Biology and Philosophy

, Volume 21, Issue 2, pp 235–252 | Cite as

The Self Model and the Conception of Biological Identity in Immunology

Article

Abstract

The self/non-self model, first proposed by F.M. Burnet, has dominated immunology for 60 years now. According to this model, any foreign element will trigger an immune reaction in an organism, whereas endogenous elements will not, in normal circumstances, induce an immune reaction. In this paper we show that the self/non-self model is no longer an appropriate explanation of experimental data in immunology, and that this inadequacy may be rooted in an excessively strong metaphysical conception of biological identity. We suggest that another hypothesis, one based on the notion of continuity, gives a better account of immune phenomena. Finally, we underscore the mapping between this metaphysical deflation from self to continuity in immunology and the philosophical debate between substantialism and empiricism about identity.

Keywords

Continuity Identity Immunology Organism and environment Self 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Albert, M.L. 2004Death-defying immunity: do apoptotic cells influence antigen processing and presentation?Nat. Rev. Immunol.4223231Google Scholar
  2. Aluvihare, V.R., Kallikourdis, M., Betz, A.G. 2004Regulatory T cells mediate maternal tolerance to the fetusNat. Immunol.5266271CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Aristotle 1984. Categories. In: Barnes J. (eds),The Complete Works of Aristotlethe revised Oxford translation. Princeton University Press, Princeton.Google Scholar
  4. Aristotle 1984. Metaphysics. In: Barnes J. (eds), The Complete Works of Aristotlethe revised Oxford translation. Princeton University Press, Princeton.Google Scholar
  5. Ashton-Rickardt, P.G., Bandeira, A., Delaney, J.R., Kaer, L., Pircher, H.P., Zinkernagel, R.M., Tonegawa, S. 1994Evidence for a differential avidity model of T-cell selection in the thymusCell76651663CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Atlan, H., Cohen, I.R. 1998Immune information, self-organization and meaningInt. Immunol.10711717CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Belkaid, Y., Piccirillo, C.A., Mendez, S., Shevach, E.M., Sacks, D.L. 2002CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells control Leishmania major persistence and immunityNature420502507CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Belkaid, Y., Rouse, B.T. 2005Natural regulatory T cells in infectious diseaseNat. Immunol.6353360CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Berg, R.D. 1996The indigenous gastrointestinal microfloraTrends Microbiol.4430435CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bianchi, D.W., Zickwolf, G.K., Weil, G.J., Sylvester, S., DeMaria, M.A. 1996Male fetal progenitor cells persist in maternal blood for as long as 27 years postpartumProc. Natl. Acad. Sci.93705707CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Billingham, R.E., Brent, L., Medawar, P.B. 1953Actively acquired tolerance of foreign cellsNature172603606Google Scholar
  12. Boniolo, G., Carrara, M. 2004On Biological IdentityBiol. Phil.19443457Google Scholar
  13. Burnet, F.M., Fenner, F. 1949The Production of Antibodies2MacmillanMelbourneGoogle Scholar
  14. Burnet, F.M. 1957A modification of Jerne’s theory of antibody production using the concept of clonal selectionAust. J. Sci.206769Google Scholar
  15. Burnet, F.M. 1959The Clonal Selection Theory of Acquired ImmunityCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  16. Burnet, F.M. 1960Immunological recognition of selfNobel Lect. Physiol. Med.3689701Google Scholar
  17. Burnet, F.M. 1962The Integrity of the BodyHarvard University PressCambridge, MassachusettsGoogle Scholar
  18. Burnet, F.M. 1965

