Advertisement

Food poverty, food waste and the consensus frame on charitable food redistribution in Italy

  • Sabrina ArcuriEmail author
Symposium/Special Issue

Abstract

Food poverty and food waste are two major contemporary food system problems, which have (re)gained prominence amongst both scholars and policy-makers, due to recent economic and environmental concerns. In this context, the culturally dominant perspective portrays charitable food redistribution as a “win–win solution” to confront food poverty and food waste in affluent societies, although this view is contested by many scholars. This paper applies the notions of framings and flat/sharp keyings to unpack the different narratives entailed by public discourses on food waste and food poverty in Italy. The aim is to problematize the representation of the recent anti-waste/pro-donations law as the optimal policy measure to effectively rectify both food poverty and food waste. The paper argues that the widespread public support for the law reflects the interpretation of charitable food redistribution as a consensus frame, standing for the convergence between flat positions and is reinforced by confusion on terms and responsibilities. Indeed, the strength of the law lies in the capacity to reconcile different positions and bring actors together around a short-term objective, whose foundations have deep roots in the common ethics. However, if the debate is to be moved forward, trade-offs between different framings of problems at stake should be explicitly navigated when designing policy instruments.

Keywords

Food poverty Food waste Charitable food redistribution Consensus frame Discourse Italy 

Abbreviations

CAP

Common agricultural policy

FBAO

Fondazione Banco Alimentare Onlus (Food Bank Foundation)

