Artificial Intelligence and Law

, Volume 21, Issue 1, pp 47–78 | Cite as

Incorporating institutions, norms and territories in a generic model to simulate the management of renewable resources

  • Sigrid Aubert
  • Jean-Pierre MüllerEmail author


Management of the renewable natural resources in Madagascar is gradually being transferred to the local communities, particularly that of forest resources. However, these local communities are struggling to assess the consequences of management plans that they themselves must develop and implement on ecologically, economically and socially sustainable grounds. In order to highlight key aspects of different management options beforehand, we have developed MIRANA, a computer model to simulate various scenarios of management plan implementation. MIRANA differs from other simulation models by not only taking into account individual practices and economic exchanges, but also by accounting for the applicable regulations. These regulations are taken into consideration by means of a multiplicity of normative structures within a spatial context. The objective of this paper is to describe the representations of institutions, norms and territories proposed by MIRANA and to discuss these representations in relation to the state of the art in the field of normative multi-agent systems.


Multi-agent simulation Institutions Norms Environmental modelling Agent behaviour models 


  1. Aubert S (2009) «L’anthropisation: le rapport entre société et nature au regard du Droit» et «Droits de propriété intellectuelle et biodiversité». In: Chretien-Vernicos G, Rude-Antoine E dir (eds) Anthropologies et droits: état des savoirs et orientations contemporaines, AFAD, Dalloz, Paris, pp 342–343, 353–355Google Scholar
  2. Aubert S, Muller JP, Ralihalizara J (2010) MIRANA: a socioecological model for assessing sustainability of community-based regulations. In: International congress on environmental modelling and software modelling for environment’s sake, Ottawa, Canada, July 2010, pp 1–8Google Scholar
  3. Boaventura De Sousa S (1987) Law: a map of misreading; toward a postmodern conception of law. J Law Soc 14(3) (Autumn, 1987):279–302Google Scholar
  4. Boella G, Van der Torre L (2004) Regulative and constitutive norms in normative multiagent systems. In: Procs. of KR’04, pp 255–265. AAAI Press, Menlo ParkGoogle Scholar
  5. Bommel P, Müller JP (2007) An introduction to UML for modelling in the human and social sciences. In: Phan D, Amblard F (eds) Agent-based modelling and simulation in the social and human sciences. Bardwell Press, Oxford, pp 273–294Google Scholar
  6. Castelfranchi C (2003) Formalising the informal? Dynamic social order, bottom-up social control, and spontaneous normative relations. J Appl Log 1(1–2):47–92MathSciNetzbMATHCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Conte R, Castelfranchi C (1999) From conventions to prescriptions. Towards an integrated view of norms. Artif Intell Law 7(4):323–340CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Crawford SES, Ostrom E (1995) A grammar of institutions. Am Polit Sci Rev 89(3):582–600CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. de Sadeleer N, Charles HB (2004) Droit international et communautaire de la biodiversité. Dalloz, ParisGoogle Scholar
  10. Debarbieux B (2003) Territoire. In: Lévy J, Lussault M (eds) Dictionnaire de la géographie et de l’espace des sociétés. Belin, ParisGoogle Scholar
  11. Dignum MV (2004) A model for organizational interaction: based on agents, founded in logic. PhD thesis, Utrecht UniversityGoogle Scholar
  12. Esteva M, Rosell B, Rodriguez-Aguilar JA, Arcos Josep L (2004) AMELI: an agent-based middleware for electronic institutions, vol 1. IEEE Computer SocietyGoogle Scholar
  13. Farolfi S, Müller JP, Bonté B (2010) An iterative construction of multi-agent models to represent water supply and demand dynamics at the catchment level. Environ Model Softw 25:1130–1148CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Ferber J (1999) Multi-agent systems. An introduction to distributed artificial intelligence. Addison Wesley, LondonGoogle Scholar
  15. Ferber J, Gutknecht O (1998) A meta-model for the analysis and design of organizations in multi-agent systems. In: International conference on multi-agent systems, pp 128–135, IEEEGoogle Scholar
  16. Ferber J, Müller JP (1996) Influences and reactions: a model of situated multiagent systems. In: Proceedings of ICMAS’96 (international conference on multi-agent systems), AAAI Press, Menlo ParkGoogle Scholar
  17. Ferber J, Michel F, Baez J (2005) AGRE: integrating environments with organizations. In: Hutchison D, Kanade J, Kittler J et al (eds) E4MAS 2004. Berlin, Heidelberg, pp 48–56Google Scholar
  18. Grossi D (2007) Designing invisible hand-cuffs. PhD thesis, Dutch Research School of Information and Knowledge SystemsGoogle Scholar
  19. Grossi D, Aldewereld H, Dignum F (2007) Ubi lex, ibi poena: designing norm enforcement in e-institutions. In: Coordination, organizations, institutions and norms in multi-agent systems II, pp 101–114Google Scholar
