Habitat quality and breeding parameters in relation to female mating status in the polygynous Eurasian Bittern Botaurus stellaris
- First Online:
- 1k Downloads
The Eurasian Bittern Botaurus stellaris has a polygynous mating system where the nests of solitary and clumped females are located within a male territory. However, the factors that may favour the formation of nest clusters remain unknown. The focus was on the clustering effect in the Eurasian Bittern population on fishpond complexes in eastern Poland in order to test whether clumped nesting is dependent on habitat quality. Breeding parameters were also assessed in order to investigate the advantages accruing to females of nesting close together in clusters. During the breeding periods between 2003 and 2009, we found 144 active nests of the Eurasian Bittern: most of them (55.5 %) were in clusters of two to four nests. The mean distance between adjacent nests in a cluster was 23.5 m. The proportion of open water to emergent vegetation and the category of fish stock have significant effects on cluster nesting in the Eurasian Bittern. There were differences between single and clumped nests with respect to the first-egg laying date and male presence. The environmental and ecological factors that may determine the Eurasian Bittern female’s nest-site choice are discussed.
KeywordsArdeidae Breeding strategy Fishponds Nesting habitat Polygyny
Habitatqualität und Brutparameter in Bezug auf den weiblichen Paarungsstatus bei der polygynen RohrdommelBotaurus stellaris
Die Rohrdommel Botaurus stellaris hat ein polygynes Paarungssystem, wo die Nester von einzeln und in Clustern nistenden Weibchen innerhalb des männlichen Territoriums liegen. Die Faktoren, welche die Bildung von Nestclustern fördern können, sind jedoch unbekannt. Der Schwerpunkt unserer Studie lag darauf, den Clustereffekt in einer Rohrdommelpopulation an Fischteichen in Ostpolen zu untersuchen und zu testen, ob das Nisten in Clustern von der Habitatqualität abhängig ist. Brutparameter wurden ebenfalls abgeschätzt, um die Vorteile zu untersuchen, die sich Weibchen bieten, welche nah beieinander in Clustern nisten. Während der Brutperioden zwischen 2003 und 2009 fanden wir 144 aktive Nester der Rohrdommel; die meisten (55,5 %) befanden sich in Clustern von zwei bis vier Nestern. Die durchschnittliche Entfernung zwischen angrenzenden Nestern in einem Cluster betrug 23,5 m. Das Verhältnis von offenem Wasser zu schwimmender Vegetation sowie die Kategorie des Fischbestandes haben bei der Rohrdommel signifikante Effekte auf das Nisten in Clustern. Einzelne Nester und Nester in Clustern unterschieden sich bezüglich des Legedatums des ersten Eies und der Anwesenheit von Männchen. Die Umweltfaktoren und ökologischen Faktoren, welche die Nistplatzwahl weiblicher Rohrdommeln bestimmen können, werden diskutiert.
The Eurasian Bittern Botaurus stellaris differs from other herons (Ardeidae) in many aspects of its ecology (Voisin 1991; Kushlan and Hafner 2000). This is a little known, solitary and secretive reedbed species which has a polygynous mating system. Females do not normally receive help from males in the care of the young (Gauckler and Kraus 1965; Cramp and Simmons 1977; Puglisi and Bretagnolle 2005; but see Klejdus 2007). Eurasian Bitterns are reported to nest on wet vegetation stands with rich food resources such as fish, crustaceans, amphibians and insects (Gilbert et al. 2003; Poulin et al. 2005; Puglisi and Bretagnolle 2005), and in related open habitats, especially highly productive marshlands, which can be monopolised by certain males; these then attract additional females to their high quality territories (Verner and Willson 1966). However, in Eurasian Bitterns, some female nest sites may not coincide with the locations of male booming territories (Gauckler and Kraus 1965; Adamo et al. 2004; Gilbert et al. 2005a; White et al. 2006). The distribution of food resources and suitable nest sites (dense vegetation with an appropriate water level) may determine the distribution of females, which collect food alone and usually in close proximity to the nest (Puglisi et al. 2003; Adamo et al. 2004). As a result of this clustering of females, some males may have easier access to more than one female (resource defence polygyny; see Ostfeld 1987; Dyrcz and Zdunek 1993; Jiguet et al. 2000). However, the factors that may influence female nest grouping in Eurasian Bitterns remain unknown.