FEAD

Fund for European Aid to the most Deprived

LMM

Last minute market

PEAD

Programme Européen d’Aide alimentaire aux plus Démunis

Notes

References

  1. AGEA (Agenzia per le Erogazioni in Agricoltura). 2013. Relazione piano di distribuzione degli alimenti agli indigenti 2013. Consuntivo delle attività realizzate al 30.04.2013. https://www.agea.gov.it/portal/pls/portal/docs/1/3806205.PDF. Accessed 26 Jun 2017.
  2. Alexander, C., and C. Smaje. 2008. Surplus retail food redistribution: An analysis of a third sector model. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 52 (11): 1290–1298.Google Scholar
  3. Alexander, C., N. Gregson, and Z. Gille. 2013. Food waste, In The handbook of food research, ed. A. Murcott, W. Belasco and P. Jackson, 471–484. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.Google Scholar
  4. Alexander, P., C. Brown, A. Arneth, J. Finnigan, D. Moran, and M. D. Rounsevell. 2017. Losses, inefficiencies and waste in the global food system. Agricultural Systems 153: 190–200.Google Scholar
  5. Alleanza contro la povertà. 2013. http://www.redditoinclusione.it/. Accessed May 2018.
  6. Azzurro, P., S. Gaiani, and M. Vittuari. 2016. Fusions Italy—Country report on national food waste policy. http://www.eu-fusions.org/phocadownload/country-report/FUSIONS%20IT%20Country%20Report%2030.06.pdf. Accessed 20 May 2017.
  7. Bacon, C. M., and G. A. Baker. 2017. The rise of food banks and the challenge of matching food assistance with potential need: Towards a spatially specific, rapid assessment approach. Agriculture and Human Values 34 (4): 899–919.Google Scholar
  8. Bandera, L. 2015. Colletta alimentare: una solidarietà senza confini. Secondo Welfare, November, 30.Google Scholar
  9. Bane, M. J., B. Coffin, and R. F. Thiemann, eds. 2000. Who will provide?: The changing role of religion in American social welfare. Boulder: Westview Press.Google Scholar
  10. Barilla Center for Food and Nutrition (BCFN). 2012. Lo spreco alimentare: cause, impatti e proposte. https://www.barillacfn.com/m/publications/spreco-alimentare-cause-impatti-proposte.pdf. Accessed 16 June 2017.
  11. Béland, D. 2009. Ideas, institutions, and policy change. Journal of European Public Policy 16 (5): 701–718.Google Scholar
  12. Benford, R. D., and D. A. Snow. 2000. Framing processes and social movements: An overview and assessment. Annual Review of Sociology 26 (1): 611–639.Google Scholar
  13. Blair, D., and J. Sobal. 2006. Luxus consumption: Wasting food resources through overeating. Agriculture and Human Values 23 (1): 63–74.Google Scholar
  14. Brunori, G., V. Malandrin, and A. Rossi. 2013. Trade-off or convergence? The role of food security in the evolution of food discourse in Italy. Journal of Rural Studies 29: 19–29.Google Scholar
  15. Callon, M. 1998. An essay on framing and overflowing: Economic externalities revisited by sociology. The Sociological Review 46 (S1): 244–269.Google Scholar
  16. Campbell, H., D. Evans, and A. Murcott. 2017. Measurability, austerity and edibility: Introducing waste into food regime theory. Journal of Rural Studies 51: 168–177.Google Scholar
  17. Candel, J. J., G. E. Breeman, S. J. Stiller, and C. J. Termeer. 2014. Disentangling the consensus frame of food security: The case of the EU Common Agricultural Policy reform debate. Food Policy 44: 47–58.Google Scholar
  18. Caritas‐CIDSE G20 Network. 2012. Food Security and the G20. http://www.caritasitaliana.it/materiali/convegni/G20/documento_sicurezza_alimentare.pdf. Accessed 12 Jun 2017.
  19. Caritas Italiana. 2014. False partenze. Rapporto 2014 sulla povertà e l’esclusione sociale in Italia. http://www.caritasitaliana.it/caritasitaliana/allegati/4776/Rapporto_2014_completo%20-%20def%20-%20light.pdf. Accessed 30 June 2015.
  20. Caritas Italiana. 2015a. Dopo la crisi costruire il welfare. Le politiche contro la povertà in Italia. http://s2ew.caritasitaliana.it/materiali/Pubblicazioni/libri_2015/Rapporto_politiche_poverta/Caritas_rapporto_politiche_poverta2015.pdf. Accessed 17 June 2017.
  21. Caritas Italiana. 2015b. Povertà plurali. Rapporto 2015 sulla povertà e l’esclusione sociale. http://www.caritasitaliana.it/materiali/pubblicazioni/libri_2015/rapporto_poverta/rapportopoverta_2015_web.pdf. Accessed 10 Mar 2017.
