Biology & Philosophy

, Volume 28, Issue 1, pp 31–52 | Cite as

Cells as irreducible wholes: the failure of mechanism and the possibility of an organicist revival

  • Michael J. Denton
  • Govindasamy Kumaramanickavel
  • Michael Legge


According to vitalism, living organisms differ from machines and all other inanimate objects by being endowed with an indwelling immaterial directive agency, ‘vital force,’ or entelechy. While support for vitalism fell away in the late nineteenth century many biologists in the early twentieth century embraced a non vitalist philosophy variously termed organicism/holism/emergentism which aimed at replacing the actions of an immaterial spirit with what was seen as an equivalent but perfectly natural agency—the emergent autonomous activity of the whole organism. Organicists hold that organisms unlike machines are ‘more than the sum of their parts’ and predict that the vital properties of living things can never be explained in terms of mechanical analogies and that the reductionist agenda is doomed to failure. Here we review the current status of the mechanist and organicist conceptions of life particularly as they apply to the cell. We argue that despite the advances in biological knowledge over the past six decades since the molecular biological revolution, especially in the fields of genetics and cell biology the unique properties of living cells have still not been simulated in mechanical systems nor yielded to reductionist—analytical explanations. And we conclude that despite the dominance of the mechanistic–reductionist paradigm through most of the past century the possibility of a twentyfirst century organicist revival cannot be easily discounted.


