Advertisement

Agriculture and Human Values

, Volume 36, Issue 2, pp 241–256 | Cite as

Desert wonderings: reimagining food access mapping

  • Kathryn Teigen De MasterEmail author
  • Jess Daniels
Article

Abstract

For over 20 years, the concept of “food deserts” has served as an evocative metaphor, signifying spatialized patterns of injustice associated with low access to nutritious foods through retail and social exclusion. Yet in spite of its pithy appeal, scholars and activists increasingly critique the food desert concept as stigmatizing, inaccurate, and insufficient to characterize entrenched structural inequities. These well-founded critiques demonstrate a convincing need to reframe approaches to spatialized food injustice. We argue that food desert maps, which aim to visually illustrate food inequality, can reproduce problematic assumptions, stigmas, and inaccuracies that form the crux of scholarly critiques. For example, food desert maps typically overlook community assets and also utilize decontextualized and overdetermined indicators, such as proximity to supermarkets and transportation access. Although we acknowledge the contributions of food desert maps, in this paper we propose a reimagining of food access mapping. To illustrate our argument, we present a course-based food justice mapping study in Providence, Rhode Island. Our project draws inspiration from studies that interrogate the deficit-oriented framing of food deserts, as well as several alternative mapping practices: critical cartography and counter-mapping, community asset mapping, participatory geographic information systems, and radical cartography. We suggest these alternative mapping approaches have potential to move practitioners and viewers beyond the desolate “desert” vantage point and toward a more textured understanding of community food access that inspires engaged exploration.

Keywords

Food deserts Food access Critical cartography and counter-mapping Asset mapping Participatory mapping Radical cartography 

Notes

Acknowledgements

The authors gratefully acknowledge the contributions of the students of Brown University’s “Sustenance and Sustainability” course and leaders of the Providence Foodshed Justice Project (http://pvdfoodshedjusticemapping.org/) to this work. We are especially thankful for contributions by Molly Bledsoe and Daniel Blaustein-Rejto, who contributed mapping information on Providence farmer’s markets and food pantries. We also thank the dozens of Providence, Rhode Island storekeepers and employees who generously accommodated our experiential course-based exercise, and we are grateful to the Environmental Justice League of Rhode Island and the Rhode Island Food Policy Council for their helpful feedback at critical junctures of this project. Finally, we thank Brown University’s Center for Environmental Studies, Swearer Center for Public Service, and Creative Mind Initiative for their support.