  22. Caritas Italiana and Fondazione Banco Alimentare Onlus. 2015. Manual Of Good Practices For Charitable organisations. http://cdn.bancoalimentare.it/sites/bancoalimentare.it/files/manualecaritasbanco_eng_007.pdf. Accessed 31 July 2017.
  23. Caritas Italiana. Campagna 2014–2015. Una sola famiglia umana, cibo per tutti: è compito nostro. Documento base. http://www.cibopertutti.it/campagna/. Accessed 26 Jun 2017.
  24. Cloke, P., J. May, and A. Williams. 2017. The geographies of food banks in the meantime. Progress in Human Geography 41 (6): 703–726.Google Scholar
  25. Coop. 2015. Dodicesimo rapporto sociale nazionale della cooperazione di consumatori 2015. Nota sui principali impegni 2016. https://www.e-coop.it/CoopRepository/COOP/CoopItalia/coop-rs-2016/Sfogliatore_RS_Coop2016_Integrale/RS2015.pdf. Accessed 15 June 2017.
  26. Davis, O., and B. B. Geiger. 2017. Did food insecurity rise across Europe after the 2008 Crisis? An analysis across welfare regimes. Social Policy and Society 16 (3): 343–360.Google Scholar
  27. Dowler, E. 2002. Food and poverty in Britain: Rights and responsibilities. Social Policy & Administration 36 (6): 698–717.Google Scholar
  28. Dowler, E., and H. Lambie-Mumford. 2015. How can households eat in austerity? Challenges for social policy in the UK. Social Policy and Society 14 (3): 417–428.Google Scholar
  29. Dowler, E. A., and D. O’Connor. 2012. Rights-based approaches to addressing food poverty and food insecurity in Ireland and UK. Social Science & Medicine 74 (1): 44–51.Google Scholar
  30. Entman, R. M. 1993. Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm. Journal of Communication 43 (4): 51–58.Google Scholar
  31. ERE (Emilia-Romagna Europa). 2012. Rivista quadrimestrale dell’IRES CGIL Emilia-Romagna N.12/Dicembre 2012. Editrice Socialmente. http://www.editricesocialmente.it/riviste/ere___emilia_romagna_europa/articolo_94.htm. Accessed 21 June 2017.
  32. EU Parliament. 2012. European Parliament resolution of 19 January 2012 on how to avoid food wastage: Strategies for a more efficient food chain in the EU (2011/2175(INI)).Google Scholar
  33. European Commission. 2016. Fund for European aid to the most deprived—Reducing deprivation, supporting inclusion: FEAD case studies 2016. https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=738&langId=en&pubId=7947&furtherPubs=yes. Accessed 1 June 2017.
  34. European Commission. 2017. https://ec.europa.eu/. Accessed 20 May 2017.
  35. European Parliament. 2012. European Parliament resolution of 19 January 2012 on how to avoid food wastage: strategies for a more efficient food chain in the EU (2011/2175(INI)).Google Scholar
  36. Eurostat Database, Accessed Sept 2018.Google Scholar
  37. FAO. 2001. The state of food insecurity 2001. Rome: FAO.Google Scholar
  38. FAO. 2011. Global food losses and food waste—Extent, causes and prevention. Rome.Google Scholar
  39. FBAO. 2014. Emergenza alimentare: la nostra priorità. 31.01.2014. https://www.bancoalimentare.it/it/Emergenza-Alimentare-la-nostra-priorita. Accessed 1 May 2017.
  40. FBAO. 2015. Spreco alimentare. Dalle parole ai fatti. 12.10.2015. http://www.bancoalimentare.it/en/node/3779. Accessed 1 May 2017.
  41. FEBA, FoodDRinkEurope and EuroCommerce. 2016. Every meal matters. Food donation guidelines. https://www.fooddrinkeurope.eu/uploads/publications_documents/Every_Meal_Matters_Food_Donation_Guidelines.pdf. Accessed 7 Apr 2017.
  42. Frigo, A. 2013. Il lungo percorso dal PEAD al FEAD. Secondo Welfare, November, 22.Google Scholar
  43. Frigo, A. 2014. Donazioni di alimenti: aiutare i poveri ed evitare lo spreco. Secondo Welfare, July, 19.Google Scholar
  44. Gamson, W. A. 1995. Constructing social protest. Social movements and culture. In Social movements and culture, eds. H. Johnston, and B. Klandermans, 85–106. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
  45. Garrone, P., M. Melacini, and A. Perego. 2014. Surplus food recovery and donation in Italy: The upstream process. British Food Journal 116 (9): 1460–1477.Google Scholar
  46. Goffman, E. 1974. Frame analysis: An essay on the organization of experience. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  47. Gori, C., and L. Lusignoli. 2017. Alleanza contro la povertà e REI. In Caritas. 2017b. Per uscire tutti dalla crisi. Rapporto 2017 sulle politiche contro la povertà in Italia. Reddito di inclusione: la sfida dell’attuazione.Google Scholar
