Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 59, Issue 1–2, pp 121–138 | Cite as

Corruption and Development: New Initiatives in Economic Openness and Strengthened Rule of Law

Article

Abstract

Corruption is a major problem in many of the world’s developing economies today. World Bank studies put bribery at over $1 trillion per year accounting for up to 12 of the GDP of nations like Nigeria, Kenya and Venezuela. Though largely ignored for many years, interest in world wide corruption has been rekindled by recent corporate scandals in the US and Europe. Corruption in the developing nations is said to result from a number of factors. Mass poverty has been cited as a facilitating condition for corruption just as an inability to manage a sudden upsurge in mineral revenues has been credited with breeding corruption and adventurous government procurement among public officials in countries like Nigeria and Venezuela. Virtually all developing nations that have serious corruption problems also have very limited economic freedom and a very weak enforcement of the rule of law. In such nations, corruption represents a regressive taxation that bears hard on the poor. It has a dampening effect on development and it could result in the production of inferior goods as companies find ways to accommodate under-the-table payments. Finally, corruption is a dangerous threat to the legitimacy of the governments of some of the developing nations themselves. It is suggested that new urgent initiatives are needed to deal with the dangers posed by corruption in the developing economies. They include making the economies of these nations more open by the withdrawal of the government from the productive sector and by the abolition of unnecessarily stringent restrictions on business conduct. The rule of law needs to be strengthened in these nations and those countries like Nigeria and Venezuela should ignore scruples over sovereignty and seek foreign assistance in the management of their oil wealth. Finally, multinationals should be made to disclose all the payments they make in developing nations to such organizations like International Chamber of Commerce or Transparency International where they can be reviewed by anyone interested.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Adeoye, S.: 2004, ‘70 million Poor People In Nigeria Says UN’, www.Guardiannewsng.com, February 16.Google Scholar
  2. Akande, L.: 2004, ‘Powell Speaks On Nigerian, African Issues In Special Interview At UN’, www.naijanet.com/news, February 9.Google Scholar
  3. Agande, B.: 2004, ‘Representative To Probe Bribery Allegation’, www.vanguardngr.com, Lagos, Nigeria, February 4.Google Scholar
  4. Agnes, M. 1999Webster’s New World College Dictionary4Cleveland, Ohio, McMillanUSA488General EditorGoogle Scholar
  5. Aluko, M.: 2004, ‘Nigeria and Her Membership of OPEC’, www.africaeconomicanalysis.org/articles, Lagos, Nigeria, February, 10.Google Scholar
  6. Banfield, E. 1998The Moral Basis of A Backward SocietyThe Free PressChicago, Illinois113Google Scholar
  7. Barro, R. 2000

    ‘Rule of Law, Democracy and Economic Performance’

    O’Driscoll, G.Holmes, K.Kirkpatrick, M. eds. 2000 Index of Economic Freedom.The Heritage Foundation/Dow Jones Company IncWashington, DC3151
    Google Scholar
  8. Bartlett, B. 2002‘Foreign Aid Is A Problem, Not A Solution’ Daily Policy DigestNational Center For Policy AnalysisWashington, DCMarch 18.Google Scholar
  9. Bowman, J. 1991

    ‘Introduction: Ethical Theory and Practice In Public Management’

    Bowman, J. eds. Ethical Frontier In Public Management: Setting New Strategies For Resolving Ethical Dilemmas.Jossey BaseSan Francisco, California3351
    Google Scholar
  10. Central Intelligence Agency: 2003, World Factbook, Country Profiles for Nigeria, Kenya and Venezuela, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  11. Clay, E.: 2004, ‘UK Envy’s Speech on Kenyan Corruption’, BBC, London, http:/news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/Africa/ 3893625.stm, July 14.Google Scholar
  12. Djebah, O.: 2004, ‘I’ll Sack Corrupt Ministers-Obasanjo’, Lagos, Nigeria, www.odili.net/news, February 5.Google Scholar
  13. Eiras, A. L.: 2003a, ‘The Poverty of Nations’, (Washington DC), www.heritage.org/press/commentary/ed091803b. cfm, September 18.Google Scholar
  14. Eiras, A. L.: 2003b, Make The Rule of Law A Necessary Condition For The Millennium Challenge Account (Washington DC), www.heritage.org/research/trade andforeignaid/BG1634.cfm, Backgrounder # 1634, March 7.Google Scholar
  15. Fourcault, H. 2004The Organization Integrity Initiative: A Novel Value-Added Approach For MultinationalsInternational Conference on Codes of Conduct For Multinational Corporations: Promises and Challenges, Baruch College, City University of New YorkNew York, New YorkMay 12–15Google Scholar
  16. Harris, H. 2004Performance Measurement for Voluntary Codes: An Opportunity and A ChallengeInternational Conference on Voluntary Codes of Conduct for Multinational Corporations, Baruch College, City University of New YorkNew York, NYMay 12–15Google Scholar
  17. Heiman, F.: 2003, ‘Presentation By The International Chamber of Commerce At The Signing Conference of United Nations Convention Against Corruption’, www.iccbwo.org/home/menu_extortion_bribery.asp, Mexico, December 11.Google Scholar
  18. Hellman, J., Geraint, J., Kufmann, D. 2000‘Procurement Kickbacks In Eastern Europe’, TransitionThe World Bank Group, Development Economics GroupWashington DCAugustGoogle Scholar
  19. Hoskins, L., Eiras, A. 2003

    ‘Property Rights: The Key To Economic Growth’

