Sources of low-arsenic groundwater in the Bengal Basin: investigating the influence of the last glacial maximum palaeosol using a 115-km traverse across Bangladesh
- 1.7k Downloads
Pollution of groundwater in the Bengal Basin (Bangladesh and West Bengal, India) by arsenic (As) puts at risk the health of more than 100 million consumers. Using 1,580 borehole lithological logs and published hydrochemistry on 2,387 wells, it was predicted that low-As (<10 μg/L) groundwater exists, in palaeo-interfluvial aquifers of brown sand capped by a protective palaeosol, beneath at least 45,000 km2 of the Bengal Basin. The aquifers were predicted to be at a depth of as little as 25 m below ground level (mbgl), and typically no more than 50 mbgl. The predictions were confirmed along an east–west traverse 115 km in length (i.e. across half of Bangladesh) by drilling 28 new boreholes to 91-m depth to reveal subsurface sedimentology, and by mapping As distribution in groundwater. The aquifers identified occur at typically <40 mbgl and so are accessible with local drilling methods. A protective palaeosol that caps the palaeo-interfluvial aquifers prevents downward movement into them of As-polluted groundwater present in shallower palaeo-channel aquifers and ensures that the palaeo-interfluvial aquifers will yield low-As groundwater for the foreseeable future. Their use, in place of the shallower As-polluted palaeo-channel aquifers, would rapidly mitigate the health risks from consumption of As-polluted groundwater.
KeywordsArsenic Contamination Bangladesh Palaeo-interfluve Palaeo-channel
Origine des eaux souterraines pauvres en arsenic dans le bassin du Bengale: recherche de l’influence du paléosol du dernier maximum glaciaire le long d’un profil de 115 km à travers le Bangladesh
La pollution des eaux souterraines du bassin du Bengale (Bangladesh et Ouest du Bengale en Inde) par l’arsenic (As) met en risque la santé de plus de 100 millions de consommateurs. En utilisant les logs lithologiques de 1,580 forages et les données publiées d’hydrochimie de 2,387 puits, il a été montré qu’il existait sur au moins 45 000 km2 du bassin du Bengale des eaux souterraines pauvres en As (<10 μg/L), localisées dans les aquifères paléo-interfluviaux de sables bruns surmontés d’un paléosol protecteur. Il est estimé que ces aquifères se trouvent à des profondeurs d’un peu plus de 25 mètres et, le plus souvent, inférieurs à 50 m. Ces estimations ont été confirmées, le long d’un profil est-ouest de 115 km de long (c’est-à-dire la moitié du Bangladesh), par le forage de 28 nouveaux puits allant jusqu’à 91 m de profondeur, permettant ainsi d’étudier la sédimentologie de subsurface, et par la cartographie de la distribution de la concentration en arsenic des eaux souterraines. Les aquifères identifiés se trouvent typiquement à moins de 40 m de profondeur et sont donc accessibles au moyen de méthodes locales de forage. Un paléosol protecteur recouvre les aquifères paléo-interfluviaux et prévient ainsi la contamination en arsenic par des eaux enrichies localisées dans les aquifères des paléo-chenaux les plus superficiels et assure que les aquifères paléo-interfluviaux pourront être exploités dans le futur sans risque de contamination par l’arsenic. L’exploitation de ces aquifères, en remplacement des aquifères superficiels riches en arsenic, permettra rapidement d’atténuer le risque pour la santé dû à la consommation d’eau souterraine riche en arsenic.
