Advertisement

Journal of Business Ethics

, 56:239 | Cite as

Indigenous Peoples, Resource Extraction and Sustainable Development: An Ethical Approach

  • David A. Lertzman
  • Harrie Vredenburg
Article

Abstract

Resource extraction companies worldwide are involved with Indigenous peoples. Historically these interactions have been antagonistic, yet there is a growing public expectation for improved ethical performance of resource industries to engage with Indigenous peoples. (Crawley and Sinclair, Journal of Business Ethics 45, 361–373 (2003)) proposed an ethical model for human resource practices with Indigenous peoples in Australian mining companies. This paper expands on this work by re-framing the discussion within the context of sustainable development, extending it to Canada, and generalizing to other resource industries. We argue that it is unethical to sacrifice the viability of Indigenous cultures for industrial resource extraction; it is ethical to engage with indigenous peoples in a manner consistent with their wishes and needs as they perceive them. We apply these ideas to a case study in the coastal temperate rainforest of Clayoquot Sound, British Columbia, Canada. In this case a scientific panel comprised of Nuu-Chah-Nulth elders, forest scientists and management professionals, achieved full consensus on developing sustainable forest practice standards by drawing equally on Indigenous traditional ecological knowledge and Western science in the context of one of the most heated and protracted environmental conflicts in Canadian history. The resulting sustainable forest practice standards were later adopted by leading forestry firms operating on the coast. Our analysis of this scientific panel’s success provides the basis for advancing an ethical approach to sustainable development with Indigenous peoples. This ethical approach is applicable to companies working in natural resource industries where the territories of Indigenous peoples are involved.

Keywords

Indigenous peoples resource industries sustainable development traditional ecological knowledge western science forest practices cross cultural bridging 

