoogle Scholar
  91. Steere, D. 1957Work and contemplationHarper & BrothersNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  92. Steiker, J. and Michael G.: 2000, Insiders Tell How Social Investors Tried to (but couldn’t) Buy Ben and Jerry’s, Business Ethics, May–June, p. 7.Google Scholar
  93. Tennant, F.: 2004, ‘The Tylenol Toxicity Issue’, Intractable Pain News, February 27, pp. 1–2.Google Scholar
  94. The Economist: 2003, ‘The Wall Street Settlement: Unclean Slate’, January 4, p. 59.Google Scholar
  95. Weick, K. E. 1979The social psychology of organizingRandom HouseNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  96. Windsor, D. B. 1980The Quaker Enterprise: Friends in BusinessFrederick Muller LimitedLondonGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Organization studiesBoston CollegeChestnut HillU.S.A
  2. 2.Ph.D. candidate in the Organization Studies Department of the Carroll School of ManagementBoston CollegeU.S.A

Personalised recommendations