Excluding to include: (Non)participation in Mexican natural resource management
Participatory processes are often intended to encourage inclusion of multiple perspectives in defining management means and goals. However, ideas about the legitimacy of certain uses and users of the resources can often lead to exclusion from participation. In this way, participation can be transformed from a process of inclusion of various resource users to one of exclusion. Using a case study from a marine protected area in Loreto, Baja California Sur, Mexico, and drawing on work in deliberative democracy, I present a typology of how individuals and groups can be excluded from participation. External exclusion includes non-invitation and other means for keeping participation from occurring. Internal exclusion refers to exclusionary events during participatory meetings. This analysis suggests that participation needs to be recognized as a valuable but easily manipulated tool in the design of projects like natural resource management.
KeywordsParticipation Exclusion Natural resource management Marine protected areas Mexico
I wish to thank the fishermen, park officials, and others in Loreto who are as much responsible for this research as I am, though not for its faults. In addition, I would like to acknowledge the support and comments of my fellow panelists at the American Anthropological Association Meetings in 2007, including Carla Roncoli, Renzo Taddei, Scott Lacy, and Kent Glenzer, as well as comments by two anonymous reviewers. Funding for field research in Mexico was generously provided by the University of California Institute for Mexico and the United States (UC MEXUS) and the UC San Diego Anthropology Department. Additional support was provided by the Center for US-Mexican Studies (CUSMEX), the Center for Iberian and Latin American Studies at UC San Diego, and the Center for Research on Environmental Decisions at Columbia University.
- Baiocchi, Gianpaolo. 2003. Participation, activism, and politics: The Porto Alegre experiment. In Deepening democracy: Institutional innovations in empowered participatory governance, ed. Archon Fung, and Erik Olin Wright. New York: Verso Press.Google Scholar
- Crosby, Harry. 1984. Antigua California: Mission and colony on the peninsular frontier, 1697–1768. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.Google Scholar
- Geoghegan, Tighe, and Yves Renard. 2002. Beyond community involvement: Lessons from the insular Caribbean. Parks 12: 16–27.Google Scholar
- Gundersen, Adolf G. 2000. The Socratic citizen: A theory of deliberative democracy. Lanham: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
- Hanna, Susan. 2003. Transition in the American fishing commons: Management problems and institutional design challenges. In The commons in the new millenium: Challenges, adaptations, ed. N. Dolsak, and E. Ostrom. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Jentoft, Svein. 2007. In the power of power: The understated aspect of fisheries and coastal management. Human Organization 66: 426–437.Google Scholar
- Kessler, Brianne L. 2004. Stakeholder participation: A synthesis of current literature. Santa Cruz, California: National Marine Protected Areas Center. http://mpa.gov/pdf/publications/Stakeholder_Synthesis.pdf.
- O’Neil, Ann, and Don O’Neil. 2001. Loreto, Baja California, first mission and capital of Spanish California. Studio City: Tio Press.Google Scholar
- Peterson, Nicole D. 2005. Casting a wide net: Decision-making in a Mexican marine park. Ph.D. dissertation. La Jolla: University of California, San Diego.Google Scholar
- Pomeroy, Robert S., John Parks, Richard Pollnac, Tammy Campson, Emmanuel Genio, Cliff Marlessy, Elizabeth Holle, Michael Pido, Ayut Nissapa, Somsak Boromthanarat, and Nguyen Thu Hue. 2007. Fish wars: Conflict and collaboration in fisheries management in Southeast Asia. Marine Policy 31: 645–656.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Walley, Christine. 2004. Rough waters: Nature and development in an East African marine park. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- World Bank. 2008. The World Bank participation sourcebook. http://www.worldbank.org/wbi/sourcebook/sbhome.htm. Accessed 19 April 2008.