Biology and Philosophy

, Volume 19, Issue 5, pp 739–764 | Cite as

The argument from biogenesis: Probabilities against a natural origin of life

  • R. C. Carrier
Article

Abstract

No evidence exists that the accidental origin of life is too improbable to have occurred naturally, but there are numerous attempts to argue so. Dizzying statistics are cited to show that a god had to be responsible. This paper identifies the Argument from Biogenesis, then explains why all these arguments so far fail, and what would actually have to be done to make such an argument succeed. Describes seven general types of error, with examples. Includes a table of forty-seven statistics used by over twenty authors to date.

Key words

biochemistry biogenesis god life naturalism origin probability statistics 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Barrow, J., Tipler, F. 1986The Anthropic Cosmological PrincipleOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  2. Bass, B.L., Cech, T.R. 1984Specific Interaction Between Self-Splicing of RNA of Tetrahymena and Its Guanosine SubstrateNature308820Google Scholar
  3. Baudin, M. 1962Probabilities and LifeDoverNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  4. Bonner, W.A. 1995Chirality and LifeOrigins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere25175190Google Scholar
  5. Borel, E. 1943Les Probabilites et la ViePresses Universitaires de FranceParisGoogle Scholar
  6. Brack, A. eds. 1998The Molecular Origins of Life: Assembling Pieces of the PuzzleCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  7. Bradley, W., Thaxton, C., Olsen, R. 1984The Mystery of Life’s Origin: Reassessing Current TheoriesPhilosophical LibraryNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  8. Bradley, W., Thaxton, C. 1994

    Information Theory and the Origin of Life

    Moreland, J.P. eds. The Creation Hypothesis: Scientific Evidence for an Intelligent DesignerInterVarsity PressDowner’s Grove, IL173234
    Google Scholar
  9. Cairns-Smith, A.G. 1985Seven Clues to the Origin of LifeCambridge University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  10. Carrier, R.: 2000 (July/August), ‘Are the Odds Against the Origin of Life Too Great?’, Reports of the National Center for Science Education 20(4), 25–34 (with supplementary material at: http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/richard_carrier/addendaB.html).Google Scholar
  11. Cech, T.R.,  et al. 1981In Vitro Splicing of the Ribosomal RNA Precursor of TetrahymenaCell27487Google Scholar
  12. Chandrasekhar, S. 1996Auto-catalysis as the Possible Origin of Biomolecular ChiralityCurrent Science70259260Google Scholar
  13. Cohen, J. 1995Getting All Turned Around Over the Origins of LifeScience26712651266Google Scholar
  14. Coppedge, J. 1973Evolution: Possible or Impossible?ZondervanGrand RapidsGoogle Scholar
  15. Cowen, R. 2001Life’s Housing May Come from SpaceScience News15968Google Scholar
  16. Cramer, G.: 1998, ‘The Crutches of Atheism’, in Trinity Consulting (http://www.direct.ca/trinity/crutches.html).Google Scholar
  17. Dembski, W. 1998The Design Inference: Eliminating Chance Through Small ProbabilitiesCambridge UniversityNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  18. Dembski, W. 2002No Free Lunch: Why Specified Complexity Cannot Be Purchased without IntelligenceRowman & LittlefieldLanham, MDGoogle Scholar
  19. Eden, M. 1967

