Biological Invasions

, Volume 13, Issue 12, pp 2911–2924

Can a highly invasive species re-invade its native community? The paradox of the red shiner

  • Edie Marsh-Matthews
  • William J. Matthews
  • Nathan R. Franssen
Original Paper


Red shiners (Cyprinella lutrensis) are among the most widespread, ecologically general, and environmentally tolerant fish species in North America, and are highly invasive where they have been introduced outside their native range. However, long-term data on fish assemblages showed that red shiners gradually (1980s to 2006) disappeared from creeks that are direct tributaries of Lake Texoma (Oklahoma, USA) where they are native and historically had been numerically dominant. Following a major flood in 2007, red shiners were detected anew in some of these creeks, but repeatedly disappeared and re-appeared through November 2009. Given their invasive abilities where they are not native, their failure to become re-established prompted us to examine factors that affect their apparent inability to re-invade their native habitat. We established assemblages of five common fish taxa native to Brier Creek in 12 large, outdoor mesocosm stream units. Subsequently, we introduced red shiners at two densities of 10 or 30 per unit, six replicates each, to examine potential effects of propagule pressure on establishment success. Approximately six months later, we ended the experiment and recovered all fish. Red shiners failed to become established in the experimental units, regardless of initial stocking density. They also exhibited much lower survival than other species in the native community, which not only survived well but exhibited some recruitment. Red shiner survival was significantly negatively related to the number of sunfish (Lepomis spp.) that grew to adult size in experimental units, suggesting that predation can inhibit early stages of invasion by red shiners.


