Biology & Philosophy

, Volume 25, Issue 2, pp 143–162 | Cite as

Race: a social destruction of a biological concept

Article

Abstract

It is nowadays a dominant opinion in a number of disciplines (anthropology, genetics, psychology, philosophy of science) that the taxonomy of human races does not make much biological sense. My aim is to challenge the arguments that are usually thought to invalidate the biological concept of race. I will try to show that the way “race” was defined by biologists several decades ago (by Dobzhansky and others) is in no way discredited by conceptual criticisms that are now fashionable and widely regarded as cogent. These criticisms often arbitrarily burden the biological category of race with some implausible connotations, which then opens the path for a quick eliminative move. However, when properly understood, the biological notion of race proves remarkably resistant to these deconstructive attempts. Moreover, by analyzing statements of some leading contemporary scholars who support social constructivism about race, I hope to demonstrate that their eliminativist views are actually in conflict with what the best contemporary science tells us about human genetic variation.

Keywords

Race Social constructivism Genetics Geographical ancestry Human variation Philosophy of science 

References

  1. Andreasen RO (1998) A new perspective on the race debate. Br J Philos Sci 49:199–225CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Andreasen RO (2000) Race: biological reality or social contract? Philos Sci 67:S653–S666CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Andreasen RO (2004) The cladistic race concept: a defense. Biol Philos 19:425–442CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Andreasen RO (2005) The meaning of ‘race’: folk conceptions and the new biology of race. J Philos 102:94–106Google Scholar
  5. Andreasen RO (2008) The concept of race in medicine. In: Ruse M (ed) The Oxford handbook of philosophy of biology. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  6. Appiah KA (1990) Racisms. In: Goldberg DT (ed) Anatomy of racism. University of Minnesota Press, MinneapolisGoogle Scholar
  7. Appiah KA (1996) Race, culture, identity: misunderstood connections. In: Peterson GB (ed) The Tanner lectures on human values, vol 17. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City, pp 51–136Google Scholar
  8. Appiah KA (1999) Why there are no races. In: Harris L (ed) Racism. Humanity Press, AmherstGoogle Scholar
  9. Appiah KA (2006) How to decide if races exist. Proc Aristot Soc 106:363–380CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Appiah KA, Gutman A (1998) Color conscious. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  11. Barbujani G (2005) Human races: classifying people vs understanding diversity. Curr Genomics 6:215–226CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Block NJ (1995) How heritability misleads about race. Cognition 56:99–128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Blumenbach JF (2005) On the natural variety of mankind. Adamant Media Corporation, BostonGoogle Scholar
  14. Bodmer WF, Cavalli-Sforza LL (1976) Genetics, evolution and man. W. H. Freeman, San FranciscoGoogle Scholar
  15. Bonham VL et al (2005) Race and ethnicity in the genome era: the complexity of the constructs. Am Psychol 60:9–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Brown RA, Armelagos G (2001) Apportionment of racial diversity: a review. Evol Anthropol 10:34–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Brues AM (1990) The once and future diagnosis of race. In: Gill GW, Rhine S (eds) Skeletal attributions of race. Maxwell Museum of Anthropology, AlbuquerqueGoogle Scholar
  18. Cavalli-Sforza LL et al (1994) The history and geography of human genes. Princeton University Press, PrinncetonGoogle Scholar
  19. Collins FS (2004) What we do and don’t know about ‘race’, ‘ethnicity’, genetics and health at the dawn of the genome era. Nat Genet 36:S13–S15CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Diamond J (1994) Race without color. Discover (November): 82–89Google Scholar
  21. Diamond J (2005) Guns, germs and steel. PBS. Accessed 12 May 2009, http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4008293090480628280
  22. Dummett M (2004) The nature of racism. In: Levine MP, Pataki T (eds) Racism in mind. Cornell University Press, IthacaGoogle Scholar
  23. Edwards AWF (2003) Human genetic diversity: Lewontin’s fallacy. BioEssays 25:798–801CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Edwards AWF (undated) Race, reason and rubbish. Unpublished manuscriptGoogle Scholar
  25. Gill GW (1990) Introduction. In: Gill GW, Rhine S (eds) Skeletal attribution of race. Maxwell Museum of Anthropology, AlbuquerqueGoogle Scholar
  26. Gill GW (2000) Does race exist? A proponent’s perspective. PBS. Accessed 8 May 2009, http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/first/gill.html