The aim of this paper is to characterise the clumped nesting system in a Eurasian Bittern population on fishponds. The ecosystem of a fishpond complex, with different nest-site vegetation types and different fish stocks in particular ponds, provides a good opportunity to study the clustering effect. The first hypothesis to be tested was that clumped nesting depends on habitat quality. It was expected that females would prefer to nest in attractive habitats offering rich food resources and suitable nesting sites. The second hypothesis was that females nesting close together in clusters are more successful than females on isolated nests. Because of the lack of or only occasional male parental care (Voisin 1991; Klejdus 2007), female reproductive success in Eurasian Bitterns may be much more dependent on territory and/or maternal quality than in other frequently studied species (Forstmeier et al. 2001; Moreno et al. 2002).
The Eurasian Bittern is an important target species for wetland conservation in many European countries, and different types of conservation projects have been drawn up and implemented. Habitat management, the main aim of these projects, should be undertaken only when sufficient knowledge of the ecology of the sites has been gained (White et al. 2006). The results of this study may provide useful guidelines for management planning in existing breeding sites and to restore the appropriate habitat components of future Eurasian Bittern nesting areas.
The study was carried out on 15 fishpond complexes situated in eastern Poland (50°55′–52º11′N, 21°58′–22°54′E). The ponds varied in area from 15 to 203 ha, covering a combined total of 1,115 ha. In this kind of extensively managed fish farming, the most abundant species stocked was Common Carp Cyprinus carpio. Most ponds were partially covered by discrete stands of vegetation dominated by Common Reed Phragmites australis. In eastern Poland, fish farms with dense, small-bodied fish populations and a large coverage of only occasionally cut emergent vegetation have a bird-friendly fish management and may still support a relatively high waterbird species richness. For a detailed description of the habitat, see Polak et al. (2008). The density of the Eurasian Bittern breeding populations in the study area ranged between 1.1 and 12.5 inds/100 ha for males, and between 1.1 and 20.0 inds/100 ha for females; this is the largest density recorded in Poland (Polak and Kasprzykowski 2009). The extensive fish management and abundant food resources were most likely responsible for the good breeding parameters obtained for this population (Polak and Kasprzykowski 2010).
Potential nest sites were surveyed throughout the breeding period, from the end of April to early July during 2003–2009. Nests were located by systematically wading through patches of emergent vegetation covering from 0.03 to 4 ha. Most nests were found in the egg-laying period or the incubation period (121), and the remainder in the nestling period (23). Because the nesting period in eastern Poland is short, we did not find any double broods. All the clutches laid in late May in our study area were probably replacement clutches (Dmitrenok et al. 2005), but after the loss of the original clutch, they were not laid in the same cluster. Nests were inspected regularly (mean 4 inspections, range 1–9) and special attention was paid to finding nest clusters. With this aim in mind, the surroundings of every nest found were searched: in a large reedbed, this was the area within a radius of 100 m from the nest. The distances between the nearest active nests were measured at 1-m intervals using a tape or GPS. During each visit to the study area, all call-locations of males were plotted on a 1:5000 map. Special attention was paid to recording the position of simultaneously active birds on a cumulative map, and the borders of booming sites of individual males were delimited by use of the minimum convex polygon method (Kenward 1987). A territory was treated as occupied when three occurrences of one male in the same patch of vegetation were noted.
Habitat variables and breeding parameters taken into consideration in this study of the effect of clustered nesting in Eurasian Bitterns Botaurus stellaris
Estimated water depth (cm) at the centre of the plot with 1-cm precision
Number of dry reed stems within a 50 × 50 cm square
Number of green reed stems within a 50 × 50 cm square
Distance (m) to open water pool
Distance (m) to the fishpond dyke
Proportion of open water area (ha) to emergent vegetation area (ha) on a given fishpond
Patch of emergent vegetation with active nests (random factor)
Category of fish stocks: 0 = young-of-year (0) carp with individual weights of 1.5–3.0 mg, to reach 8–15 g in early July; 1 = medium carp after first wintering at 30–50 g; 2 = 2-year-old-carp at 150–240 g; and W = wild or fish ponds, with different species and different age categories
Standardised first-egg laying date
The number of 15-day nestlings (fledglings)
Nests where at least one young bird had survived up to 15 days old: 0 = without success, 1 = with success
Nests located within the male booming area: 0 = outside (male absent), 1 = inside (male present)
Two types of nests were distinguished: single (no cluster effect) and clumped. The category of clumped nests refers to the nests located close to one another within a separate patch of emergent vegetation, i.e. one that is situated on one pond and surrounded by open water and/or the fishpond dyke. The following breeding parameters were analysed: the first-egg laying date (EGGDATE), the number of 15-day nestlings (FLEDG) and nest success (SUCCESS). Because 2-week-old Bitterns can disperse from the nest into the dense vegetation, nests were defined as being successful when at least one young bird had survived up to 15 days old (after Puglisi and Bretagnolle 2005). To eliminate the year effect, the data were standardised against the median of the first egg date in the population in each year. Some nests (29 %) were located during the egg-laying period, but in the majority of nests the first-egg laying date was established by backdating, assuming 25–26 days for incubation (Cramp and Simmons 1977; Mallord et al. 2000; Demongin et al. 2007).