Vitalism Holism organicism Sentience Self organization 


  1. Agar WE (1943) A contribution to the theory of the living organism. Melbourne University Press, MelbourneGoogle Scholar
  2. Ainsworth C (2009) Cells go fractal. Nature News published on line 4 Sept. doi: 10.1038/news.2009.880
  3. Alberts B et al (2007) Molecular biology of the cell. Garland Press, NYGoogle Scholar
  4. Alexander S (1920) Space, time, and deity. Macmillan, LondonGoogle Scholar
  5. Anderson PW (1972) More is different. Science 177:393–396CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Aon MA, O’Bourke B, Cortassa S (2004) The fractal architecture of cytoplasmic organization: scaling, kinetics, and emergence in metabolic networks. Mol Cell Biochem 256(257):169–184CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Aristotle (1937) Parts of animals. English translation by A. L. Peck. Heinemann, LondonGoogle Scholar
  8. Beckner M (1967) Organismic biology. In: Paul E (ed) Encyclopedia of philosophy, vol 5. MacMillan Publishing Inc.\The Free Press, NY, pp 549–551Google Scholar
  9. Bedau M (2002) Downward causation and the anatomy of weak emergence. Principia 6:5–50Google Scholar
  10. Bertalanffy VL (1969) General systems theory, foundations, development, applications. George Braziller, NYGoogle Scholar
  11. Brandon C, Tooze J (1999) Introduction to protein structure, 2nd edn. Garland Publishing Inc., NYGoogle Scholar
  12. Broad CD (1925) The mind and its place in nature. Kegan Paul, LondonGoogle Scholar
  13. Camazine S, Deneubourg J-L, Franks NR, Theraulaz G, Bonabeau E (2001) Self-organization in biological systems. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  14. Carelli PV, Reyes MB, Sartorelli JC, Pinto RD (2005) Whole cell stochastic model reproduces the irregularities found in the membrane potential of bursting. Neurons J Neurophysiol 94:1169–1179CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Chalmers DJ (2006) Strong and weak emergence. In: Clayton P, Davies PCW (eds) The reemergence of emergence; the emergentist hypothesis from science and religion. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 244–255Google Scholar
  16. Chialvo DR (2010) Emergent complex neural dynamic. Nat Phys 6:744–750CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Clark KB (2010) Origins od learned reciprocity in solitary ciliates searching groups ‘courting’ assurances at quantum efficiencies. Biosysystems 99:27–41Google Scholar
  18. Clayton P (2004) Mind and emergence: from quantum to consciousness. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  19. Clayton P (2006) The conceptual foundations of emergence theory. In: Clayton P, Davies PCW (eds) The re-emergence of emergence: the emergentist hypothesis from science to religion. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 1–25Google Scholar
  20. Clayton NS, Emery NJ (2008) Clever corvids and political primates. In: Morris SC (ed) The deep structure of biology. Templeton Foundation Press, PennslyvaniaGoogle Scholar
  21. Collins J (2010) Got parts, need manual. Nature 465:424Google Scholar
  22. Crick FC (1957) On protein synthesis. Symp Soc Exp Biol 12:138–163Google Scholar
  23. Crick F (2004) Of molecules and men. Prometheus Books, NYGoogle Scholar
  24. Davies PCW (2006) The physics of downward causation. In: Clayton P, Davies PCW (eds) The reemergence of emergence; the emergentist hypothesis from science and religion. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 35–51Google Scholar
  25. Descartes (1985) Principles of philosophy. In: The philosophical writings of Descartes, vol 1 (Trans: Cottingham J, Stoothhoff R, Murdoch D). Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  26. Drexler E (1986) The engines of creation. Ancor Press, NYGoogle Scholar
  27. Driesch H (1914) The history and theory of vitalism. Macmillan, LondonGoogle Scholar
  28. Driesch H (1929) The science and philosophy of the organism. A. and C. Black, LondonGoogle Scholar
  29. Dupont C, Randall AD, Brenner CA (2009) Epigenetics: definitions mechanism and clinical perspectives. Semin Reprod Med 27:351–357CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Eccleston A, DeWitt N, Gunter C, Marte B, Noth D (eds) (2007) Epigenetics. Nat Insights Epigenet 447:396–440Google Scholar
  31. Edelmann J, Denton MJ (2007) The uniqueness of biological self organization: challenging the Darwinian paradigm. Biol Philos 22:579–601CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Fletcher DA, Mullins RD (2010) Cell mechanics and the cytoskeleton. Nature 463:485–492CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Ford BJ (2010) The secret power of the single cell. New Sci (2757):26–27Google Scholar
  34. Forgacs G, Newman SA (2005) The biological physics of the developing embryo. CUP, NYCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Gierasch LM, Gershenson A (2009) Post-reductionist protein science, or putting Humpty–Dumpty back together again. Nat Chem Biol 11:774–777CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Gilbert SF, Sarkar S (2000) Embracing complexity: organicism for the 21st century. Dev Dyn 219:1–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Gleick J (1998) Chaos. Vintage Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  38. Goldberg AD, ALLis CD, Berstein E (2007) Epigenetics: a landscape takes shape. Cell 128:635–638Google Scholar
  39. Gould SJ (2002) The structure of evolutionary theory. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  40. Gribben J (2005) Deep simplicity. Penguin Books, LondonGoogle Scholar