    Inadequacies of Neo-Darwinian Evolution as a Scientific Theory

    Moorhead, P.Kaplan, M. eds. Mathematical Challenges to the Neo-Darwinian Interpretation of Evolution: A Symposium Held at the Wistar Institute of Anatomy and Biology April 25 and 26, 1966Wistar InstitutePhiladelphia520(transcribed from an audio recording)
    Google Scholar
  20. Fenchel, T. 2003Origin and Early Evolution of LifeOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  21. Foster, D. 1993The Philosophical ScientistsBarnes & NobleNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  22. Fry, I. 2000The Emergence of Life on Earth: A Historical and Scientific OverviewRutgers University PressNew Brunswick, NJGoogle Scholar
  23. Goho, A. 2003Amino Acid Lends a Heavy HandScience News164157158Google Scholar
  24. Goho, A. 2003Clays Catalyze Life?Science News164285Google Scholar
  25. Golay, M. 1961Reflections of a Communications EngineerAnalytical Chemistry3323AGoogle Scholar
  26. Greenberg, J.M.,  et al. 1994Interstellar Dust, Chirality, Comets and the Origins of Life -Life from Dead StarsJournal of Biological Physics206170Google Scholar
  27. He, Y., Qi, F., Qi, S. 1998Effect of Chiral Helical Force Field on Molecular Helical Enantiomers and Possible Origin of Biomolecular HomochiralityMedical Hypotheses51125128Google Scholar
  28. Hesman, T. 2000Code Breakers: Scientists are Altering Bacteria in a Most Fundamental WayScience News157360362Google Scholar
  29. Horgan, J. 1991In the Beginning ...Scientific American264116125CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Hoyle, F. 1981The Big Bang in AstronomyNew Scientist92521527Google Scholar
  31. Hoyle, F. 1982Evolution From Space: The Omni Lecture and Other Papers on the Origin of LifeEnslowHillside, NJGoogle Scholar
  32. Hoyle, F. 1983The Intelligent UniverseJosephLondonGoogle Scholar
  33. Hoyle, F., Wickramasinghe, N.C. 1981Evolution From Space: A Theory of Cosmic CreationismSimon & SchusterNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  34. Hoyle, F., Wickramasinghe, N.C. 1993Our Place in the Cosmos: The Unfinished RevolutionJ. M. DentLondonGoogle Scholar
  35. Huxley, J. 1953Evolution in Action: Based on the Patten Foundation Lectures Delivered at Indiana University in 1951Scientific Book ClubLondonGoogle Scholar
  36. Jelinek, U. 1961Campus Challenge, Campus Crusade for ChristArrowheadSprings, CAGoogle Scholar
  37. Kauffman, S. 1993The Origins of Order: Self-Organization and Selection in EvolutionOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  38. Küppers, B.-O. 1990Information and the Origin of LifeMIT PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  39. Lahav, N. 1999Biogenesis: Theories of Life’s OriginOxford UniversityNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  40. Lecompte du Noüy, P. 1947Human DestinyLongmansLondonGoogle Scholar
  41. Lee, D.H.,  et al. 1996A Self-replicating PeptideNature382525528Google Scholar
  42. Ludwig, M. 1993Computer Viruses, Artificial Life and EvolutionAmerican EagleTucson, ARGoogle Scholar
  43. Mason, S.F. 1991Prebiotic Sources of Biomolecular HandednessChirality3223226Google Scholar
  44. Maynard Smith, J., Szathmáry, E. 1999The Origins of Life: From the Birth of Life to the Origin of LanguageOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  45. McFadden, J. 2000Quantum EvolutionW. W. NortonNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  46. McHarris, W.: 1986 (January), ‘Handedness in Nature’, Analog: Science Fiction & Fact, 68.Google Scholar
  47. Moreland, J.P. eds. 1994The Creation Hypothesis: Scientific Evidence for an Intelligent DesignerIntervarsity PressDowners Grove, ILGoogle Scholar
  48. Moreland, J.P. 1989Christianity and the Nature of Science: A Philosophical InvestigationBaker Book HouseGrand Rapids, MIGoogle Scholar
  49. Morgan, K. 2003A Rocky Start: Fresh Take on Life’s Oldest StoryScience News163264266Google Scholar
  50. Morowitz, H. 1969