  27. Gissis SB (2008) When is ‘race’ a race? 1946–2003. Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci 39:437–450CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Gitschier J (2005) The whole side of it—an interview with Neil Risch. PLoS Genet 1:3–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Glasgow J (2009) A theory of race. Routledge, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  30. Hacking I (2005) Why race still matters. Daedalus (Winter): 102–116Google Scholar
  31. Hacking I (2006) Genetics, biosocial groups and the future of identity. Daedalus (Fall): 81–95Google Scholar
  32. Hardimon M (2003) The ordinary concept of race. Journal of Philosophy 100:437–455Google Scholar
  33. Harpending HC (2000) Review of taboo: why black athletes dominate sports and why we’re afraid to talk about it. Popul Environ 22:83–89CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Haslanger S (2005) You mixed? Racial identity without racial biology. In: Haslanger S, Witt C (eds) Adoption matters: philosophical and feminist essays. Cornell University Press, IthacaGoogle Scholar
  35. Hull D (1998) Species, subspecies, and races. Soc Res 65:351–367Google Scholar
  36. James M (2008) Race. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Accessed 1 May 2009, http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/race/
  37. Kitcher P (2003) In Mendel’s mirror: philosophical refelections on biology. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  38. Kitcher P (2007) Does ‘race’ have a future? Philos Public Aff 35(4):293–317CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Klein J, Takahata N (2002) Where do we come from? The molecular evidence for human descent. Springer, BerlinGoogle Scholar
  40. Konigsberg LW et al (2009) Estimation and evidence in forensic anthropology: sex and race. Am J Phys Anthropol 139:77–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Levin M (1997) Why race matters. Praeger, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  42. Lewontin RC (1972) The apportionment of human diversity. Evol Biol 6:381–398Google Scholar
  43. Lewontin R (1987) Are the races different? In: Gill D, Levidow L (eds) Anti-racist science teaching. Free Association Books, LondonGoogle Scholar
  44. Livingstone FB (1962) On the non-existence of human races. Curr Anthropol 3:279CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Machery E, Faucher L (2005) Social construction and the concept of race. Philos Sci 72:1208–1219CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Mallon R (2006) ‘Race’: normative, not metaphysical or semantic. Ethics 116:525–551CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Mead M (ed) (1968) Science and the concept of race. Columbia University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  48. Mitton JB (1977) Genetic differentiation of races of man as judged by single-locus and multilocus analyses. Am Nat 111:203–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Mitton JB (1978) Measurement of differentiation: reply to Lewontin, Powell, and Taylor. Am Nat 112:1142–1144CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Ousley S et al (2009) Understanding race and human variation: why forensic anthropologists are good at identifying race. Am J Phys Anthropol 139:68–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Pigliucci M, Kaplan J (2003) On the concept of biological race and its apllicability to humans. Philos Sci 70:1161–1171CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Richardson RC (2000) Review of M. Levin’s why race matters. Ethics 110:847–848CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Ridley M (2004) Evolution. Blackwell, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  54. Risch N et al (2002) Categorization of humans in biomedical research: genes, race and disease. Genome Biol 3:1–12CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Rosenberg NA et al (2002) Genetic structure of human populations. Science 298:2381–2385CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Rushton JP, Jensen AR (2005) Thirty years of research on race differences in cognitive ability. Psychol Public Policy Law 11:235–294CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Sauer NJ (1992) Forensic anthropology and the concept of race: if races do not exist, why are forensic anthropologists so good at identifying them? Soc Sci Med 34:107–111CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Schwartz RS (2001) Racial profiling in medical research. N Engl J Med 344:1392–1393CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Tang H et al (2005) Genetic structure, self-identified race/ethnicity, and confounding in case-control association studies. Am J Hum Genet 76:268–275CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Witherspoon DJ et al (2007) Genetic similarities within and between human populations. Genetics 176:351–359CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Zack N (2002) Philosophy of science and race. Routledge, New YorkGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Lingnan UniversityTuen MunHong Kong

Personalised recommendations