  20. Grossi D, Meyer JJCh, Dignum F (2008) The many faces of counts-as: a formal analysis of constitutive rules. J Appl Log 6:192–217MathSciNetzbMATHCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Gruber TR (1993) Formal ontology in conceptual analysis and knowledge representation. Chapter: towards principles for the design of ontologies used for knowledge sharing. Kluwer Academic, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
  22. Hübner JF, Sichman JS, Boissier O (2002) A model for the structural, functional, and deontic specification of organizations in multiagent systems. In: SBIAGoogle Scholar
  23. Jonker CM, Sharpanskykh A, Treur J, Yolum P (2007) A framework for formal modeling and analysis of organizations. Appl Intell 27(1):49–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Kirk M (1999) Land tenure, technological change and resource use: transformation process in African agrarian systems. Peter Lang, FrankfurtGoogle Scholar
  25. Le Roy E (1999) Le jeu des lois, une anthropologie “dynamique” du Droit, Paris, LGJD, col. Droit & société, Série anthropologiqueGoogle Scholar
  26. Le Roy E (2012) La terre de l’autre, une anthropologie des régimes d’appropriation foncière. LGDJ, Paris 364 pGoogle Scholar
  27. Lopez y Lopez F, Luck M, d’Inverno M (2006) A normative framework for agent-based systems. Comput Math Organ Theory 12(2–3):227–250CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. López y López F, Luck M, d’Inverno M (2002) Constraining autonomy through norms. In: Proceedings of the international conference on multi-agent systemsGoogle Scholar
  29. Merry SE (1988) Legal pluralism, law & society review 22: 869–896, Published by Blackwell Publishing on behalf of the Law and Society Association Stable. Accessed 20 Jan 2009, 05:36
  30. Montagne P, Razanamaharo Z, Cooke A (2007) Tanteza, le transfert de gestion à Madagascar, 10 ans d’efforts, Antananarivo, Resolve/CIRADGoogle Scholar
  31. Müller JP (2007) Mimosa: using ontologies for modeling and simulation. In: Proceedings of informatik 2007, 25 Sept 2007, Bremen, Germany. s.l.: s.n., [5] pGoogle Scholar
  32. Müller JP (2009) Towards a formal semantics of event-based multi-agent simulations. In: Nuno D, Sichman JS (eds). Multi-agent-based simulation IX: ninth international workshop, MABS 2008, Estoril, Portugal, 12–13 May 2008. Revised selected papers. Springer, Berlin [Allemagne], pp 110–126. (Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence, 5269)Google Scholar
  33. Müller JP (2010) A framework for integrated modeling using a knowledge-driven approach. In: Swayne DA, Yang W, Voinov AA, Rizzoli A, Filatova T (eds) Proceedings of the iEMSs fifth biennial meeting : international congress on environmental modelling and software (iEMSs 2010), Ottawa, CanadaGoogle Scholar
  34. Müller JP, Aubert S (2012) Une ontologie pour construire une représentation multi-niveau de et par les systèmes sociaux. In: Rochebrune 2011, pp 1–11, Jan 2011 (Les Chemins de Traverse, to be published)Google Scholar
  35. Müller JP, Rakotonirainy HL, Hervé D (2011) Towards a description logics for scientific modeling. In: Proceedings of KEOD’2011, Paris, FranceGoogle Scholar
  36. Neale Walter C (1994) Institutions. In: Hodgson GM, Samuels WJ, Tool MR (eds) The elgar companion to institutional and evolutionary economics. Edward Elgar, Ann Arbor, pp 402–406Google Scholar
  37. North Douglass C (1991) Institutions. J Econ Perspect 5(1):97–112CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Ostrom E (2005) Understanding institutional diversity—Google books. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  39. Ostrom E (2009) A general framework for analysing sustainability of socio-ecological systèmes. Science 325:419–422MathSciNetzbMATHCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Parker DC, Filatova T (2008) A conceptual design for a bilateral agent-based land market with heterogeneous economic agents. Comput Environ Urban Syst 32:454–463CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Porter-Bolland L, Eillis EA, Guariguata MR, Ruiz-Mallen I, Negrete-Yannkelevich S, Reyes-Garcia V (2011) Community managed forests and forest protected areas: an assessment of their conservation effectiveness across the tropics. For Ecol Manag. doi: 10.1016/J.foreco.2011.05.034 Google Scholar
  42. Rives F, Antona M, Aubert S (2012) Socio-ecological functions and vulnerability frameworks to analyse forest policy reform. Ecol Soc (no spécial “public policies and management of rural forest: lasting alliance or fool’s dialogue ?” submitted)Google Scholar
  43. Sack R (1986) Human territoriality. Its theory and history. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  44. Santi R (2002) L’ordre juridique. Dalloz, ParisGoogle Scholar
  45. Searle J (1995) The construction of social reality. The Free Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  46. Soulié JC, Marcenac P (2000) A framework to model multiple environments in multiagent systems. In: PRICAI’ 00Google Scholar
  47. Wooldridge M (2009) An introduction to multiagent systems, 2nd edition. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  48. Zeigler B, Kim TG, Praehofer H (2000) Theory of modeling and simulation, 2nd edn. Academic Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.CIRAD-GREENMontpellier Cedex 5France
  2. 2.ESSA, AmpandrianombyAntananarivoMadagascar

Personalised recommendations