Fuentes de agua subterránea con bajo arsénico en la cuenca de Bengala: investigaciones de la influencia del paleosuelo del último máximo glacial usando una transecta de 115 km en Bangladesh
La contaminación del agua subterránea en la cuenca de Bengala (Bangladesh y West Bengal, India) por arsénico (As) pone en riesgo la salud de más de 100 millones de consumidores. Mediante el uso de 1,580 registros litológicos de perforaciones y datos publicados de hidroquímica de 2,387 pozos, se predijo que existe agua subterránea con bajo contenido de As (<10 μg/L) en el acuífero paleointerfluvial de arenas marrones cubiertas por un paleosuelo protector, por debajo de por lo menos 45,000 km2 de la cuenca de Bengala. Se predijo que los acuíferos están a una profundidad tan solo de 25 m debajo del nivel del terreno (mbgl), y típicamente no más que 50 mbgl. Las predicciones se confirmaron a lo largo de una transecta este – oeste de 115 km de longitud (es decir a través de la mitad de Bangladesh) perforando 28 nuevos pozos a 91-m de profundidad para revelar la sedimentología subsuperficial, y mapear la distribución de As en el agua subterránea. Los acuíferos identificados se encuentran típicamente a <40 mbgl y por lo tanto son accesibles con métodos locales de perforación. Un paleosuelo protector que cubre el acuífero paleointerfluvial previene el movimiento descendente hacia ellos de agua subterránea contaminada de As (presente en los acuíferos más someros de paleocanales) y asegura que el acuífero paleointerfluvial brindará agua subterránea de bajo As en un futuro previsible. Su uso, en lugar de acuíferos más someros de paleocanales contaminados por As, rápidamente mitigaría los riesgos a la salud por el consumo de agua subterránea contaminado por As.
বেঙ্গল বেসিনে নিম্নমাত্রার আর্সেনিক থাকা ভূগর্ভস্থ পানির উৎসঃ বাংলাদেশে ১১৫ কিলোমিটার দীর্ঘ আড়াআড়ি পথ বরাবর সর্বশেষ বরফ যুগের প্রাগৈতিহাসিক-মৃত্তিকাস্তরের প্রভাব অনুসন্ধান ।
ভূ-গর্ভস্থ পানির আর্সেনিক দূষণ বেঙ্গল বেসিন (বাংলাদেশ ও ভারতের পশ্চিম বঙ্গ) এর ১০ কোটির ও বেশি মানুষকে স্বাস্থ্যঝুঁকির মধ্যে রেখেছে । এই গবেষণায় ১,৫৮০ টি খনন-কূপ লব্ধ পললের তথ্য ও ২,৩৪৭ টি নলকূপের পানির রাসায়নিক গুনাগুন পরীক্ষা করে বেঙ্গল বেসিনের কমপক্ষে ৪৫,০০০ বর্গকিলোমিটার তলদেশে একটি প্রবাহনিরোধক প্রাগৈতিহাসিক-মৃত্তিকাস্তর দ্বারা ঢাকা প্রাগৈতিহাসিক-নদী-মধ্যবর্তী বাদামি বর্ণের একুইফারে নিম্নমাত্রার আর্সেনিক থাকা (<১০ মাইক্রোগ্রাম / লিটার) ভূগর্ভস্থ পানি পাওয়ার সম্ভাবনা প্রস্থাব করা হয় । উক্ত একুইফারগুলো ভূ-স্তরের কমপক্ষে ২৫ মিটার নিচে এবং সধারনত ৫০ মিটার গভীরাতায় পাওয়া যাবে বলে ধারণা করা হয় । বাংলাদেশে পূর্ব থেকে পশ্চিমে ১১৫ কিলোমিটার দীর্ঘ (অর্থাৎ বাংলাদেশের অর্ধেক জুড়ে) আড়াআড়ি পথ বরাবর সর্বোচ্চ ৯১ মিটার গভীর ২৮ টি নতুন খনন-কূপ লব্ধ পলল স্তরের বিন্যাস এবং ভূ-গর্ভস্থ পানির আর্সেনিকের বণ্টন-মানচিত্র প্রনয়নের মাধ্যমে প্রস্থাবিত সম্ভাবনার সত্যতা যাচাই করা