Managed Care Organizations’ Use of Treatment Management Strategies for Outpatient Mental Health Care

  • Elizabeth Levy Merrick
  • Constance M. Horgan
  • Deborah W. Garnick
  • Dominic Hodgkin


A nationally representative sample of managed care organizations was surveyed (response rate=92%) regarding use of treatment management techniques for outpatient mental health care in their commercial products in 1999. Bivariate tests and logistic regression models were used to examine the relationship between product type, behavioral health contracting arrangement and treatment management techniques (prior authorization, standards for time to initial appointment, concurrent review, standards for follow-up after discharge, case management, practice guidelines). Prevalence varied from 43% to 87% depending on the technique. HMO products and products with specialty behavioral health contracts were more likely to use the techniques. Product type and contracting arrangement had independent effects.


mental health managed care utilization management contracting 


  1. Baker L. C. (2001). Managed care and technology adoption in health care: Evidence from magnetic resonance imaging. Journal of Health Economics 20(3): 395–421CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  2. Barry C. L., Gabel J. R., Frank R. G., Hawkins S., Whitmore H. H., Pickreign J. D. (2003). Design of mental health benefits: Still unequal after all these years. Health Affairs 22(5): 127–137CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. Bauer M. S. (2002). A review of quantitative studies of adherence to mental health clinical practice guidelines. Harvard Review of Psychiatry 10(3): 138–153CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. Borenstein D. B. (1990). Managed care: a means of rationing psychiatric treatment. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 41(10): 1095–1098PubMedGoogle Scholar
  5. Cannon D. S., Allen S. N. (2000). A comparison of the effects of computer and manual reminders on compliance with a mental health clinical practice guideline. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association 7(2): 196–203PubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Chen R. S., Rosenheck R. (2001). Using a computerized patient database to evaluate guideline adherence and measure patterns of care for major depression. Journal of Behavioral Health Services Research 28(4): 466–474CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  7. Dickey B., Azeni H. (1992). Impact of managed care on mental health services. Health Affairs 11(3): 197–204CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Fortney J., Rost K., Zhang M., Pyne J. (2001). The relationship between quality and outcomes in routine depression care. Psychiatric Services 52(1): 56–62CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  9. Frank R. G., Brookmeyer R. (1995). Managed mental health care and patterns of inpatient utilization for treatment of affective disorders. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 30(5): 220–223PubMedGoogle Scholar
  10. Frank R. G., McGuire T. G. (1998). Parity for mental health and substance abuse care under managed care. Journal of Mental Health Policy and Economics 1: 153–159CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  11. Grembowski D. E., Diehr P., Novak L. C., Roussel A. E., Martin D. P., Patrick D. L., Williams B., Ulrich C. M. (2000). Measuring the “managedness” and covered benefits of health plans. Health Services Research 35(3): 707–731PubMedGoogle Scholar
  12. Hennessy K. D., Green-Hennessy (1997). An economic and clinical rationale for changing utilization review practices for outpatient psychotherapy. Journal of Mental Health Administration 25(3): 340–349CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Hodgkin D. (1992). The impact of private utilization management on psychiatric care: A review of the literature. Journal of Mental Health Administration 19(2): 143–157CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  14. Hodgkin D., Horgan C. M., Garnick D. W. (1997). Make or buy: HMOs’ contracting arrangements for mental health care. Administration and Policy in Mental Health 24(4): 359–376CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  15. Hodgkin D., Horgan C. M., Garnick D. W., Merrick E. L. (2003). Cost sharing for substance abuse and mental health services in managed care plans. Medical Care Research and Review 60(1): 101–116CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  16. Howard R. C. (1998). The sentinel effect in an outpatient managed care setting. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 29(3): 262–268CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Jinnett K., Alexander J. A., Ullman E. (2001). Case management and quality of life: Assessing treatment and outcomes for clients with chronic and persistent mental illness. Health Services Research 36(1): 61–90PubMedGoogle Scholar
  18. Kemper P., Blumenthal D., Corrigan J. M., Cunningham P. J., Felt S. M., Grossman J. M., Kohn L. T., Metcalf C. E., St. Peter R. F., Strouse R. C., Ginsburg P. B. (1996). The design of the Community Tracking Study: A longitudinal study of health system change and its effects on people. Inquiry 33(2): 195–206PubMedGoogle Scholar