References

  1. Aldred, R. 2011. From community participation to organizational therapy? World café and appreciative inquiry as research methods. Community Development 46 (1): 57–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Alevizou, G. 2015. Mapping assets within the media, community and the creative citizen project. Asset Mapping: Comparative Approach. http://comparativeassetmapping.org/?p=98. Retrieved 15 Oct 2015.
  3. Alkon, A. H., D. Block, K. Moore, C. Gillis, N. DiNuccio, and N. Chavez. 2013. Foodways of the urban poor. Geoforum 48: 126–135.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Battersby, J., and J. Crush. 2014. Africa’s urban food deserts. Urban Forum 25 (2): 143–151.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Beaumont, J., T. Lang, S. Leather, and C. Mucklow. 1995. Report from the Policy Sub-group to the Nutrition Task Force Low Income Project: Department of Health. Hertfordshire: Radlett Institute of Grocery Distribution.Google Scholar
  6. Bhagat, A., and L. Mogel. 2007. Introduction. In An atlas of radical cartography, eds. L. Mogel, and A. Bhagat, 6–11. Los Angeles, CA: Journal of Aesthetics & Protest Press.Google Scholar
  7. Bilková, K., and F. Križan. 2015. Mapping of grocery stores in slovak countryside in context of food deserts. Acta Universitatis Agriculturae et Silviculturae Mendelianae Brunensis 63 (5): 1633–1638.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Blevins, J., S. Thurman, M. Kiser, and L. Beres. 2012. Community health assets mapping: A mixed methods approach in Nairobi. Mapping, cost, and reach to the poor of faith-inspired health care providers in Sub-Saharan Africa: Strengthening the evidence for faith-inspired health engagement in Africa, vol. 3, The World Bank: Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  9. Breyer, B., and A. Voss-Andreae. 2013. Food mirages. Health & Place 24: 131–139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Brinkley, C., S. Raj, and M. Horst. 2017. Culturing food deserts: Recognizing the power of community-based solutions. Built Environment 43 (3): 328–342.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Brones, A. 2018. Karen Washington: It’s not a food desert, it’s food apartheid. In Guernica. https://www.guernicamag.com/karen-washington-its-not-a-food-desert-its-food-apartheid. Retrieved 12 Oct 2018.
  12. Buczynski, A. B., H. Freishtat, and S. Buzogany. 2015. Mapping Baltimore city’s food environment: 2015 report. Maryland Food System Map. http://mdfoodsystemmap.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Baltimore-Food-Environment-Report-2015-11.pdf. Retrieved 6 Nov 2018.
  13. Büscher, B., and R. Fletcher. 2015. Accumulation by conservation. New Political Economy 20 (2): 273–298.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Chen, X., and J. Clark. 2015. Measuring space–time access to food retailers: A case of temporal access disparity in Franklin County, Ohio. The Professional Geographer 68 (2): 1–14.Google Scholar
  15. Cohen, B. 2002. USDA community food security assessment toolkit. USDA Economic Research Service: Electronic Publications from the Food Assistance & Nutrition Research Program. https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/publications/43164/15824_efan02013_1_.pdf?v=0. Retrieved 9 Sept 2012.
  16. Collier, J. Jr. 1967. Visual anthropology: Photography as research method. Foreword by George and Louise Spindler. New York, Chicago, San Francisco, Toronto, London: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.Google Scholar
  17. Coveney, J., and L. O’Dwyer. 2008. Effects of mobility and location on food access. Health & Place 15 (1): 45–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Crampton, J. W., and J. Krygier. 2005. An introduction to critical cartography. ACME 4 (1): 11–33.Google Scholar
  19. Cummins, S., and S. Macintyre. 2002. Food deserts-evidence and assumption in health policy making. BMJ 325 (7361): 436–438.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Daniels, Jessica. 2013. Wondering in the desert: Context, cartography, and visions of an Alternative Food Desert. Brown University: Providence, RI. Unpublished undergraduate thesis.Google Scholar
  21. Denil, M. 2011. The search for a radical cartography. Cartographic Perspectives. 68: 7–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Dunn, C. E. 2007. Participatory GIS: A people’s GIS? Progress in Human Geography 31 (5): 616–637.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Eisenhauer, E. 2001. In poor health: Supermarket redlining and urban nutrition. GeoJournal 53 (2): 125–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Elbel, B., A. Moran, L. B. Dixon, K. Kiszko, J. Cantor, C. Abrams, and T. Mijanovich. 2015. Assessment of a government-subsidized supermarket in a high-need area on household food availability and children’s dietary intakes. Public Health Nutrition 15: 2881–2890.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Elwood, S. 2006. Beyond cooptation or resistance: Urban spatial politics, community organizations, and GIS based spatial narratives. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 96 (2): 323–341.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Fielding, J. E., and P. A. Simon. 2011. Food deserts or food swamps?: Comment on “Fast food restaurants and food stores. JAMA Internal Medicine 171 (13): 1171–1172.Google Scholar