হয় । অনুসন্ধানে দেখা গেছে একুইফারগুলো সাধারনত ৪০ মিটারের কম গভীরতাতেই পাওয়া যায় এবং যে কারনে স্থানীয় নলকূপ খনন পদ্ধতির আওতাসাধ্য । একটি প্রবাহনিরোধক প্রাগৈতিহাসিক-মৃত্তিকাস্তর প্রাগৈতিহাসিক-নদী-মধ্যবর্তী একুইফারগুলোকে ঢেকে রাখে বলে (স্বল্প গভীরতার প্রাগৈতিহাসিক-নদীজ একুইফারে উপস্থিত) আর্সেনিক দূষিত ভূ-গর্ভস্থ পানির নিম্নমুখী প্রবাহকে বাধা দেয়, এবং প্রাগৈতিহাসিক-নদী-মধ্যবর্তী একুইফারের সুদূর ভবিষ্যত অবধি নিম্নমাত্রার আর্সেনিক থাকা পানি সরবরাহের ক্ষমতা নিশ্চিত করে । যেসব স্থানে কম গভীরতায় আর্সেনিক দূষিত প্রাগৈতিহাসিক-নদীজ একুইফার আছে সেসব স্থানে এই একুইফারগুলোর ব্যবহার আর্সেনিক গ্রহনজনিত স্বাস্থ্যঝুঁকি প্রশমিত করবে ।
(印度西孟加拉邦和孟加拉)孟加拉盆地地下水砷污染给1亿多人口带来了健康风险。根据1580个钻孔岩性记录资料和发表的2387口井的水文化学资料,得到的预测结果是,在孟加拉盆地至少45000平方公里范围内,上面覆盖着古土壤保护层的棕色砂层古河间含水层中存在着低含量砷地下水(<10 μg/L)。估计含水层的深度仅仅在地表以下25米,通常不超过50米。在东西115公里的断面上打了28个新钻孔,深度91米,揭示了地表以下的沉积条件,绘制了地下水中砷的分布状况,这些使预测结果得到进一步验证。确认的含水层一般深度 <40米,因此,普通的钻探方法可以贯穿。覆盖古河间含水层的古土壤保护层可避免(存在于浅层古河道含水层中的)砷污染地下水进入下伏含水层,确保古河间含水层中地下水在可预见的将来是低含量砷地下水。在分布着浅层砷污染的古河道含水层的地方,使用低含量砷地下水可迅速缓解使用砷污染地下水带来的健康风险。
Fontes de água subterrânea com baixa concentração de arsénio na Bacia de Bengala: investigando a influência de paleossolos do último máximo glacial usando um perfil de 115 km através do Bangladesh
A poluição das águas subterrâneas na Bacia de Bengala (Bangladesh e Bengala Ocidental, Índia) por arsénio (As) coloca em risco a saúde de mais de 100 milhões de consumidores. Usando 1,580 perfis litológicos de furos e dados publicados de hidroquímica de 2,387 poços, foi prevista a existencia de água subterrânea com baixa concentração de As (<10 μg/L) em aquíferos paleo-interfluviais de areia castanha cobertos por um paleossolo protetor, sob pelo menos 45,000 km2 da Bacia de Bengala. Os aquíferos previsivelmente encontram-se a uma profundidade de apenas 25 m abaixo do nível do solo (mbgl) e, normalmente, a não mais do que 50 mbgl. As previsões foram confirmadas ao longo de um perfil de 115 km com orientação este-oeste (ou seja, ao longo de metade do Bangladesh) através da perfuração de 28 novos furos com 91 m de profundidade, para se obter a sedimentologia de subsuperfície, e pelo mapeamento da distribuição de As nas águas subterrâneas. Os aquíferos identificados ocorrem tipicamente a menos de 40 mbgl e assim são acessíveis com os métodos de perfuração locais. O paleossolo protetor que cobre os aquíferos paleo-interfluviais impede o movimento descendente, em direção a eles, de águas subterrâneas poluídas por As (presentes em aquiferos de paleocanais a menor profundidade) e assegura que os aquíferos paleo-interfluviais fornecerão água com baixa concentração de As para o futuro próximo. O seu uso, em lugar dos aquiferos de paleocanais de menor profundidade poluidos com As, iria atenuar rapidamente os riscos para a saúde do consumo de águas subterrâneas poluídas com As.
