Advertisement

Archival Science

, Volume 17, Issue 1, pp 27–54 | Cite as

On or off the record? Detecting patterns of silence about death in Guatemala’s National Police Archive

  • Tamy Guberek
  • Margaret Hedstrom
Original Paper

Abstract

This paper investigates how the production of police records was linked to the policies of repression and violence during Guatemala’s civil war. We provide empirical evidence from the Historical Archive of the Guatemalan National Police that the police used language, terminology and codes to record deaths in ways that produced silences about the level of violence during the height of repressive military rule. Using a dataset derived from a statistically valid sample of police records together with qualitative archival analysis, we find evidence of profound changes in the terminology used to record and report on deaths—changes that follow a pattern consistent with the policies of information control and concealment of the three different military regimes that ruled Guatemala between 1978 and 1985. We argue that researchers will need to consider the silences created through the selective use of terminology in documents when using archives to produce historical knowledge. Detecting and intercepting silence will be especially important as state records are increasingly sought in service of ongoing pursuits for truth and justice about past atrocities.

Keywords

Guatemala Sampling in archives Silences Police archives Violence Human rights 

Notes

Acknowledgements

The authors wish to acknowledge the hard work by the leadership and staff at the AHPN over the past decade. They also wish to recognize the Human Rights Data Analysis Group for their leadership in the archival sampling project and their efforts in preparing the AHPN quantitative dataset. A special thanks to David Wallace, Tanya Harmer, Daniel Guzmán, Patrick Ball, Kirsten Weld, Ciaran Trace, John Ciorciari, Claudia Carolina López and the anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments on earlier drafts of this paper.

National Science Foundation (US), Open Data IGERT (Grant No. 0903629).

Authors' contribution

TG conducted the research and the analysis in this paper. With colleagues at HRDAG, she co-led the design, collection and preparation of the probabilistically sampled data from the AHPN. MH provided the comparative framework on sampling in archives and assisted with writing in this version of the paper.