  41. Haig D (2004) The (dual) origins of epigenetics. Cold Spring Harb Symp Quant Biol 69:67–71CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Haken H (1977) Synergetics: an introduction. Nonequilibrium phase transitions and self-organization in physics chemistry and biology. Springer, NYGoogle Scholar
  43. Harold F (2005a) To shape a cell: an enquiry into the causes of morphogenesis of microorganisms. Microbiol Rev 54:381–431Google Scholar
  44. Harold F (2005b) Molecules into cells: specifying spatial architecture. Micro Mol Biol Rev 69:544–564Google Scholar
  45. Hayden EC (2010) Life is complicated. Nature 464:664–667CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Hofstadter DR (1999) Gödel, Escher, Bach. Basic Books, NYGoogle Scholar
  47. Hyman AA, Karsenti E (1996) Morphogenetic properties of microtubules and mitotic spindle assembly. Cell 84:401–410CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Jennings HS (1906/1976) Behavior of the lower organisms. Indiana University Press, BloomingtonGoogle Scholar
  49. Jirtle RL, Skinner MK (2007) Environmental epigenomics and disease susceptibility. Nat Rev Genet 8:253–262CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Johannsen W (1923) Some remarks about heredity. Hereditas 4:133–141Google Scholar
  51. Jonas H (2001) The phenomenon of life. North Western University Press, ILGoogle Scholar
  52. Judson HF (1979) The eighth day of creation. CSHL Press, PlainviewGoogle Scholar
  53. Kant I (2010) Critique of judgement. Digireads, KSGoogle Scholar
  54. Karsenti E (2008) Self-organization in cell biology: a brief history. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 9:255–262CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Kauffman SA (2000) Investigations. Oxford University Press, NYGoogle Scholar
  56. Keller EF (2000) The century of the gene. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  57. Kelly EF (2007) Introduction. In: Kelly EF, Kelly EW (eds) Irreducible mind. Rowman and Littlefield, MDGoogle Scholar
  58. Keren K, Pinccus Z, Allen GM, Barnhart EL, Marriot G, Mogilner A, Theriot JA (2008) Mechanism of shape determination in motile cells. Nature 453:475–480CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Kim J (1999) Making sense of emergence. Philos Stud 95:3–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Kim J (2005) Physicalism, or something near enough. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  61. Kirschner M, Mitchison T (1986) Beyond self-assembly: from microtubules to morphogenesis. Cell 45:329–342CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Kitano H (2002) Computational systems biology. Nature 420:206–210CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Koestler A (1990) The ghost in the machine. Penguin, LondonGoogle Scholar
  64. Kuhn TS (1962) The structure of scientific revolutions. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  65. Lanza R, Gearhart J, Hogan B, Melton D, Pedersen R, Thomas ED, Thompson J, Wilmut I (2009) Essentials of stem cell biology. Academic Press, NYGoogle Scholar
  66. Laughlin RB, Pines D, Schamlian J, Stojkovic BP, Wolynes P (2000) The middle way. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97:32–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Lazarides E (1987) From genes to structural morphogenesis: the genesis and epigenesis of a red blood cell. Cell 51:345–356CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Lear J (1988) Aristotle: the desire to understand. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Lehn JM (2002) Towards self-organization and complex matter. Science 295:2400–2403CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Lewin R (1992) Complexity. Macmillan Press, NYGoogle Scholar
  71. Li M, Wang IX, Li Y, Bruzel A, Richards AL, Toung JM, Cheung VG (2011) Widespread RNA and DNA sequence differences in the human transcriptome. Science 333:53–58Google Scholar
  72. Lopez J, Percharde M, Coley HM, Webb A, Crook I (2009) The context and potential of epigenetics in ocology. Br J Cancer 100:571–577CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Maher B (2008) Personal genomes: the case of the missing hereditability. Nature 456:18–21CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Mayer BJ, Blinoy ML, Loew LM (2009) Molecular machines or pleiomorphic ensembles: signaling complexes revisited. J Biol 8:81.1–81.8. doi: 10.1186/jbiol185 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. McDougall W (1938) The riddle of life. Methuen, LondonGoogle Scholar
  76. Misteli T (2001) The concept of self organization in cellular architecture. J Cell Biol 155:181–185CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Misteli T (2009) Self organization in the genome. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 106:6885–6886CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Monod J (1972) Chance and necessity. Collins, LondonGoogle Scholar
  79. Morgan Lloyd C (1923) Emergent evolution. Williams and Norgate, LondonGoogle Scholar
  80. Morrison M (2006) Emergence, reduction and theoretical principles: rethinking fundamentalism. Philos Sci 73:876–887CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Nanney DL (1957) The role of the cytoplasm in heredity. In: McElroy WD, Glass B (eds) The chemical basis of heredity. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, pp 134–163Google Scholar
