Framing and reframing the environmental risks and economic benefits of ethanol production in Iowa
- 1.1k Downloads
Recent research exposing environmental and social externalities of biofuels has undermined the earlier national consensus that they would provide climate mitigation and rural development benefits, but support for ethanol remains strong in Iowa. The objective of this paper is to understand how stakeholder groups in Iowa have framed the benefits and risks associated with ethanol’s impact on the local economy and environment. Our case study draws on in-depth, semi-structured interviews conducted with key informants from agricultural organizations, environmental organizations, and government departments in the state. We find that in Iowa, widespread support for ethanol production exists among government, energy, and farm groups, and that they frame ethanol production as economically beneficial to rural communities and agriculture, while minimizing the possibility of associated environmental risks. Although participants from environmental organizations in Iowa express apprehension about the environmental impacts of expanded corn ethanol production, their unease is muted in relation to economic benefits and in relation to other environmental issues, and few have publicly voiced their concerns. To understand these findings, we draw from the environmental sociology literature that examines the role of powerful natural resource interests in framing the importance of resource extraction and commodity production to community identity and economy and in delegitimizing and naturalizing associated environmental issues and problems. We argue that powerful natural resource interests in Iowa both naturalize environmental problems related to ethanol production and engage in diversionary reframing to emphasize the economic benefits while minimizing or rejecting the potential environmental risks.
KeywordsAgriculture and environment Biofuels Climate change Environmental risk Natural resource interests Water quality
This research was supported by the United States Department of Energy (DOE) under Grant No. DE-FG02-07ER64476. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the DOE. The authors would like to thank the editor and the anonymous reviewers for their valuable comments on earlier versions of this article. We would also like to thank Albert Jaray, Brandi Geisinger, and Michael Burdick for their research assistance. Finally, we would like to acknowledge our collaborators on this project: Richard Goe, Laszlo Kulcsar, and Gerad Middendorf.
- Babcock, B., and J. Fabiosa. 2011. The impact of ethanol and ethanol subsidies on corn prices: Revisiting history. CARD Policy Brief 11-PB 5 (April). Ames, IA: Iowa State University.Google Scholar
- Beeman, P. 2007. Industry affects every facet of Iowa’s environment. Des Moines Register. 3 June: ET.3.Google Scholar
- Carr, P., and M. Kefalas. 2009. Hollowing out the middle. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
- Catton, W., and R. Dunlap. 1978. Environmental sociology: A new paradigm. The American Sociologist 13: 41–49.Google Scholar
- Cox, C., A. Hug, and N. Bruzelius. 2011. Losing ground. Environmental Working Group. http://static.ewg.org/reports/2010/losingground/pdf/losingground_report.pdf. Accessed 30 Sep 2012.
- Creswell, J. 2007. Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
- Duffy, M. 2012. 2011 Farmland value survey. Ames, IA: Iowa State University.Google Scholar
- Dunlap, R.E. 2002. Paradigms, theories, and environmental sociology. In Sociological theory and the environment: Classical foundations, contemporary insights, ed. R. Dunlap, F.H. Buttel, P. Dickens, and A. Gijswijt, 329–350. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.Google Scholar
- EWG (Environmental Working Group). 2012. EWG’s guide to understanding ethanol. http://www.ewg.org/report/ethanol/facts. Accessed 11 Mar 2012.
- FAO. 2006. Introducing the international bioenergy platform. Rome: FAO. ftp://ftp.fao.org/docrep/fao/009/a0469e/a0469e00.pdf. Accessed 9 Aug 2011.
- Freudenburg, W., and R. Gramling. 1994. Mid-range theory and cutting edge sociology: A call for cumulation. Environment, Technology, and Society 76(1): 3–6.Google Scholar
- Hannigan, M. 1995. Environmental sociology: A social constructionist perspective. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Hart, C., S. Ellis, D. Swenson, L. Eathington, and K. Schulte. 2012. Iowa farm outlook. Econ. Info. 2021. Ames, IA: Department of Economics, Iowa State University.Google Scholar
- Heffernan, A., T. Galluzzo, and W. Hoyer. 2010. Solution to pollution: It starts on the farm. The Iowa Policy Project. Iowa City, IA: The Iowa Policy Project.Google Scholar
- ICGA (Iowa Corn Growers Association). 2012. Ethanol Campaign. http://www.iowacorn.org/index.cfm?nodeID=30471&audienceID=1. Accessed 11 Mar 2012.
- IDED (Iowa Department of Economic Development). 2008. Governor Culver signed bill to expand fuels infrastructure and access. Iowa Department of Economic Development. March 12. http://www.iowalifechanging.com/documents/documents.aspx?id=7. Accessed 14 Mar 2011.