Abbreviations

TEK

Traditional Ecological Knowledge

TEKS

Traditional Ecological Knowledge Systems

References

  1. Assembly of First Nations1994Breaking the silence, an interpretive study of residential school impact and healing as illustrated by the stories of First Nations individualsOntarioOttawaGoogle Scholar
  2. Barman, J. D., McCaskill, , Hébert, Y. 1986Indian Education in Canada Vol 1 The LegacyUniversity of British Columbia PressVancouverGoogle Scholar
  3. Battiste, M., (Sa’ke’j)Youngblood Henderson, J. 2000Protecting Indigenous Knowledge and HeritagePurichSaskatoonGoogle Scholar
  4. Berkes, F. 1993Traditional Ecological Knowledge in PerspectiveInglis, J. T. eds. Traditional Ecological Knowledge Concepts and CasesInternational Program on Traditional Ecological Knowledge (Canadian Museum of Nature) and International Development Research CentreOttawaGoogle Scholar
  5. Berkes, F., Folkes, C. 1994Investing in Cultural Capital for Sustainable Use of Natural CapitalJannson, A-M.Hammer, M.Carl, FolkeRobert, Costanza eds. Investing In Natural Capital The Ecological Economics Approach to SustainabilityIsland PressWashington DCGoogle Scholar
  6. Canada, Supreme Court: 1997, Delgamuukw v. British Columbia. File No.: 23799, 1997; June 16, 17; December 11, under General Principles, Item No. 84Google Scholar
  7. Coleman, J. 1990The Foundations of Social TheoryHarvard University PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  8. Crawley, A., Sinclair, A. 2003Indigenous Human Resource Practices in Australian Mining Companies: Towards and Ethical ModelJournal of Business Ethics45361373Google Scholar
  9. Cruikshank, J. 1981Legend and Landscape: Convergence of Oral and Scientific Tradition in the Yukon TerritoryArctic Anthropology186793Google Scholar
  10. Cruikshank, J. 1998The Social Life of StoriesUniversity of Nebraska PressLincolnGoogle Scholar
  11. Daly, H. 1994Operationalizing Sustainable Development by Investing in Natural CapitalJannson, A-M.Hammer, M.Folke, C.Costanza, R. eds. Investing In Natural Capital: The Ecological Economics Approach to SustainabilityIsland PressWashington, D.CGoogle Scholar
  12. DesJardins, J. 1998Corporate Environmental ResponsibilityJournal of Business Ethics17825838Google Scholar
  13. Duerden, F., Kuhn, R. 1998Scale, Context and Application of Traditional Knowledge in the Canadian NorthPolar Record343138CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Fisher, R. 1983Contact and Conflict, Indian-European Relations in British ColumbiaUBC PressVancouver17741890Google Scholar
  15. Freeman, M. M. R.,  et al. 1985Appeal to Tradition: Different Perspectives on Wildlife ManagementBrosted, J. eds. Native Power: The Quest for Autonomy and Nationhood of Aboriginal PeoplesUniversitetsforlagetOsloGoogle Scholar
  16. Freeman, M. M. R. 1995The Nature and Utility of Traditional Ecological KnowledgeChad, GaffieldPam, Gaffield eds. Consuming CanadaCopp Clark LtdTorontoGoogle Scholar
  17. Garcia, P., Vredenburg, H. 2003Building Corporate Citizenship through Strategic Bridging in the Oil and Gas Industry in Latin AmericaJournal of Corporate Citizenship103749Google Scholar
  18. Hall, J., Vredenburg, H. 2003The Challenges of Innovating for Sustainable DevelopmentMIT Sloan Management Review456168Google Scholar
  19. Hart, S. 1995A Natural Resource-Based-View of the FirmAcademy of Management Review209861014Google Scholar
  20. Hart, S.: 1997, ‘Beyond Greening: Strategies for a Sustainable World’, Harvard Business Review 75 (January/February)Google Scholar
  21. Hart, S., Milstein, M. 1999Global Sustainability and the Creative Destruction of IndustriesMIT Sloan Management Review412334Google Scholar
  22. Higginson, N.: 2004, Firm-ENGO Strategic Alliances as a Knowledge-Based Strategy for Sustainability: The Case of the Joint Solutions Project in B.C.’s Coastal Forest Products Industry, Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, Haskayne School of Business, (University of Calgary, Calgary)Google Scholar
  23. Lertzman, D. 1996A Spirit of Understanding: Community Based Program and Curriculum Guidelines for the First Nations Integrated Resource Management ProgramMinistry of Education, Skills and Training, Province of British ColumbiaVictoriaGoogle Scholar
  24. Lertzman, D. A.: 1999, Planning Between Cultural Paradigms: Traditional Knowledge and the Transition to Ecological Sustainability, Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, School of Community and Regional Planning, (University of British Columbia, Vancouver)Google Scholar
  25. Lertzman, D. A.: 2002, ‘Rediscovering Rites of Passage: Education, Transformation and the Transition to Sustainability’, Conservation Ecology 5(2)Google Scholar
  26. Lertzman, D. A. 2003Caveat on Consilience: Barriers and Bridges for Traditional Knowledge and Conservation ScienceWestley, Miller,  eds. Experiments in Consilience: Integrating Social and Scientific Responses to Save Endangered SpeciesIsland PressWashington DCGoogle Scholar
  27. Lozano, J. F., Boni, A. 2002The Impact of The Multi-National in the Development: An Ethical ChallengeJournal of Business Ethics39169178Google Scholar
  28. Mac Gregor, R.: 2001, ‘Natives meet ‘to save our children”, Globe and Mail, February 8: 9Google Scholar
  29. McKee, C. 2000Treaty Talks in British ColumbiaUBC PressVancouverGoogle Scholar
  30. Macklem, P. 2001Indigenous Difference and the Constitution of CanadaUniversity of Toronto PressTorontoGoogle Scholar
  31. Nadasdy, P. 1999The Politics of TEK: Power and the ‘Integration’ of KnowledgeArctic Anthropology36118Google Scholar