  82. Nanney DL (1958) Epigenetic control systems. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 44:712–717CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Nedelec FJ, Surrey T, Maggs AC, Liebler S (1997) Self-organization of microtubules and motors. Nature 389:305–308CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Nijhout HF (1990) Metaphors and the role of genes in development. Bioessays 12:441–446CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Nijhout FH (1999) When developmental pathways diverge. PNAS US 96:5348–5350CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Nilsen TW, Graveley BR (2010) Expansion of the eukaryotic proteome by alternative splicing. Nature 463:457–463Google Scholar
  87. Perdew GH, Vanden Heuvel JP, Peters JM (2006) Regulation of gene expression: molecular mechanisms. Humana Press, TotowaGoogle Scholar
  88. Platt JR (1961) Properties of large molecules that go beyond the properties of their chemical subgroups. J Theoret Biol 1:342–358Google Scholar
  89. Rajapakse I, Perlmanc MD, Scalzoa D, Kooperbergb C, Groudinea M, Kosake ST (2009) The emergence of lineage-specific chromosomal topologies from coordinate gene regulation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106:6679–6684CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Rhind SM, Taylor JE, De Sousa PA, King TJ, McGrary M, Wilmut I (2003) Human cloning: can it be made safe. Nat Rev Genet 4:855–864CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Rickles D (2006) Supervenience and determination. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
  92. Ridley M (2007) Thinker: Francis Crick. New Humanist 122(1):6Google Scholar
  93. Ritter WE (1919) The unity of the organism, or the organismal conception of life. Gorham Press, BostonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Roll-Hansen N (1984) E. S. Russell and J. H. Woodger: the failure of two twentieth-century opponents of mechanistic biology. J Hist Biol 17:399–428Google Scholar
  95. Russell ES (1930) The interpretation of development and heredity. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  96. Searle J (1992) The rediscovery of the mind. MIT Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  97. Sherrington C (1963) Man on his nature. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  98. Shinbrot T, Muzzio FJ (2001) Noise to order. Nature 410:251–258CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  99. Silberstein M, McGeever J (1999) The search for ontological emergence. Philos Q 49:182–200CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  100. Sipper M, Reggia JA (2001) Go forth and replicate. Sci Am 285:34–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Smith A-S (2010) Physics challenged by cells. Nat Phys 6:726–729CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  102. Smuts J (1927) Holism and evolution. Macmillan Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  103. Strohman RC (1993) Ancient genes, wise bodies, unhealthy people: limits of genetic thinking in biological medicine. Perspect Biol Med 37:112–144Google Scholar
  104. Sowerby SJ, Holm NG, Petersen GB (2001) Origins of life: a route to nanotechnology. Biosystems 61:69–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  105. Strogatz SH (1994) Non linear dynamics and chaos. Perseus Books, NYGoogle Scholar
  106. Tartar V (1961) The biology of Stentor. Pergammon Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  107. Taylor E (2001) E.B. Wilson lecture: the cell as a molecular machine. Mol Biol Cell 12(2):251–254Google Scholar
  108. Thompson DW (1942) On growth and form, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  109. von Neumann J (1966) Theory of self-reproducing automata. University of Illinois Press, UrbanaGoogle Scholar
  110. Waddington CH (1956) Embryology, epigenetics and biogenetics. Nature 177:1241CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  111. Waddington CH (1962) New patterns on genetics and development. Columbia Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  112. Watson JD (2003) DNA: the secret of life. Heinemann, LondonGoogle Scholar
  113. Weismann A (1904) The evolution theory. Edward Arnold, LondonGoogle Scholar
  114. Weiss P (1963) The cell as unit. J Theor Biol 5:389–397CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  115. Weiss P (1969) The living system: determinism stratified. In: Koestler A, Smythies JR (eds) Beyond reductionism. Hutchinson and Co, UK, pp 3–55Google Scholar
  116. Welch GR, Clegg JS (2010) From protoplasmic theory to cellular systems biology: a 150-year reflection. Am J Physiol Cell Physiol 298:C1280–C1290CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  117. Whitehead AN (1927) Science and the modern world. Cambridge University press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  118. Whitesides GM, Grzybowski B (2002) Self-assembly at all scales. Science 295:2418–2421CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  119. Wolpert L, Lewis J (1975) Towards a theory of development. Fed Proc 34:14–20Google Scholar
  120. Woodger JH (1929) Biological principles: a critical study. Paul Trench Trubner and Co, LondonGoogle Scholar
  121. Yates FE (1994) Order and complexity in dynamical systems: homeodynamics as a generalized mechanics for biology. Math Comput Model 19:49–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  122. Yerkes RM (1905) Animal psychology and criteria of the psychic. J Philos Psychol Sci Method 2:141–149Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  • Michael J. Denton
    • 1
  • Govindasamy Kumaramanickavel
    • 1
    • 2
  • Michael Legge
    • 3
  1. 1.Aditya Jyot Eye HospitalMumbaiIndia
  2. 2.Narayana Nethralaya at Narayana Health CityNarayana Hrudayalaya Campus, BommasandraBangaloreIndia
  3. 3.Biochemistry DepartmentUniversity of OtagoDunedinNew Zealand

Personalised recommendations