Biology & Philosophy

, Volume 28, Issue 4, pp 657–673

Mirror self-recognition and symbol-mindedness

Article

Abstract

The view that mirror self-recognition (MSR) is a definitive demonstration of self-awareness is far from universally accepted, and those who do support the view need a more robust argument than the mere assumption that self-recognition implies a self-concept (e.g. Gallup in Socioecology and Psychology of Primates, Mouton, Hague, 1975; Gallup and Suarez in Psychological Perspectives on the Self, vol 3, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, 1986). In this paper I offer a new argument in favour of the view that MSR shows self-awareness by examining the nature of the mirror image itself. I argue, using the results of ‘symbol-mindedness’ experiments by Deloache (Trends Cogn Sci 8(2):66–70, 2004), that where self-recognition exists, the mirror image must be functioning as a symbol from the perspective of the subject and the subject must therefore be ‘symbol-minded’ and hence concept possessing. Further to this, according to the Concept Possession Hypothesis of Self-Consciousness (Savanah in Conscious Cogn 2011), concept possession alone is sufficient to demonstrate the existence of self-awareness. Thus MSR as a demonstration of symbol-mindedness implies the existence of self-awareness. I begin by defending the ‘mark test’ protocol as a robust methodology for determining self-recognition. Then follows a critical examination of the extreme views both for and against the interpretation of MSR as an indication of self-awareness: although the non-mentalistic interpretation of MSR is unconvincing, the argument presented by Gallup is also inadequate. I then present the symbol-mindedness argument to fill in the gaps in the Gallup approach.

Keywords

Self-awareness Self-consciousness Mirror self-recognition Symbol Symbol-mindedness Mark test Concept 

