Population Ecology

, Volume 56, Issue 3, pp 481–492 | Cite as

Comparison of occupancy modeling and radiotelemetry to estimate ungulate population dynamics

  • Jared F. Duquette
  • Jerrold L. Belant
  • Nathan J. Svoboda
  • Dean E. BeyerJr.
  • Craig A. Albright
Original article


Radiotelemetry and unmarked occupancy modeling have been used to estimate animal population growth, but have not been compared for ungulates. We compared white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) population growth estimates from radiomarked individuals and occupancy modeling of unmarked individuals and evaluated advantages and disadvantages of each method. Estimates of population growth were obtained using remote camera (N = 54/year) detection/non-detection occupancy surveys of unmarked deer and from survival and recruitment data of radiomarked adult females (N = 87) and neonate fawns (N = 127) in a predominantly forested region of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, USA, 2009–2011. We hypothesized that occupancy models and radiotelemetry data would have similar population growth trends because both methods sampled the same temporally closed population. Percent changes in camera trap data generally reflected finite population growth (λ) of radiomarked deer which increased (λ = 1.10 ± 0.01) from 2009 to 2010, but decreased (λ = 0.87 ± 0.02) from 2010 to 2011. Also, unmarked adult female abundance and fawn:adult female ratios generally reflected trends in radiomarked deer survival and recruitment. Royle–Nichols occupancy model abundance estimates had wide confidence intervals, which may preclude using this method from accurately estimating deer population growth. Radiotelemetry provided more precise population growth estimates, while allowing collection of vital rates and location data. However, the Royle–Nichols occupancy model may be preferred to radiotelemetry because it reflected yearly variation in population growth with reduced labor and no invasive marking. Researchers should consider the objectives and logistics of their study when choosing a specific method.


