“It’s hard to be strategic when your hair is on fire”: alternative food movement leaders’ motivation and capacity to act
Despite decades of struggle against the industrial food system, academics still question the impact of the alternative food movement. We consider what food movement leaders themselves say about their motivation to act and their capacity to scale up their impact. Based on semi-structured interviews with 27 food movement leaders in Michigan, our findings complicate the established academic narratives that revolve around notions of prefigurative and oppositional politics, and suggest pragmatic strategies that could scale up the pace and scope of food movement impacts. In contrast to the apolitical perspective some scholars see guiding alternative food movements, local leaders we interviewed see the food system from a structural-political lens. Though some see strength in fragmentation, most are not under the illusion that they can work alone and aspire to build their collective strength further. Concerns about organizational survival and conflicting views about the goals of the food movement, however, present ongoing challenges. Ultimately, we argue that there is a middle ground food movement leaders can walk between prefigurative and oppositional politics, one that still attempts to intentionally change the state, while also maintaining the inventiveness that can come from autonomous, grassroots initiatives. Specifically, interviewees suggested that increased strategic capacity around policy advocacy, critical food systems education, and negotiation could help them extend cross-movement networks and mainstream more equitable food policies, while continuing to experiment with customized solutions.
KeywordsFood systems Alternative food movement Food governance Strategic capacity Michigan
Community supported agriculture
Supplemental nutrition assistance program
We would like to thank the numerous food movement leaders in Michigan who shared their time and insight for the interviews we conducted in this study. We also thank Kameshwari (Kami) Pothukuchi, Rich Pirog, Kathryn Colasanti, Lilly Fink Shapiro, Robert Fishman, Scott Campbell, Harley Etienne, Ana Paula Pimentel Walker, Joy Knoblauch, and the blind reviewers for their invaluable feedback on earlier drafts. This project would also not have been possible without University of Michigan MCubed funding, and students who engaged in early discussions and literature reviews, including Danielle Rivera, Kelly McGraw and graduate research teams led by John Vandermeer and Ivette Perfecto. We chose not to directly identify individuals or organizations we interviewed, as most asked to remain anonymous and worried that revealing some, and not others, might contribute to inequitable representation of the accomplishments of some actors over others. However, we do want to dedicate this article to the memory of Charity Hicks, who asked us explicitly to name her as a contributor. We only had the chance to get to know Charity during the interview we conducted with her a month before her tragic death. She left us with a lasting impression of what it means to be a relentless activist and “movement weaver”, as someone who linked food movements with the fight for water rights and many other grassroots struggles in Detroit and nationally (see http://www.onthecommons.org/magazine/commoner/remembering-charity-hicks).
- Anada, R. 2011. Will Allen’s growing power gets a million from slaver Wal-Mart. https://foodfreedom.wordpress.com/2011/09/18/will-allen-walmart-greenwash/. Accessed 27 Oct 2015.
- Bingen, J., C. Osborne, and E. Reardon. 2007. Organic agriculture in Michigan. Lansing, MI: Michigan State University.Google Scholar
- Bosman, J., and M. Davey. 2016. Anger in Michigan over appointing emergency managers. New York Times, 22 January. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/23/us/anger-in-michigan-over-appointing-emergency-managers.html?_r=0. Accessed 29 Oct 2017.
- Burns, G. 2014. Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan’s mind changed on Hantz Woodlands inner-city urban farm project. MLive, 10 December. http://www.mlive.com/news/detroit/index.ssf/2014/12/hantz_woodlands_changes_mayor.html. Accessed 29 Oct 2017.
- Cocciarelli, S., S. Smalley, and M. Hamm. 2011. Farm viability and development: Michigan good food work group report No. 4 of 5. http://www.michiganfood.org/uploads/files/Farm_Viability_Report.pdf. Accessed 21 Sept 2017.
- Colasanti, K., and A. Sexton. 2016. Successes in building a “good food” system in Michigan. http://foodsystems.msu.edu/news/2016-michigan-good-food-summit. Accessed 5 Jan 2017.
- Colasanti, K., P. Cantrell, S. Cocciarelli, A. Collier, T. Edison, J. Doss, V. George, M. Hamm, R. Lewis, C. Matts, B. McClendon, C. Rabaut, S. Schmidt, I. Satchell, A. Scott, and S. Smalley. 2010. Michigan good food charter. http://www.canr.msu.edu/michiganfood/uploads/files/Charter.pdf. Accessed 4 April 2015.
