Governance and stakeholder perspectives of managed re-alignment: adapting to sea level rise in the Inner Forth estuary, Scotland
- 179 Downloads
With climate change, coastal areas are faced with unprecedented sea level rise and flooding, raising questions as to how societies will choose to adapt. One option is to strengthen existing sea walls to maintain current land uses; however, scientists, policy-makers and conservationists increasingly see the benefits of managed realignment, which is a nature-based coastal adaptation that involves the conversion of reclaimed farmland back to wetlands, allowing periodic local flooding in designated areas to reduce the risk of flooding downstream. We interviewed 16 local organisations, landowners and farmers and held workshops with 109 citizens living the Inner Forth estuary in eastern Scotland, to examine how managed realignment is supported by stakeholder attitudes and their engagement. Most of the farmers we interviewed prefer strengthened sea walls, to maintain their livelihoods and agricultural heritage. Citizens and local organisations were mainly supportive of managed realignment, because it provided wildlife and flood regulation benefits. However, we identified several barriers that could present obstacles to implementing managed realignment, for example, uncertainty whether it would support their principles of economic and rational decision-making. Our findings suggest that the local capacity to cope with rising sea levels is limited by lack of engagement with all relevant stakeholder groups, the limited scope of existing stakeholder partnerships and poor short-term funding prospects of landscape partnerships that would facilitate collaboration and discussion. We suggest that including citizens, landowners, farmers and industries would strengthen existing stakeholder deliberation and collaboration, and support the Inner Forth’s transition towards a more sustainable future shoreline.
KeywordsManaged realignment Climate change adaptation Nature-based solutions Wetland restoration Participatory research Coastal management
Thank you to all the people living and working in the Inner Forth for their time and help with the interviews and workshops. Thank you to both David Anderson (Royal Society for the Protection of Birds) and Neville Makan (Scottish Natural Heritage) who have supported us in the Inner Forth. Thank you to the workshop facilitators Aster De Vries Lentsch, Isobel Jones, Jakob Assmann, Ben Garlick and Rachael Scrimgeour. Thank you also to the workshop transcribers Kathleen Allen and Isabel Hoffman.
The project was funded by the European Commission FP7 under Grant Agreement FP7-ENV-2012-308393-2 (OPERAs).
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
We obtained informed consent from all research participants and adequately handled their confidentiality, in line with the School of Geosciences (University of Edinburgh) Research Ethics Procedure. For the citizen workshops, the research plan was reviewed and approved by the School of Geosciences Ethics Committee, and permission was obtained for photography and filming. Prior to the stakeholder interviews, participants provided consent to how the data would be used.
- Abel N, Gorddard R, Harman B, Leitch A, Langridge J, Ryan A, Heyenga S (2011) Sea level rise, coastal development and planned retreat: analytical framework, governance principles and an Australian case study. Environ Sci Pol 14:279–288. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2010.12.002 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Agardy T, Alder J, Dayton P, Curran S, Kitchingman A, Wilson M, Catenazzi (2005) Coastal systems. In: Millennium ecosystem assessment. ecosystems and human well-being: current state and trends assessment. World Resources Institute, Washington DC, p 37Google Scholar
- Akompab DA, Bi P, Williams S, Saniotis A, Walker I, Augoustinos M (2013) Engaging stakeholders in an adaptation process: governance and institutional arrangements in heat-health policy development in Adelaide, Australia. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Chang 18:1001–1018. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11027-012-9404-4 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ambros P (2016) Bridging to the common ground, adapting to climate change through sustainable estuarine land use: a study of the Inner Forth. Master Thesis Lund University Centre for Sustainability Science, ScotlandGoogle Scholar
- Aradóttir Á, Petursdottir T, Halldorsson G, Svavarsdóttir K, Arnalds O (2013) Drivers of ecological restoration: Lessons from a century of restoration in Iceland. Ecol Soc 18:33. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-05946-180433
- Babbie ER (2013) The practice of social research. Wadsworth Cengage Learning, Belmont, CaliforniaGoogle Scholar