    The Darwinian approach to immunity

    Sterzl, J. eds. Molecular and Cellular Basis of Antibody FormationAcademic PressNew York1720
    Google Scholar
  19. Burnet, F.M. 1969Self and Not-selfMelbourne University Press and Cambridge University PressVictoriaGoogle Scholar
  20. Burnet, F.M. 1970Immunological SurveillancePergamonSydneyGoogle Scholar
  21. Buscaglia, C.A., Di Noia, J.M. 2003Trypanosoma cruzi clonal diversity and the epidemiology of Chagas’ diseaseMicrobes and Infection5419427CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Carosella, E.D., Moreau, P., Maoult, J., Discorde, M., Dausset, J., Rouas-Freiss, N. 2003HLA-G molecules: from maternal-fetal tolerance to tissue acceptanceAdv. Immunol.81199252Google Scholar
  23. Claas, F. 2004Chimerism as a tool to induce clinical transplantation toleranceCurr. Opin. Immunol.16578583CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Cohen, I.R. 1992The cognitive paradigm and the immunological homunculusImmunol. Today13490494Google Scholar
  25. Cohen, I.R. 2000Tending Adam’s Garden – Evolving the Cognitive Immune SelfAcademic PressSan DiegoGoogle Scholar
  26. Douek, D.C., Picker, L.J., Koup, R.A. 2003T Cells Dynamics in HIV-1 InfectionAnnu. Rev. Immunol.21265304CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Ehrlich, P. 1900On immunity with special reference to cell lifeProc. Royal Soc.66424448Google Scholar
  28. Ferguson, T.A., Griffith, T.S. 1997A vision of cell death: insights into immune privilegeImmunol. Rev.156167184Google Scholar
  29. Freitas, A.A., Rocha, B. 1999Peripheral T cell survivalCurr. Opinion Immunol.11152156Google Scholar
  30. Garcia, K.C., Degano, M., Pease, L.R., Huang, M., Peterson, P.A., Teyton, L., Wilson, I.A. 1998Structural basis of plasticity in T cell receptor recognition of a self peptide-MHC antigenScience27911661172CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Gilbert, S.F. 2002The genome in its ecological contextAnn. N.Y. Acad. Sci.981202218Google Scholar
  32. Girones, N., Fresno, M. 2003Etiology of Chagas disease myocarditis: autoimmunity, parasite persistenceor both?Trends Parasitol191922Google Scholar
  33. Godfrey-Smith, P. 2001