  27. Fields, T. 2013. [FOOD JUSTICE] End the Corporate Exploitation of ‘Food Deserts’. Ebony, 3 April. https://www.ebony.com/health/food-justice-end-the-corporate-exploitation-of-food-deserts/. Retrieved 6 July 2018.
  28. Figueroa, M. 2015. Food sovereignty in everyday life: Toward a people-centered approach to food systems. Globalizations 12 (4): 498–512.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Foucault, M. 1977. Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison. New York: Pantheon Books.Google Scholar
  30. Galt, R. E. 2011. Counting and mapping Community Supported Agriculture (CSA) in the United States and California: Contributions from critical cartography/GIS. ACME 10 (2): 131–162.Google Scholar
  31. Gillespie, G. W. 2003. Visual sociology and food. Journal for the Study of Food and Society 6 (2): 7–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Goldsberry, K., C. Duvall, P. Howard, and J. Stevens. 2010. Nutritional terrain mapping: A geospatial investigation of pedestrian produce accessibility. GeoCarto International 25 (6): 485–499.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Gottlieb, R., and A. Joshi. 2010. Food justice. Boston, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  34. Guminski, S. 2015. If you build it, they won’t come: Why eliminating food deserts won’t close the nutrition gap. Chicago Policy Review. http://chicagopolicyreview.org/2015/10/26/if-you-build-it-they-wont-come-why-eliminating-food-deserts-wont-close-the-nutrition-gap/. Retrieved 15 Oct 2015.
  35. Guthman, J. 2008. Bringing good food to others: Investigating the subjects of alternative food practice. Cultural Geographies 15 (4): 431–447.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Guthman, J. 2011. Weighing in: Obesity, food justice, and the limits of capitalism. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  37. Hackett, A., L. Boddy, J. Boothby, T. J. B. Dummer, B. Johnson, and G. Stratton. 2008. Mapping dietary habits may provide clues about the factors that determine food choice. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics 21 (5): 428–437.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hajer, M. 1995. The politics of environmental discourse: Ecological modernization and the policy process. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  39. Handbury, J., I. Rahkovsky, and M. Schnell. 2015. What drives nutritional disparities? Retail access and food purchases across the socioeconomic spectrum. The National Bureau of Economic Research. https://www.nber.org/papers/w21126. Accessed 15 Oct 2015.
  40. Haraway, Donna. 1988. Situated knowledges: The science question in feminism and the privilege of partial perspective. Feminist Studies 14 (30): 575–599.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Harmon, K., and G. Clemans. 2009. The map as art: Contemporary artists explore cartography. New York, NY: Princeton Architectural Press.Google Scholar
  42. Harper, D. 1998. An argument for visual sociology. In Image-based research: A sourcebook for qualitative researchers, ed. J. Prosser, (pp. 24–41), London: Routledgefalmer.Google Scholar
  43. Harris, L. M., and H. Hazen. 2006. Power of maps: (Counter) mapping for conservation. ACME 4 (1): 99–130.Google Scholar
  44. Heesen, J., D. F. Lorenz, M. Nagenborg, B. Wenzel, and M. Voss. 2014. Blind spots on Achilles’ heel: The limitations of vulnerability and resilience mapping in research. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science 5 (1): 74–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Herries, J. 2010. Mapping food deserts. Presentation for “Healthy Communities By Design” conference, Redlands and Loma Linda, California, pp. 15–17.Google Scholar
  46. Horst, M., and B. Gaolach. 2015. The potential of local food systems in North America: A review of foodshed analyses. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 30 (5): 399–407.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Howard, P. 2009. Visualizing food system concentration and consolidation. Southern Rural Sociology 24 (2): 87–110.Google Scholar
  48. Jakes, S., A. Hardison-Moody, S. Bowen, and J. Blevins. 2015. Engaging community change: The critical role of values in asset mapping. Community Development 46 (4): 392–406.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Jensen, D., and M. Roy, eds. 2012. Mission possible: A neighborhood atlas. http://missionpossiblesf.org/. Accessed 29 Oct 2015.
  50. Kelly, A. B. 2011. Conservation practice as primitive accumulation. The Journal of Peasant Studies 38 (4): 683–701.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Kloppenburg, J. Jr., J. Hendrickson, and G. W. Stevenson. 1996. Coming into the foodshed. Agriculture and Human Values 13 (3): 33–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Kretzmann, J. P., and J. L. McKnight. 1993. Building communities from the inside out: A path toward finding and mobilizing a community’s assets. Chicago, IL: ACTA.Google Scholar