The relationships between the clustering effect in the Eurasian Bittern and the variables were modelled using a generalised linear mixed modelling (GLMM) procedure. Two models were constructed, in which single nests and clumped nests were treated as a binomial dependent variable (0 = lack of cluster effect, 1 = nest situated in cluster). Six different habitat variables and categories of fish stock were included in the first model. The second model tested the null hypothesis that single and clumped nests did not differ in the following breeding parameters: the first-egg laying date, the number of fledglings and nest success. Because male parental care was not excluded, allowance was made for the situation where nests were recorded within or outside booming sites: male present or absent (MALE). In both models, the patch of emergent vegetation with active nests was used as a random factor.
Akaike’s information criterion (AIC) was used to evaluate which of the models was best supported by the data (Burnham et al. 2011). Only the models with AIC < 2 are discussed, because they are regarded as being equally supported. The models with the lowest AIC value were selected as the best fitting models. Statistical processing was performed using the STATISTICA 9.0 package (Statsoft 2011).
Model selection using Akaike’s information criteria (AIC) to determine the effect of habitat variables (Model 1) and differences in breeding parameters (Model 2) on clumped nesting of Eurasian Bitterns
NEW + PROARE + CARP
WATER + NEW + PROARE + CARP
DISDYKE + NEW + PROARE + CARP
OLD + NEW + PROARE + CARP
DISTOW + NEW + PROARE + CARP
EGGDATE + MALE
EGGDATE + FLEDG + MALE
EGGDATE + MALE + 1 × 2
Best models testing the effects of habitat variables and breeding parameters on clustered nesting in Eurasian Bitterns
Mean and standard deviations (SD) of habitat variables measured at single (n = 61) and clumped nests (n = 78) of the Eurasian Bittern
For the second analysis, where breeding parameters in 63 different variations were analysed, the selected model included two variables: the first-egg laying date and the presence of a male booming site (Table 2). As in the first analysis, these two variables were included in the best and subsequent models. Two categories of nests differed significantly in the first-egg laying date (Table 3). In single nests, the first eggs were laid 5 days earlier than in the clustered nests, and the first-egg laying period (53 days) was longer in nest clusters than in single nests (47 days). The presence of males in the nesting habitat was also significant. In male territories, there were more clumped nests (97.5 %) than single ones (69.6 %). Neither the number of fledglings nor nest success was taken into consideration as differences between single and clumped nests.
The study shows that clumped nesting is a common strategy in the population of the Eurasian Bittern in the fishponds of eastern Poland. In different European populations, from one to five female nests have been found within male territories (Gauckler and Kraus 1965; Puglisi and Bretagnolle 2005), but nest clusters have only occasionally been reported (White et al. 2006). The high percentage of clumped nests (55 %) may be explained by the good breeding habitats and food resources in the fishpond complexes studied (Polak and Kasprzykowski 2010).