References

  1. Amsterdam B (1972) Mirror self-image reactions before age two. Dev Psychobiol 5:297–305CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Anderson JR, Gallup GG (2011) Do rhesus monkeys recognize themselves in mirrors? Am J Primatol 73:1–4Google Scholar
  3. Bermũdez JoséLuis (1998) The paradox of self-consciousness. MIT Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  4. Bertenthal B, Fischer K (1978) Development of self-recognition in the infant. Dev Psychol 14(1):44–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bigelow A (1981) The correspondence between self- and image-movement as a cue to self-recognition for young children. J Genet Psychol 139:11–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Brentano F (1874/1973) Psychology from an Empirical Standpoint. In: Kraus O, McAlister LL (eds) (trans: Rancurello AC, Terrell DB, McAlister LL). Routledge, Kegan Paul, LondonGoogle Scholar
  7. Deacon T (1997) The symbolic species. Allen Lane, The Penguin Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  8. DeLoache JS (2004) Becoming symbol-minded. Trends Cogn Sci 8(2):66–70CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. de Veer M, van den Bos R (1999) A critical review of methodology and interpretation of mirror self-recognition research in nonhuman primates. Anim Behav 58:459–468CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Epstein R, Lanza RP, Skinner BF (1981) “Self-awareness” in the pigeon. Science 212:695–696CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Gallagher S (1995) Body schema and intentionality. In: Bermũdez J, Marcel J, Eilan N (eds) The body and the self, a bradford book. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 225–244Google Scholar
  12. Gallup GG Jr (1970) Chimpanzees: self-recognition. Science 167:86–87CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Gallup GG Jr (1975) Towards an operational definition of self-awareness. In: Tuttle RH (ed) Socioecology and psychology of primates. Mouton, The HagueGoogle Scholar
  14. Gallup GG Jr (1998) Can animals empathize? Yes. Scientific American Presents, Exploring Intelligence, Jan 1998Google Scholar
  15. Gallup GG Jr, Suarez SD (1986) Self-awareness and the emergence of mind in humans and other primates. In: Suls J, Greenwald A (eds.) Psychological perspectives on the self, vol 3. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, pp 3–26Google Scholar
  16. Gallup GG, Anderson JR, Platek SM (2011) Self-recognition. In: Gallagher S (ed) The Oxford handbook of the self. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 80–110Google Scholar
  17. Gibson JJ (1979) The ecological approach to visual perception. Houghton Mifflin, BostonGoogle Scholar
  18. Grice HP (1957) Meaning. Philos Rev 66(3):377–388CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Hauser MD, Kralik J, Botto-Mahan C, Garrett M, Oser J (1995) Self-recognition in primates: phylogeny and the salience of species-typical features. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 92:10811–10814CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Hauser M, Miller C, Liu K, Gupta R (2001) Cotton-top tamarins (Saguinus oedipus) fail to show mirror-guided self-exploration. Am J Primatol 53(3):131–137CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Heyes C (1998) Theory of mind in nonhuman primates. Behav Brain Sci 21(1):101–148Google Scholar
  22. Lewis M, Brooks-Gunn J (1979) Social cognition and the acquisition of self. Plenum Press, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Marino L, Reiss D, Gallup GG (1994) Mirror self-recognition in bottlenose dolphins: implications for comparative investigations of highly dissimilar species, chap 25. In: Parker S, Mitchell R, Boccia M (eds.) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  24. Marten K, Psarakos S (1994) Evidence of self-awareness in the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus). In: Parker S, Mitchell R, Boccia M (eds.) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 361–379Google Scholar
  25. Mitchell RW (1997a) Kinesthetic-visual matching and the self-concept as explanations of mirror-self-recognition. J Theory Soc Behav 27(1):17–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Mitchell RW (1997b) A comparison of the self-awareness and kinesthetic-visual matching theories of self-recognition: autistic children and others. In: Snodgrass J, Thompson L (eds) The self across psychology, vol 818. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, New York, pp 39–63Google Scholar
  27. Patterson FG, Cohn RH (1994) Self-recognition and self-awareness in lowland gorillas. In: Parker S, Mitchell R, Boccia M (eds) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 273–290Google Scholar
  28. Perner Josef (1991) Understanding the representational mind. A Bradford book. MIT Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  29. Plotnik JM, de Waal FBM, Reiss D (2006) Self-recognition in an Asian elephant. Proc Nat Acad Sci 103(45):17053–17057CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Povinelli DJ (1989) Failure to find self-recognition in Asian elephants (Elephas maximus) in contrast to their use of mirror cues to discover hidden food. J Comp Psychol 103:122–131CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Povinelli DJ, Rulf AB, Landau KR, Bierschwale DT (1993) Self-recognition in Chimpanzees: distribution, ontogeny, and patterns of emergence. J Comp Psychol 107:347–372CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Prior H, Schwarz A, Güntürkün O (2008) Mirror-induced behavior in the magpie (Pica pica): evidence of self-recognition. PLoS Biol 6(8):e202. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0060202
  33. Rajala AZ, Reininger KR, Lancaster KM, Populin LC (2010) Rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) do recognize themselves in the mirror: implications for the evolution of self-recognition. PLoS ONE 5(9):e12865. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012865 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Savanah S (2011) The concept possession hypothesis of self-consciousness. Conscious Cogn. doi:10.1016/j.concog.2011.02.019
  35. Schilhab TSS (2004) What mirror self-recognition in nonhumans can tell us about aspects of self. Biol Philos 19:111–126CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Schulman AH, Kaplowitz C (1977) Mirror-image response during the first two years of life. Dev Psychobiol 10(3):133–142CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Shillito DJ, Gallup GG, Beck BB (1999) Factors affecting mirror behaviour in western lowland gorillas. Anim Behav 57:999–1004CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Suddendorf T, Corballis M (1997) Mental time travel and the evolution of the human mind. Genetic Soc General Psychol Monogr 123:133–167Google Scholar
  39. Swartz KB, Evans S (1994) Social and cognitive factors in chimpanzee and gorilla mirror behaviour and self-recognition. In: Parker S, Mitchell R, Boccia M (eds) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 189–206Google Scholar
  40. Thompson RKR, Contie CL (1994) Further reflections on mirror usage by pigeons: lessons from Winnie-The-Pooh and Pinnochio Too. In: Parker S, Mitchell R, Boccia M (eds) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 392–409Google Scholar
  41. Wellman HM, Cross D, Watson J (2001) Meta-analysis of theory-of-mind development: the truth about false belief. Child Dev 72(3):655–684CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.ARC Centre of Excellence in Cognition and its Disorders (CCD)Macquarie UniversitySydneyAustralia

Personalised recommendations