  53. Kwan, Mei-Po. 2002. Feminist visualization: Re-envisioning GIS as a method in feminist geographic research. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 92: 645–661.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. LeClair, M. S., and A. M. Aksan. 2014. Redefining the food desert: Combining GIS with direct observation to measure food access. Agriculture and Human Values 31 (4): 537–547.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Leete, L., N. Bania, and A. Sparks-Ibanga. 2012. Congruence and coverage: Alternative approaches to identifying urban food deserts and food hinterlands. Journal of Planning Education and Research 32 (2): 204–218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Lutz, C., and J. Collins. 1991. The photograph as an intersection of gazes: The example of National Geographic. Visual Anthropology Review 7 (1): 134–149.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. MacNell, L., S. Elliott, A. Hardison-Moody, and S. Bowen. 2017. Black and Latino urban food desert residents’ perceptions of their food environment and factors that influence food shopping decisions. Journal of Hunger & Environmental Nutrition 12 (3): 375–393.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Mathie, A., and G. Cunningham. 2003. From clients to citizens: Asset-based community development as a strategy for community-driven development. Development in Practice 13 (5): 474–486.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. McClintock, N. 2011. From industrial garden to food desert: Demarcated devaluation in the flatlands of Oakland, California. In Cultivating food justice: Race, class, and sustainability, eds. A. H. Alkon, and J. Agyeman, 89–120. Boston, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  60. McEntee, J. 2009. Highlighting food inadequacies: Does the food desert metaphor help this cause? British Food Journal 111 (4): 349–363.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Minaker, L., P. Fisher, K. Raine, and L. Frank. 2016. Measuring the food environment: From theory to planning practice. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 2 (1): 65–82.Google Scholar
  62. Mogel, L., and A. Bhagat, eds. 2007. An atlas of radical cartography. Los Angeles, CA: Journal of Aesthetics & Protest Press.Google Scholar
  63. Morland, K., S. Wing, A. Diez Roux, and C. Poole. 2002. Neighborhood characteristics associated with the location of food stores and food service places. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 22 (1): 23–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Morton, L. W., E. A. Bitto, M. J. Oakland, and M. Sand. 2005. Solving the problems of iowa food deserts: Food insecurity and civic structure. Rural Sociology 70: 94–112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Pavlovskaya, M. 2018. Critical GIS as a tool for social transformation. The Canadian Geographer 62 (1): 40–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Pavlovskaya., M. 2009. Non-quantitative GIS. In Qualitative GIS: A mixed methods approach, eds. M. Cope, and S. Elwood, 13–38. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
  67. Peluso, N. L. 1995. Whose woods are these? Counter-mapping forest territories in Kalimantan, Indonesia. Antipode 27: 383–406.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Peters, A. 2013. Change through food: Bringing an oasis to the West Oakland food desert. 1 March: GOOD: 1 March. https://www.good.is/articles/change-through-food-bringing-an-oasis-to-the-west-oakland-food-desert. Accessed 6 July 2018.
  69. Pickles, John. 2003. A history of spaces. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  70. Pollard, C. M., T. J. Landrigan, P. L. Ellies, D. A. Kerr, M. L. Lester, and S. E. Goodchild. 2014. Geographic factors as determinants of food security: A Western Australian food pricing and quality study. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 23 (4): 703–713.Google Scholar
  71. Rai, N. D., T. A. Benjaminsen, S. Krishnan, and C. Madegowda. 2018. Political ecology of tiger conservation in India: Adverse effects of banning customary practices in a protected area. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography.Google Scholar
  72. Raja, S., Changxing Ma, and P. Yadav. 2008. Beyond food deserts: Measuring and mapping racial disparities in neighborhood food environments. Journal of Planning Education and Research 27 (4): 469–482.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Rankin, William. 2016. After the map: Cartography, navigation, and the transformation of territory in the Twentieth Century. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Rose, G. On the need to ask how, exactly, is geography “visual”?. Antipode 25: 212–221.Google Scholar
  75. Rose, D., J. N. Bodor, C. M. Swalm, J. C. Rice, T. A. Farley, and P. L. Hutchinson. 2009. Deserts in New Orleans? Illustrations of urban food access and implications for policy. University of Michigan National Poverty Center/USDA Economic Research Service Research “Understanding the Economic Concepts and Characteristics of Food Access.”.Google Scholar
  76. Saletan, W. 2008. Food apartheid: Banning fast food in poor neighborhoods. Slate. Accessed 31 July 2008.Google Scholar
  77. Sbicca, J. 2012. Growing food justice by planting an anti-oppression foundation: Opportunities and obstacles for a budding social movement. Agriculture and Human Values 29 (4): 455–466.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Scorza, D., N. Henderson, and L. M. Castillo. 2012. Facilitating change in the food justice movement. Social Justice Learning Institute & People’s Grocery, http://sjli.org/sites/default/files/PG_and_SJLI_Final_Paper.pdf#overlay-context=program/health-equity/research-and-resources. Accessed 6 July 2018.