Re-invasion Propagule pressure Predation pressure Freshwater fish Red shiner 


  1. Albanese B, Angermeier PL, Peterson JT (2009) Does mobility explain variation in colonization and population recovery among stream fishes? Freshwater Biol 54:1444–1460CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bestgen KR, Beyers DW, Rice JA, Haines GB (2006) Factors affecting recruitment of young Colorado pikeminnow: synthesis of predation experiments, field studies, and individual-based modeling. T Am Fish Soc 135:1722–1742CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Blum MJ, Walters DM, Burkhead NM, Freeman BJ, Porter BA (2010) Reproductive isolation and the expansion of an invasive hybrid swarm. Biol Invasions. doi:10.1007/s10530-010-9688-9
  4. Carlander KD (1977) Handbook of freshwater fishery biology, vol 2. Iowa State University Press, AmesGoogle Scholar
  5. Carpenter J, Mueller GA (2008) Small nonnative fishes as predators of larval razorback suckers. Southwest Nat 53:236–242CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Cross FB (1967) Handbook of fishes of Kansas. University of Kansas Museum of Natural History, LawrenceGoogle Scholar
  7. Cross FB, Collins JT (1995) Fishes in Kansas, 2nd edn. University of Kansas Natural History Museum, LawrenceGoogle Scholar
  8. Davis MA (2009) Invasion biology. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  9. Douglas ME, Marsh PC, Minckley WL (1994) Indigenous fishes of western North America and the hypothesis of competitive displacement: Meda fulgida (Cyprinidae) as a case study. Copeia 1994:9–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Gale WF (1986) Indeterminate fecundity and spawning behavior of capture red shiners—fractional, crevice spawners. T Am Fish Soc 115:429–437CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Gelwick FP (2000) Grazer identity changes the spatial distribution of cascading trophic effects in stream pools. Oecologia 125:573–583CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Gelwick FP, Matthews WJ (1992) Effects of an algivorous minnow on temperate stream ecosystem properties. Ecology 73:1630–1645CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. George AL, Caldieraro JB, Chartrand KM, Mayden RL (2008) Population genetics of the blue shiner, Cyprinella caerulea. Southeast Nat 7:637–650CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Gido KB, Matthews WJ (2001) Ecosystem effects of water column minnows in experimental streams. Oecologia 126:247–253CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Gido KB, Schaefer JF, Work K, Lienesch PW, Marsh-Matthews E, Matthews WJ (1999) Effects of red shiner (Cyprinella lutrensis) on Red River pupfish (Cyprinodon rubrofluviatilis). Southwest Nat 44:287–295Google Scholar
  16. Gilliam JF, Fraser DF, Alkins-Koo M (1993) Structure of a tropical stream fish community: a role for biotic interactions. Ecology 74:1856–1870CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Hargrave CW (2006) A test of three alternative pathways for consumer regulation of primary productivity. Oecologia 149:123–132PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Hargrave CW (2009) Effects of fish species richness and assemblage composition on stream ecosystem function. Ecol of Freshw Fish 18:24–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Hargrave CW, Ramirez R, Brooks M, Eggleton MA, Sutherland K, Deaton R, Galbraith H (2006) Indirect food web interactions increase growth of an algivorous stream fish. Freshwater Biol 51:1901–1910CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Harvey BC, White JL, Nakamoto RJ (2004) An emergent multiple predator effect may enhance biotic resistance in a stream fish assemblage. Ecology 85:127–133CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Hayes KR, Barry SC (2008) Are there any consistent predictors of invasion success? Biol Invasions 10:483–506CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Herrington SJ (2004) Ecology and impacts of nonindigenous red shiner in the Chattahoochee River drainage, Georgia. Dissertation. Auburn UniversityGoogle Scholar
  23. Herrington SJ, DeVries DR (2008) Reproductive and early life history of nonindigenous red shiner in the Chattahoochee River drainage, Georgia. Southeast Nat 7:413–428CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Hubbs CL (1954) Establishment of a forage fish, the red shiner (Notropis lutrensis), in the lower Colorado River system. Calif Fish Game 40:287–294Google Scholar
  25. Knight GL, Gido KB (2005) Habitat use and susceptibility to predation of four prairie stream fishes: Implications for conservation of the endangered Topeka shiner. Copeia 2005:38–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Kolar CS, Lodge DM (2001) Progress in invasion biology: predicting invaders. Trends Ecol Evol 16:199–204PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Kolar CS, Lodge DM (2002) Ecological predictions and risk assessment for alien fishes in North America. Science 298:1233–1236PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Lienesch PW, Lutterschmidt WI, Schaefer JF (2000) Seasonal and long-term changes in the fish assemblage of a small stream isolated by a reservoir. Southwest Nat 45:274–288CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Lockwood JL, Hoopes MF, Marchetti MP (2007) Invasion ecology. Blackwell Publishing, MaldenGoogle Scholar
