Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere and Fazio Londe syndrome is associated with a riboflavin transporter defect mimicking mild MADD: a new inborn error of metabolism with potential treatment
We report on three patients (two siblings and one unrelated) presenting in infancy with progressive muscle weakness and paralysis of the diaphragm. Metabolic studies revealed a profile of plasma acylcarnitines and urine organic acids suggestive of a mild form of the multiple acyl-CoA dehydrogenation defect (MADD, ethylmalonic/adipic acid syndrome). Subsequently, a profound flavin deficiency in spite of a normal dietary riboflavin intake was established in the plasma of all three children, suggesting a riboflavin transporter defect. Genetic analysis of these patients demonstrated mutations in the C20orf54 gene which encodes the human homolog of a rat riboflavin transporter. This gene was recently implicated in the Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere syndrome, a rare neurological disorder which may either present in infancy with neurological deterioration with hypotonia, respiratory insufficiency and early death, or later in life with deafness and progressive ponto-bulbar palsy. Supplementation of riboflavin rapidly improved the clinical symptoms as well as the biochemical abnormalities in our patients, demonstrating that high dose riboflavin is a potential treatment for the Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere syndrome as well as for the Fazio Londe syndrome which is considered to be the same disease entity without the deafness.
Brown-Vialetto-van Laere syndrome (MIM 211530), is a rare neurological disorder which may present in infancy with a devastating neurological deterioration with hypotonia, respiratory insufficiency and early death, or later in life with deafness and progressive ponto-bulbar palsy (Green et al. 2010; Sathasivam 2008). The same clinical presentation without deafness is also known as Fazio Londe disease (MIM 211500). Both are now considered to be a single disease entity (Dipti et al. 2005).
The multiple acyl-CoA dehydrogenation defect (MADD) is an inherited defect of mitochondrial fatty acid beta-oxidation and branched-chain amino acid catabolism (MIM231680). This disorder is characterized by the malfunctioning of an array of dehydrogenation reactions caused by the absence of either electron transfer flavoprotein (ETF) or electron transfer flavoprotein oxidoreductase (ETFDH). The electrons which are liberated in the dehydrogenation reactions are primarily captured by flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD), a metabolite of the vitamin riboflavin. MADD may present at any age, varying from a lethal neonatal form and an infantile form characterized by hazardous hypoketotic hypoglycaemia (Rhead et al. 1987) to relatively mild adult lipid storage myopathy (Antozzi et al. 1994). Riboflavin responsive forms of MADD are usually the consequence of a defective ETFDH (Olsen et al. 2007).
We present two siblings and one unrelated patient, presenting in infancy with progressive muscle weakness and paralysis of the diaphragm, later recognized as Fazio Londe and Brown-Vialetto-van Laere syndrome. Our patients demonstrated abnormalities on metabolic evaluation mimicking mild MADD and were found to be severely flavin deficient. Riboflavin therapy resulted in a rapid clinical and biochemical improvement.
Patients and methods
Plasma acylcarnitines (μmol/L) in patient, 2, and 3 compared to a MADD patient, a patient with the ethylmalonic acid syndrome, and healthy controls. Bold values are outside normal range
Pat 1 before riboflavin
Pat 2 before riboflavin
Pat 3 at start of treatment
Urine organic acids (mmol/mol creat) in patient 1 compared to a MADD patient, a patient with the ethylmalonic acid syndrome, and healthy controls
Pat 1 before riboflavin
A tracheotomy was placed and the boy’s muscle tone slowly improved over the next month. He was able to walk independently at the age of 22 months. As the diaphragmatic paralysis persisted, he needed nightly ventilation until the age of 41 months. Recently, the clinical diagnosis of Fazio Londe Syndrome was made. He is currently 46 months old, his cognitive development is fully normal and he demonstrates no further cranial nerve palsy.