Abundance Cameras Odocoileus virginianus Recruitment Survival White-tailed deer 


  1. Anderson CW, Nielsen CK, Hubbard RD, Stroud JK, Schauber EM (2013) Comparison of indirect and direct methods of distance sampling for estimating density of white-tailed deer. Wildl Soc Bull 37:146–154CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bender LC (2006) Uses of herd composition and age ratios in ungulate management. Wildl Soc Bull 34:1125–1230CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Beringer J, Hansen LP, Wilding W, Fischer J, Sheriff SL (1996) Factors affecting capture myopathy in white-tailed deer. J Wildl Manag 60:373–380CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Burnham KP, Anderson DR (1998) Model selection and multimodel inference: a practical information-theoretic approach, 2nd edn. Springer, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Carstensen M, DelGiudice GD, Sampson BA (2003) Using doe behavior and vaginal-implant transmitters to capture neonate white-tailed deer in north-central Minnesota. Wildl Soc Bull 31:634–641Google Scholar
  6. Carstensen M, DelGiudice GD, Sampson BA, Kuehn DW (2009) Survival, birth characteristics, and cause-specific mortality of white-tailed deer neonates. J Wildl Manag 73:175–183CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Caughley G (1974) Interpretation of age ratios. J Wildl Manag 38:557–562CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Clover MR (1956) Single-gate deer trap. Calif Fish Game 42:199–210Google Scholar
  9. Collier BA, Ditchkoff SS, Raglin JB, Smith JM (2007) Detection probability and sources of variation in white-tailed deer spotlight surveys. J Wildl Manag 71:277–281CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. DeCesare NJ, Hebblewhite M, Bradley M, Smith KG, Hervieux D, Neufeld L (2012) Estimating ungulate recruitment and growth rates using age ratios. J Wildl Manag 76:144–153CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. DelGiudice GD, Riggs MR, Joly P, Pan W (2002) Winter severity, survival, and cause-specific mortality of female white-tailed deer in north-central Minnesota. J Wildl Manag 66:698–717CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. DelGiudice GD, Fieberg J, Riggs MR, Carstensen-Powell M, Pan W (2006) A long-term age-specific survival analysis of female white-tailed deer. J Wildl Manag 70:1556–1568CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. DelGiudice GD, Lenarz MS, Carstensen-Powell M (2007) Age-specific fertility and fecundity in northern free-ranging white-tailed deer: evidence for reproductive senescence? J Mamm 88:427–435CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. DeYoung CA, Guthery FS, Beasom SL, Coughlin SP, Heffelfinger JR (1989) Improving estimates of white-tailed deer abundance from helicopter surveys. Wildl Soc Bull 17:275–279Google Scholar
  15. Dougherty SQ, Bowman JL (2012) Estimating sika deer abundance using camera surveys. Popul Ecol 54:357–365CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Duong T (2007) ks: Kernel density estimation and kernel discriminant analysis for multivariate data in R. J Stat Softw 21:1–16 (package in R)Google Scholar
  17. Duquette JF, Belant JL, Beyer DE Jr, Svoboda NJ (2012) Comparison of pregnancy detection in live white-tailed deer. Wildl Soc Bull 36:115–118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Duquette JF, Belant JL, Svoboda NJ, Beyer DE Jr (2013) Body condition and dosage effects on ketamine-xylazine immobilization of female white-tailed deer. Wildl Soc Bull 37:162–167CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Ebert C, Sandrini J, Spielberger B, Thiele B, Hohmann U (2012) Non-invasive genetic approaches for estimation of ungulate population size: a study on roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) based on faeces. Anim Biodiv Conserv 35:267–275Google Scholar
  20. Environmental Systems Research Institute, Inc (2010) ArcGIS 10.0. Redlands, CaliforniaGoogle Scholar
  21. Fiske I, Chandler R (2011) Unmarked: an R package for fitting hierarchical models of wildlife occurrence and abundance. J Stat Softw 43:1–23Google Scholar
  22. Fuller TK (1990) Dynamics of a declining white-tailed deer population in north-central Minnesota. Wildl Monogr 110:3–37Google Scholar
