Archives of Sexual Behavior

, Volume 34, Issue 4, pp 423–438 | Cite as

Gender Identity Outcome in Female-Raised 46,XY Persons with Penile Agenesis, Cloacal Exstrophy of the Bladder, or Penile Ablation

  • Heino F. L. Meyer-BahlburgEmail author


This review addresses the long-term gender outcome of gender assignment of persons with intersexuality and related conditions. The gender assignment to female of 46,XY newborns with severe genital abnormalities despite a presumably normal-male prenatal sex-hormone milieu is highly controversial because of variations in assumptions about the role of biological factors in gender identity formation. This article presents a literature review of gender outcome in three pertinent conditions (penile agenesis, cloacal exstrophy of the bladder, and penile ablation) in infancy or early childhood. The findings clearly indicate an increased risk of later patient-initiated gender re-assignment to male after female assignment in infancy or early childhood, but are nevertheless incompatible with the notion of a full determination of core gender identity by prenatal androgens.

Key Words

gender dysphoria gender identity penile agenesis cloacal bladder exstrophy penile ablation 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Attie, J. (1961). Congenital absence of the penis: A report of a case with congenital concealed penile agenesis and congenital absence of the left kidney and ureter. Journal of Urology, 86, 343–345.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  2. Avolio, L., Koo, H. P., Bescript, A. C., Snyder, H. M., Canning, D. A., & Duckett, J. W. (1996). The long-term outcome in men with exstrophy/epispadias: Sexual function and social integration. Journal of Urology, 156, 822–825.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. Baker Towell, D. M., & Towell, A. D. (2003). A preliminary investigation into quality of life, psychological distress and social competence in children with cloacal exstrophy. Journal of Urology, 169, 1850–1853.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. Bakker, A., van Kesteren, P., Gooren, L. J. G., & Bezemer, P. D. (1993). The prevalence of transsexualism in the Netherlands. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 87, 237–238.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  5. Baskin, L. S., Erol, A., Li, Y. W., Liu, W. H., Kurzrock, E., & Cunha, G. R. (1999). Anatomical studies of the human clitoris. Journal of Urology, 162, 1015–1020.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Baskin, L. S., Lee, Y. T., & Cunha, G. R. (1997). Neuroanatomical ontogeny of the human fetal penis. British Journal of Urology, 79, 628–640.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  7. Ben-Chaim, J., Jeffs, R. D., Reiner, W. G., & Gearhart, J. P. (1996). The outcome of patients with classic bladder exstrophy in adult life. Journal of Urology, 155, 1251–1252.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Bernardinelli, W., Mattoso, J., Albuquerque, D., & Cordeiro, J.-G. (1953). Aplasie du pénis. La Presse Médicale, 61, 432.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  9. Bradley, S. J., Oliver, G. D., Chernick, A. B., & Zucker, K. J. (1998). Experiment of nurture: Ablatio penis at 2 months, sex reassignment at 7 months, and a psychosexual follow-up in young adulthood. Pediatrics, 102, E91-E95. (Available on the World Wide Web
  10. Cendron, M. (2001). Disorders of the penis and scrotum. In J. P. Gearhart, R. C. Rink, & P. D. E. Mouriquand (Eds.), Pediatric urology (pp. 729–737). Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Saunders.Google Scholar
  11. Choudhury, S. R., & Maji, B. P. (1993). Penile agenesis: An unusual variant. International Urology and Nephrology, 25, 71–76.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  12. Ciftci, A. O., Şenocak, M. E., & Büyükpamukçu, N. (1995). Male gender assignment in penile agenesis: A case report and review of the literature. Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 30, 1358–1360.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Cogan, S. F., Becker, R. D., & Hofmann, A. D. (1975). Adolescent males with urogenital anomalies: Their body image and psychosexual development. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 4, 359–373.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Colapinto, J. (2000). As nature made him: The boy who was raised as a girl. New York: HarperCollins.Google Scholar