Recently, the 3 months-old sister of patient 1 presented with failure to thrive and generalized axial muscle weakness. Based on the results of the additional studies in her brother, flavin deficiency was suspected, subsequently confirmed by the analysis of plasma flavins and acylcarnitines, and treatment with riboflavin (10 mg/kg body weight /day) was started. This resulted in normalization of her muscle tone within 7 days and a rapid catch-up growth. Sensorineural hearing loss was excluded by brainstem evoked response audiometry. Therefore, the clinical diagnosis of Fazio Londe Syndrome was made. After 3 months of riboflavin supplementation her growth and development are normal.
A now 7 year old girl, second child of healthy parents, demonstrated feeding problems and a slow motor development since birth. At the age of 5 months she had generalized weakness, more pronounced in distal than proximal muscle groups, and developed respiratory insufficiency necessitating artificial ventilation due to diaphragmatic paralysis. Furthermore, she was found to have a severe sensorineural hearing loss. SMA and SMARD were excluded by genetic testing. Muscle histology at the age of one year showed slight predominance of type 1 fibers without type grouping. Biochemical analysis of the mitochondrial respiratory chain in muscle tissue was inconclusive.
At the age of 6 months, metabolic studies revealed an acylcarnitine profile suggestive of MADD (Table 1). A fat restricted diet and supplementation with carnitine (50 mg/kg / day), riboflavin (10 mg/kg /day) and glycine and 3-hydroxybutyrate according to the publication by Van Hove et al. (2003) were started. Her muscle strength improved and from the age of 2 years artificial ventilation was only necessary during sleep. Cognitive development was normal.
Classical MADD was ruled out by enzymatic testing in fibroblasts and mutation analysis of the ETFDH, ETFA and ETFB genes. Following the normalization of the acylcarnitine profiles, the fat restriction was gradually discontinued and the glycine, 3-hydroxybutyrate and carnitine supplementations were stopped without problems. However, withdrawal of riboflavin at the age of 4 years resulted in a rapid clinical deterioration with vomiting, progressive fatigue, and elevations of lactate, liver enzymes and CK. The acylcarnitine profile became abnormal again. Reintroduction of riboflavin (50 mg b.i.d.) resulted in clinical improvement and normalization of the biochemical abnormalities. Sequence analysis of the mitochondrial FAD transporter (Spaan et al. 2005) was performed on suspicion of a possible mitochondrial riboflavin transporter defect, but showed no abnormalities.
After reintroduction of riboflavin supplementation the patient had a stable clinical course. She walked with a foot drop and attended a school for hearing impaired children. The parents gradually decreased the dose of riboflavin to 10 mg b.i.d. because they suspected gastrointestinal side effects of the high doses of riboflavin. However, after 5 years she developed palsies of the 7th and 12th cranial nerves, and became wheelchair bound. Furthermore, following a lower respiratory tract infection at the age of 6.5 years she became once again completely ventilator dependent, and her muscle strength slowly deteriorated. Only recently, the clinical diagnosis of Brown-Violetto-Van Laere syndrome was confirmed. The riboflavin dose was increased to 50 mg t.i.d., thus far without improvement of her symptoms.
Selective screening for inborn errors of metabolism was performed by standard techniques including analysis of organic acids in urine and acylcarnitines in plasma. Plasma riboflavin, flavin mononucleotide (FMN) and FAD concentrations were measured by high-performance liquid chromatography using fluorescence detection of the analytes according to the method of Capo-chichi et al. (2000) with minor modifications.
Because plasma flavins were deficient in all three patients despite a normal intake, we suspected a defect in intestinal riboflavin uptake and we therefore performed mutation analysis of the C20orf54 gene. The protein encoded by this gene is highly similar to the rat rRFT2 protein, which has been shown to be the transporter of riboflavin in the small intestine (Yamamoto et al. 2009). Mutation analysis of the gene was performed by sequencing all exons plus flanking intronic sequences amplified from genomic DNA extracted from the patients’ cells. Confirmation of the mutation in the parental genes was performed in genomic DNA extracted from blood cells.