- CRFS (Center for Regional Food Systems). 2016. Our work. http://foodsystems.msu.edu/our-work/. Accessed 20 Jan 2017.
- DeLind, L., and S. Benitez. 1990. The reindustrialization of Michigan agriculture: An examination of state agricultural policies.. Rural Sociologist 10 (3): 29–41.Google Scholar
- Dewar, M., and J. M. Thomas. 2013. Introduction: The city after abandonment. In The city after abandonment, eds. M. Dewar, and J. M. Thomas, 1–17. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.Google Scholar
- Fair Food Network. 2014. Double up food bucks: A five-year success story. http://www.fairfoodnetwork.org/resources/double-up-food-bucks-5-year-report. Accessed 20 Mar 2015.
- Fink-Shapiro, L., L. Hoey, K. Colassanti, and S. Savas. 2015. “You can’t rush it”: Collective impact models of food systems change. http://www.canr.msu.edu/foodsystems/uploads/files/Michigan_Good_Food/Collective_Impact_Models_of_Food_System_Change.pdf. Accessed Oct 20, 2017.
- Finn, M. 2017. Discriminating taste: How class anxiety created the American food revolution. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
- Forester, J. 2013. Planning in the face of conflict: The surprising possibilities of facilitative leadership. Chicago, IL: American Planning Association.Google Scholar
- Forester, J. 2016. The challenge of transformative learning: Mining practice stories to study collaboration and dispute resolution strategies. In The challenges of collaboration in environmental governance: Barriers and responses, eds. R. Margerum, and C. Robinson, 338–354. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Friedmann, H. 1993. After Midas’s feast: Alternative food regimes for the future. In Food for the future, ed. P. Allen, 213–233. New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
- Galt, R. 2017. Alternative food movement. The International Encyclopedia of Geography. March 6: 1–7.Google Scholar
- GCRC (Groundwork Center for Resilient Communities). 2016. 10 cents a meal for school kids and farms: State pilot project overview. http://www.groundworkcenter.org/projects/ farm-to-school/10-cents-a-meal.html. Accessed 5 Dec 2017.
- Ghallager, J. 2016. Michigan still digging out of its ‘lost decade’ hole. Detroit Free Press, 3 July. https://www.freep.com/story/money/business/2016/07/03/ballard-michigan-economy-unemployment/86224610/. Accessed 21 Oct 2017.
- Glen, A. 2017. The hidden history of Ann Arbor, MI: A small town’s big impact on the sixties. http://freeingjohnsinclair.aadl.org/freeingjohnsinclair/essays/hidden_history_of_ann_arbor. Accessed 5 Dec 2017.
- Guthman, J. 2011. Weighing in: Obesity, food Justice, and the limits of capitalism. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Hague, R., M. Harrop, and S. Breslin. 1998. Comparative government and politics: An introduction. 4th ed. Basingstoke: Macmillan.Google Scholar
- Hakala, J. 2016. How did we get here? A look back at Michigan’s emergency manager law. Michigan Radio. http://michiganradio.org/post/how-did-we-get-here-look-back-michigans-emergency-manager-law. Accessed 6 Oct 2017.
- Hekman, S. 1983. Weber, the ideal type, and contemporary social theory. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
- Hill, R., W. Gonzalez, and D. Pelletier. 2011. The formulation of consensus on nutrition policy: Policy actors’ perspectives on good process. Food and Nutrition Bulletin 32 (2): S92-S104.Google Scholar
- Hoey, L., K. Colasanti, R. Pirog, and L. Fink Shapiro. 2017. Implementing collective impact for food systems change: Reflections and adaptations from Michigan. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems and Community Development 7 (2): 101–115.Google Scholar
- Holt- Giménez, E. 2012. Detroit: A tale of two… farms? Civil Eats, 16 July. http://civileats.com/2012/07/16/detroit-a-tale-of-two-farms/. Accessed 5 April 2015.