  15. Diamond, M. (1982). Sexual identity, monozygotic twins reared in discordant sex roles and a BBC follow-up. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 11, 181–186.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  16. Diamond, M. (1997). Sexual identity and sexual orientation in children with traumatized or ambiguous genitalia. Journal of Sex Research, 34, 199–211.Google Scholar
  17. Diamond, M. (1999). Pediatric management of ambiguous and traumatized genitalia. Journal of Urology, 162, 1021–1028.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  18. Diamond, M., & Sigmundson, H. K. (1997). Sex reassignment at birth: Long-term review and clinical implications. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 151, 298–304.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  19. Diseth, T. H., Bjordal, R., Schultz, A., Stange, M., & Emblem, R. (1998). Somatic function, mental health and psychosocial functioning in 22 adolescents with bladder exstrophy and epispadias. Journal of Urology, 159, 1684–1690.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. Dittmann, R. W. (1998). Ambiguous genitalia, gender-identity problems, and sex reassignment. Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy, 24, 255–271.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  21. Drury, R. B., & Schwarzell, H. H. (1935). Congenital absence of penis. Archives of Surgery, 30, 236–242.Google Scholar
  22. Duckro, P. N., Purcell, M., Gregory, J., & Schultz, K. (1985). Biofeedback for the treatment of anal incontinence in a child with ureterosigmoidostomy. Biofeedback and Self-Regulation, 10, 325–333.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  23. Egan, S. K., & Perry, D. G. (2001). Gender identity: A multidimensional analysis with implications for psychosocial adjustment. Developmental Psychology, 37, 451–463.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  24. Eisler, J. A., Tannenbaum, P. L., Mann, D. R., & Wallen, K. (1993). Neonatal testicular suppression with a GnRH agonist in rhesus monkeys: Effects on adult endocrine function and behavior. Hormones and Behavior, 27, 551–567.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  25. El Khader, K., El Fassi, J., Koutani, A., Attya, A. I., Hachimi, M., & Lakrissa, A. (2003). Aspects psychologiques, sexuels et sociaux de l’exstrophie vésicale chez l’adulte. Analyse de 3 cas. Annales d’Urologie, 37, 113–116.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  26. Evans, J. A., Erdile, L. B., Greenberg, C. R., & Chudley, A. E. (1999). Agenesis of the penis: Patterns of associated malformations. American Journal of Medical Genetics, 84, 47–55.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  27. Feitz, W. F. J., van Grunsven, E. J. K. J. E. M., Froeling, F. M. J. A., & de Vries, J. D. M. (1994). Outcome analysis of the psychosexual and socioeconomical development of adult patients born with bladder exstrophy. Journal of Urology, 152, 1417–1419.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  28. Filler, R. M. (1988). [Discussion]. Annals of Surgery, 208, 311–312.Google Scholar
  29. Fineman, A. D. (1959). Preliminary observations on ego development in children with congenital defects of the genitourinary system. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 29, 110–120.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  30. Fineman, A. D. (1963). Ego development in boys with a congenital defect of the genitourinary system. Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry, 2, 636–652.Google Scholar
  31. Fleiss, J. L., Levin, B., & Paik, M. C. (2003). Statistical methods for rates and proportions (3rd ed.). Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.Google Scholar
  32. Gautier, T., Salient, J., Pena, S., Imperato-McGinley, J., & Peterson, R. E. (1981). Testicular function in 2 cases of penile agenesis. Journal of Urology, 126, 556–557.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  33. Gearhart, J. P. (2001). The bladder exstrophy-epispadias-cloacal exstrophy complex. In J. P. Gearhart, R. C. Rink, & P. D. E. Mouriquand (Eds.), Pediatric urology (pp. 511–546). Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Saunders.Google Scholar
  34. Gearhart, J. P., & Rock, J. A. (1989). Total ablation of the penis after circumcision with electrocautery: A method of management and long-term followup. Journal of Urology, 142, 799–801.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  35. Giedd, J. N. (2004). Structural magnetic resonance imaging of the adolescent brain. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1021, 77–85.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  36. Gillies, H., & Harrison, R. J. (1948). Congenital absence of the penis. British Journal of Plastic Surgery, 1, 8–28.Google Scholar
