Food sovereignty: the debate, the deadlock, and a suggested detour
- 1.8k Downloads
Whereas hundreds of social movements and NGOs all over the world have embraced the concept of food sovereignty, not many public authorities at the national and international level have adopted the food sovereignty paradigm as a normative basis for alternative agriculture and food policy. A common explanation of the limited role of food sovereignty in food and agriculture policy is that existing power structures are biased towards maintaining the corporatist food regime and neo-liberal thinking about food security. This article sets out to provide an alternative explanation for this limited role by critically reflecting on the debate about food sovereignty itself. The main argument is that this debate is characterized by deadlock. Two mechanisms underlying the deadlock are analyzed: confusion about the concept of sovereignty and the failure of the epistemic community to debate how to reconcile conflicting values, discourses, and institutions regarding food. To overcome this deadlock and organize meaningful debate with public authorities, it is proposed that the food sovereignty movement uses insights from legal pluralism and debates on governance and adopts the ending of “food violence” as a new objective and common frame.
KeywordsFood sovereignty Sovereignty Food values Food violence Food governance Reconciling conflicting values on food
The author is grateful for the inspiring debates on food law, food values and food sovereignty with Professor Francois Collart Dutilleul, head of the LASCAUX programme at Nantes University. The author also wishes to thank the LASCAUX programme and Nantes University for funding and facilitating his stay as a visiting professor at Nantes University in March and June 2011. The author is also grateful for advice of Joy Burrough on the English.
- Beauregard, S. 2009. Food policy for people: incorporating food sovereignty principles into state governance. Case studies of Venezuela, Mali, Ecuador, and Bolivia. http://www.ieham.org/html/docs/Incorporating%20food%20sovereignty%20principles%20into%20State%20governance.pdf. Accessed August 2012.
- Bolwig, S., Ponte, S., du Toit, A., Riisgaard, L., and Halberg, N. 2008. Integrating poverty, gender, and environmental concerns into value chain analysis: a conceptual framework and lessons for action research. DIIS Working Papers 16. Copenhagen: Danish Institute for International Studies.Google Scholar
- Charlier, S., and Warnotte G., eds. 2007. La souveraineté alimentaire: Regards croisés. UCL Presses Universitaires de Louvain.Google Scholar
- Comaroff, J., and J. Comaroff. 2009. Reflections on the anthropology of law, governance, and sovereignty. In Rules of law and laws of ruling: on the governance of law, ed. F. von Benda-Beckmann, K. von Benda-Beckmann, and J. Eckert, 31–59. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing.Google Scholar
- Dobusch, L., and Quack, S. 2008. Epistemic communities and social movements: transnational dynamics in the case of creative commons. Discussion Paper 08/8. Max Planck institute for the study of societies.Google Scholar
- Duncan, J., and D. Barling. 2012. Renewal through participation in global food security governance: implementing the international food security and nutrition civil society mechanism to the committee on world food security. International Journal of the Sociology of Agriculture and Food 19: 143–161.Google Scholar
- Eakin, H., H.-G. Bohle, A.-M. Izac, A. Reenberg, P. Gregory, and L. Pereira. 2010. Food, violence, and human rights. In Food security and global environmental change, ed. J. Ingram, P. Ericksen, and D. Liverman, 245–271. London: Earthscan.Google Scholar
- Fairbairn, M. 2010. Framing resistance: International food regimes and the roots of food sovereignty. In Food sovereignty: Reconnecting food, nature, and community, ed. H. Wittman, A. Desmarais, and N. Wiebe, 15–32. Oxford: Pambazuka Press.Google Scholar
- FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization). 2007. FAO: The challenge of renewal. Report of the independent external evaluation of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). ftp://fao.org/docrep/fao/meeting/012/k0827erev1.pdf. Accessed August 2012.
- FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization). 2009. Committee on Food Security (CFS). Reform of the committee on world food security. Final version. ftp://fao.org/docrep/fao/meeting/017/k3023e3.pdf. Accessed August 2012.
- FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization). 2008. Committee on Food Security (CFS). Participation of civil society/non-governmental organizations (CSOs/NGOs). Rome 14–17 October 2008. ftp://fao.org/docrep/fao/meeting/014/k3028e.pdf. Accessed August 2012.