References

  1. Archivo Histórico de la Policía Nacional (AHPN), Guatemala City, Guatemala:Google Scholar
  2. AHPN\GTPN\26\S001\DDR-573171. Secret, operational plan. EMGE, copy 13/20. “Plan Fuego,” 5 December 1982Google Scholar
  3. AHPN\GTPN\30\01\S004\F28352. Memorandum. Oficial Mayor de la Secretaría General a Encargados de Grupo de Oficiales Nocturnos, 20 December 1982Google Scholar
  4. AHPN\GTPN\30\02\S007\CUIT-22224471772012. Annual report. Memorias de labores de la PN, enviadas al Ministerio de Gobernación, 31 December 1980Google Scholar
  5. AHPN\GTPN\30\02\S007\CUIT- 22224471772012. Annual report. Memorias de labores de la PN, enviadas al Ministerio de Gobernación, 7 January 1981Google Scholar
  6. AHPN\GTPN\30\02\S007\CUIT- 8334681672012. Annual report. Memorias de labores de la PN, enviadas al Ministerio de Gobernación, 31 March 1979.Google Scholar
  7. AHPN\GTPN\30\01\S010\DDR-1667246\&\DDR- 1667247. Oficio. Director General a Ministro del Interior, 25 January 1971Google Scholar
  8. AHPN\GTPN\30\01\S020\DDR-1925071. Confidential, Oficio. Jefe Departamental de Escuintla al Director General, 16 June 1984Google Scholar
  9. AHPN\GTPN\30\DSC\F41966. Prensa libre [clipping]. 13 August 1983Google Scholar
  10. AHPN\GTPN\35\DDR-758897. General order. Decreto-Ley No. 20-82, pp. 314–315. 21–22 April 1982Google Scholar
  11. AHPN\GTPN\35\DDR-1849940. General order. Reglamento interno del Departamento de Relaciones Públicas, artículos. 150–161, pp. 486–488Google Scholar
  12. AHPN\GTPN\51\Clave-102. Instruction. Clave 102. Subdirector a Jefes Departamentales República y Jefes Cuerpos Ciuidad Capital, 2 November 1982.Google Scholar
  13. AHPN\GTPN\51\01\S003\26-Dec-3-Ene-1985. Police activity report. 26 December–3 January 1985.Google Scholar
  14. AHPN\GTPN\51\01\S003\2-Ene-8-Ene-1984. Police activity report. 2–8 January 1984Google Scholar
  15. AHPN\GTPN\51\01\S003\9-Ene-15-Ene-1984. Police activity report. 9–15 January 1984.Google Scholar
  16. AHPN\GTPN\51\01\S003\23-Ene-29-Ene-1984. Police activity report, 23–29 January 1984Google Scholar
  17. AHPN\GTPN\51\01\S003\30-Ene-5-Feb-1984. Police activity report, 30 January–5 February 1984Google Scholar
  18. AHPN\GTPN\51\01\S003\7-Nov-13-Nov-1983. Police activity report. 7–13 November 1983Google Scholar
  19. AHPN\GTPN\51\01\S011\F27826. Police intelligence training document. COCP, 16 January 1980Google Scholar
  20. AHPN\GTPN\años\1982\DDR-1783049. Memorandum. Oficial de Turno de Relaciones Públicas al Sr. Jefe del Departamento, 14 August 1982Google Scholar
  21. AHPN\GTPN\años\1982\DDR-1784362. Circular. Subdirector a Todo el Personal del Departamento de Relaciones Públicas, 12 July 1982Google Scholar
  22. AHPN\GTPN\años\1982\DDR-1784362. Correspondencia enviada y recibida. Cuarto Cuerpo. Jefatura de ServiciosGoogle Scholar
  23. AHPN (2013a) Del silencio a la memoria: revelaciones del Archivo Histórico De La Policía Nacional, 2011. Archivo Histórico de la Policía Nacional, GuatemalaGoogle Scholar
  24. AHPN (2013b) From silence to memory: revelations of the Archivo Histórico De La Policia Nacional (English version). University of Oregon Libraries, EugeneGoogle Scholar
  25. AHPN, HRDAG (2016) Una mirada al Archivo Histórico de la Policía Nacional a partir de un estudio cuantitativo: guía para el usuario. Archivo Histórico de la Policía Nacional, 2016Google Scholar
  26. Ball P, Kobrak P, Spirer HF (1999) State violence in Guatemala, 1960–1996: a quantitative reflection. American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1999. https://hrdag.org/publications-year/1999/
  27. Blanton T (2008) Recovering the memory of the Cold War: forensic history and Latin America. In: Joseph G, Spencer D (eds) In from the cold: Latin America’s new encounter with the Cold War. Duke University Press, DurhamGoogle Scholar
  28. Bradsher JG (1988) The FBI records appraisal. Midwest Arch 13(4):51–66Google Scholar
  29. Burns K (2010) Into the archive: writing and power in colonial Peru. Duke University Press, DurhamCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Caswell M (2014) Archiving the unspeakable: silence, memory, and the photographic record in Cambodia. University of Wisconsin Press, MadisonGoogle Scholar
  31. Cicchetti DV (1994) Guidelines, criteria, and rules of thumb for evaluating normed and standardized assessment instruments in psychology. Psychol Assess 6(4):284–290CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Coatsworth JH (1994) Central America and the United States: the clients and the colossus. Twayne Publishers, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  33. Cochran N, Gordon AC, Krause MS (1980) Proactive records: reflections on the village watchman. Knowl Creat Diffus Util 2(1):5–18Google Scholar
  34. Cohen S (2001) States of denial: knowing about atrocities and suffering. Polity Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  35. Comission for Historical Clarification (CEH) (1999) Guatemala: memory of silence. United Nations Office of Project Services, CopenhagenGoogle Scholar
  36. Cook T (1991) Many are called, but few are chosen: appraisal guidelines for sampling and selecting case files. Archivaria 32(1):25–50Google Scholar
  37. Diario de Centroamerica (1983) Guatemala City, Guatemala. 6 June 1983Google Scholar
  38. Digital National Security Archive, DNSA\GU00880. Eyes only, secret/sensitive [report]. Charles Fairbanks to Elliot Abrams and Mel Levitsy (DOS), 23 November 1982Google Scholar