  48. Grant, W. P. 2012. Can political science contribute to agricultural policy? Policy and Society 31 (4): 271–279.Google Scholar
  49. Griffin, M., J. Sobal, and T. A. Lyson. 2009. An analysis of a community food waste stream. Agriculture and Human Values 26 (1–2): 67–81.Google Scholar
  50. Ilfattoalimentare. 2014. Prodotti in scadenza: la lotta allo spreco alimentare si combatte nei supermercati. Coop, Auchan e Carrefour li vendono a metà prezzo. https://ilfattoalimentare.it/prodotti-in-scadenza-lotta-spreco.html Accessed 1 June 2017.
  51. Kirwan, J., and D. Maye. 2013. Food security framings within the UK and the integration of local food systems. Journal of Rural Studies 29: 91–100.Google Scholar
  52. Lambie-Mumford, H. 2013. ‘Every town should have one’: Emergency Food Banking in the UK. Journal of Social Policy 42: 73–89.Google Scholar
  53. Lambie-Mumford, H. 2017. Hungry Britain: The rise of food charity. Bristol: Policy Press.Google Scholar
  54. Lambie-Mumford, H., and E. Dowler. 2014. Rising use of “food aid” in the United Kingdom. British Food Journal 116 (9): 1418–1425.Google Scholar
  55. Lodi Rizzini, C. 2015. A Milano apre il nuovo Emporio di Caritas. Secondo Welfare, March, 25.Google Scholar
  56. Loopstra, R., A. Reeves, and D. Stuckler, D. 2015. Rising food insecurity in Europe. The Lancet 385(9982): 2041.Google Scholar
  57. Lorenz, S. 2012. Socio-ecological consequences of charitable food assistance in the affluent society: The German Tafel. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 32 (7/8): 386–400.Google Scholar
  58. MacMillan, T., and E. Dowler. 2012. Just and sustainable? Examining the rhetoric and potential realities of UK food security. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 25 (2): 181–204.Google Scholar
  59. Madama, I., M. Natili, and M. Jessoula. 2013. National report: Italy. COPE. http://cope-research.eu. Accessed Mar 2016.
  60. Maino, F., Lodi Rizzini, C. and L. Bandera. 2016. La povertà alimentare in Italia. Le risposte del secondo welfare. Bologna: Il Mulino.Google Scholar
  61. Maxwell, S. 1996. Food security: A post-modern perspective. Food policy 21 (2): 155–170.Google Scholar
  62. McMichael, P. 2009. A food regime analysis of the ‘world food crisis’. Agriculture and Human Values 26 (4): 281.Google Scholar
  63. Midgley, J. L. 2014. The logics of surplus food redistribution. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 57 (12): 1872–1892.Google Scholar
  64. Ministero del Lavoro e delle Politiche Sociali (MINLAVORO). 2014. Indigenti: Poletti, già inviato a Bruxelles il nuovo Programma di aiuti alimentari. http://www.lavoro.gov.it/stampa-e-media/Comunicati/Pagine/2014_06_11-Indigenti.aspx. Accessed 28 Nov 2016.
  65. Ministero dell’Ambiente e della Tutela del Territorio e del Mare (MINAMB). 2015. Audizione ministro in Commissione Affari Sociali Camera: semplificazioni già in Stabilità, incoraggiare donazione invenduto. 29.10.2015. http://www.minambiente.it/comunicati/spreco-alimentare-galletti-nuova-legge-onorare-lavoro-expo. Accessed 1 Aug 2017.
  66. Ministero delle Politiche Agricole, Alimentari e Forestali (MIPAAF). 2015. Expo: presentate le azioni del governo per ridurre sprechi e potenziare aiuti agli indigenti. 12.06.2015. https://www.politicheagricole.it/flex/cm/pages/ServeBLOB.php/L/IT/IDPagina/331. Accessed 1 May 2017.
  67. Ministero delle Politiche Agricole, Alimentari e Forestali (MIPAAF). 2013. Povertà alimentare, De Girolamo: trovate risorse per far partire fondo indigenti. Ora stimolare anche la filiera contro lo spreco di cibo. 16.10.2013. https://www.politicheagricole.it/flex/cm/pages/ServeBLOB.php/L/IT/IDPagina/331. Accessed 1 May 2017.
  68. Mooney, P. H., and S. A. Hunt. 2009. Food security: The elaboration of contested claims to a consensus frame. Rural Sociology 74 (4): 469–497.Google Scholar
  69. Moragues-Faus, A. 2017. Problematising justice definitions in public food security debates: Towards global and participative food justices. Geoforum 84: 95–106.Google Scholar
  70. Mourad, M. 2016. Recycling, recovering and preventing “food waste”: Competing solutions for food systems sustainability in the United States and France. Journal of Cleaner Production 126: 461–477.Google Scholar