- Fowler, M., and J. Bunck. 1995. Law, power, and the sovereign state: the evolution and application of the concept of sovereignty. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press.Google Scholar
- Hospes, O., and J. Clancy. 2011. Unpacking the discourse on social inclusion. In Value chains, inclusion, and endogenous development: Contrasting theories and realities, ed. B. Helmsing, and S. Vellema, 17–31. London: Routledge Press.Google Scholar
- ICPS (International Centre for Participation Studies). 2010. The reformed committee on world food security: A briefing paper for civil society. Department of peace studies, University of Bradford, United Kingdom. http://www.foodsovereignty.org/Portals/0/documenti%20sito/Home/News/reformed%20CFS_english.pdf. Accessed August 2012.
- IPC (International NGO/CSO Planning Committee for Food Sovereignty). 2006. Agrarian reform in the context of food sovereignty, the right to food, and cultural diversity. Via Campesina Issue Paper no. 5.Google Scholar
- IPC (International NGO/CSO Planning Committee for Food Sovereignty). 2009a. What is the IPC? http://www.foodsovereignty.org/Aboutus/WhatisIPC.aspx. Accessed August 2012.
- IPC (International NGO/CSO Planning Committee for Food Sovereignty). 2009b. IPC comments on draft proposal for CFS reform. http://www.mstbrazil.org/http%3A/%252Fwww.icarrd.org/en/icard_doc_down/Issue_Paper5sum.pdf. Accessed August 2012.
- Jackson, J. 2003. Sovereignty - Modern: A new approach to an outdated concept. Georgetown Law Faculty Publications and Other Works. Paper 110. http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/facpub/110. Accessed August 2012.
- Kooiman, J. 2003. Governing as governance. London: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
- Nuijten, M. 2004. Governance in action: Some theoretical and practical reflections on a key concept. In Globalization and development: Themes and concepts in current research, ed. D. Kalb, W. Pantsers, and H. Siebers, 103–130. Dordrecht, Boston, London: Kluwer Academic Publishers.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Patel, Ray. 2010. What does food sovereignty look like? In Food sovereignty: Reconnecting food, nature, and community, ed. H. Wittman, A.A. Desmarais, and N. Wiebe, 186–196. Oxford: Pambazuka Press.Google Scholar
- Pimbert, M. 2008. Towards food sovereignty: Reclaiming autonomous food systems. London: IIED.Google Scholar
- Rhodes, R. 1996. The new governance: governing without government. Political Studies XLIV: 652–667.Google Scholar
- Robinson, P. 2008. Fair trade, food sovereignty, and the food crisis. http://smallfarmersbigchange.coop/2008/12/31/fair-trade-food-sovereignty-and-the-food-crisis/. Accessed August 2012.
- Rosset, P. 2003. Food sovereignty: Global rallying cry of farmer movements. Food first: Institute for food and development policy. Backgrounder 9(4): 1–4. http://www.foodfirst.org/en/node/47. Accessed August 2012.
- Rosset, P. 2006. Food is different: Why we must get the WTO out of agriculture. London: Zed Books.Google Scholar
- Schanbacher, W. 2010. The politics of food: The global conflict between food security and food sovereignty. Oxford: Praeger.Google Scholar
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2010. Sovereignty. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/sovereignty/. Accessed August 2012.
- Via Campesina. 1996. Food sovereignty: a future without hunger. Statement by the NGO Forum to the World food summit, NGO Forum to the world food summit. http://www.voiceoftheturtle.org/library/1996 Declaration of Food Sovereignty.pdf. Accessed August 2012.
- Via Campesina. 2007. Declaration of Nyéléni. http://viacampesina.org/en/index.php/main-issues-mainmenu-27/food-sovereignty-and-trade-mainmenu-38/262-declaration-of-nyi. Accessed August 2012.
- Via Campesina. 2009. La Via Campesina policy documents. http://viacampesina.org/downloads/pdf/policydocuments/POLICYDOCUMENTS-EN-FINAL.pdf. Accessed August 2012.
- Via Campesina. 2011. World food sovereignty day: big business has failed—we small farmers can feed the world. http://viacampesina.org/en/index.php/main-issues-mainmenu-27/food-sovereignty-and-trade-mainmenu-38/1100-world-food-sovereignty-day-big-business-has-failed-we-small-farmers-can-feed-the-world. Accessed August 2012.
- Windfuhr, M., and J. Jonsén. 2005. Food sovereignty: Towards democracy in localized food systems. FIAN-International: ITDG Publishing.Google Scholar
- Wittman, H., A. Desmarais, and N. Wiebe (eds.). 2010. Food sovereignty: Reconnecting food, nature, and community. Oxford: Pambazuka Press.Google Scholar
- World Trade Organization. 2012. UN rapporteur and WTO head debate the impact of trade on hunger. http://www.wto.org/english/forums_e/debates_e/debate14_summary_e.htm. Accessed August 2012.