- City of Edinburgh Council (2016) Local flood risk management plan. http://www.edinburgh.gov.uk/downloads/file/7455/draft_local_flood_risk_management_plan. Accessed 23 Jan 2018
- ClimateXChange (2016) Flooding and infrastructure. ClimateXChange secretariat. http://www.climatexchange.org.uk/adapting-to-climate-change/indicators-and-trends/flooding-and-infrastructure. Accessed 16 June 2017
- Durham E, Baker H, Smith M, Moore E, Morgan V (2014) The BiodivERsA Stakeholder Engagement Handbook. BiodivERsA, ParisGoogle Scholar
- European Commission (2013) Share of population in coastal regions living within 50km from the coastline by NUTS3 regions. Eurostat. http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/File:Share_of_population_in_coastal_regions_living_within_50km_from_the_coastline_by_NUTS3_regions.png#filehistory. Accessed 16 June 2017
- Scottish Government (2014) Scottish planning policy. Scottish Government. http://www.gov.scot/Publications/2014/06/5823. Accessed 16 June 2017
- Hansen M, Ramasar V, Buchanan K (2014) Localising global environmental governance norms: implications for justice. In: Sowman M, Wynberg R (eds) Governance for justice and environmental sustainability: lessons across natural resource sectors in sub-Saharan Africa. Routledge. pp 43–62Google Scholar
- Kenter JO (2014) Valuing the inner forth. Final report for the inner forth landscape initiative. http://innerforthlandscape.co.uk/files/KenterValuingtheInnerForth.pdf Accessed 28 Jan 2018
- Liski AH, Koetse MJ, Metzger MJ (2019) Addressing awareness gaps in environmental valuation: choice experiments with citizens in the Inner Forth, Scotland. Reg Environ Change https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-018-01458-4
- Lowe JA, Howard TP, Pardaens A, Tinker J, Holt J, Wakelin S, Milne G, Leake J, Wolf J, Horsburgh K, Reeder T, Jenkins G, Ridley J, Dye S, Bradley S (2009) UK climate projections science report: marine and coastal projections. Met Office Hadley Centre. http://ukclimateprojections.metoffice.gov.uk/media.jsp?mediaid=87905&. Accessed 19 Aug 2017
- Macalister T (2016) Longannet power station closes ending coal power use in Scotland. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/mar/24/longannet-power-station-closes-coal-power-scotland. Accessed 19 Aug 2017
- MacDonald MA, de Ruyck C, Field RH, Bedford A and Bradbury RB (2017) Benefits of coastal managed realignment for society: evidence from ecosystem service assessments in two UK regions. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecss.2017.09.007
- Oxford English Dictionary Online (2017a) Norm, n.1. Oxford University Press. http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/128266. Accessed 21 June 2017
- Oxford English Dictionary Online (2017b) Institution, n. Oxford University Press. http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/97110. Accessed 21 June 2017
- Pirie D (2017) Taking stock - where we are now. Conference presentation at the sniffer flood risk management conference 2017. Sniffer. https://www.sniffer.org.uk/flood-risk-management-conference-2017. Accessed 16 June 2017
- Rogers S, Kaiser M, Jennings S (1998) Ecosystem effects of demersal fishing: a European perspective. In: Dorsey EM, Pederson J (eds) Effects of fishing gear on the sea floor of New England. Conservation Law Foundation, Boston, pp 68–79Google Scholar
- Scavia D, Field JC, Boesch DF, Buddemeier RW, Burkett V, Cayan DR, Fogarty M, Harwell MA, Howarth RW, Mason C, Reed DJ, Royer TC, Sallenger AH, Titus JG (2002) Climate change impacts on U. S. Coastal and marine ecosystems. Estuaries 25:149–164. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02691304 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Scottish Government (2016a) Draft Budget 2016. http://www.gov.scot/Publications/2015/12/9056/8. Accessed 11th October 2017
- Scottish Government (2016b) Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009. Scottish Government. http://www.gov.scot/Topics/Environment/Water/Flooding/FRMAct. Accessed 16.06.2017
- Scottish Natural Heritage (2011) Firth of Forth - site of special scientific interest: site management statement. Scottish Natural Heritage. http://gateway.snh.gov.uk/sitelink/siteinfo.jsp?pa_code=8163#links. Accessed 19 August 2017
- Small C, Nicholls RJ (2003) A global analysis of human settlement in coastal zones. J Coast Res 19:584–599Google Scholar
- Smout TC, Stewart M (2012) The Firth of Forth: An Environmental History. Birlinn, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
- UK Committee on Climate Change (2016) UK Climate Risk Assessment 2017. Committee on climate change. https://www.theccc.org.uk/uk-climate-change-risk-assessment-2017. Accessed 16 June 2017
- Zhu X, Linham MM, Nicholls RJ (2010) Technologies for climate change adaptation-coastal erosion and flooding. Danmarks Tekniske Universitet, Risø Nationallaboratoriet for Bæredygtig Energ. http://www.tech-action.org/Publications/TNA-Guidebooks. Accessed 19 August 2017