Advances in Health Sciences Education

, Volume 12, Issue 1, pp 71–86 | Cite as

Medical Students’ Attitudes Toward Underserved Patients: A Longitudinal Comparison of Problem-Based and Traditional Medical Curricula

  • Sonia J. S. Crandall
  • Beth A. Reboussin
  • Robert Michielutte
  • Jennie E. Anthony
  • Michelle J. Naughton


Medical education has been shown to negatively influence student attitudes toward certain types of patient populations. Past research does not inform current educational practice because today’s medical school environment is different from when most of the published research was conducted. There are more female students, curricular innovations such as problem-based learning have changed the framework for educational delivery, and longitudinal studies, which could inform when interventions may be needed, are uncommon. The purposes of this longitudinal, prospective cohort study were to compare the attitudes of Problem-based learning and Traditional curriculum students toward providing care for medically indigent patients as they progressed through the four-year undergraduate medical education curriculum, and to determine if gender differences were apparent and persisted over time. Attitudes of one cohort of students enrolled in separate curricula were studied. The outcome measure was the Medical Student Attitudes Toward the Underserved questionnaire, which was administered three times. A linear mixed effects regression analysis was performed to examine changes in factor scores over time and whether these changes differed between Problem-based and Traditional students, and males and females. Longitudinal findings revealed that commitment to caring for the medically underserved was greater when students entered medical school than when they graduated. Students in both curricula, as well as male and female students, experienced increasingly negative attitudes over the four year period. Decline in attitudes toward medically underserved patients was similar to previous research results. This study showed that attitudes of students were not influenced by the preclinical curriculum they experienced.