Fibroblast fatty acid oxidation studies were carried out in patients 1 and 3 by incubating the cells with U-13C palmitate for 96 hours followed by the analysis of acylcarnitines in the supernatant (Ventura et al. 1999).
After the diagnosis had been established, the acylcarnitine profiles of the newborn screening bloodspots of patients 1 and 2 were evaluated by standard ESI-tandem mass spectrometric analysis. The newborn sample of patient 3 was no longer available.
The initial diagnostic work-up of patient 1 included an analysis of plasma acylcarnitines and urine organic acids (Tables 1 and 2). A moderate accumulation of short and medium-chain acylcarnitines was observed. The long-chain acylcarnitines were normal. The profiles observed in patients 2 and 3 were similar but differed somewhat in the levels of the long-chain acylcarnitines, demonstrating the biochemical variability of this defect. The acylcarnitine profiles of the newborn screening bloodspots of patients 1 and 2 were normal (not shown), which demonstrates that newborn screening for a riboflavin transporter by this method is not feasible.
For comparison, plasma of a patient with an ETHE defect was also investigated, demonstrating an accumulation of short-chain acylcarnitines only (Table 1). Finally, plasma of an infantile patient with hypoketotic hypoglycaemic MADD resulting from a homozygous mutation of the ETFDH gene showed increased levels of all characteristic short-, medium-, and long-chain acylcarnitines as well as glutarylcarnitine. Glutarylcarnitine was normal in both the riboflavin transporter patients and the ETHE patient (Table 1). The C4 carnitine consisted mainly of the isobutyrylcarnitine, pointing to a considerable vulnerability of Acad 8 in all conditions described here.
Plasma flavin values in patients 1, 2,and 3 before and after the start of riboflavin therapy
Controls (mean +/- 2 SD) (n = 43, ages 0–35 y)
Patient 1 before treatment
Patient 1 2 weeks after start therapy
Patient 2 before treatment
Patient 2 4 weeks after start treatment
Patient 3 at start of treatment
Patient 3 with supplementation
The fibroblast fatty acid oxidation studies in patients 1 and 3 revealed a normal profile of acylcarnitines, in sharp contrast to the results obtained in the ETFDH patient, showing accumulation of all C4-C16 intermediates.
Concentrations of riboflavin, FMN and FAD in plasma before treatment revealed a deficiency of all flavins in patients 1 and 2 (Table 3) whereas patient 3 had markedly decreased levels of FMN and FAD. Riboflavin levels normalized within weeks after the start of riboflavin supplementation. Cessation of supplementation in patients 1 and 3 resulted in rapid recurrence of the deficient state. Plasma flavins of the mother of patients 1 and 2 were normal.
Patient 1 and 2 were found to be homozygous for a pathogenic splice acceptor site mutation in C20orf54: c.1198-2A>C which is most probably pathogenic as it concerns a mutation of an invariant nucleotide of a splice acceptor site and thus will lead to incorrect mRNA splicing. The parents, second cousins, were heterozygous for this mutation. Patient 3 was found to be heterozygous for two mutations in the C20orf54 gene: c.49T>C (p.W17R) and c.639C>G (p.Y213X). The latter mutation was also identified by Green et al. (2010). The c.49T>C mutation affects a tryptophan at position 17, which is highly conserved in orthologs of different species.
Riboflavin is the precursor of FAD, which acts as an electron acceptor in a number of acyl-CoA dehydrogenation reactions involved in mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation and branched-chain amino acid catabolism (Gregersen et al. 2008). An inherited or acquired deficiency of riboflavin will therefore mimic the biochemical presentation observed in classical MADD, which was indeed observed in a riboflavin-deficient rat (Goodman 1981). The biochemical abnormalities observed in our patients are reminiscent of the mild forms of MADD, originally described as ethylmalonic/adipic aciduria (Tanaka et al. 1977). Our data suggest that the short-chain and medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenases are more vulnerable to the shortage of the physiological electron acceptor than the long-chain analogues. Similarly, glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase was only mildly affected, in contrast to the D-2 hydroxyglutarate dehydrogenase.