    Organismenvironmentand dialectics

    Singh, R.S.Krimbas, K.Paul, D.B.Beatty, J. eds. Thinking About Evolution: Historical, Philosophical and Political PerspectivesCambridge University PressNew York
    Google Scholar
  34. Haig, D. 1999What is a marmoset?Am. J. Primatol.49285296CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Hooper, L.V., Gordon, J.I. 2001Commensal host-bacterial relationships in the gutScience29211151118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Jerne, N.K. 1974Towards a network theory of the immune systemAnn. d’immunologie125373389Google Scholar
  37. Kappler, J.W., Roehm, N., Marrack, P.T. 1987T cell tolerance by clonal elimination in the thymusCell49273280Google Scholar
  38. Klein, J. 1982Immunology: The Science of Self-Nonself DiscriminationWileyNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  39. Langman, R.E., Cohn, M. 2000A minimal model for the self-nonself discrimination: a return to the basicsSem. Immunol.12189195Google Scholar
  40. Leibniz, G.W. 1714Monadologietranslation Monadology and Other Philosophical EssaysBobbs-MerrillIndianapolisedited and trans. P. and A.M. Schrecker1965.Google Scholar
  41. Lewontin, R. 2000The Triple Helix: GeneOrganismand EnvironmentHarvard University PressCambridge, MassachusettsGoogle Scholar
  42. Lila, N., Rouas-Freiss, N., Dausset, J., Carpentier, A., Carosella, E.D. 2001Soluble HLA-G protein secreted by allo-specific CD4 + T cells suppresses the allo-proliferative response: a CD4 + T cell regulatory mechanismProc. Natl. Acad. Sci.981215012155CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Löwy I. 1991. The immunological construction of the self. In A.I. Taubered., Organism and the Origins of Self, KluwerBoston, (1991), pp. 43–75.Google Scholar
  44. Margulis, L., Chapman, M. J. 1998Endosymbioses: cyclical and permanent in evolutionTrends Microbiol.6342345CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Marincola, F., Jaffee, E., Hicklin, D., Ferrone, S. 2000Escape of human solid tumors from T-cell recognition: molecular mechanisms and functional significanceAdv. Immunol.74181273Google Scholar
  46. Martin, W., Müller, M. 1998The hydrogen hypothesis for the first eukaryoteNature3923741CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Maturana H.R. and Varela F.J. 1980. Autopoiesis and Cognition – The Realization of the Living D. Reidel. Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 42: Boston. Google Scholar
  48. Matzinger, P., Gallucci, S., Lolkema, M. 1999Natural adjuvants: Endogenous activators of dendritic cellsNat. Med.512491255Google Scholar
  49. Medzhitov, R., Janeway, C. 2000How does the immune system distinguish self from non-self?Sem. Immunol.12185188CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Medzhitov, R., Janeway, C. 2002Decoding the Patterns of Self and Nonself by the Innate Immune SystemScience296298300CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Miller, J.F.A.P. 1961Immunological function of the thymusThe Lancetii748749Google Scholar
  52. Murphy, J.B. 1913Transplantability of tissues to the embryo of foreign speciesJ. Exp. Med.17482492CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Nanda, N., Sercarz, E. 1995Induction of anti-self-immunity to cure cancerCell821317CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Owen, R. 1945Immunogenetic consequences of vascular anastomoses between bovine twinsScience102400401Google Scholar
  55. Oyama, S. 1985The Ontogeny of Information – Developmental Systems and EvolutionCambridge University PressCambridge2nd ed. 2000.Google Scholar
  56. Pardoll, D. 2003Does the immune system see Tumors as Foreign or Self?Ann. Rev. Immunol.21807839CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Pedotti, R., Mitchell, D.,  et al. 2001An unexpected version of horror autotoxicus: anaphylactic shock to a self-peptideNat. Immunol.3216222Google Scholar
  58. Pradeu, T., Carosella, E.D. 2004Analyse critique du modèle immunologique du soi et du non-soi et de ses fondements métaphysiques implicitesComptes Rendus de l’Académie des Sciences Biologies327481492Google Scholar
  59. Sakaguchi, S. 2004Naturally arising CD4+ regulatory T cells for immunologic self-tolerance and negative control of immune responsesAnn. Rev. Immunol.2217.117.32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Savill, J., Dransfield, I., Gregory, C., Haslett, C. 2002A blast from the past: clearance of apoptotic cells regulates immune responsesNat. Rev. Immunol.2965975CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Seung, E., Mordes, J.P, Rossini, A.A., Greiner, D.L. 2003Hematopoietic chimerism and central tolerance created by peripheral-tolerance induction without myeloablative conditioningJ. Clin. Invest.112795808CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Silverstein, A.M., Rose, N.R. 1997On the mystique of the immunological selfImmunol. Rev.159197206Google Scholar
  63. Silverstein, A.M., Rose, N.R. 2000There is only one immune system! The view from immunopathologySem. Immunol.12173178CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Smits, H.H., Jong, E.C., Wierenga, E.A., Kapsenberg, M.L. 2005Different faces of regulatory DCs in homeostasis and immunityTrends Immunol.26123129CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Tauber, A.I. 1994The Immune Self: Theory or Metaphor?Cambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  66. Tauber, A.I. 1999The elusive immune self: a case of category errorsPerspect. Biol. Med.42459474Google Scholar
  67. Tauber, A.I. 2000Moving beyond the immune self?Sem. Immunol.12241248CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Walker, L.S.K., Abbas, A.K. 2001The enemy within: keeping self-reactive T cells at bay in the peripheryNat. Rev. Immunol.21119Google Scholar
  69. Wells, H.G., Huxley, J.S., Wells, G.P. 1929The Science of LifeThe Literary GuildNew York(1934).Google Scholar
  70. Wiggins, D. 2001Sameness and Substance RenewedCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  71. Wilson, D. 1972The Science of Self – A Report of the New ImmunologyLongmanLondonGoogle Scholar
  72. Zinkernagel, R.M., Callahan, G.N., Althage, A., Cooper, S., Klein, P.A., Klein, J. 1978On the thymus in the differenciation of “H-2 self-recognition“ by T cells: evidence for dual recognition?J. Exp. Med.147882896Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Institut d’Histoire et de Philosophie des Sciences et des Techniques (IHPST) Department of PhilosophyParis1-Sorbonne UniversityParisFrance
  2. 2.Service de Recherches en Hémato-Immunologie, Commissariat à l’Énergie Atomique CEA-DRM-DSVHôpital Saint-LouisParisFrance

Personalised recommendations