Discussion on “GIS-based kinematic slope instability and slope mass rating (SMR) maps: application to a railway route in Sivas (Turkey)” by Işık Yilmaz, Marian Marschalko, Mustafa Yildirim, Emek Dereli and Martin Bednarik, Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment 71 (2012), 351–357, doi:10.1007/s10064-011-0384-5

  • R. TomásEmail author
  • M. Cano
  • J. García-Barba
We read the original paper entitled ‘‘GIS-based kinematic slope instability and slope mass rating (SMR) maps: application to a railway route in Sivas (Turkey)’’ by Yilmaz et al. (2012), Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment. The paper shows the potential use of kinematic stability and slope mass rating (SMR) maps using a geographical information system (GIS). However, there are several aspects in the paper regarding the SMR geomechanical maps elaboration that are debated on this note. As the authors explain in their paper, SMR (Romana 1985) is a slope geomechanical classification based on Bieniawski’s ( 1989) classification. This geomechanical index is computed adding to basic Rock Mass Rating (RMR) index, calculated by characteristic values of the rock mass, several geometrical correction factors ( F 1, F 2, F 3) and a fourth factor ( F 4) depending on the excavation method, respectively. Focusing our attention on F 1, F 2 and F 3parameters, we can see that these parameters are...


  1. Bieniawski ZT (1989) Engineering rock mass classification. Wiley, ChichesterGoogle Scholar
  2. González de Vallejo LG, Ferrer M (2011) Geological engineering. CRC Press, USAGoogle Scholar
  3. Romana M (1985) New adjustment ratings for application of Bieniawski classification to slopes. In: Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Role of Rock Mechanics in Excavations for Mining and Civil Works. Int Soc Rock Mech, Zacatecas, pp 49–53Google Scholar
  4. Tomás R, Delgado J, Serón JB (2007) Modification of slope mass rating (SMR) by continuous functions. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 44:1062–1069CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Tomás R, Delgado J, Serón JB, Cano M, Cuenca A (2009) Methodological proposal for the implementation of continuous slope mass rating (SMR-C) using a geographical information system. In: Proceedings of the VII Simposio Nacional sobre Taludes y Laderas inestables, vol I, pp 339–350 (in Spanish)Google Scholar
  6. Tomás R, Cuenca A, Cano M, García-Barba J (2012) A graphical approach for slope mass rating (SMR). Eng Geol 124:67–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Dpto. Ingeniería de la Construcción, OO.PP. e Infraestructura Urbana. Escuela Politécnica Superior de AlicanteUniversidad de AlicanteAlicanteSpain

Personalised recommendations