  37. Hayden, P. W., Chapman, W. H., & Stevenson, J. K. (1973). Exstrophy of the cloaca. American Journal of Diseases of Children, 125, 879–883.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  38. Hendren, W. H. (1997). The genetic male with absent penis and urethrorectal communication: Experience with 5 patients. Journal of Urology, 157, 1469–1474.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  39. Hines, M. (2002). Sexual differentiation of human brain and behavior. In D. W. Pfaff, A. P. Arnold, A. M. Etgen, S. E. Fahrbach, & R. T. Rubin (Eds.), Hormones, brain, and behavior (Vol. 4, pp. 452–462). Amsterdam: Academic Press (Elsevier Science).Google Scholar
  40. Howell, C., Caldamone, A., Snyder, H., Ziegler, M., & Duckett, J. (1983). Optimal management of cloacal exstrophy. Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 18, 365–369.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  41. Husmann, D. A., McLorie, G. A., & Churchill, B. M. (1989). Phallic reconstruction in cloacal exstrophy. Journal of Urology, 142, 563–564.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  42. Johnston, W. G., Yeatman, G. W., & Weigel, J. W. (1977). Congenital absence of the penis. Journal of Urology, 117, 508–512.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  43. Kessler, W. O., & McLaughlin, A. P. (1973) Agenesis of penis. Embryology and management. Urology, 1, 226–229.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  44. Lattimer, J. K., Beck, L., Yeaw, S., Puchner, P. J., MacFarlane, M. T., & Krisiloff, M. (1978). Long-term followup after exstrophy closure: Late improvement and good quality of life. Journal of Urology, 119, 664–666.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  45. Lisa, L., Hanak, J., Cerny, M., Faflova, H., Kafka, V., & Braza, J. (1973). Agenesis of the penis. Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 8, 327–328.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  46. Lund, D. P., & Hendren, W. H. (1993). Cloacal exstrophy: Experience with 20 cases. Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 28, 1360–1369.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  47. Mann, D. R., Akinbami, M. A., Gould, K. G., Paul, K., & Wallen, K. (1998). Sexual maturation in male rhesus monkeys: Importance of neonatal testosterone exposure and social ranks. Journal of Endocrinology, 156, 493–501.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  48. Mann, D. R., Akinbami, M. A., Gould, K. G., Tanner, J. M., & Wallen, K. (1993). Neonatal treatment of male monkeys with a gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist alters differentiation of central nervous system centers that regulate sexual and skeletal development. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 76, 1319–1324.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  49. Martin, C. L., Ruble, D. N., & Szkrybalo, J. (2002). Cognitive theories of early gender development. Psychological Bulletin, 128, 903–933.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  50. Mathews, R. I., Perlman, E., Marsh, D. W., & Gearhart, J. P. (1999). Gonadal morphology in cloacal exstrophy: Implications in gender assignment. British Journal of Urology International, 84, 99–100.Google Scholar
  51. McCrea, L. E. (1942). Congenital absence of the penis. Journal of Urology, 47, 818–823.Google Scholar
  52. Mesrobian, H.-G. J., Kelalis, P. P., & Kramer, S. A. (1986). Long-term followup of cosmetic appearance and genital function in boys with exstrophy: Review of 53 patients. Journal of Urology, 136, 256–258.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  53. Meyer-Bahlburg, H. F. L. (1990). Short stature: Psychological issues. In F. Lifshitz (Ed.), Pediatric endocrinology (2nd ed., pp. 173–196) New York: Marcel Dekker.Google Scholar
  54. Meyer-Bahlburg, H. F. L., Dolezal, C., Baker, S. W., Carlson, A. D., Obeid, J. S., & New, M. I. (2004). Prenatal androgenization affects gender-related behavior but not gender identity in 5–12 year old girls with congenital adrenal hyperplasia. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 33, 97–104.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  55. Meyer-Bahlburg, H. F. L., Ehrhardt, A. A., Pinel, A., & Gruen, R. (1989, October). Gender identity development in two 46,XY individuals with normal gonads raised female because of severe genital abnormalities. Paper presented at the meeting of the Society for Sex Therapy and Research, Cleveland, OH.Google Scholar