  30. Lotrich VA (1973) Growth, production, and community composition of fishes inhabiting a first-, second- and third-order stream of eastern Kentucky. Ecol Monogr 43:377–397CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Mack RN, Simberloff D, Lonsdale WM, Evans H, Clout M, Bazzaz FA (2000) Biotic invasions: causes, epidemiology, global consequences, and control. Ecol Appl 10:689–710CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Marchetti MP, Moyle PB, Levine R (2004) Invasive species profiling? Exploring the characteristics of non-native fishes across invasion stages in California. Freshwater Biol 49:646–661CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Marsh-Matthews E, Matthews WJ (2000) Spatial variation in relative abundance of a widespread, numerically dominant fish species and its effect on fish assemblage structure. Oecologia 125:283–292CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Marsh-Matthews E, Matthews WJ, Gido KB, Marsh RL (2002) Reproduction by young-of-year red shiner (Cyprinella lutrensis) and its implications for invasion success. Southwest Nat 47:605–610CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Matthews WJ (1980) Notropis lutrensis. In: Lee DS, Gilbert CR, Hocutt CH, Jenkins RE, McAllister DE, Stauffer J Jr (eds) Atlas of freshwater fishes of North America. North Carolina State Museum, Raleigh, p 285Google Scholar
  36. Matthews WJ (1985) Distribution of midwestern fishes on multivariate environmental gradients, with emphasis upon Notropis lutrensis. Am Midl Nat 113:225–237CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Matthews WJ (1986) Geographic variation in thermal tolerance of a widespread minnow (Notropis lutrensis) of the North American Midwest. J Fish Biol 27:407–417CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Matthews WJ (1987) Physicochemical tolerance and selectivity of stream fishes as related to their geographic ranges and local distributions. In: Matthews WJ, Heins DC (eds) Community and evolutionary ecology of North American stream fishes. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, pp 111–120Google Scholar
  39. Matthews WJ (1998) Patterns in freshwater fish ecology. Kluwer, NorwellCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Matthews WJ, Hill LG (1977) Tolerance of the red shiner, Notropis lutrensis (Cyprinidae) to environmental parameters. Southwest Nat 22:89–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Matthews WJ, Hill LG (1979) Influence of physico-chemical factors on habitat selection by red shiners, Notropis lutrensis (Pisces:Cyprinidae). Copeia 1979:70–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Matthews WJ, Hill LG (1980) Habitat partitioning in the fish community of a southwestern river. Southwest Nat 25:51–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Matthews WJ, Maness J (1979) Critical thermal maxima, oxygen tolerances, and population fluctuations in southwestern stream fishes. Am Midl Nat 102:374–377CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Matthews WJ, Marsh-Matthews E (2006a) Persistence of fish species associations in pools of a small stream of the southern Great Plains. Copeia 2006:696–710CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Matthews WJ, Marsh-Matthews E (2006b) Temporal changes in replicated experimental stream fish assemblages: predictable or not? Freshwater Biol 51:1605–1622CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Matthews WJ, Marsh-Matthews E (2007) Extirpation of red shiner in direct tributaries of Lake Texoma (Oklahoma-Texas): a cautionary case history from a fragmented river-reservoir system. T Am Fish Soc 136:1041–1062CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Matthews WJ, Surat E, Hill LG (1982) Heat death of the orangethroat darter Etheostoma spectabile (Percidae) in a natural environment. Southwest Nat 27:216–217CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Matthews WJ, Stewart AJ, Power ME (1987) Grazing fishes as components of North American stream ecosystems. In: Matthews WJ, Heins DC (eds) Community and evolutionary ecology of North American stream fishes. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, pp 128–135Google Scholar
  49. Matthews WJ, Cashner RC, Gelwick FP (1988) Stability and persistence of fish faunas and assemblages in three midwestern streams. Copeia 1988:947–957Google Scholar
  50. Matthews WJ, Harvey BC, Power ME (1994) Spatial and temporal patterns in the fish assemblages of individual pools in a midwestern stream (USA). Environ Biol Fish 39:381–397CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Matthews WJ, Gido KB, Marsh-Matthews E (2001) Density-dependent overwinter survival and growth of red shiners from a southwestern river. T Am Fish Soc 130:478–488CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Matthews WJ, Gido KB, Garrett GP, Gelwick FP, Stewart J, Schaefer J (2006) Modular experimental riffle-pool stream system. T Am Fish Soc 135:1559–1566CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. MedCalc (2008) MedCalc Software version 9.5, Mariakerke, BelgiumGoogle Scholar
  54. Miller TE, Kneitel JM, Burns JH (2002) Effect of community structure on invasion success and rate. Ecology 83:898–905CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Minckley WL (1959) Fishes of the Big Blue River Basin, Kansas. University of Kansas Publications, Museum of Natural History 11:401–442Google Scholar
  56. Minckley WL (1972) Notes on the spawning behavior of red shiner, introduced into Burro Creek, Arizona. Southwest Nat 17:101–103CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Minckley WL (1973) Fishes of Arizona. Arizona Game and Fish Department, PhoenixGoogle Scholar
  58. Minckley WL (1991) Native fishes of the Grand Canyon region: an obituary? In: (Editors not listed) Colorado River ecology and dam management. National Academy Press, Washington, DC, pp 124–177Google Scholar