- IDNR (Iowa Department of Natural Resources). 2008. Biofuels: From corn to cellulose consider the policy issues. Iowa Department of Natural Resources 1–12.Google Scholar
- IDNR (Iowa Department of Natural Resources). 2010. State of the environment. Iowa Department of Natural Resources. http://www.iowadnr.gov/status.html. Accessed 12 Feb 2011.
- IEC (Iowa Environmental Council). 2006. Biofuels in Iowa. Policy Advisory Statement Iowa Environmental Council 1–9.Google Scholar
- IRFA (Iowa Renewable Fuels Association). 2011. Renewable fuels caucus voter guide released. http://www.iowarfa.org/RenewableFuelsCaucusVoterGuideReleased.php. Accessed 13 Mar 2012.
- Love, O. 2010. Iowa pheasant harvest at all-time low. The Gazette. http://thegazette.com/2010/06/09/iowa-pheasant-harvest-at-all-time-low/. Accessed 9 Jun 2010.
- Miao, R. 2011. The Land-use change effect of ethanol plants in Iowa: 1997–2009. Working paper. Ames, Iowa: Iowa State University.Google Scholar
- NCGA (National Corn Growers Association). 2012. Corn production trends. http://www.ncga.com/production/1-corn-production-trends/. Accessed 14 Mar 2012.
- OEI (Office of Energy Independence). 2010a. Energy independence plan. Iowa office of energy Independence.Google Scholar
- OEI (Office of Energy Independence). 2010b. Energy information report. Iowa office of energy independence. http://www.energy.iowa.gov/files/2010EnergyInformationReport.pdf. Accessed 7 Nov 2010.
- Oxfam. 2008. Another inconvenient truth: How biofuels policies are deepening poverty accelerating climate change. Oxford: Oxfam.Google Scholar
- Piller, D. 2012. Country strong. Des Moines Sunday Register. 26 February: D1; D4.Google Scholar
- Rood, L. 2012. Half of incentives went to biofuels firms. Des Moines Sunday Register 15 January: 6A.Google Scholar
- Scott, R. 2010. Removing mountains: Extracting nature and identity in the Appalachian coalfields. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
- Secchi, S., L. Kurkalova, P. Gassman, and C. Hart. 2011a. Land use change in a biofuels hotspot: The case of Iowa, USA. Biomass and Bioenergy 2391–2400.Google Scholar
- Sierra Club and Worldwatch Institute. 2007. Destination Iowa: Getting to a sustainable biofuels future. Washington DC: Sierra Club.Google Scholar
- Sierra Club and Worldwatch Institute. 2009. Smart choices for biofuels. Washington DC: Sierra Club.Google Scholar
- Sierra Club. 2006. Sierra Club (Iowa Chapter) letter to Hon. Frank Cownie, Mayor of Des Moines. 6 November. http://iowa.sierraclub.org/DM%20Ethanol%20plant%20letter.pdf. Accessed 14 Mar 2011.
- Sulzberger, A.G. 2011. As crop prices soar, Iowa farms add acreage. New York Times 30 December.Google Scholar
- Tibbetts, Ed. 2009. Iowa farms losing the middle ground. The Quad-City Times 5 Feb. http://qctimes.com/business/article_2bc46805-c87d-5846-a472-b9e3988a2975.html. Accessed 5 Mar 2012.
- USDA/ERS. 2012. State fact sheets: Iowa. Washington, DC: Economic Research Service, USDA.Google Scholar
- USDA/FSA. 2012. Conservation reserve program: Monthly summary–January 2012. Washington, DC: USDA/FSA.Google Scholar
- USDA/NASS. 2000–2011. Acreage. http://usda.mannlib.cornell.edu/MannUsda/viewDocumentInfo.do?documentID=1000. Accessed 14 Mar 2012.
- Vilsack, T. 2011. Speech to the Growth Energy Legislative Conference. Hyatt Regency Washington, Capitol Hill. 20 September. http://www.growthenergy.org/news-media-center/broadcast-media/usda-secretary-tom-vilsack-at-growth-energy-conference/.
- Washington Post. 2012. People in the news: Chet Culver (D) http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/chet-culver-d/gIQAUqKHAP_topic.html.npn. Accessed 24 Feb 2012.
- Worldwatch Institute. 2006. Biofuels for transportation: Global potential and implications for sustainable agriculture and energy in the 21st century. [CB1] http://www.worldwatch.org/system/files/EBF038.pdf. Accessed 10 Mar 2012.