Increased substantia nigra echogenicity correlated with visual hallucinations in Parkinson’s disease: a Chinese population-based study
As a noninvasive technique, transcranial sonography (TCS) of substantia nigra (SN) has gradually showed its effectiveness not only in diagnosis but also in understanding clinical features of Parkinson’s Disease (PD). This study aimed to further evaluate TCS for clinical diagnosis of PD, and to explore the association between sonographic manifestations and visual hallucinations (VH). A total of 226 subjects including 141 PD patients and 85 controls were recruited. All participants received TCS. A series of rating scales to evaluate motor and non-motor symptoms were performed in PD patients. Results showed that 172 subjects were successfully assessed by TCS. The area of SN was greater in PD patients than that in controls (P < 0.001). As receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis showed, the best cutoff value for the larger SN echogenicity size was 23.5 mm2 (sensitivity 70.3%, specificity 77.0%). Patients with VH had larger SN area (P = 0.019), as well as higher Non-Motor Symptoms Scale (NMSS) scores (P = 0.018). Moreover, binary logistic regression analysis indicated that SN hyperechogenicity (odds ratio = 4.227, P = 0.012) and NMSS scores (odds ratio = 0.027, P = 0.042) could be the independent predictors for VH. In conclusion, TCS can be used as an auxiliary diagnostic tool for Parkinson’s disease. Increased SN echogenicity is correlated with VH in Parkinson’s disease, possibly because the brain stem is involved in the mechanism in the onset of VH. Further studies are needed to confirm these findings.
KeywordsParkinson’s disease Transcranial sonography Visual hallucinations Clinical features Diagnosis
Parkinson’s disease (PD) is one of the most common neurodegenerative diseases. Though dopamine transporter positron emission computed tomography (DAT-PET) is proved to be an effective diagnostic technique , it has not been widely used due to high expense and radio action. The diagnosis of PD mainly relies on clinical manifestations . As a noninvasive technique, transcranial sonography (TCS) is potentially useful for the diagnosis of PD by showing the structural changes in substantia nigra (SN). Even though previous studies have proved that the specificity was 88.2–85% and the sensitivity was 84–94.9% in diagnostic accuracy of TCS in PD patients [3, 4], and the concordance rate between TCS patterns and PD diagnosis increased from 87 to 95% in a 4-year follow-up . Still, the data based on Chinese population need to be supplemented.
It is still unclear whether the extent of SN hyperechogenicity correlates with only motor symptoms or other clinical status, more precise quantification of the damage is required in order to improve extensive and in-depth understanding in PD. There were studies exploring the correlation between SN echogenicity and clinical features, and found that patients with larger hyperechogenic SN area tended to have severer motor and non-motor symptoms [6, 7, 8]; however, visual hallucinations (VH), one of the most common psychotic symptoms, which was reported to affect 9.8 to 82.7% of PD population in different stages [9, 10, 11], in relation to SN, have not been reported before.
Our objective is to evaluate the validity of TCS for the diagnosis of PD in Chinese population, and to investigate the correlation of sonographic manifestations with clinical features, especially in VH.
Subjects and methods
From May 2015 to March 2018, 141 participants with PD were recruited after giving their informed consent at the Department of Neurology, Dongzhimen Hospital. These 141 participants all met the criteria of the UK Parkinson’s Disease Society Brain Bank , and had enough audio-visual functions to complete motor and non-motor symptom evaluation test. Participants were excluded if they had possible dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) according to 2005 DLB diagnostic criteria (DLBC-3) . From May 2015 to January 2018, 85 volunteers without parkinsonism consented to participate as control subjects from the Department of Neurology, Dongzhimen Hospital and Poster recruitment. All volunteers were assessed by neurology specialists and were excluded if they had positive family history of PD or the possibility of parkinsonism.
This study had been approved by the ethics committee of Dongzhimen Hospital, the First Affiliated Hospital of Beijing University of Chinese Medicine.
Transcranial sonography operation and diagnosis standard
The SN hyperechogenicity were obtained from right and left temporal windows. Some of the patients were measured from only one temporal window if it was impossible to obtain images from both sides. The larger SN echogenic area (SNL) was used to perform receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis.
Clinical features assessment
We recorded the clinical parameters including age, gender, disease duration, and symptoms of onset. To assess the disease severity, the PD patients received evaluation of the Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS) , and their Hoehn and Yahr Stage (H-Y stage) was graded during the 12-h medication “off” phase. Participants received a series of tests to evaluate their non-motor symptoms (NMS). The Non-Motor Symptoms Scale (NMSS)  was used to test the overall status. The PDSS , CSI , and PFS  were used to evaluate the participants’ sleep disorder, constipation, and fatigue symptom respectively. Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE)  was used to evaluate the cognitive function. The degree of depression and anxiety was assessed by Hamilton Depression Scale (HAMD)  and Hamilton Anxiety Scale (HAMA) . And the living quality was evaluated by PDQ-39 . The presence of VH was defined according to item 13 from NMSS scale.