  19. Kemper P., Tu H. T., Reschovsky J. D., Schaefer E. (2002). Insurance product design and its effects: Trade-offs along the managed care continuum. Inquiry 39: 101–117PubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. Kessler R. C., Berglund P., Demler O., Jin R., Koretz D., Merikangas K. R., Rush A. J., Walters E. E., Wang P. S. (2003). The epidemiology of major depressive disorder. Results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication (NCS-R). Journal of the American Medical Association 289(23): 3095–3105CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  21. Kuno E., Rothbard A. B., Sands R. G. (1999). Service components of case management which reduce inpatient care use for persons with serious mental illness. Community Mental Health Journal 35(2): 153–167CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  22. Landon B. E., Wilson I. B., Cleary P. D. (1998). A conceptual model of the effects of health care organizations on the quality of medical care. Journal of the American Medical Association 279: 1377–1382CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  23. Liu X., Sturm R., Cuffel B. (2000). The impact of prior authorization on outpatient utilization on managed behavioral health care plans. Medical Care Research and Review 57(2): 182–195PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Mechanic D., Schlesinger M., McAlpine D. D. (1995). Management of mental health and substance abuse services: state of the art and early results. Milbank Quarterly 73(1): 19–55CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  25. Merrick E. L. (1999). Effects of a behavioral health carve-out on inpatient-related quality indicators for major depression treatment. Medical Care 37(10): 1023–1033CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  26. Merrick E. L., Garnick D. W., Horgan C. M., Hodgkin D. (2002). Quality measurement and accountability for substance abuse and mental health services in managed care organizations. Medical Care 40: 1238–1248CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Mihalik G., Scherer M. (1998). Fundamental mechanisms of managed behavioral health care. Journal of Health Care Finance 24(3): 1–15PubMedGoogle Scholar
  28. Miller I. (1996). Managed care is harmful to outpatient services: a call for accountability. Professional Psychology, Research, and Practice 27: 349–363CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Olfson M. (1990). Assertive community treatment: an evaluation of the experimental evidence. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 41(6): 634–641PubMedGoogle Scholar
  30. Regier D. A., Narrow W. E., Rae D. S., Manderscheid R. W., Locke B. Z., Goodwin F. K. (1993). The de facto US mental and addictive disorders service system. Archives of General Psychiatry 50: 85–94PubMedGoogle Scholar
  31. Robinson J. C. (2001). The end of managed care. The Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) May 285(20): 2622–2628CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Schlesinger M., Gray B., Perreira K. (1997). Medical professionalism under managed care: the pros and cons of utilization review. Health Affairs 16(1): 106–124CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  33. Shah B. V., Barnwell B. G., Bieler G. S. (1997). SUDAAN User’s Manual: Release 7.5. Research Triangle Park. North Carolina, Research Triangle InstituteGoogle Scholar
  34. Sturm, R. (1999). Cost and quality trends under managed care: Is there a learning curve in behavioral health carve-out plans? Journal of Health Economics 593–604Google Scholar
  35. Tischler G. L. (1990). Utilization management of mental health services by private third parties. American Journal of Psychiatry 147(8): 967–973PubMedGoogle Scholar
  36. U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Services (USDHHS). (1999). Mental health: A report of the Surgeon General. Rockville, MD: US Dept. of Health and Human Services, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, Center for Mental Health Services, National Institutes of HealthGoogle Scholar
  37. US Health Resources and Services Administration. (2001). “Health work force” [accessed on September 20, 2001]. Available at:
  38. Wang P. S., Berglund P., Kessler R. C. (2000). Recent care of common mental disorders in the United States: prevalence and conformance with evidence-based recommendations. Journal of General Internal Medicine 15(5): 284–292CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  39. Wickizer T. M., Lessler D. (1998). Do treatment restrictions imposed by utilization management increase the likelihood of readmission for psychiatric patients?. Medical Care 36(6): 844–850CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  40. Wolff N., Schlesinger M. (2002). Clinicians as advocates: an exploratory study of responses to managed care by mental health professionals. Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research 29(3): 274–287CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  • Elizabeth Levy Merrick
    • 1
    • 2
  • Constance M. Horgan
    • 1
  • Deborah W. Garnick
    • 1
  • Dominic Hodgkin
    • 1
  1. 1.Schneider Center for Behavioral Health, Heller School for Social Policy and ManagementBrandeis UniversityWalthamUSA
  2. 2.Schneider Center for Behavioral Health, Heller School for Social Policy and ManagementBrandeis UniversityWalthamUSA

Personalised recommendations