  56. Money, J. (1968). Sex errors of the body: Dilemmas, education, counseling. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press.Google Scholar
  57. Money, J. (1975). Ablatio penis: Normal male infant sex-reassigned as a girl. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 4, 65–71.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  58. Money, J. (1998a). Medicine and law: Case consultation, ablatio penis. In J. Money (Ed.), Sin, science, and the sex police: Essays on sexology and sexosophy (pp. 286–296). Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books.Google Scholar
  59. Money, J. (1998b). Ablatio penis: Nature/nurture redux. In J. Money (Ed.), Sin, science, and the sex police: Essays on sexology and sexosophy (pp. 297–326). Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books.Google Scholar
  60. Money, J., & Ehrhardt, A. A. (1972). Man and woman, boy and girl: The differentiation and dimorphism of gender identity from conception to maturity. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press.Google Scholar
  61. Mutaf, M. (2001) Nonmicrosurgical use of the radial forearm flap for penile reconstruction. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 107, 80–86.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  62. New York Times. (2004, May 12). David Reimer, 38, subject of the John/Joan case. p. A21.Google Scholar
  63. Ochoa, B. (1998). Trauma of the external genitalia in children: Amputation of the penis and emasculation. Journal of Urology, 160, 1116–1119.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  64. Oesch, I. L., Pinter, A., & Ransley, P. G. (1987). Penile agenesis: A report of six cases. Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 22, 172–174.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  65. O’Neill, J. A., Holcomb, G. W., Schnaufer, L., Templeton, J. M., Jr., Bishop, H. C., Ross, A. J., et al. (1988). Surgical experience with thirteen conjoined twins. Annals of Surgery, 208, 299–312.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  66. Pohlandt, F., Kühn, H., Teller, W., & Thomä, H. (1974). Penisagnesie. Weibliche Geschlechtszuweisung unter psychotherapeutischer Betreuung der Eltern. Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift, 99, 2166–2172.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  67. Reiner, W. G., & Gearhart, J. P. (2004). Discordant sexual identity in some genetic males with cloacal exstrophy assigned to female sex at birth. New England Journal of Medicine, 350, 333–341.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  68. Reiner, W. G., Gearhart, J. P., & Jeffs, R. (1999). Psychosexual dysfunction in males with genital anomalies: Late adolescence, Tanner stages IV to VI. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 38, 865–872.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  69. Reiner, W. G., & Kropp, B. P. (2004). A 7-year experience of genetic males with severe phallic inadequacy assigned female. Journal of Urology, 172, 2395–2398.Google Scholar
  70. Rickham, P. P. (1960). Vesico-intestinal fissure. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 35, 97–102.Google Scholar
  71. Rosenblum, R. R., & Turner, W. R. (1973). Congenital absence of the penis. Journal of the South Carolina Medical Association, 69, 178–179.Google Scholar
  72. Rösler, A., & Kohn, G. (1983). Male pseudohermaphroditism due to 17β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase deficiency: Studies on the natural history of the defect and effect of androgens on gender role. Journal of Steroid Biochemistry, 19, 663–674.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  73. Ruble, D. N., & Martin, C. L. (1998). Gender development. In W. Damon (Series Ed.) & N. Eisenberg (Vol. Ed.), Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 3. Social, emotional, and personality development (5th ed., pp. 933–1016). New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
