The more it changes; the more it remains the same: a foucauldian analysis of Canadian policy documents relevant to student selection for medical school
Calls to increase the demographic representativeness of medical classes to better reflect the diversity of society are part of a growing international trend. Despite this, entry into medical school remains highly competitive and exclusive of marginalized groups. To address these questions, we conducted a Foucauldian discourse analysis of 15 publically available policy documents from the websites of Canadian medical education regulatory bodies, using the concepts of “excellence” (institutional or in an applicant), “diversity,” and “equity” to frame the analysis. In most documents, there were appeals to broaden definitions of institutional excellence to include concerns for greater social accountability. Equity concerns tended to be represented as needing to be dealt with by people in positions of authority in order to counter a “hidden curriculum.” Diversity was represented as an object of value, situated within a discontinuous history. As a rhetorical strategy, documents invoked complex societal shifts to promote change toward a more humanistic medical education system and profession. “Social accountability” was reified as an all-encompassing solution to most issues of representation. Although the policy documents proclaimed rootedness in an ethos of improving the societal responsiveness of the medical profession, our analysis takes a more critical stance towards the discourses identified. On the basis of our research findings, we question whether these calls may contribute to the maintenance of the specific power relations they seek to address. These conclusions lead us to consider the possibility that the discourses represented in the documents might be reframed to take into account issues of power distribution and its productive and reproductive features. A reframing of discourses could potentially generate greater inclusiveness in policy development processes, and afford disadvantaged and marginalized groups more participatory roles in the discussion.
KeywordsDiscourse Social accountability Diversity Equity Medical student selection
- Addams, A. N., Beer-Bletzinger, R., Sondheimer, H. R., White, S. E., & Johnson, L. M. (2010). Roadmap to diversity: Integrating holistic review practices into medical school admission processes. Washington: Association of American Medical Colleges.Google Scholar
- Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada. (2001). Social accountability: A vision for Canadian Medical Schools [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.afmc.ca/pdf/pdf_sa_vision_canadian_medical_schools_en.pdf.
- Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada. (2003). Social accountability: Moving beyond the rhetoric—Proceedings. Plenary session of the Annual Meeting held in Quebec, April 28, 2003[PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.afmc.ca/pdf/Apr28_Social%20Accountability.pdf.
- Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada. (2006). Enhancing the health of the population: The role of Canadian faculties of medicine [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.afmc.ca/pdf/2006_april_afmc_public_health_vison_paper.pdf.
- Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada. (2010). The future of medical education in Canada [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012 from http://www.afmc.ca/future-of-medical-education-in-canada/medical-doctor-project/index.php.
- Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada. (2011). Equity and diversity audit tool for Canadian medical schools [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012 from http://www.afmc.ca/pdf/committees/AFMC_Equity_and_Diversity_Audit_Tool_10MAY2011.pdf.
- Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada. Indigenous Physicians Association of Canada (2007). Best practices to recruit mature aboriginal students to medicine [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012 from http://www.afmc.ca/pdf/IPAC-AFMC_Recruitment_of_Mature_Aboriginal_Students_Eng.pdf.
- College of Family Physicians of Canada. (2004). Admission of rural origin students to medical school: Recommended strategies [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.cfpc.ca/uploadedFiles/Resources/Resource_Items/Health_Professionals/AdmissionRuralOrigin.pdf.
- College of Family Physicians of Canada. (2007). Rethinking undergraduate medical education—a view from family medicine [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.cfpc.ca/projectassets/templates/resource.aspx?id=1124&langType=4105.
- College of Family Physicians of Canada. (2009). CanMEDS-FMU: Undergraduate competencies from a family medicine perspective [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.cfpc.ca/uploadedfiles/education/canmeds-fmu_Feb2010_final_formatted.pdf.
- Foucault, M. (1971). L'Ordre du Discours: leçon inaugurale au Collège de France présentée le 2 décembre 1970. Paris:Gallimard.Google Scholar
- Foucault, M. (1972). The archaeology of knowledge. New York: Pantheon Books.Google Scholar
- Foucault, M. (1977). Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison. New York: Pantheon Books.Google Scholar
- General Medical Council. (2009). Tomorrow’s doctors education: Outcomes and standards for undergraduate medical education. London: General Medical Council.Google Scholar
- Hodder, I. (1994). The Interpretation of Documents and Material Culture. In N. K. Denzin & Y.S. Lincoln (Eds.), The Handbook of qualitative research (pp. 393–402). Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
- Hodges, B.D., Kuper, A., & Reeves, S. (2008). Discourse analysis. British Medical Journal, 337, a879.Google Scholar
- McHoul, A., & Grace, W. (1993). A foucault primer: Discourse, power and the subject. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
- Medical Council of Canada. (2012). Registration to practice medicine in Canada. Link updated in 2012 [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.mcc.ca/pdf/Registration_Chart_en.pdf.
- Mills, S. (1997). Discourses. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Nietzsche, F.W. (1994). On the genealogy of morality. New York: Cambridge University Press. Google Scholar
- Pennycook, A. (2001). Critical applied linguistics: A critical introduction. Mahwah: Laurence Erlbaum.Google Scholar
- Physician Human Resource Strategy for Canada Task Force Two. (2006). A physician human resource strategy for Canada: Final Report [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.cha.ca/documents/pa/TF2FinalStrategicReport-e.pdf.
- Revel, J. 2004. « Michel Foucault : discontinuité de la pensée ou pensée du discontinu? », Le Portique, 13-14 [HTML]. Retrieved Febrary 15, 2012 from http://leportique.revues.org/index635.html.
- Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. (2006). RCPSC statement on appropriate physician resource for Canada: Toward achieving responsible self-sufficiency [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.royalcollege.ca/shared/documents/advocacy/workforce_self_sufficiency_e.pdf.
- Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. (2009a). Health human resources: An essential part of a sustainable, accessible and responsive health care system [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012 from http://rcpsc.medical.org/publicpolicy/brief_hoc_april09_e.pdf.
- Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. (2009b). One step forward—two steps back? A discussion paper on physician mobility in Canada. Office of Health Policy and Governance Support [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012, from http://www.royalcollege.ca/shared/documents/advocacy/physician_mobility_e.pdf.
- Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. (2011). Addressing societal health needs [PDF]. Retrieved 15 Feb 2012 from http://www.royalcollege.ca/shared/documents/fmec/societal_health_needs.pdf.
- Starr, P. (1982). The social transformation of American medicine. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
- Strong-Boag V. (1981). Canada’s women doctors: Feminism constrained. In S. Sed (Ed.) Medicine in Canadian Society: Historical Perspectives. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.Google Scholar
- Visker, R. (1995). Michel Foucault: Genealoty as Critique. New York: Version.Google Scholar
- Whitehead, C.R., Hodges, B.D., & Austin, Z. (2012). Captive on a carousel: Discourses of 'New' in medical education 1910–1920. Advance in Health Science Education, 17(4). doi:10.1007/s10459-012-9414-8.
- World Health Organization. (1995). Defining and measuring the social accountability of medical schools. Geneva: World Health Organization.Google Scholar
- Young, M.E., Razack, S., Hanson, M.D., Slade, S., Varpio, L., Dore, K.L., & McKight, D. (2012). Calling for a broader conceptualization of diversity: Surface and deep diversity in four Canadian medical schools. Academic Medicine 87(11), 1501–1510.Google Scholar