The data were analyzed by using SPSS 22.0. The descriptive statistics were given as mean value ± standard deviation. The categorical statistics were recorded as count and percentage data. Descriptive statistics received normality test, and further variation analysis was performed by two-sample t test and Mann-Whitney U test. The statistical difference of categorical data was calculated by chi-square test. Correlations of the scale scores and SNL were performed by Pearson correlation coefficients. Statistical significance was set at P < 0.05. The ROC curve analysis was applied to acquire the cutoff value to distinguish PD patients from normal controls. The classifier for ROC curve analysis was defined as The UK Brain Bank Criteria . For each point in the curve, sensitivity and 1-specificity were shown for a certain cutoff value. And the best cutoff value was defined as where the sum of sensitivity and specificity was highest.
A binary logistic regression analysis was used to determine the most significant variables which were independently correlated with VH. As a dependent variable, the presence of VH was defined as a binary variable. Age, duration, SNL, UPDRS total scores, NMSS scores, and MMSE scores were included as covariates.
Among the 226 subjects, TCS was successfully performed in 172 subjects (76.10%, 111 PD patients, 72 men and 39 women, and 61 normal controls, 38 men and 23 women). Fifty-four subjects (23.90%) failed to acquire sonographic image due to poor penetration of ultrasound through both bony windows, and were excluded from further analysis.
SN echogenicity in the participants
Data of SN in the normal controls and PD patients
(N = 111)
(N = 61)
66.35 ± 9.10
63.10 ± 11.44
Sex , male , n (%)
21.61 ± 18.00
8.28 ± 14.58
25.44 ± 20.24
12.44 ± 15.97
32.30 ± 18.42
14.61 ± 17.55
34.33 ± 12.65
49.73 ± 23.16
27.28 ± 3.98
115.21 ± 19.88
21.69 ± 11.67
47.58 ± 11.01
11.26 ± 6.35
8.68 ± 4.34
32.52 ± 21.25
Discriminative power of SN echogenicity for PD
Correlation between clinical features and SN echogenicity
We analyzed the correlation between age, H-Y stage, disease duration, UPDRS scores, UPDRS sub domain scores, NMSS scores, PDSS scores, CSI scores, PFS scores, HAMA scores, HAMD scores, MMSE scores, PDQ-39 scores, and SNL with the Pearson correlation analysis. The UPDRS-II scores were significantly correlated with SNL (r = 0.196, P = 0.039). Other scales did not show the correlation.
Correlation of variables in PD with VH
Clinical data of PD patients grouped according to VH
(n = 111)
With visual hallucination
(n = 18)
Without visual hallucination
(n = 93)
66.35 ± 9.10
70.67 ± 8.85
65.52 ± 8.96
Sex , male , n (%)
21.61 ± 18.00
31.06 ± 20.09
19.74 ± 17.06
25.44 ± 20.24
29.17 ± 23.65
24.72 ± 19.58
32.30 ± 18.42
41.67 ± 20.75
30.48 ± 17.48
2.25 ± 1.72
2.94 ± 2.29
2.11 ± 1.57
12.41 ± 5.18
14.22 ± 5.56
12.06 ± 5.06
18.20 ± 6.77
19.28 ± 6.62
17.99 ± 6.82
1.47 ± 1.73
1.22 ± 1.48
1.52 ± 1.77
34.33 ± 12.65
37.67 ± 12.87
33.69 ± 12.57
27.28 ± 3.98
26.56 ± 3.52
27.42 ± 4.06
49.73 ± 23.16
61.50 ± 28.48
47.42 ± 21.40
Disease duration (years)
5.97 ± 5.57
6.17 ± 5.69
5.94 ± 5.58
Further binary logistic regression analysis was used to identify the correlation between VH and other clinical features. Among age, duration, SNL, UPDRS total scores, NMSS scores and MMSE scores, SNL and NMSS scores were the only two variables included in the final model. This demonstrated that there was a significant correlation between the VH and SNL (odds ratio = 4.227, P = 0.012) and NMSS total scores (odds ratio = 0.027, P = 0.042).
This study explored the correlation between SN echogenicity and clinical characteristics in Chinese PD patients. We found that the SN echogenicity area in PD patients with VH was significantly higher than those without VH, which to our knowledge, had not been reported before.