  74. Schlegel, P. N., & Gearhart, J. P. (1989). Neuroanatomy of the pelvis in an infant with cloacal exstrophy: A detailed microdissection with histology. Journal of Urology, 141, 583–585.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  75. Schober, J. M., Carmichael, P. A., Hines, M., & Ransley, P. G. (2002). The ultimate challenge of cloacal exstrophy. Journal of Urology, 167, 300–304.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  76. Sisk, C. L., Schulz, K. M., & Zehr, J. L. (2003). Puberty: A finishing school for male social behavior. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1007, 189–198.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  77. Skoog, S. J., & Belman, A. B. (1989). Aphallia: Its classification and management. Journal of Urology, 141, 589–592.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  78. Slijper, F. M. E., Drop, S. L. S., Molenaar, J. C., & de Muinck Keizer-Schrama, S. M. P. F. (1998). Long-term psychological evaluation of intersex children. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 27, 125–144.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  79. Stein, R., Stöckle, M., Fisch, M., Nakai, H., Müller, S. C., & Hohenfellner, R. (1994). The fate of the adult exstrophy patient. Journal of Urology, 152, 1413–1416.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  80. Stjernqvist, K., & Kockum, C. C. (1999). Bladder exstrophy: Psychological impact during childhood. Journal of Urology, 162, 2125–2129.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  81. Stolar, C. J. H., Wiener, E. S., Hensle, T. W., Silen, M. L., Sukarochana, K., Sieber, W. K., et al. (1987). Reconstruction of penile agenesis by a posterior sagittal approach. Journal of Pediatric Surgery, 22, 1076–1080.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  82. Stoller, R. J. (1965). The sense of maleness. Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 34, 207–218.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  83. Tank, E. S., & Lindenauer, S. M. (1970). Principles of management of exstrophy of the cloaca. American Journal of Surgery, 119, 95–98.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  84. Thompson, R. A., & Nelson, C. A. (2001). Developmental science and the media: Early brain development. American Psychologist, 56, 5–15.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  85. Tillem, S. M., Stock, J. A., & Hanna, M. K. (1998). Vaginal construction in children. Journal of Urology, 160, 186–190.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  86. Woodhouse, C. R. J., Ransley, P. G., & Williams, D. I. (1983). The patient with exstrophy in adult life. British Journal of Urology, 55, 632–635.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  87. Young, H. H., Cockett, A. T. K., Stoller, R., Ashley, F. L., & Goodwin, W. E. (1971). The management of agenesis of the phallus. Pediatrics, 47, 81–87.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  88. Yucel, S., & Baskin, L. S. (2003). Neuroanatomy of the male urethra and perineum. British Journal of Urology International, 92, 624–630.Google Scholar
  89. Yucel, S., de Souza, A., & Baskin, L. S. (2004). Neuroanatomy of the human female lower urogenital tract. Journal of Urology, 172, 191–195.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  90. Yunger, J. L., Carver, P. R., & Perry, D. G. (2004). Does gender identity influence children’s psychological well-being? Developmental Psychology, 40, 572–582.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  91. Zabbo, A., & Kay, R. (1986). Ureterosigmoidostomy and bladder exstrophy: A long-term followup. Journal of Urology, 136, 396–398.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  92. Zderic, S. A., Canning, D. A., Carr, M. C., Kodman-Jones, C., & Snyder, H. McC. (2002). The CHOP experience with cloacal exstrophy and gender reassignment. In S. A. Zderic, D. A. Canning, M. C. Carr, & H. McC. Snyder (Eds.), Pediatric gender assignment: A critical reappraisal (pp. 135–147). New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.Google Scholar
  93. Zucker, K. J. (1999). Intersexuality and gender identity differentiation. Annual Review of Sex Research, 10, 1–69.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  94. Zucker, K. J. (2002). Evaluation of sex- and gender-assignment decisions in patients with physical intersex conditions: A methodological and statistical note. Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy, 28, 269–274.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  95. Zucker, K. J. (2005). Measurement of psychosexual differentiation. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 34, 375–388.Google Scholar
  96. Zwiren, G. T., & Patterson, J. H. (1965). Extrophy of the cloaca. Report of a case treated surgically. Pediatrics, 35, 687–692.PubMedGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science + Business Media, Inc. 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.New York State Psychiatric InstituteNew York
  2. 2.Department of PsychiatryColumbia UniversityNew York
  3. 3.Department of Psychiatry, New York State Psychiatric InstituteColumbia UniversityNew York

Personalised recommendations