  79. Shannon, J. 2014. Food deserts: Governing obesity in the neoliberal city. Progress in Human Geography 38 (2): 248–266.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Sheppard, E. 2005. Knowledge production through critical GIS: Genealogy and prospects. Cartographica 40 (4): 5–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Short, A., J. Guthman, and S. Raskin. 2007. Food deserts, oases, or mirages? Small markets and community food security in the San Francisco Bay Area. Journal of Planning Education and Research 26 (3): 352–364.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Solnit, R. 2010. Infinite city: A San Francisco atlas. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  83. Soss, J., R. Fording, and S. F. Schram. 2011. Disciplining the poor: Neoliberal paternalism and the persistent power of race. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Sparks, A. L., N. Bania, and L. Leete. 2011. Comparative approaches to measuring food access in urban areas: The case of Portland, Oregon. Urban Studies 48 (8): 1715–1737.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Stallmann, T. 2012. Alternative cartographies: Building collective power. Master’s thesis, Department of Geography. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. https://www.tim-maps.com/static/stallmann-ma_thesis.pdf.
  86. Taylor, D. E., and K. J. Ard. 2015. Food availability and the food desert frame in Detroit: An overview of the city’s food system. Environmental Practice 17 (2): 102–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. Tepper, R. 2011. D.C. mobile market bus to bring fresh produce to city’s food deserts. The Huffington Post, 15 September. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/09/15/dc-mobile-market-bus-food-desert_n_962763.html. Accessed 5 July 2018.
  88. The Economist. 2011. If you build it, they may not come: A shortage of healthy food is not the only problem. 7 July. http://www.economist.com/node/18929190. Accessed 6 July 2018.
  89. The Providence Plan. 2012. Providence neighborhood profiles. http://local.provplan.org/profiles/index.html. Accessed 5 June 2012.
  90. Thomas, C. 2011. Emanuel seeks to eliminate Chicago food deserts. ABC7 Local WLS-TV Chicago, 1 February. http://abclocal.go.com/wls/story?section=news/politics&id=7932706. Accessed 6 July 2018.
  91. Thornes, J. E. 2004. The visual turn and geography (response to Rose 2003 intervention). Antipode 36: 787–794.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Todd, J., and M. Ver Ploeg. 2015. Restricting sugar-sweetened beverages from SNAP purchases not likely to lower consumption. United States Department of Agriculture http://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2015-march/restricting-sugar-sweetened-beverages-from-snap-purchases-not-likely-to-lower-consumption.aspx#.Vb5hcjBVikr. Accessed 15 October 2015.
  93. Treuhaft, S., and A. Karpyn. 2010. The grocery gap: Who has access to healthy food and why it matters. PolicyLink and The Food Trust. http://thefoodtrust.org/uploads/media_items/grocerygap.original.pdf. Accessed 3 July 2018.
  94. Van Wart, S., and T. S. Parikh. 2013. Increasing youth and community agency in GIS. GeoHCI Workshop, 27–28 April: Paris. http://tap2k.org/papers/vanwart-localground-geohci2013.pdf. Accessed 15 Oct 2015.
  95. Ver Ploeg, M. 2009. Access to affordable and nutritious food: Measuring and understanding food deserts and their consequences. United States Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service.Google Scholar
  96. Ver Ploeg, M., and V. Breneman eds. 2011. Food Desert Locator. United States Department of Agriculture Agriculture Marketing Service. http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-desert-locator/go-to-the-locator.aspx. Accessed 25 Nov 2012.
  97. Ver Ploeg, M., P. Dutko, and V. Breneman. 2015. Measuring food access and food deserts for policy purposes. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy 37 (2): 205–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Wainwright, J. 2008. Decolonizing development: Colonial power and the Maya. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  99. Walsh, S. C. 2011. Big retailers make pledge of stores for ‘food deserts.’ The New York Times, 20 July. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/21/us/21food.html. Accessed 6 July 2018.
  100. Whelan, A., N. Wrigley, D. Warm, and E. Cannings. 2002. Life in a “food desert. Urban Studies 39 (11): 2083–2100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Widener, M. J., S. Metcalf, and Y. Bar-Yam. 2011. Dynamic urban food environments: A temporal analysis of access to healthy foods. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 41 (4): 439–441.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  102. Wood, D. 2010. Rethinking the power of maps. New York, NY: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
  103. Wrigley, N. 2002. “Food deserts” in British cities: Policy context and research priorities. Urban Studies 39 (11): 2029–2040.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  104. Wrigley, N., D. Warm, and B. Margetts. 2003. Deprivation, diet and food retail access: Findings from the Leeds “Food Deserts” study. Environment and Planning A 35 (1): 151–188.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  105. Yaccino, S. 2011. In Chicago, Michelle Obama takes on ‘food deserts’. The New York Times: The Caucus, The Politics and Government Blog of The Times, 25 October. https://thecaucus.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/10/25/in-chicago-michelle-obama-takes-on-food-deserts/. Accessed 6 July 2018.

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Environmental Science, Policy & ManagementUniversity of California-BerkeleyBerkeleyUSA
  2. 2.FibershedSan GeronimoUSA

Personalised recommendations