  71. O’Connor, C., M. Gheoldus, and O. Jan. 2014. Comparative study on EU member states’ legislation and practices on food donation. Final report. https://www.eesc.europa.eu/resources/docs/comparative-study-on-eu-member-states-legislation-and-practices-on-food-donation_finalreport_010714.pdf. Accessed 29 May 2017.
  72. OXFAM. 2017. Italiani, povera gente. Oxfam media briefing. https://www.oxfamitalia.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/MediaBrief_ItalianiPoveraGente.pdf. Accessed 24 Jun 2017.
  73. Oxfam, ActionAid, and Slow Food. 2015. Dichiarazione congiunta di Oxfam Italia, ActionAid Italia, Slow Food. Carta di Milano si sostanzi di impegni concreti del Governo italiano sul diritto al cibo e la sicurezza alimentare globale. https://www.oxfamitalia.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Dichiarazione-congiunta_Oxfam_AA_Slow-Food.pdf. Accessed 24 Jun 2017.
  74. Papargyropoulou, E., R. Lozano, J. K. Steinberger, N. Wright, and Z. Bin Ujang. 2014. The food waste hierarchy as a framework for the management of food surplus and food waste. Journal of Cleaner Production 76: 106–115.Google Scholar
  75. PINPAS. 2014. Piano Nazionale di Prevenzione degli Sprechi Alimentari. Le azioni prioritarie per la lotta allo spreco, 5 giugno 2014. http://www.minambiente.it/sites/default/files/archivio_immagini/Galletti/Comunicati/PINPAS%2010%20MISURE%20PRIORITARIE%205%20GIUGNO%202014.pdf. Accessed 1 May 2017.
  76. Poppendieck, J. 1998. Sweet charity? Emergency food and the end of entitlement. NY: Penguin.Google Scholar
  77. Riches, G. 1999. Advancing the human right to food in Canada: Social policy and the politics of hunger, welfare, and food security. Agriculture and Human Values 16 (2): 203–211.Google Scholar
  78. Riches, G. 2011. Thinking and acting outside the charitable food box: Hunger and the right to food in rich societies. Development in Practice 21 (4–5): 768–775.Google Scholar
  79. Riches, G., and T. Silvasti, eds. 2014. First world hunger revisited: Food charity or the right to food? Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan.Google Scholar
  80. Secondo Welfare. 2013. Focus sulla povertà alimentare. 14.10.2013. http://secondowelfare.it/povert-alimentare/focus-poverta-alimentare.html. Accessed 2 May 2017.
  81. Segrè, A., and P. Azzurro. 2016. Spreco alimentare: dal recupero alla prevenzione. Indirizzi applicativi della legge per la limitazione degli sprechi. Milano: Fondazione Giangiacomo Feltrinelli.Google Scholar
  82. Silvasti, T., and T. Kortetmäki. 2017. Nordic Welfare Universalism, Charity Food Aid and Environmental Ethics Enter. In Ecosocial transition in society. Contribution of social work and social policy, eds, eds. A.-L. Matthies, and K. Närhi, 219–233. London, UK: Routledge.Google Scholar
  83. Slow Food. no date. Slow food international position paper on food losses and waste. https://www.slowfood.com/sloweurope/wp-content/uploads/ING-position-paper-foodwaste.pdf. Accessed 2 May 2017.
  84. Smil, V. 2010. Improving efficiency and reducing waste in our food system. Environmental Sciences 1 (1):17–26.Google Scholar
  85. Spreco Zero website. 2017. http://www.sprecozero.it/. Accessed 2 May 2017.
  86. Stuart, T. 2009. Waste: Uncovering the global food scandal. New York: WW Norton & Company.Google Scholar
  87. Van Gorp, B., and M. J. van der Goot. 2012. Sustainable food and agriculture: Stakeholder’s frames. Communication, Culture & Critique 5 (2): 127–148.Google Scholar
  88. Van der Horst, H., S. Pascucci, and W. Bol. 2014. The “dark side” of food banks? Exploring emotional responses of food bank receivers in the Netherlands. British Food Journal 116 (9): 1506–1520.Google Scholar
  89. Vlaholias, E., K. Thompson, D. Every, and D. Dawson. 2015. Charity starts… at work? Conceptual foundations for research with businesses that donate to food redistribution organisations. Sustainability 7 (6): 7997–8021.Google Scholar
  90. Warshawsky, D. N. 2015. The devolution of urban food waste governance: Case study of food rescue in Los Angeles. Cities 49: 26–34.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Economics and ManagementUniversità degli Studi di FirenzeFlorenceItaly

Personalised recommendations