As the results showed, 18 (16.2%) of 111 PD patients had VH, similar to another study in China (14.06%) . Previous studies demonstrated that the impairment of visual input and central visual processing, as well as the impairment of brainstem regulation of the sleep-wake cycle may be the possible mechanisms [24, 25]. The exact pathogenesis of VH in PD patients is not clearly understood. Current studies concerning VH in PD and neuroimaging mainly used the technology of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), positron emission tomography (PET), and single photon emission computerized tomography (SPECT). Based on imaging studies, there was evidence which supported the hypothesis that abnormality and dysfunction in visual cortex and cholinergic structures such as the SN and pedunculopontine nucleus were to blame for VH . However, the interaction between SN echogenicity and VH in PD was rarely investigated before.
Transcranial sonography can detect trace metal accumulation in deep brain structures with higher sensitivity than conventional MRI. In PD, particularly, the accumulation of iron has been suggested as an important substrate of extended SN echogenicity . Berg reported close connections between SN echogenicity and elevated iron content of the SN in both animal and human studies [28, 29]. However, only a few cases of parkinsonism with VH have been reported with significant midbrain iron accumulation . There was no direct evidence of correlation between iron accumulation in the SN and VH in PD. Another mechanism of enhanced SN echogenicity in PD might be microglial activation , which was demonstrated in midbrain specimens from postmortem PD patients [31, 32] and PD rat model . A case report of PD with VH and delusions showed that neuronal loss with gliosis was noteworthy in the substantia nigra, locus ceruleus, dorsal vagal nucleus, nucleus basalis of Meynert, and intermediate lateral nuclei, and cholinergic projections from the nucleus basalis of Meynert could be responsible for generation of hallucinations and delusions . However, there was also no direct evidence of correlation between microglial activation in the SN and VH in PD.
Among assessment of SN echogenicity, PD with VH had larger echogenic areas compared to those without. The correlation was further confirmed by binary logistic regression analysis. Together with these findings, we preliminarily inferred that the impairment of cholinergic structure in SN might contribute to VH in PD. Future studies may combine multiple imaging modalities to identify the main nerve damage in SN from iron accumulation, microglial activation, and other pathological processes.
Previous studies [35, 36] showed that VH in PD were associated with disease duration, dopamine agonist use, sleep quality, and cognition. In our study, there was significant difference between PD with VH and those without VH in age, NMSS, and UPDRS-II scores, while no statistic difference was found in disease duration, MMSE, and UPDRS-III scores. Moreover, there is no correlation between echogenicity and age, H-Y stage, NMSS scores, UPDRS-III, or disease duration. These results indicated that the correlation between VH and SN echogenicity was independent from NMSS scores, UPDRS-III scores, and disease duration. Considering there was no correlation between age and SN echogenicity in our study, similar conclusion was drew out in another Asian population-based study  (no difference in age between SN ≥ 18 mm2 group and SN < 18 mm2 group). We could initially speculate that the correlation between VH and SN echogenicity was also independent from age. However, PD with VH had higher UPDRS-II scores, and the UPDRS-II scores were associated with SNL. Therefore, we can not currently rule out the impact of UPDRS-II on the result that PD with VH had larger echogenic area.
There have been some studies concerning the relationship between SN echogenicity and clinical features of PD. Results showed that depression, urinary incontinence, UPDRS-II, SCOPA-AUT, and postural instability gait difficulty were related to SN hyperechogenicity [8, 37]. In our cohort, only UPDRS-II scores were associated with SNL, consistent with the result of Zhou’s study  based on Chinese patients. Yet, the underlying mechanism remains unclear. PD patients with VH had higher UPDRS-II scores might be a possible reason.
Clinical characteristic comparison among different studies
The TCS penetration rate was an important issue and might affect the study result to some extent, because some participants were excluded due to bad penetration of ultrasound through both bony windows. Among the 226 participants, 172 acquired adequate SN sonographic image; the insufficient penetration rate was 23.9% (21.3% in PD group, 28.2% in control group). In studies among Caucasian population, the insufficient penetration rate was in a level of 6.9–15.5% [7, 42, 43], while several Asian studies reported a higher temporal insufficiency rate varied from 20.5 to 30.2% [8, 39]. The Asian and Caucasian temporal bone structure diversity may cause the difference. Moreover, hyperostosis frontalis interna occurs as age grows, especially in female . This might be another reason why the insufficient penetration rate was higher in our study.
In conclusion, enlarged SN hyperechogenic area significantly correlates with the presence of VH in a Chinese population with PD. This finding may provide evidence for brain stem involvement mechanism in the onset of VH. However, with a relatively small sample size of VH group, further studies are needed to confirm our findings.
This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NO.81473518 and No.81573824), Beijing Municipal Science and Technology Commission (No.Z141107002515019), and the Capital Health Research and Development of Special (No.SF2014-1-4191).
