The fickle activity of a fly and a moth: variation in activity of two biocontrol agents of Chrysanthemoides monilifera
- 9 Downloads
Biocontrol agents released to control exotic pests may not have the same spatial distribution as the pest species and may therefore vary in efficacy across the exotic range. These changes in distribution are unlikely to be known until species have had time to fill all preferred niches in the invasive habitat. However, studies of post-release activity of biocontrol agents rarely assess longer-term patterns of establishment in the landscape. Comostolopsis germana and Mesoclanis polana were released to control Chrysanthemoides monilifera spp. rotundata (bitou bush) between 29 and 32 years ago. We assessed their activity in foredune and hinddune habitats of coastal beaches across the major distribution of bitou bush and experimentally assessed the effectiveness of C. germana at preventing flowering and seed set. Both biocontrol agents were found to be distributed along the 870 km of coastline, representing the core area of infestation. Tip damage by C. germana was highly variable but was consistently more effective in the foredune. Comostolopsis germana was found to reduce flower production from 15 to 59% with tip damage increasing with latitude. Mesoclanis polana did not show differences in activity with latitude and only showed a marginal increase in activity in hinddunes. Comostolopsis germana and M. polana are reducing the reproductive output of bitou bush but are unlikely to be effective as a sole management strategy particularly in warmer latitudes where more seeds are released.
KeywordsComostolopsis germana: bitou tip moth Mesoclanis polana: bitou seed fly Dunes
We thank the University of Wollongong for supporting this work.
- Briese DT (2000) Classical biological control. In: Sindel B (ed) Australian weed management systems. Richardson Publishing, Melbourne, pp 161–192Google Scholar
- DEC (Department of Environment and Conservation) (2006) NSW threat abatement plan invasion of native plant communities by Chrysanthemoides monilifera (bitou bush and boneseed). Department of Environment and Conservation (NSW), HurstvilleGoogle Scholar
- Dhileepan K (2002) Evaluating the effectiveness of weed biocontrol at the local scale. In: Spafford JH, Briese DT (eds) Improving the selection, testing and evaluation of weed biological control agents. CRC for Australian weed management technical series 7. Proceedings of the CRC for weed management biological control of weeds symposium and workshop. CRC for Australian Weed Management, Glen Osmond, pp 51–60Google Scholar
- Downey PO, Holtkamp RH, Ireson JE, Kwong RM, Swirepik AE (2007) A review of the Chrysanthemoides monilifera biological control program in Australia: 1987–2005. Plant Prot Q 22:24–32Google Scholar
- Holtkamp RH (2002) Impact of bitou tip moth, Comostolopsis germana, on bitou bush in New South Wales. In: Spafford JH, Dodd J, Moore J (eds) 13th Australian weed conference, Perth. Plant Protection Society of WA, South Perth, pp 405–406Google Scholar
- Ireson JE, Gourlay AH, Kwong RM, Holloway RJ, Chatterton WS (2003) Host specificity, release, and establishment of the gorse spider mite, Tetranychus lintearius Dufour (Acarina: Tetranychidae) for the biological control of gorse, Ulex europaeus L. (Fabaceae) in Australia. Biol Control 26:117–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Julien M, McFadyen R, Cullen J (eds) (2012) Biological control of weeds in Australia. CSIRO Publishing, MelbourneGoogle Scholar
- Stuart R, Kriticos DJ, Ash JE (2002) Modelling the biological control of bitou bush (Chrysanthemoides monifera: Asteraceae) by Mesoclanis polana (Tephritidae). In: Spafford JH, Dodd J, Moore JH (eds) 13th Australian weeds conference proceedings: weeds ‘threats now and forever’. Plant Protection Society of WA, Perth, Australia, pp 591–594Google Scholar
- Thomas J, Leys A (2002) Strategic management of bitou bush (Chrysanthemoides monilifera ssp. rotundata (L.) T.Norl.). In: Spafford JH, Dodd J, Moore JH (eds) 13th Australian weeds conference proceedings: weeds ‘threats now and forever’. Plant Protection Society of WA, Perth, Australia, pp 586–590Google Scholar
- Winkler MA, Cherry H, Downey PO (2008) Bitou bush management manual: current management and control options for bitou bush (Chrysanthemoides monilifera ssp. rotundata) in Australia. Department of Environment and Climate Change (NSW), SydneyGoogle Scholar