Can Self-declared Personal Values be Used to Identify those with Family Medicine Career Aspirations?
- First Online:
- 115 Downloads
Self-declaration of personal values has been suggested as a means of identifying students with greater predilection for future primary care careers. While statistically significant differences have been demonstrated, absolute differences between those interested in primary care and those interested in specialist careers tend to be small. This study’s objective was to determine whether limited differences can nevertheless be used to identify those with particular interest in primary care.
Schwartz’ values were submitted to a paired comparison design in which respondents were asked to identify the value they held most dearly for possible pairings of values. 88 medical school applicants, 57 first year medical students, 78 final year medical students, and 34 admissions interviewers participated. Applicant and medical student subgroups were analyzed as a whole and as a function of self-identified career interest (i.e., primarily interested in Family medicine or other specialty careers).
The values statements were remarkably consistent (r > 0.90) between groups, regardless of which subgroups were analyzed.
Despite apparent differences in the literature between those interested in primary care and those interested in other specialist careers, the differences are small and do not correlate with career aspirations in a way that could inform admissions decisions.
Keywordsfamily medicine personality recruitment specialty choice
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Bland C.J., Meurer L.N., Maldonado G., 1995 Determinants of primary care specialty choice: a non-statistical meta-analysis of the literature Academic Medicine 70: 620–641Google Scholar
- Council of Ontario Universities, Family Medicine Meeting: Retreat to discuss family medicine in the undergraduate curriculum. October 8, 2003Google Scholar
- David H.A., 1988 The method of paired comparisons 2nd edn. Griffin LondonGoogle Scholar
- Reiter, H.I., Eva, K.W., Rosenfeld, J. & Norman, G.R. Multiple mini-interview predicts clerkship and licensing exam performance. Submitted manuscriptGoogle Scholar
- Ross L., Nisbett R.E., 1991 The person and the situation: perspectives of social psychology McGraw-Hill New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Schubot D.B., Cayley W., Elliason B.C., 1996 Personal values related to primary care specialty aspirations Family Medicine 28: 726–731Google Scholar
- Scott, I., Wright, B., Brenneis, F. (2004). Career choice of new medical students at three Canadian universities: family medicine versus specialty medicine. Canadian Medical Association Journal 170(13): 1920–1924Google Scholar
- Streiner D.L., Norman G.R., 2003 Health measurement scales: a practical guide to their development and use 3rd edn. Oxford University Press New YorkGoogle Scholar
- The College of Family Physicians of Canada. New poll: Canadians say family doctors most important to their health care and want them by their side in hospital. http://www.cfpc.ca/English/cfpc/communications/news%20releases/2003%2010%2023/default.asp?s=1 (23 October 2003; retrieved 27 June 2005)Google Scholar