Based on the profiles of acylcarnitines and organic acids it is difficult to make the distinction between the riboflavin transporter defect and the ETHE defect. Both conditions, however, have their own diagnostic analytes, i.e., riboflavin in the riboflavin transporter defect (Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere / Fazio Londe syndrome) and thiosulfate and sulfo(thio)cysteine in ETHE (Duran et al. 1997). Metabolic studies in intact fibroblasts were normal in the transporter defect cells, probably because the riboflavin in the cell culture medium corrected the defect resulting in a normal fatty acid oxidation. Likewise, maternal riboflavin supply is the probable cause of the normal clinical condition of the patients at birth and the fact that the acylcarnitines were normal in the newborn blood spots of patients 1 and 2.
Riboflavin deficiency usually presents with different clinical symptoms (Powers 2003), but neurological symptoms resolving with riboflavin supplementation have been previously reported in a child with moderate riboflavin deficiency (Leshner 1981). Although further pathophysiological studies are needed to explain the clinical symptoms, we demonstrate that the riboflavin deficiency in our patients resulted from a defect in the riboflavin transporter, encoded by the C20orf54 gene.
Remarkably, at the same time that we discovered the molecular defects in our patients, causing a defective intestinal riboflavin transport, Green et al. (2010) reported the identification of mutations in the C20orf54 gene as the cause of the Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere Syndrome (MIM 211530). Indeed, the clinical presentation of all three patients is compatible with the diagnosis of Brown-Vialetto-van Laere (patient 3) or the Fazio Londe (patients 1 and 2) syndrome. This implies that at least part of the clinical signs and symptoms observed in these syndromes are caused by a deficiency of riboflavin and subsequently of FAD and FMN. The striking clinical and biochemical improvement on riboflavin supplementation seen in our patients strongly supports this hypothesis. We therefore presume that riboflavin may be an effective therapy in the Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere syndrome, at least in young patients. Early treatment appears to be crucial as diaphragmatic paralysis may be irreversible. Furthermore, in spite of the riboflavin supplementation since the age of 6 months, patient three now, at age 7, demonstrates the neurological deterioration frequently observed in untreated Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere patients. This can be due to damage which already occurred during the extended periods of low FAD values probably present during the first 6 months of life as well as around the age of four, or to periods of limited riboflavin availability during intercurrent illnesses, as she demonstrated clinical deterioration mostly during periods of viral illness. On the other hand, it is possible that riboflavin supplementation only shifts the clinical course of the Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere / Fazio Londe syndrome to a later presentation of the clinical symptoms. A long term follow up of a cohort of early treated children, and more insight in the pathophysiology is warranted.
Finally, our results demonstrate that selective metabolic screening, including acylcarnitine profiling and organic acid analysis of the urine, is warranted in all patients with unexplained hypotonia and that plasma flavins should be measured in patients with riboflavin responsive MADD in whom sequencing of the relevant genes fails to detected a mutation.
The authors wish to thank M. Turkenburg for technical assistance, and F.M. Vaz and R.C.M. Hennekam for valuable input and discussions.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
- Duran M, Dorland L, Van den Berg IET et al. (1997) The ethylmalonic acid syndrome is associated with deranged sulfur aminoacid metabolism leading to urinary excretion of thiosulfate and sulfothiocysteine. 8th Int Congress IEM,Vienna, Abstract 048Google Scholar
- Green P, Wiseman M, Crow YJ, et al. (2010) Brown-Vialetto-Van Laere syndrome, a pontobulbar palsy with deafness, is caused by mutations in c20orf54. Am J Hum Genet 12;86(3):485-489Google Scholar
- Leshner RT (1981) Riboflavin deficiency-a reversible neurodegenerative disease. Ann Neurol 10:294–295Google Scholar
- Tanaka K, Mantagos S, Genel M, Seashore MR, Billings BA, Baretz BH (1977) New defect in fatty acid metabolism with hypoglycaemia and organic aciduria. Lancet ii:986-987Google Scholar