Only one of the six habitat variables analysed, the ratio of emergent vegetation area to open water area, is clearly important to clumped females. The mean value of this parameter was lower for nests in clusters than for single nests. Both habitat components (emergent vegetation and open water) are probably key factors with regard to the richness of potential prey items and nesting preferences. In fishpond ecosystems, the prey fed to Eurasian Bittern nestlings by females consists mostly of fish (Polak 2007). A suitable proportion of fish fry habitat (open water) and Eurasian Bittern breeding habitat (reedbeds) in a semi-natural ecosystem seems optimal for the polygynous system of reproduction. Habitat use by the Eurasian Bittern population in this study was corroborated by studies carried out in the UK, which found that the male’s home-range encompassed on average 30 % open water and 48 % reed edge (Gilbert et al. 2005b). The lack of influence of other microhabitat parameters on nest clumping is due to stable nest preferences within a particular patch of emergent vegetation (Polak et al. 2008). The remaining micro- and macrohabitat parameters (water depth, number of new and old reed stems, distance to the dyke and distance to open water) were the same for single and clumped nests. Some habitat variables that affect the selection of nesting positions, regardless of female status, appear to be crucial for Eurasian Bittern females (see Adamo et al. 2004; Gilbert et al. 2005a; Polak et al. 2008).
Besides the anti-predator role of habitat components (Polak 2007), the most important factor causing daily losses of Eurasian Bittern chicks was starvation (Gilbert et al. 2007). This could have been due to poor food availability (mainly a lack of fish) or poor weather conditions. In a specific habitat type like fishpond complexes, an important factor related to food resources is the Common Carp year-class. This study shows that females readily nested in clusters around ponds with Common Carp of the second year-class (1); this category of fish weight is suitable as food for Eurasian Bittern chicks (Polak 2007). Ponds with Common Carp in the first year-class (0) had a negative effect on clustering, probably because of the very small weight of the fish. Ponds with the third category of Common Carp (2) are also unattractive, since the fish have grown too large to be eaten by either chicks or adults. Moreover, ponds stocked with older cohorts of Common Carp are unsuitable for breeding amphibians (Kloskowski 2009), another of the Eurasian Bittern’s prey items (Polak 2007; White et al. 2006).
In the present study, solitary females started laying eggs 6 days earlier than clumped females. The decision of secondary females (with a lower status in the polygynous system) to form a cluster could be due mainly to the existence of appropriate habitat components and food resources. A review of data from 28 bird species shows that a median interval of 8.6 days was found between the laying times of primary and secondary females (Slagsvold and Lifjeld 1994). Eurasian Bittern females established themselves earlier in the territories of males that started booming early and with a high vocalisation rate (Polak 2006). It is possible that males monopolising the best territories could be first to attract a mate early in the season, and would then be more likely to attract further females. Data from a French study suggest that boom length is likely to reflect a male’s body condition and habitat quality (Poulin and Lefebvre 2003a, b). But no correlation between booming parameters and harem size has been found (Polak 2006).
Females of polygynous species may incur potential costs because they compete for territorial resources like food and appropriate nest-sites (Slagsvold and Lifjeld 1994; Forstmeier et al. 2001; Qvarnström et al. 2003). However, because of the good and stable food resources in the population studied, the nest success of clumped females was similar to that of single females. A few authors have found no differences in breeding parameters between females of different mating status (Petit 1991; Bensch 1996; Grønstøl 2003). Female Eurasian Bitterns nesting in clusters do not have to compete for a male contribution to feeding the young and may select this form of nesting as the best breeding strategy (a combination of male and territorial quality), especially if polygynous males offer better breeding and feeding grounds. The difference found in our study between single and clumped nests with respect to male presence confirms the attraction of male territories. We also wanted to know whether females could detect each other in the clusters (Dyrcz 1986; Bensch and Hasselquist 1992; Slagsvold and Lifjeld 1994; Qvarnström et al. 2003). The distance between the nests in Eurasian Bittern clusters was relatively small, making it possible for females to discover their mating status.
Our study shows that Eurasian Bitterns are quite flexible, selecting nesting and feeding grounds according to the distribution of suitable resources, and that individuals from populations breeding under different ecological situations can choose different breeding strategies. The most important aspects of clumped nesting are the appropriate proportion of macrohabitats in which a female can find rich food resources (fish stock category) and suitable nest-sites. Knowledge of the Eurasian Bittern’s optimal habitat requirements can provide useful guidelines for future conservation projects involving this vulnerable species.
We would like to thank everyone who helped with the fieldwork, especially M. Gąska, J. Kloskowski, J. Krogulec, M. Nieoczym, E. Zębek, R. Kuropieska and M. Szaniawska. The study was in compliance with current Polish Law and was permitted by the Local Ethical Commission and the Ministry of the Environment.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.