  39. Drake JM (2014) Insurgent citizens: the manufacture of police records in post-Katrina New Orleans and its implications for human rights. Arch Sci 14(3–4):365–380CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Garcia P (2014) Documenting and classifying labor: the effect of legal discourse on the treatment of H-2a workers. Arch Sci 14(3):345–363CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Grandin G (2004) The last colonial massacre: Latin America in the Cold War. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Guberek T (2012) Off the record: concealing state violence in Guatemala’s national police, 1978–1985. Columbia University and London School of Economics and Political Science, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  43. Guzmán D (2011) Speaking stats to justice: expert testimony in a Guatemalan human rights trial based on statistical sampling. Chance Am Stat Assoc 24(3):23–29Google Scholar
  44. Guzmán D, Guberek T, Shapiro G, Zador P (2009) Studying millions of rescued documents: sampling plan at the Guatemalan National Police Archive. In: Paper presented at the proceedings to the joint statistical meetings, survey research methods section, AlexandriaGoogle Scholar
  45. Hamilton C, Harris V, Pickover M, Reid G, Saleh R, Taylor J (2002) Refiguring the archive. Springer, BerlinCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Harris V (2002) The archival sliver: power, memory, and archives in South Africa. Arch Sci 2(1–2):63–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Hindus M, Hammett T, Hobson BM (1980) The files of the Massachusetts superior court, 1859–1959: an analysis and a plan for action. Hall and Co, BostonGoogle Scholar
  48. Holden RH (2004) Armies without nations: public violence and state formation in Central America, 1821–1960. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  49. Huggins MK (1998) Political policing: the United States and Latin America. Duke University Press, DurhamGoogle Scholar
  50. Hull F (1981) The use of sampling techniques in the retention of records: a ramp study with guidelines. Unesco, General Information Programme and UNISET, ParisGoogle Scholar
  51. Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) (1983) Report on the situation of human rights in the republic of Guatemala. OEA/Ser.L/V/II.61Google Scholar
  52. Jonas S (1991) The battle for Guatemala: rebels, death squads and US power. Westview Press, BoulderGoogle Scholar
  53. Kepley D (1984) Sampling in archives: a review. Am Arch 47(3):237–242Google Scholar
  54. Kulsrud C (1947) Sampling rural rehabilitation records for transfer to the national archives. Am Arch 10(4):328–334Google Scholar
  55. Kuzmarov J (2009) Modernizing repression: police training, political violence, and nation-building in the ‘American century’, Dipl Hist 33(2):191–221CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Maanen JV, Pentland BT (1994) Cops and auditors: the rhetoric of record. In: Sitkin SB, Bies RJ (eds) The legalistic organization. Sage Publications, Thousand OaksGoogle Scholar
  57. McClintock M (1985) The American connection: state terror and popular resistance in Guatemala, vol 2. Zed Books, LondonGoogle Scholar
  58. McKay E (1978) Random sampling techniques: a method of reducing large homogeneous series in congressional papers. Am Arch 41(3):281–289Google Scholar
  59. Price ME, Guberek T, Guzmán DR, Zador P, Shapiro GM (2009) A statistical analysis of the Guatemalan National Police Archive: searching for documentation of human rights abuses. In: Proceedings JSM (ed) Survey research methods section. American Statistical Association, AlexandriaGoogle Scholar
  60. Schirmer J (1998) The Guatemalan military project: a violence called democracy. University of Pennsylvania Press, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
  61. Schirmer J (1999) The guatemalan politico-military project: legacies for a violent peace? Latin Am Perspect 26(105):92–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Shapiro G, Guzman D, Zador P, Guberek T, Price M, Lum K (2009) Weighting for the Guatemalan National Police Archive sample: unusual challenges and problems. In: Proceedings to the joint statistical meetings, survey research methods section. AlexandriaGoogle Scholar
  63. Snow CC, Peccerelli FA, Susanávar JS, Robinson AG, Najera Ochoa JM (2008) Hidden in plain sight: x.x. burials and the desaparecidos in the Department of Guatemala, 1977–1986. In: Asher J, Banks DL, Scheuren F (eds) Statistical methods for human rights. Springer, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  64. Stoler AL (2002) Colonial archives and the arts of governance. Arch Sci 2(1):87–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Stoler AL (2009) Along the archival grain: epistemic anxieties and colonial common sense. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  66. Tomuschat C (2001) Clarification commission in Guatemala. Hum Rights Q 23(2):233–258CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Torres MG (2004) The paper trails of counterinsurgency violence: the documented design and implementation of political violence in Guatemala, 1976–1984. Ph.D Dissertation in Social Anthropology. York University, TorontoGoogle Scholar
  68. Torres MG (2005) Bloody deeds/Hechos sangrientos: reading Guatemala’s record of political violence in cadaver reports. In: Menjívar C, Rodrígez N (eds) When states kill: Latin America, the US, and technologies of terror. University of Texas Press, AustinGoogle Scholar
  69. Trace CB (2002) What is recorded is never simply ‘what happened:’ record-keeping in modern organizational culture. Arch Sci 2(1):137–159CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Trouillot MR (1995) Silencing the past: power and the production of history. Beacon Press, BostonGoogle Scholar
  71. Trundle C (2011) Searching for culpability in the archives: commonwealth nuclear test veterans’ claims for compensation. Hist Anthropol 22(4):497–512CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Weld K (2014) Paper cadavers: the archives of dictatorship in Guatemala. Duke University Press, DurhamCrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.School of InformationUniversity of MichiganAnn ArborUSA

Personalised recommendations