Key words

caring for underserved patients gender and attitudes medical education medical student attitudes physician social responsibility problem-based learning 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Albanese M.A. (1993). Problem-based learning: A review of literature on its outcomes and implementation issues. Academic Medicine 68(1): 52–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Ayanian J.Z. (1994). Race, class and the quality of medical care. Journal of the American Medical Association 271: 1207–1208CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bickel J. and Ruffin A (1995). Gender-associated differences in matriculating and graduating medical students. Academic Medicine 70(6): 552–559CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Cariaga-Lo, L.D., Crandall, S.J.S., Conner, D., Georgesen, J. & Greek, D. (1997). Developing attitudes of social responsibility in the professions: The impact of medical students’ gender and personality attributes. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago ILGoogle Scholar
  5. Christakis D.A. and Feudtner C (1993). Ethics in a short white coat: The ethical dilemmas that medical students confront. Academic Medicine 68: 249–254CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Crandall S.J., Volk R.J. and Loemker V (1993). Medical students’ attitudes toward providing care for the underserved. Are we training socially responsible physicians?. Journal of the American Medical Association 269(19): 2519–2523CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Crandall S.J.S., Volk R.J. and Cacy D.S (1997). A longitudinal investigation of medical student attitudes toward the medically indigent. Teaching and Learning in Medicine 9(4): 254–260CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Cronbach L.J. (1951). Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests. Psychometrika 16: 297–334CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Davies D.P. and Shortland G (1993). Are medical students missing out?. Medical Teacher 15(1): 93–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Des Marchais J.E. (1993). A student-centered, problem-based curriculum: 5 years’ experience. Canadian Medical Association Journal 148: 1567–1572Google Scholar
  11. Eron L.D. (1958). The effect of medical education on attitudes: A follow-up study. Journal of Medical Education 33: 25–33Google Scholar
  12. Feudtner C. and Christakis D.A (1994). Making the rounds. The ethical development of medical students in the context of clinical rotations. Hastings Center Report : 6–12Google Scholar
  13. Feudtner C., Christakis D.A. and Christakis N.A (1994). Do clinical clerks suffer ethical erosion? students’ perceptions of their ethical environment and personal development. Academic Medicine 69: 670–679CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Finucane P., Allery L.A. and Hayes T.M (1995). Comparison of teachers at a “traditional” and an “innovative” medical school. Medical Education 29: 104–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Finucane P.M., Johnson S.M. and Prideaux D.J (1998). Problem-based learning: Its rationale and efficacy. Medical Journal of Australia 168: 445–448Google Scholar
  16. Gordon L.V. and Mensh I.N (1962). Values of medical school students at different levels of training. Journal of Educational Psychology 53(1): 48–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Gray R.M., Moody P.M. and Newman W.R.E (1965). An analysis of physicians’ attitudes of cynicism and humanitarianism before and after entering medical practice. Journal of Medical Education 40: 760–766Google Scholar
  18. Guthrie E.A., Black D., Shaw C.M., Hamilton J., Creed F.H. and Tomenson B (1995). Embarking upon a medical career: Psychological morbidity in first year medical students. Medical Education 29: 337–341CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Haidet P., Dains J.E., Paterniti D.A., Hechtel L., Chang T. and Tseng E. (2002). Medical student attitudes toward the doctor-patient relationship. Medical Education 36(6): 568–574CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Iglehart J. (1997). Forum on the future of academic medicine: Session I–setting the stage. Academic Medicine 72(7): 595–599CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Johnson S.M. and Finucane P.M (2000). The emergence of problem-based learning in medical education. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 6(3): 281–291CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Kalishman, S., Mines, J., Skipper, B., Serna, L. & Skipper, E. (2002). A study of the relationship of a medical school curriculum to the attitudes of students toward service in medicine. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LAGoogle Scholar
  23. Kane R.L. and Olsen D.M (1975). Attitude changes among medex and medical students. Journal of Medical Education 50(9): 895–897Google Scholar
  24. Kaufman D.M. and Mann K.V (1996). Comparing students’ attitudes in problem-based and conventional curricula. Academic Medicine 71(10): 1096–1099CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Kleinbaum D.G., Kupper L.L., Muller K.E. and Nizam A (1998). Applied Regression Analysis and Other Multivariate Methods. Duxbury Press, Pacific Grove, CAGoogle Scholar
  26. Kopelman L. (1983). Cynicism among medical students. Journal of the American Medical Association 250(15): 2006–2010CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Lumpkin J.R. (1985). Validity of a brief locus of control scale for survey research. Psychological Reports 57: 655–659Google Scholar
  28. Lyons N. (1987). Ways of knowing, learning and making moral choices. Journal of Moral Education 16(3): 226–239CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Merrill J.M., Camacho Z., Laux L.F., Lorimor R., Thornby J.I. and Vallbona C (1994). Uncertainties and ambiguities: Measuring how medical students cope. Medical Education 28: 316–322CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Merrill J.M., Camacho Z., Laux L.F., Thornby J.I. and Vallbona C (1991). Influences on professional qualities. How medical school shapes students’ orientation to patients’ psychological problems. Academic Medicine 66(9): S4–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Merrill J.M., Laux L.F., Lorimor R., Thornby J.I. and Vallbona C (1995). Authoritarianism’s role in medicine. American Journal of the Medical Sciences 310(3): 87–90Google Scholar