    O’Driscoll, G.Holmes, K.O’Grady, M. eds. 2002 Index of Economic FreedomThe Heritage Foundation/Dow Jones Company IncWashington DC
    Google Scholar
  20. International Center For Corporate Accountability.2004International Conference on Voluntary Codes of Conduct For Multinational CorporationsPromises and Challenges, Bernard Baruch College, City University of NewYork New York New YorkMay 12–15Google Scholar
  21. InternationalChamber of, Commerce. 2004Statement of MissionFranceParisJanuaryGoogle Scholar
  22. Lipset, S., Lenz, G. 2000

    ‘Competition, Culture and Markets’

    Lawrence, HansonSamuel, Huntington eds. Cultural MattersBasic BooksNew York, NY112
    Google Scholar
  23. Lovitt, J. 2004Transparency International Urges African Leaders To Sign And Ratify AU And UN Anti-Corruption ConventionsEthiopiaBerlin, Germany and Addis, AbabaJuly 6Google Scholar
  24. Merton, R. 1987Social Theory and Social StructureThe Free PressNew York, New York212Google Scholar
  25. Murungi K.: 2004, ‘Kenya Finds $1 billion Stashed Abroad’, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/3728729.stm, London, UK, May 19.Google Scholar
  26. Newton, L., Ford, M. 2004Taking Sides: Clashing Views On Controversial Issues In Business Ethics and SocietyMcGraw-Hill/Dushkin GuilfordConnecticut1141198thGoogle Scholar
  27. Nwabuzor, A. 2004‘Dealing With Corruption In Developing Economies: A Nigerian Test Case’, International Conference On Voluntary Codes of Conduct For Multinational Corporations: Promises and ChallengesBaruch College, City University of New York, New YorkNew YorkMay 12–15Google Scholar
  28. O’Driscoll, G., Holmes, K., O’Grady, M. 20032002 Index of Economic FreedomThe Heritage Foundation/Dow Jones Company IncWashington DCGoogle Scholar
  29. O’Driscoll G., K. Holmes, and M. O’Grady: 2003, 2002 Index of Economic Freedom, (The Heritage Foundation/ Dow Jones Company Inc., Washington DC).Google Scholar
  30. Okeke, C.: 2004, ‘ICPC Holds Governor, 63 Others Over Corruption’, www.dailyindependentng.com, Lagos, Nigeria, February 18.Google Scholar
  31. Okwe, M.: 2004, ‘Minister Alleges N100 million Bribe By Contractor’ www.guardiannewsngr.com, Lagos, Nigeria, February 20.Google Scholar
  32. Olaleye, Y.: 2004, ‘Banks’ Recapitalization: First Bank Boss Predicts Consolidation’ www.odili.net/news, Lagos, Nigeria, February 9.Google Scholar
  33. Onalaja, T., Onalaja, K. 1991How Polygamy Wrecks Nigeria, AfricaCapwona BooksLondon, UK29Google Scholar
  34. Organization For Economic Cooperation and Development: 1999, Development Assistance Committee, ‘Aid Activities In Least Developed Countries’, www.oecd.org/scripts/cde/viewbase.asp.Google Scholar
  35. Osagie, C.: 2004, ‘Nigeria Records N261 million Import Duty Shortfall’, www.thisdayonline.com/news, Lagos, Nigeria, February 16.Google Scholar
  36. Phombeah, G.: 1999, ‘Profile: Kenya’s anti-graft czar’, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/2670075.stm, Nairobi, KenyaSen Armatya, Development AS Freedom, (Alfred Knopf, New York, NY) p. 42.Google Scholar
  37. Posadas, A.: 2000, ‘Conbating Corruption Under International Law: The World Changes and International Anti-Corruption Initiatives Flourish 1989–199’, Duke Journal of Comparative and International Law 10(4).Google Scholar
  38. Rogriguez, C. 2001International Management: A Cultural Approach2Southwestern College Publishing, Thomson Learning CincinnatiOhio213Google Scholar
  39. Schleifer, A., Vishny, R. 1993‘Corruption’Quarterly Journal of Economics103599617Google Scholar
  40. Todaro, M., Smith, S. 2003Economic DevelopmentAddison WesleyNew York, NY711Google Scholar
  41. Sticka, J. 2004‘New EU Members Join Campaign Against Public Sector Corruption’Transparency InternationalBerlin, GermanyJuly 14Google Scholar
  42. Transparency International: 1995–2003, The Corruption Perceptions Index.Google Scholar
  43. The Financial Times: 2004, ‘The New 419 Scam In Nigeria’, London, UK, February 6.Google Scholar
  44. The Guardian.2004‘Minister Frowns At Corruption By Foreign Company Executives’Guardian NewspapersLagos NigeriaFebruary 13Google Scholar
  45. ThisDay.2004‘Representatives Unhappy With Privatization Pace’ThisDay NewspapersLagos NigeriaFebruary 18Google Scholar
  46. The White House: 2002, ‘The Millennium Challenge Account’, www.whitehouse.gov/infocus/developingnations/millennium.html, Washington DC, March 11.Google Scholar
  47. The World Bank Group: 2004, Development Data Group, ‘ICT At A Glance: Nigeria, Kenya and Venezuela’, Washington DC.Google Scholar
  48. Veral, E. 2004‘Voluntary Codes of Conduct: Challenge of Performance Measurement and Evaluation’, International Conference on Voluntary Codes of Conduct For Multinational CorporationsBaruch College, City University of NewYork New, York NYMay 12–15Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Florida A and M UniversityTallahasseeU.S.A.

Personalised recommendations