Managing for the middle: rancher care ethics under uncertainty on Western Great Plains rangelands
Ranchers and pastoralists worldwide manage and depend upon resources from rangelands (which support indigenous vegetation with the potential for grazing) across Earth’s terrestrial surface. In the Great Plains of North America rangeland ecology has increasingly recognized the importance of managing rangeland vegetation heterogeneity to address conservation and production goals. This paradigm, however, has limited application for ranchers as they manage extensive beef production operations under high levels of social-ecological complexity and uncertainty. We draw on the ethics of care theoretical framework to explore how ranchers choose management actions. We used modified grounded theory analysis of repeated interviews with ranchers to (1) compare rancher decision-making under relatively certain and uncertain conditions and (2) describe a typology of practices used to prioritize and choose management actions that maintain effective stewardship of these often multi-generational ranches. We contrast traditional decision-making frameworks with those described by interviewees when high levels of environmental and market uncertainty or ecological complexity led ranchers toward use of care-based, flexible and relational frameworks for decision-making. Ranchers facing complexity and uncertainty often sought “middle-ground” strategies to balance multiple, conflicting responsibilities in rangeland social-ecological systems. For example, ranchers’ care-based decision-making leads to conservative stocking approaches to “manage for the middle,” e.g. to limit risk under uncertain weather and forage availability conditions. Efforts to promote heterogeneity-based rangeland management for biodiversity conservation through the restoration of patch burn grazing and prairie dog conservation will require increased valuation of ranchers’ care work.
KeywordsGrasslands Agriculture Decision-making Heterogeneity Beef cow-calf Production and conservation tradeoffs Complexity
Animal unit equivalent
United States Department of Agriculture-Natural Resources Conservation Service
The authors appreciate Dr. Emily Kachergis who helped initiate the research, developed the study design and collected data in Wyoming in 2012, and Dr. Kachergis, Dr. Paul Meiman, Brad Palmer, Dr. David Briske, Dr. Tracy Hruska, Julie Kennedy, Sam Cannon and Dr. David Augustine for helpful comments on the study and/or manuscript. Research assistance provided by Pam Freeman, Nicole Kaplan and Shakota Dilley. Funding provided by: USDA-ARS; USDA-NIFA AFRI awards 2009-04442 and 2012- 38415-20328, Colorado Agricultural Experiment Station project COLO0698; Western Sustainable Agriculture, Research, and Education program (Project Number SW10-073); and the Center for Collaborative Conservation Fellows Program at Colorado State University.
- Agrawal, A. 2008. The Role of Local Institutions in Adaptation to Climate Change. Paper prepared for the Social Dimensions of Climate Change, Social Development Department, The World Bank, Washington DC, March 5-6, 2008. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/234591468331456170/pdf/691280WP0P11290utions0in0adaptation.pdf.
- Battiste, M., and J. Youngblood Henderson. 2000. Protecting indigenous knowledge and heritage: A global challenge. Saskatoon, SA, Canada: Purich Publishing Ltd.Google Scholar
- Bennett, J.W. 1969. Northern plainsmen: Adaptive strategy and agrarian life. Chicago, IL: Aldine.Google Scholar
- Bentley Brymer, A.L., D.T. Taylor, J.D. Wulfhorst, L.A. Torell, and R. Neil. 2018. Economic and social impact assessment of ranching on public lands: A guide to concepts, methods, and applications. Journal of Rangeland Applications 4: 1–16.Google Scholar
- Charmaz, K. 2006. Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
- Deloria Jr., V. 1988. Custer died for your sins: An Indian manifesto. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.Google Scholar
- Derner, J.D., D.D. Briske, M. Reeves, T. Brown-Brandl, M. Meehan, D. Blumenthal, W. Travis, D.J. Augustine, H. Wilmer, J.D. Scasta, J. Henderickson, J. Volesky, L. Edwards, and D.E. Peck. 2018. Vulnerability of grazing and confined livestock in the northern Great Plains to projected mid-and late-twenty-first century climate. Climatic Change 146 (1–2): 19–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Fernández-Giménez, M.E., B. Batkhishig, B. Batbuyan, and T. Ulambayar. 2015. Lessons from the dzud: Community-based rangeland management increases the adaptive capacity of Mongolian herders to winter disasters. World Development 68: 48–65. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2014.11.015.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Fuhlendorf, S.D., and D.M. Engle. 2001. Restoring heterogeneity on rangelands: ecosystem management based on evolutionary grazing patterns: We propose a paradigm that enhances heterogeneity instead of homogeneity to promote biological diversity and wildlife habitat on rangelands grazed by livestock. BioScience 51 (8): 625–632.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Fulton, A., F. Vanclay, D. Pannel, and F. Vanclay. 2011. Enabling change in family farm businesses. Changing land management, 95–106. Collingwood, VIC, Australia: CSIRO.Google Scholar
- Gibson, D.J. 2009. Grasses and grassland ecology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Gilligan, C. 1982. In a different voice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Glesne, C. 1992. Becoming qualitative researchers: An introduction. White Plains, N.Y.: Longman.Google Scholar
- Haraway, D.J. 2003. The companion species manifesto: Dogs, people, and significant otherness. Chicago: Prickly Paradigm Press.Google Scholar
- Harding, S. 2006. Science and social inequality: Feminist and postcolonial issues. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
- Holling, C.S., and L.H. Gunderson. 2002. Resilience and adaptive cycles. Panarchy: Understanding transformations in human and natural systems. Washington, DC: Island Press.Google Scholar
- Huang, R. 2016. R-based qualitative data analysis. http://rqda.r-forge.r-project.org/.