  23. Fuller TK (1991) Do pellet counts index white-tailed deer numbers and population change? J Wildl Manag 55:393–396CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Gaillard JM, Festa-Bianchet M, Yoccoz NG, Loison A, Toïgo C (2000) Temporal variation in fitness components and population dynamics of large herbivores. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 31:367–393CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Grund MD, Woolf A (2004) Development and evaluation of an accounting model for estimating deer population sizes. Ecol Model 180:345–357CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Harris NC, Kauffman MJ, Mills LS (2008) Inferences about ungulate population dynamics derived from age ratios. J Wildl Manag 72:1143–1151CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Haroldson BS, Wiggers EP, Beringer J, Hansen LP, McAninch JB (2003) Evaluation of aerial thermal imaging for detecting white-tailed deer in a deciduous forest environment. Wildl Soc Bull 31:1188–1197Google Scholar
  28. Hatter IW, Bergerud WA (1991) Moose recruitment, adult mortality, and rate of change. Alces 27:65–73Google Scholar
  29. Hawkins RE, Klimstra WD (1970) A preliminary study of the social organization of white-tailed deer. J Wildl Manag 34:407–419CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Hood GM (2011) PopTools version 3.2.5. http://www.poptools.org
  31. Ikeda T, Takahashi H, Yoshida T, Igota H, Kaji K (2013) Evaluation of camera trap surveys for estimation of sika deer herd composition. Mamm Study 38:29–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Jackson RM, White M, Knowlton FF (1972) Activity patterns of young white-tailed deer fawns in south Texas. Ecology 53:262–270CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Jacobson HA, Kroll JC, Browning RW, Koerth BH, Conway MH (1997) Infrared-triggered cameras for censusing white-tailed deer. Wildl Soc Bull 25:547–556Google Scholar
  34. Karanth KU, Gopalaswamy AM, Kumar NS, Vaidyanathan S, Nichols JD, MacKenzie DI (2011) Monitoring carnivore populations at the landscape scale: occupancy modelling of tigers from sign surveys. J Appl Ecol 48:1048–1056CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Koerth BH, Kroll JC (2000) Bait type and timing for deer counts using cameras triggered by infrared monitors. Wildl Soc Bull 28:630–635Google Scholar
  36. Koerth BH, McKown CD, Kroll JC (1997) Infrared-triggered camera versus helicopter counts of white-tailed deer. Wildl Soc Bull 25:557–562Google Scholar
  37. Kreeger TJ, Arnemo JM (2007) Handbook of wildlife chemical immobilization, 3rd edn. Laramie, WyomingGoogle Scholar
  38. Leslie PH (1945) On the use of matrices in certain population mathematics. Biometrika 3:183–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. MacKenzie DI, Nichols JD, Royle JA, Pollock KH, Bailey LL, Hines JE (2006) Occupancy estimation and modeling. Academic Press, BurlingtonGoogle Scholar
  40. McCaffery KR (1976) Deer trail counts as an index to populations and habitat use. J Wildl Manag 40:308–316CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. McCoy JC, Ditchkoff SS, Steury TD (2011) Bias associated with baited camera sites for assessing population characteristics of deer. J Wildl Manag 75:472–477CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. McCullough DR (1994) In my experience: what do herd composition counts tell us? Wildl Soc Bull 22:295–300Google Scholar
  43. McGarigal K, Marks BJ (1995) FRAGSTATS: spatial pattern analysis program for quantifying landscape structure. United States Forest Service General Technical Report PNW-GTR-351, Portland, OregonGoogle Scholar
  44. Michigan Department of Natural Resources (2009–2011) West U.P. deer camp survey. Michigan Department of Natural Resources, Wildlife Division, Gladstone, MichiganGoogle Scholar
  45. Millspaugh JJ, Marzluff JM (2001) Radio tracking and animal populations. Academic Press, BurlingtonGoogle Scholar
  46. Millspaugh JJ, Washburn BE, Milanick MA, Beringer J, Hansen LP, Meyer TM (2002) Non-invasive techniques for stress assessment in white-tailed deer. Wildl Soc Bull 30:899–907Google Scholar
  47. Morellet N, Champely S, Gaillard JM, Ballon P, Boscardin Y (2001) The browsing index: new tool uses browsing pressure to monitor deer populations. Wildl Soc Bull 29:1243–1252Google Scholar
  48. Naugle DE, Jenks JA, Kernohan BJ (1996) Use of thermal infrared sensing to estimate density of white-tailed deer. Wildl Soc Bull 24:37–43Google Scholar
  49. Nelson ME (2001) Tooth extractions from live-captured white-tailed deer. Wildl Soc Bull 29:245–247Google Scholar
  50. Ozoga JJ, Verme LJ, Bienz CS (1982) Parturition behavior and territoriality in white-tailed: impact on neonatal mortality. J Wildl Manag 46:1–11CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Pradel R (1996) Utilization of capture-mark-recapture for the study of recruitment and population growth rate. Biometrics 52:703–709CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. R Core Team (2013) R: a language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. http://www.R-project.org