  59. Minckley WL, Deacon JE (1968) Southwestern fishes and the enigma of “endangered species”. Science 159:1424–1432PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Minckley WL, Marsh P (2009) Inland fishes of the greater Southwest: chronicle of a vanishing biota. University of Arizona Press, TucsonGoogle Scholar
  61. Moyle PB (1976) Inland fishes of California. University of California Press, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  62. Moyle PB, Light T (1996a) Fish invasions in California: do abiotic factors determine success? Ecology 77:1666–1670CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Moyle PB, Light T (1996b) Biological invasions of fresh water: empirical rules and assembly theory. Biol Conserv 78:149–161CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Moyle PB, Marchetti MP (2006) Predicting invasion success; freshwater fishes in California as a model. Bioscience 56:515–524CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Olden JD, Poff NL (2005) Long-term trends of native and non-native fish faunas in the American Southwest. Anim Biodivers Conserv 28:75–89Google Scholar
  66. Olden JD, Poff NL, Bestgen KR (2006) Life-history strategies predict fish invasions and extirpations in the Colorado River basin. Ecol Monogr 76:25–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Page LM, Smith RL (1970) Recent range adjustments and hybridization of Notropis lutrensis and Notropis spilopterus in Illinois. T Illinois Acad Sci 63:264–272Google Scholar
  68. Power ME, Matthews WJ (1983) Algae-grazing minnows (Campostoma anomalum), piscivorous bass (Micropterus spp.) and the distribution of attached algae in a small prairie-margin stream. Oecologia 60:328–332CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Power ME, Matthews WJ, Stewart AJ (1985) Grazing minnows, piscivorous bass and stream algae: dynamics of a strong interaction. Ecology 66:1448–1456CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Pringle CM, Freeman MC, Freeman BJ (2000) Regional effects of hydrologic alterations on riverine macrobiota in the New World: tropical-temperate comparisons. Bioscience 50:807–823CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Rhodes K, Hubbs C (1992) Recovery of Pecos River fishes from a red tide fish kill. Southwest Nat 37:178–187CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Ribeiro F, Elvira B, Collares-Pereira MJ, Moyle PB (2008) Life-history traits of non-native fishes in Iberian watersheds across several invasion stages: a first approach. Biol lnvasions 10:89–102CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Rinne JN, Miller D (2006) Hydrology, geomorphology and management: implications for sustainability of native southwestern fishes. Rev Fish Sci 14:91–110CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Ross ST, Matthews WJ, Echelle AA (1985) Persistence of stream fish assemblages: effects of environmental change. Am Nat 126:24–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Schade CB, Bonar SA (2005) Distribution and abundance of nonnative fishes in streams of the western United States. N Am J Fish Manage 25:1386–1394CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Schaefer JF (2001) Riffles as barriers to interpool movement by three cyprinids (Notropis boops, Campostoma anomalum and Cyprinella venusta). Freshwater Biol 46:1–10CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Seaburg KG, Moyle JB (1964) Feeding habits, digestive rates, and growth of some Minnesota warmwater fishes. T Am Fish Soc 93:269–285CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Shea K, Chesson P (2002) Community ecology theory as a framework for biological invasions. Trends Ecol Evol 17:170–176CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Simberloff D (2009) The role of progagule pressure in biological invasions. Ann Rev Ecol Syst 40:81–102CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Smith CL, Powell CR (1971) The summer fish communities of Brier Creek, Marshall County, Oklahoma. Am Mus Novit 2458:1–30Google Scholar
  81. Taylor CM, Hastings A (2005) Allee effects in biological invasions. Ecol Lett 8:895–908CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Vives SP (1993) Choice of spawning substrate in red shiner with comments on crevice spawning in Cyprinella. Copeia 1993:229–232CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Wallace RK, Ramsey SJ (1982) A new cyprinid hybrid, Notropis lutrensis and N. callitaenia, from the Apalachicola drainage in Alabama. Copeia 1982:214–217CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Walters DM, Blum MJ, Rashleigh B, Freeman BJ, Porter BA, Burkhead NM (2008) Red shiner invasion and hybridization with blacktail shiner in the upper Coosa River, USA. Biol Invasions 10:1229–1242CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Ward DM, Nislow KH, Folt CL (2008) Do native species limit survival of reintroduced Atlantic salmon in historic rearing streams? Biol Conserv 141:146–152CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Zeug SC, Winemiller KO, Tarim S (2005) Response of Brazos River oxbow fish assemblages to patterns of hydrologic connectivity and environmental variability. T Am Fish Soc 134:1389–1399CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  • Edie Marsh-Matthews
    • 1
  • William J. Matthews
    • 2
  • Nathan R. Franssen
    • 2
  1. 1.Sam Noble Oklahoma Museum of Natural History and Department of ZoologyUniversity of OklahomaNormanUSA
  2. 2.Department of ZoologyUniversity of OklahomaNormanUSA

Personalised recommendations