    Biological Self-Replicating Systems

    Snell, F. eds. Progress in Theoretical BiologyAcademic PressNew York35 ff
    Google Scholar
  51. Morowitz, H. 1968Energy Flow in Biology: Biological Organization as a Problem in Thermal PhysicsAcademic PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  52. Morris, H.: 1974, Scientific Creationism, Creation Life, El Cajon, CA (now past its 11th printing).Google Scholar
  53. Mulkidjanian, A.Y., Cherepanov, D.A. and Galperin, M.Y.: 2003 (May 28), ‘Survival of the Fittest Before the Beginning of Life: Selection of the First Oligonucleotide-like Polymers by UV Light’, BMC Evolutionary Biology 3(12), at http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2148/3/12.Google Scholar
  54. Musgrave, I.: 1998, ‘Lies, Damned Lies, Statistics, and Probability of Abiogenesis Calculations’, in the Talk.Origins Archive (http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/abioprob/abioprob.html).Google Scholar
  55. Noebel, D. 1994Understanding the Times: The Religious Worldviews of Our Day and the Search for TruthHarvest HouseEugene, ORGoogle Scholar
  56. Overman, D. 1997A Case Against Accident and Self-OrganizationRowman & LittlefieldLanham, MDGoogle Scholar
  57. Pigliucci, M. 1999Where Do We Come From? A Humbling Look at the Biology of Life’s OriginThe Skeptical Inquirer232127Google Scholar
  58. Popselov, M.E. 1996Chiral-selective Radiolysis in a Magnetic FieldPhysics Letters A220194200Google Scholar
  59. Prigogine, I.,  et al. 1972Thermodynamics of EvolutionPhysics Today252328CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Quastler, H. 1964The Emergence of Biological OrganizationYale University PressNew HavenGoogle Scholar
  61. Ratzsch, D. 2001Nature, Design and Science: The Status of Design in Natural ScienceSUNY PressAlbany, NYGoogle Scholar
  62. Sagan, C. eds. 1973Communication with Extra-Terrestrial IntelligenceMIT PressCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  63. Salisbury, F. 1969Natural Selection and the Complexity of the GeneNature224342343Google Scholar
  64. Salisbury, F. 1971Doubts About the Modern Synthetic Theory of EvolutionAmerican Biology Teacher33335338Google Scholar
  65. Schopf,  eds. 2002Life’s Origin: The Beginnings of Biological EvolutionUniversity of California PressBerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  66. Schroeder, Gerald 1997The Science of God: The Convergence of Scientific and Biblical WisdomFree PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  67. Schwartz, A. 1993

    Biology and Theory: RNA and the Origin of Life

    Greenberg, J.M.Mendoza-Gomez, C.X.Pirronello, V. eds. The Chemistry of Life’s OriginsKluwer AcademicBoston323344
    Google Scholar
  68. Shapiro, R. 1988Prebiotic Ribose SynthesisOrigins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere1871Google Scholar
  69. Snoke, D. 2001In Favor of God-of-the-Gaps ReasoningPerspectives on Science and Christian Faith53152158Google Scholar
  70. Stockwell, J.: 2002, ‘Borel’s Law and the Origin of Many Creationist Probability Assertions’, in the Talk.Origins Archive (http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/abioprob/borelfaq.html).Google Scholar
  71. Strickberger, M. 2000

    Molecules and the Origin of Life

    Evolution3rd ed.Jones & BartlettBoston
    Google Scholar
  72. Sunderland, L. 1984Darwin’s Enigma: Fossils and Other ProblemsMaster BooksSantee, CAGoogle Scholar
  73. Tranter, G.E.,  et al. 1992Computational Studies of the Electroweak Origin of Biomolecular Handedness in Natural-SugarsProceedings of the Royal Society of London A - Mathematical and Physical Sciences436603615CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Travis, J. 2000Molecule Sparks Origin-of-Life DebateScience News157363Google Scholar
  75. Trevors, J.T. 1997Evolution of Bacterial GenomesAntonie van Leeuwenhoek International Journal of General and Molecular Microbiology71265270Google Scholar
  76. Ward, P., Brownlee, D. 2000Rare Earth: Why Complex Life is Uncommon in the UniverseCopernicusNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  77. Weiss, P. 1998Another Face of Entropy: Particles Self Organize to Make Room for RandomnessScience News154108109Google Scholar
  78. Wills, C., Bada, J. 2000The Spark of Life: Darwin and the Primeval SoupPerseusCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  79. Wilson, C., Weldon, J. 1978Close Encounters: A Better Explanation, Involving Trauma, Terror, and TragedyMaster BooksSan Diego, CAGoogle Scholar
  80. Yockey, H. 1981Self Organization Origin of Life Scenarios and Information TheoryJournal of Theoretical Biology911331Google Scholar
  81. Yockey, H. 1977A Calculation of the Probability of Spontaneous Biogenesis by Information TheoryJournal of Theoretical Biology67377398Google Scholar
  82. Yockey, H. 1992Information Theory and Molecular BiologyCambridge University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  83. Zubay, G. 2000Origins of Life: On Earth and in the Cosmos2nd ed.Academic PressSan DiegoGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • R. C. Carrier
    • 1
  1. 1.Columbia UniversityUSA

Personalised recommendations