  53. Roberts CW, Pierce BL, Braden AW, Lopez RR, Silvy NJ, Frank PA, Ransom D Jr (2006) Comparison of camera and road survey estimates for white-tailed deer. J Wildl Manag 70:263–267CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Roth T, Amrhein V (2010) Estimating individual survival using territory occupancy data on unmarked animals. J Appl Ecol 47:386–392CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Rowcliffe JM, Field J, Turvey ST, Carbone C (2009) Estimating animal density using camera traps without the need for individual recognition. J Appl Ecol 45:1228–1236CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Royle JA, Nichols JD (2003) Estimating abundance from repeated presence-absence data or point counts. Ecology 84:777–790CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Skalski JR, Ryding KE, Millspaugh JJ (2005) Wildlife demography: analysis of sex, age, and count data, 1st edn. Academic Press, BurlingtonGoogle Scholar
  58. Stevens DL Jr, Olsen AR (2004) Spatially-balanced sampling of natural resources. J Am Stat Assoc 99:262–278CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Storm DJ, Samuel MD, Van Deelen TR, Malcolm KD, Rolley RE, Frost NA, Bates DP, Richards BJ (2011) Comparison of visual-based helicopter and fixed-wing forward looking infrared surveys for counting white-tailed deer Odocoileus virginianus. Wildl Biol 17:431–440CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Tempel DJ, Gutiérrez RJ (2013) Relation between occupancy and abundance for a territorial species, the California spotted owl. Conserv Biol 27:1087–1095PubMedGoogle Scholar
  61. Therneau T (2012) Survival analysis, including penalized likelihood. Version 2.36-14. http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/survival/survival.pdf
  62. United States Geological Survey (2011) National landcover database 2006. http://www.mrlc.gov/nlcd2006.php
  63. Urbanek RE, Nielsen CK, Preuss TS, Glowacki GA (2012) Comparison of aerial surveys and pellet-based distance sampling methods for estimating deer density. Wildl Soc Bull 36:100–106CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Verme LJ (1969) Reproductive patterns of white-tailed deer related to nutritional plane. J Wildl Manag 33:881–887CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Verme LJ (1983) Sex ratio variation in Odocoileus: a critical review. J Wildl Manag 47:573–582CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Verme LJ (1989) Maternal investment in white-tailed deer. J Mamm 70:438–442CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Watts DE, Parker ID, Lopez RR, Silvy NJ, Davis DS (2008) Distribution and abundance of endangered Florida Key deer on outer Islands. J Wildl Manag 72:360–366CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Weckel M, Rockwell RF, Secret F (2011) A modification of Jacobson et al.’s (1997) individual branch-antlered male method for censusing white-tailed deer. Wildl Soc Bull 35:445–451CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Welsh AH, Lindenmayer DB, Donnelly CF (2013) Fitting and interpreting occupancy models. PLos One 8:e52015PubMedCentralPubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. White GC, Burnham KP (1999) Program MARK: survival estimation from populations of marked animals. Bird Study 46(Suppl):120–138CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. White GC, Freddy DJ, Gill RB, Ellenberger JH (2001) Effect of adult sex ratio on mule deer and elk productivity in Colorado. J Wildl Manag 65:543–551CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Wibisono HT, Linkie M, Guillera-Arroita G, Smith JA, Sunarto, Pusparini W, Asriadi, Baroto P, Brickle N, Dinata Y, Gemita E, Gunaryadi D, Haidir IA, Herwansyah, Karina I, Kiswayadi D, Kristiantono D, Kurniawan H, Lahoz-Monfort JJ, Leader-Williams N, Maddox T, Martyr DJ, Maryati, Nugroho A, Parakkasi K, Priatna D, Ramadiyanta E, Ramono WS, Reddy GV, Rood EJJ, Saputra DY, Sarimudi A, Salampessy A, Septayuda E, Suhartono T, Sumantri A, Susilo, Tanjung I, Tarmizi, Yulianto K, Yunus M, Zulfahmi (2011) Population status of a cryptic top predator: an island-wide assessment of tigers in Sumatran rainforests. PLos One 6:e25931Google Scholar
  73. Zar JH (1999) Biostatistical analysis, 4th edn. Prentice Hall, Englewood CliffsGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© The Society of Population Ecology and Springer Japan 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jared F. Duquette
    • 1
  • Jerrold L. Belant
    • 1
  • Nathan J. Svoboda
    • 1
  • Dean E. BeyerJr.
    • 2
  • Craig A. Albright
    • 3
  1. 1.Carnivore Ecology LaboratoryForest and Wildlife Research Center, Mississippi State UniversityMississippi StateUSA
  2. 2.Michigan Department of Natural ResourcesWildlife DivisionMarquetteUSA
  3. 3.Michigan Department of Natural ResourcesWildlife DivisionGladstoneUSA

Personalised recommendations