- Leopold, A. 1949. A sand county almanac and sketches here and there. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Lund, C. 2014. Truth comes out. On Conterfeit Blues. Nashville: New West.Google Scholar
- Noddings, N. 1984. Caring: A feminine approach to ethics and moral education. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Oeberst, A., J. Kimmerle, and U. Cress. 2016. What is knowledge? Who creates it? Who possesses it? The need for novel answers to old questions. Mass collaboration and education. New York, NY: Springer.Google Scholar
- Otkin, J.A., M.C. Anderson, C. Hain, M. Svoboda, D. Johnson, R. Mueller, T. Tadesse, B. Wardlow, and J. Brown. 2016. Assessing the evolution of soil moisture and vegetation conditions during the 2012 United States flash drought. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 218: 230–242.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Prokopy, L.S., K. Floress, J.G. Arbuckle, S.P. Church, F.R. Eanes, Y. Gao, B.M. Gramig, P. Ranjan, and A.S. Singh. 2019. Adoption of agricultural conservation practices in the United States: Evidence from 35 years of quantitative literature. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 74 (5): 520–534.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ragin, C.C. 2014. The Comparative Method: Moving Beyond Qualitative and Quantitative Strategies. Oakland: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Reeves, J.L., J.D. Derner, M.A. Sanderson, M.K. Petersen, L.T. Vermeire, J.R. Hendrickson, and S.L. Kronberg. 2013. Temperature and precipitation affect steer weight gains differentially by stocking rate in northern mixed-grass prairie. Rangeland Ecology and Management 66 (4): 438–444.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Rizza, C., and A. Guimarães Pereira. 2014. Building a resilient community through social network: Ethical considerations about the 2011 Genoa floods. In Proceedings of the 11th International ISCRAM Conference- University Park, Pennsylvania, USA, eds. S.R. Hilz, M.S. Pfaff, L. Plotnick, and P.C. Shih.Google Scholar
- Ruff, S.P., D. Ee Peck, C.T. Bastian, and W.E. Cook. 2016. Economics of transitioning from a cow-calf-yearling operation to a stocker operation. Journal of ASFMRA 55–76.Google Scholar
- Sayre, N.F., and M.E. Fernández-Giménez. 2003. The genesis of range science, with implications for current development policies. Proceedings of the 7th International Rangelands Congress, Durban, South Africa, N. Allsopp, A.R. Palmer, S.J. Milton, K.P. Kirman, G.I.H. Kerley, C.R. Hurt, C.J. Brown, eds.Google Scholar
- TallBear, K. 2017. Beyond the life/not life binary: A feminist-indigenous reading of cryopreservation, interspecies thinking and the new materialisms. In Cryopolitics: Frozen life in a melting world, ed. J. Randin and E. Kowal, 179–202. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Torell, L.A., N.R. Rimbey, J.A. Tanaka, and S.A. Bailey. 2001. The lack of a profit motive for ranching: implications for policy analysis. Current Issues in Rangeland Resource Economics: Symposium Proceedings (2001) 16629, Western Regional Coordinating Committee on Rangeland Economics: WCC-55. https://doi.org/10.22004/ag.econ.16629.
- Tronto, J.C. 1994. Moral boundaries: A political argument for an ethic of care. New York, NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Tronto, J.C. 1999. Care ethics: Moving forward. Hypatia 14 (1): 112–119.Google Scholar
- Tuhiwai Smith, L. 2013. Decolonizing methodologies: Research and Indigenous peoples. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
- USDA NASS. 31 May 2019. Prices received for cattle by month, United States. www.nass.usda.gov/Charts_and_Maps/Agricultural_Prices/priceca.php.
- Whyte, K.P., and C.J. Cuomo. 2016. Ethics of caring in environmental ethics. The Oxford handbook of environmental ethics, 234. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Wilmer, H., D.J. Augustine, J.D. Derner, M.E. Fernández-Giménez, D.D. Briske, L.M. Roche, K.W. Tate, and K.E. Miller. 2018. Diverse management strategies produce similar ecological outcomes on ranches in western Great Plains: Social-ecological assessment. Rangeland Ecology and Management 71 (5): 626–636. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rama.2017.08.001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Wintle, B.A., H., Kujala, A. Whitehead, A. Cameron, S. Veloz, A. Kukkala, A. Moilanen, A. Gordon, P.E. Lentini, P.E., N.C. Cadenhead and S.A. Bekessy. 2019. Global synthesis of conservation studies reveals the importance of small habitat patches for biodiversity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 116 (3): 909–914.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Wylie, J. 2017. Vanishing points: An essay on landscape, memory and belonging. Irish Geography 50 (1): 3–18.Google Scholar