  32. Merrill J.M., Laux L.F., Lorimor R., Thornby J.I. and Vallbona C (1996). Personal and professional qualities of medical students. Using attribution theory models to predict senior medical students’ perceptions of patients and career choice. Academic Medicine 71(11): S67–69Google Scholar
  33. Miller L.B. and Erwin E.F (1961). Attitude changes in medical students during a comprehensive care program. Journal of Medical Education 36: 442–428Google Scholar
  34. Mills R. J., & Bhandari S. (2003). Health insurance coverage in the united states: 2002. Retrieved July 30, 2005, from–223.pdfGoogle Scholar
  35. Moore-West M., Harrington D.L., Mennin S.P., Kaufman A. and Skipper B.J (1989). Distress and attitudes toward the learning environment: Effects of a curricular innovation. Teaching and Learning in Medicine 1: 151–157CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Moore G.T., Block S.D., Style C.B. and Mitchell R (1994). The influence of the new pathway curriculum on Harvard medical students. Academic Medicine 12: 983–989Google Scholar
  37. Nickens H.W. (1995). The role of race/ethnicity and social class in minority health status. HSR: Health Services Research 30: 151–162Google Scholar
  38. Noddings N. (2002). Educating Moral People. A Caring Alternative to Character Education. Teachers College Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  39. Norman G.R. and Schmidt H.G (1992). The psychological basis of problem-based learning: A review of the evidence. Academic Medicine 67: 557–565Google Scholar
  40. Patenaude J., Niyonsenga T. and Fafard D (2003). Changes in students’ moral development during medical school: A cohort study. Canadian Medical Association Journal 168(7): 840–844Google Scholar
  41. Pathman D.E. and Riggins T.A (1996). Promoting medical careers in underserved areas through training. Family Medicine 28(7): 508–510Google Scholar
  42. Peters A.S., Greenberger-Rosovsky R., Crowder C., Block S.D. and Moore G.T (2000). Long-term outcomes of the new pathway program at Harvard medical school: A randomized controlled trial. Academic Medicine 75: 470–479CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Price J., Price D., Williams G. and Hoffenberg R (1998). Changes in medical student attitudes as they progress through a medical course. Journal of Medical Ethics 24(2): 110–117CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Reinhardt A.M. and Gray R.M (1972). A social psychological study of attitude change in physicians. Journal of Medical Education 47(2): 112–117Google Scholar
  45. Rezler A.G. (1974). Attitude changes during medical school: A review of the literature. Journal of Medical Education 49(11): 1023–1030Google Scholar
  46. Ring J.J. (1991). The right road for medicine. Professionalism and the new American medical association. Journal of the American Medical Association 266(12): 1694CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Roche W.P., Scheetz A.P., Dane F.C., Parish D.C. and O’Shea J.T (2003). Medical students’ attitudes in a pbl curriculum: Trust, altruism, and cynicism. Academic Medicine 78(4): 398–402CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Satterwhite R.C., Satterwhite W.M. and Enarson C (2000). An ethical paradox: The effect of unethical conduct on medical students’ values. Journal of Medical Ethics 26(6): 462–465CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Seifer S.D. (1998). Service-learning: Community-campus partnerships for health professions education. Academic Medicine 73(3): 273–277CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Seifer S.D. and Connors K (2000). Improved student learning and community health: The CCPH faculty service-learning institute. Academic Medicine 75(5): 533–534CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Singleton R.A., Straits B.C. and Straits M.M (1993). Approaches to Social Research. Oxford University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  52. Strahan R. and Gerbasi K.C (1972). Short, homogeneous versions of the Marlowe-Crowne social desirability scale. Journal of Clinical Psychology 28: 191–193CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Swick H.M. (2000). Toward a normative definition of medical professionalism. Academic Medicine 75(6): 612–616CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Testerman J.K., Morton K.R., Loo L.K., Worthley J.S. and Lamberton H.H (1996). The natural history of cynicism in physicians. Academic Medicine 71(10 Suppl): S43–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Vernon D.T. and Blake R.L (1993). Does problem-based learning work? A meta-analysis of evaluative research. Academic Medicine 68(7): 550–563CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Wolf T.M., Balson P.M., Faucett J.M. and Randall H.M (1989). A retrospective study of attitude change during medical education. Medical Education 23(1): 19–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Wolf T.M., Randall H.M. and Tynes L.L (1991a). Perceived mistreatment and attitude change by graduating medical students: A retrospective study. Medical Education 25(3): 182–190CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Wolf T.M., Randall H.M. and Franklin F.A (1991b). Psychosocial changes during the first year of medical school. Medical Education 25: 174–181CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Xu G., Rattner S.L., Veloski J.J., Hojat M., Fields S.K. and Barzansky B (1995). A national study of the factors influencing men and women physicians’ choices of primary care specialties. Academic Medicine 70(5): 398–404CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  • Sonia J. S. Crandall
    • 1
  • Beth A. Reboussin
    • 2
  • Robert Michielutte
    • 1
  • Jennie E. Anthony
    • 1
  • Michelle J. Naughton
    • 2
  1. 1.Department of Family and Community MedicineWake Forest University School of Medicine Medical Center BoulevardWinston, SalemUSA
  2. 2.Department of Public Health SciencesWake Forest University School of Medicine Medical Center BoulevardWinston, SalemUSA

Personalised recommendations