Agriculture and Human Values

, Volume 33, Issue 4, pp 943–947 | Cite as

Does certified organic farming reduce greenhouse gas emissions from agricultural production? Comment on the McGee study

  • Adrian Muller
  • Eduardo Aguilera
  • Colin Skinner
  • Andreas Gattinger
Discussion Piece

Abstract

A recent study by McGee (Agriculture and Human Values, 32, 255–263, 2015) from the University of Oregon has led to discussions in international media and on the web. This study addresses an interesting question and applies advanced statistics for its analysis. However, we identify several methodological flaws that invalidate the results. First, McGee tests a hypothesis that does not correspond to his main question and which does not allow McGee to derive the conclusions that are drawn in his paper and reported in the media coverage. Second, the data used are not adequate for the analysis because: i) the dependent variable does not reflect the greenhouse gas emissions characteristics of organic agriculture (e.g. different emission factors in organic and conventional agriculture or avoidance of emissions from fertilizer production), ii) the explanatory variables neglect the livestock sector, and iii) trade aspects are missing. Third, McGee fails to discuss his findings in the light of quite a substantial body of experimental, bio-physical research from the US and elsewhere.

Keywords

Organic farming Greenhouse gas emissions Conventionalization 

References

  1. Aguilera, E., L. Lasaletta, A. Gattinger, and B. Gimeno. 2013. Managing soil carbon for climate change mitigation and adaptation in Mediterranean cropping systems: A meta-analysis. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 168(168): 25–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Aguilera, E., G. Guzmán, and A. Alonso. 2015a. Greenhouse gas emissions from conventional and organic cropping systems in Spain. I. Herbaceous crops. Agronomy for Sustainable Development 35(2): 713–724.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Aguilera, E., G. Guzmán, and A. Alonso. 2015b. Greenhouse gas emissions from conventional and organic cropping systems in Spain. II. Fruit tree orchards. Agronomy for Sustainable Development 35(2): 725–737.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Beck, N. 2008. Time-series cross-section methods. In The Oxford Handbook of Political Methodology, ed. J. Box-Steffensmeir, H. Brady, and D. Collier, 475–493. London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  5. Deaton, A., and J. Muellbauer. 1980. An almost ideal demand system. The American Economic Review 70(3): 312–326.Google Scholar
  6. Gattinger, A., A. Muller, M. Haeni, C. Skinner, A. Fließbach, N. Buchmann, P. Mäder, M. Stolze, P. Smith, N.E.-H. Scialabba, and U. Niggli. 2012. Enhanced top soil carbon stocks under organic farming. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109(44): 18226–18231.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Kesse-Guyot, E., S. Péneau, C. Méjean, F. Szabo de Edelenyi, P. Galan, S. Hercberg, and D. Lairon. 2013. Profiles of organic food consumers in a large sample of French adults: Results from the nutrinet-santé cohort study. PLoS One 8: e76998. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0076998.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Kong, A.Y., S. Fonte, C. van Kessel, and J. Six. 2007. Soil aggregates control N cycling efficiency in long-term conventional and alternative cropping systems. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 79(1): 45–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. MailOnline. 2015. Is organic farming making climate change worse? Demand for ‘sustainable’ food has increased greenhouse gas emissions, by Richard Grey, Wednesday 15 July. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3162733/Is-organic-farming-making-climate-change-worse-Demand-sustainable-food-increased-greenhouse-gas-emissions.html. Accessed 30 July 2015.
  10. Marsh, T.L. 2005. Economic substitution for US wheat food use by class. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 49(3): 283–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. McGee, J. 2015. Does certified organic farming reduce greenhouse gas emissions from agricultural production? Agriculture and Human Values 32(2): 255–263. doi:10.1007/s10460-014-9543-1.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Robertson, G.P., E.A. Paul, and R.R. Harwood. 2000. Greenhouse gases in intensive agriculture: Contributions of individual gases to the radiative forcing of the atmosphere. Science 289(5486): 1922–1925.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Skinner, C., A. Gattinger, A. Muller, P. Mäder, A. Fliessbach, R. Ruser, M. Stolze, and U. Niggli. 2014. Greenhouse gas fluxes from agricultural soils under organic and non-organic management—a global meta-analysis. Science of the Total Environment 468–469: 553–563.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Stehfest, E., L. Bouwman, D.P. van Vuuren, M.G.J. den Elzen, B. Eickhout, and P. Kabat. 2009. Climate benefits of changing diet. Climatic Change 95: 83–102. doi:10.1007/s10584-008-9534-6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Teasdale, J.R., C.B. Coffman, and R.W. Mangum. 2007. Potential long-term benefits of no-tillage and organic cropping systems for grain production and soil improvement. Agronomy Journal 99(5): 1297–1305.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. The Guardian. 2015. Organic farms don’t have the tiny carbon footprint they like to tout. But they could by Julius McGee, Tuesday 21 July. http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jul/21/organic-farms-carbon-footprint-climate-change. Accessed 30 July 2015.
  17. Tilman, D., and M. Clark. 2014. Global diets link environmental sustainability and human health. Nature 515:518–522. doi: 10.1038/nature13959 http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v515/n7528/abs/nature13959.html#supplementary-information.
  18. UoO. 2015. Study suggests organic farming needs direction to be sustainable, University of Oregon, Sunday, 12 July. https://around.uoregon.edu/content/study-suggests-organic-farming-needs-direction-be-sustainable. Accessed 30 July 2015.
  19. Venkat, K. 2012. Comparison of twelve organic and conventional farming systems: A life cycle greenhouse gas emissions perspective. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture 36: 620–649. doi:10.1080/10440046.2012.672378.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. York, R. 2012. Do alternative energy sources displace fossil fuels? Nature Climate Change 2(6): 441–443.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Zhang, W.-F., Z. Dou, P. He, X.T. Ju, D. Powlson, D. Chadwick, D. Norse, Y.-L. Lu, Y. Zhang, L. Wu, X.-P. Chen, K.G. Cassman, and F.-S. Zhang. 2013. New technologies reduce greenhouse gas emissions from nitrogenous fertilizer in China. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 110: 8375–8380. doi:10.1073/pnas.1210447110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Research Institute of Organic AgricultureFrickSwitzerland
  2. 2.Universidad Pablo de OlavideSevilleSpain
  3. 3.Research Institute of Organic AgricultureFrankfurt Am MainGermany

Personalised recommendations