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
- 11.Gibson G, Mottram PG, Burn DJ, Hindle JV, Landau S, Samuel M, Hurt CS, Brown RG, M Wilson KC (2013) Frequency, prevalence, incidence and risk factors associated with visual hallucinations in a sample of patients with Parkinson’s disease: a longitudinal 4-year study. Int J Geriatr Psych 28:626–631PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 12.McKeith IG, Dickson DW, Lowe J, Emre M, O'Brien JT, Feldman H, Cummings J, Duda JE, Lippa C, Perry EK, Aarsland D, Arai H, Ballard CG, Boeve B, Burn DJ, Costa D, del Ser T, Dubois B, Galasko D, Gauthier S, Goetz CG, Gomez-Tortosa E, Halliday G, Hansen LA, Hardy J, Iwatsubo T, Kalaria RN, Kaufer D, Kenny RA, Korczyn A, Kosaka K, Lee VM, Lees A, Litvan I, Londos E, Lopez OL, Minoshima S, Mizuno Y, Molina JA, Mukaetova-Ladinska EB, Pasquier F, Perry RH, Schulz JB, Trojanowski JQ, Yamada M, Consortium on DLB (2005) Diagnosis and management of dementia with Lewy bodies: third report of the DLB Consortium. Neurology 65:1863–1872PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 13.Fahn S, Elton RL (1987) Unified Parkinson’s disease rating scale. In: vol., pp. 153-163,293-304. Recent Developments in Parkinsons Disease, Vol 2 Florham Park, NJ: Macmillan Healthcare Information.Google Scholar
- 14.Martinez-Martin P, Rodriguez-Blazquez C, Abe K, Bhattacharyya KB, Bloem BR, Carod-Artal FJ, Prakash R, Esselink RA, Falup-Pecurariu C, Gallardo M, Mir P, Naidu Y, Nicoletti A, Sethi K, Tsuboi Y, van Hilten J, Visser M, Zappia M, Chaudhuri KR (2009) International study on the psychometric attributes of the non-motor symptoms scale in Parkinson disease. Neurology 73:1584–1591PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 15.Chaudhuri KR, Pal S, DiMarco A, Whately-Smith C, Bridgman K, Mathew R, Pezzela FR, Forbes A et al (2002) The Parkinson’s disease sleep scale: a new instrument for assessing sleep and nocturnal disability in Parkinson’s disease. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 73:629–635PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 18.Folstein MF, Folstein SE, McHugh PR (1975) Mini-mental state. A practical method for grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinician J Psychiatr Res 12:189–198Google Scholar
- 21.Peto V, Jenkinson C, Fitzpatrick R, Greenhall R (1995) The development and validation of a short measure of functioning and well being for individuals with Parkinson’s disease. Qual Life Res Int J Qual Life Asp Treat Care Rehab 4:241–248Google Scholar
- 23.Wan Y, Wang G, Zeng J, Laake K (2009) Investigation on prevalence and risk factors of visual hallucination in patients with Parkinson’s disease. J Shanghai Jiaotong Univ 29:862–865Google Scholar
- 34.Sakai K, Ikeda T, Ishida C, Komai K, Yamada M (2019), Delusions and visual hallucinations in a patient with Parkinson’s disease with dementia showing pronounced Lewy body pathology in the nucleus basalis of Meynert. Neuropathology: official journal of the Japanese Society of Neuropathology 39:319-323.PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 36.Trojano L, Papagno C (2018), Cognitive and behavioral disorders in Parkinson’s disease: an update. II: behavioral disorders. Neurological sciences: official journal of the Italian Neurological Society and of the Italian Society of Clinical Neurophysiology 39:53-61.PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 40.Luo WF, Zhang YC, Sheng YJ, Fang JC, Liu CF (2012), Transcranial sonography on Parkinson’s disease and essential tremor in a Chinese population. Neurological sciences: official journal of the Italian Neurological Society and of the Italian Society of Clinical Neurophysiology 33:1005-1009.PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 42.Bor-Seng-Shu E, Pedroso JL, Felicio AC, de Andrade DC, Teixeira MJ, Braga-Neto P, Batista IR, Barsottini OG, Borges V, Ferraz HB, Shih MC, Bressan RA, de Andrade LA, Walter U (2014) Substantia nigra echogenicity and imaging of striatal dopamine transporters in Parkinson’s disease: a cross-sectional study. Parkinsonism Relat Disord 20:477–481PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 43.Mahlknecht P, Stockner H, Kiechl S, Willeit J, Rastner V, Gasperi A, Rungger G, Poewe W, et al. (2012), Is transcranial sonography useful to distinguish drug-induced parkinsonism from Parkinson’s disease? Movement disorders: official journal of the Movement Disorder Society 27:1194-1196.PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.