  32. Nettle, D., Romaine, S. 2001Vanishing Voices: the Extinction of the World’s LanguagesOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  33. Pablo, A., Sharma, S., Vredenburg, H. 1999Corporate Environmental Responsiveness Strategies: The Importance of Issue Interpretation and Organizational ContextJournal of Applied Behavioral Science3587108Google Scholar
  34. Pasquero, J. 1991Supra-organizational Collaboration: The Canadian Environmental ExperimentJournal of Applied Behavioral Science273864Google Scholar
  35. Payne, D. M., Raiborn, C. A. 2001Sustainable Development, The Ethics Support the EconomicsJournal of Business Ethics32157168Google Scholar
  36. Pearce, D., Markandya, A., Barbler, E. B. 1989Blueprint for a Green EconomyEarthscanLondonGoogle Scholar
  37. Porter, M., Linde, C. 1995Green and Competitive: Ending the StalemateHarvard Business Review73120134Google Scholar
  38. Price, R. 1999The Spirit of the Alberta Indian TreatiesUniversity of Alberta PressEdmontonGoogle Scholar
  39. Putnam, R. 1993Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern ItalyPrinceton University PressPrinceton, New JerseyGoogle Scholar
  40. Rees, W.: 1989, Defining ‘Sustainable Development’, UBC Centre for Human Settlements, CHS Research Bulletin, University of British ColumbiaGoogle Scholar
  41. Rees, W.: 1990, ‘Sustainable Development and the Biosphere.’ Teilhard Studies 23Google Scholar
  42. Rees, W.: 1996, ‘Revisiting Carrying Capacity: Area-Based Indicators of Sustainability.’ Population and Environment 17Google Scholar
  43. Rees, W. 1997Is ’Sustainable City’ an Oxymoron?in Local Environment2303310Google Scholar
  44. Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples1995Choosing Life: Special Report on Suicide Amongst Aboriginal PeopleMinister of Supply and Services CanadaOttawaGoogle Scholar
  45. Scientific Panel for Sustainable Forest Practices in Clayoquot Sound: 1995,Report 3 First Nations’ Perspectives Relating To Forest Practices in Clayoquot Sound, VictoriaGoogle Scholar
  46. Semmens, G.: 2004, ‘Environmentalists Attack Encana’s Record in Ecuador’, Calgary Herald, March 26, B10Google Scholar
  47. Senge, P., Carstedt, G. 2001Innovating Our Way to the Next Industrial RevolutionMIT Sloan Management Review422438Google Scholar
  48. Sharma, S., Vredenburg, H. 1998Proactive Corporate Environmental Strategy and the Development of Competitively Valuable Organizational CapabilitiesStrategic Management Journal19729753Google Scholar
  49. Sharma, , Vredenburg, H., Westley, F. 1994Strategic Bridging: A Role for the Multinational Corporation in Third World DevelopmentJournal of Applied Behavioral Science30458476Google Scholar
  50. Stormer, F. 2003Making the Shift: Moving from ‘Ethics Pays’ to an Inter-systems Model of BusinessJournal of Business Ethics44279289Google Scholar
  51. Titley, E. B. 1986A Narrow Vision, Duncan Campbell Scott and the Administration of Indian Affairs in CanadaUniversity of British Columbia PressVancouverGoogle Scholar
  52. Treaty Seven Elders and Tribal Council with W. Hilderandt, S. Carter and D. First Rider: 1997,The True Spirit and Original Intent of Treaty 7, (McGill–Queen’s University Press, Montreal)Google Scholar
  53. Trosper, R. L. 1998Incentive Systems That Support Sustainability: A First Nations ExampleConservation Ecology211Google Scholar
  54. Tuhiwai Smith, L. 2001Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous PeoplesZed BooksNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  55. Turner, N. J., Ignace, M. B., Ignace, R. 2000Traditional ecological knowledge and wisdom of aboriginal peoples of British ColumbiaEcological Applications1012751287Google Scholar
  56. Turner, R. K., Doktor, P., Adger, N. 1994Sea-Level Rise & Coastal Wetlands in the U.K.: Mitigation Strategies for Sustainable DevelopmentJannson, A. M.Hammer, M.Folke, C.Costanza, R. eds. Investing In Natural Capital: The Ecological Economics Approach to SustainabilityIsland PressWashington D.CGoogle Scholar
  57. Vredenburg, H. 2003Strangers at the Party: An Industry Strategy Perspective on PHVAsWestley, Miller,  eds. Experiments in Consilience: Integrating Social and Scientific Responses to Save Endangered SpeciesIsland PressWashington DCGoogle Scholar
  58. Vredenburg, H., Westley, F. 1997Innovation and Sustainability in Natural Resource IndustriesOptimum: the Journal of Public Sector Management273249Google Scholar
  59. Vredenburg, H. and F. Westley: 2002, ‘Sustainable Development Leadership in Three Contexts: Managing for Global Competitiveness’, Journal of Business Administration (Special Issue), 239–259Google Scholar
  60. Westley, F., Vredenburg, H. 1996Sustainability and the Corporation: Criteria for Aligning Economic Practice with Environmental ProtectionJournal of Management Inquiry5104119Google Scholar
  61. Wilson, E. O. 1999Consilience: The Unity of KnowledgeVintage BooksNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  62. World Commission on Environment nd Development1987Our Common FutureOxford University PressTorontoGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Environmental Management and Sustainable Development, TransCanada International Institute for Resource Industries and Sustainability Studies, Haskayne School of BusinessUniversity of CalgaryAlbertaCanada
  2. 2.Suncor Energy Chair of Competitive Strategy and Sustainable Development, TransCanada International Institute for Resource Industries and Sustainability Studies, Haskayne School of BusinessUniversity of CalgaryAlbertaCanada

Personalised recommendations