- Horst, M. 2017. Food justice and municipal government in the United States. Journal of Planning Theory and Practice 18 (1): 55–70.Google Scholar
- INCITE! Women of Color Against Violence. 2009. The revolution will not be funded: Beyond the non-profit industrial complex. Burbank, CA: Author.Google Scholar
- Innes, J., and D. Booher. 2010. Planning with complexity: An introduction to collaborative rationality for public policy. NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Jayaraman, S., and E. Schlosser. 2013. Behind the kitchen door. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
- Kania, J., and M. Kramer. 2011. Collective impact. Stanford Social Innovation Review. http://www.ssireview.org/articles/entry/collective_impact. Accessed 5 Apr 2015.
- Kellogg Foundation. 2015. Racial healing and racial equity. http://2015annualreport.wkkf.org/#Introduction. Accessed 15 Oct 2016.
- Kelly, R., and L. Gensler. 2017. Michigan local food council network awards seed grants to six Michigan councils. http://www.canr.msu.edu/news/michigan-local-food-council-network-awards-seed-grants-to-six-michigan-councils. Accessed 10 Dec 2017.
- Leach, D. 2013. Prefigurative politics. The Wiley-Blackwell encyclopedia of social and political movements, 1–2.Google Scholar
- Michigan Good Food Fund. n.d.. Frequently asked questions. http://migoodfoodfund.org/about/faq/. Accessed 10 Dec 2017.
- MIFMA (MI Farmers Market Association). 2016. Annual Report. http://mifma.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/2016-MIFMA-Annual-Report.pdf. Accessed 5 Jan 2017.
- Minnesota Food Charter. 2013. Ripe for change: How state food charters work. https://mnfoodcharter.com/developing-the-right-process-for-statewide-initiatives/. Accessed 5 Apr 2017.
- Pelletier, D., E. A. Frongillo, S. G. Gervais, L. Hoey, P. Menon, T. Ngo, R. J. Stoltzfus, A. M. Shamsir Ahmed, and T. Ahmed. 2012. Nutrition agenda Setting, policy formulation and implementation: Lessons from the Mainstreaming Nutrition Initiative. Health Policy and Planning 27: 19–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Pirog, R., A. Harper, M. Gerencer, M. Lelle, and C. Gerencer. 2014. The Michigan food hub network: A case study in building effective networks for food system change. http://www.canr.msu.edu/foodsystems/uploads/files/MI_Food_Hub_Case_Study_2014.pdf. Accessed 10 Oct 2017.
- Pirog, R., K. Koch, and A. Guel. 2015. Race, ethnicity, and the promise of “Good Food” for Michigan: A three-voice commentary. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 5 (4): 83–86.Google Scholar
- Pothukuchi, K. 2015a. Urban agriculture policy in Detroit: History and prospects. In Urban agriculture: Policy, law, strategy, and implementation, eds., H. Chumbler, S. Negro, and L. Bechler, 279–298. Chicago, IL: American Bar Association.Google Scholar
- Raja, S., D. Picard, S. Baek, and C. Delgado. 2014. Rustbelt radicalism: A decade of food systems planning in Buffalo, New York (USA). Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 4 (4): 173–189.Google Scholar
- Reynolds, K., and N. Cohen. 2016. Beyond the kale: Urban agriculture and social justice activism in New York City. Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press.Google Scholar
- Roberts, W. 2014. Food for City Building. Toronto, CA: Author.Google Scholar
- Schindler, S. 2014. Unpermitted urban agriculture: Transgressive actions, changing norms, and the local food movement. Wisconsin Law Review 2014 (2): 369–396.Google Scholar
- Strolling of the Heifers. 2017. Strolling of the Heifers 2017 Locavore Index ranks states on local food commitment. https://www.strollingoftheheifers.com/locavore/. Accessed 9 Dec 2017.
- Thompson, M., and C. Matts. 2015. Farm to school in Michigan: Statewide response shows widespread activity. http://www.canr.msu.edu/foodsystems/uploads/files/2014-survey-brief.pdf. Accessed 10 Jan 2016.
- USDA (United States Department of Agriculture). 2017. Secretary Perdue announces $16.8 million to encourage SNAP participants to purchase healthy foods. http://www.usda.gov/media/press-releases/2017/08/07/secretary-perdue-announces-168-million-encourage-snap-participants. Accessed 5 Dec 2017.
- Vandeventer, P., and M. Mandell. 2007. Networks that work. Los Angeles, CA: Community Partners.Google Scholar
- Yakini, M. 2017. Determined community—Malik Yakini Detroit BCFSN. Farm to Table Talk. https://soundcloud.com/farmtotabletalk/determined-communities. Accessed 9 Dec 2017.