In Bangladesh and West Bengal (India), i.e. the Bengal Basin, at least 85 % of the combined populations of 240 million use groundwater for domestic water supply, including for drinking. The groundwater is widely polluted with arsenic (PHED 1991; DPHE 1999, 2001; van Geen et al. 2003b; Jakariya et al. 2007; Nickson et al. 2007; Fendorf et al. 2010), the long-term consumption of which degrades human health (Dhar et al. 1997; Smith et al. 2000; Argos et al. 2010). Mitigation strategies include rainwater harvesting, use of treated surface-water supplies, and exploitation of deep aquifers (>150 m below ground level (mbgl) and mostly >300 mbgl) which typically contain much less than 10 μg/L of As (DPHE 1999, 2001; Ahmed et al. 2006; van Geen et al. 2007; Ravenscroft et al. 2009). These strategies require capital investment and maintenance that is beyond the capacity of most of the population, given that 90 % of it lives in a rural environment sustained by subsistence farming.
Cheaper mitigation can be obtained by emplacing well screens in aquifers of brown sand, where they are found in the subsurface, typically at depths between 25 and 70 mbgl. Recognised as distinct aquifers by Davies and Exley (1992) and Davies (1995), the brown sand’s connection to low-As groundwater was established by P. Ravenscroft of the Department of Public Health Engineering (DPHE) of Government of Bangladesh (DPHE 1999), and confirmed by others (DPHE 2001; van Geen et al. 2003a; McArthur et al. 2004; von Brömssen et al. 2007). Such aquifers contain groundwater in which concentrations of As are <5 μg/L and not uncommonly <1 μg/L. Other work by Goodbred and Kuehl (1999, 2000) suggested that the presence of such brown sands, as part of their ‘oxidised facies’, may be widespread across the Bengal Basin, although those authors did not link them to low-As groundwater. With hindsight, the development of the Bengal Basin outlined by Umitsu (1993) also allows the inference to be drawn that palaeo-interfluves are widespread across the basin and so, by further inference, are brown-sand aquifers.
Mitigation by exploiting aquifers of brown sand is an approach that is at risk from migration downward of As-polluted groundwater in overlying aquifers. The risk is removed where the brown-sand aquifers are protected from downward recharge by a capping red-clay palaeosol, first noted in central Bangladesh (Davies 1995), that formed much of the land surface (i.e. palaeo-interfluves) during the last glacial maximum (Goodbred and Kuehl 1999, 2000; McArthur et al. 2004, 2008). The combination of capping palaeosol over brown sand is seen most prominently as the upstanding Madhupur and Barind Tracts. The subcrop of this palaeosol represents the buried palaeo-interfluvial regions of the Bengal Basin. If truly widespread and not subsequently removed by erosion, those palaeo-interfluves, now known to host brown-sand aquifers, would constitute a substantial source of low-As groundwater that could be used to mitigate As-pollution in the Bengal Basin. Such a strategy might be applicable to other low-latitude deltas where groundwater is exploited for human consumption, e.g. the aquifers of the Indus (Pakistan), Red and Mekong (Vietnam), Pearl and Yangtze (China) river deltas.
Given the potential importance of these palaeo-interfluvial aquifers (brown sand capped by a palaeosol) to the provision of low-As water across Asian deltas, it is important that their distribution be documented, and their true value as sources of low-As water is assessed. A start to such explicit mapping and assessment has been made in the Bengal Basin by McArthur et al. (2008, 2011, 2012) and Hoque et al. (2012), who document areas of palaeo-interfluvial aquifer across parts of West Bengal.
The work reported here has extended that mapping across a large part of Bangladesh by using a combination of groundwater composition and historic drilling logs to distinguish, in the subsurface, between aquifers in palaeo-channel (PC) settings that host As-polluted groundwater, and aquifers in palaeo-interfluvial (PI) settings that host low-As groundwater. These methods suggested that largely unexploited PI aquifers yielding low-As groundwater exist beneath about one third of Bangladesh and also suggested that they are common in areas where presently almost all groundwater exploitation is from shallower, As-polluted, PC aquifers. Those suggestions were tested by drilling 28 new boreholes along a 115-km traverse across Bangladesh, by doing further analysis for chemical proxies in groundwater of PI/PC settings, and by undertaking a new colour survey of wells (McArthur et al. 2011) that enables PI/PC settings to be distinguished in the subsurface without drilling or chemical analysis of groundwater.
Study area and its sedimentological development
The climate of the region is monsoonal, and delivers between 1.5 and 3 m of rain per year, with the amount increasing from SW to NE. The rain occurs mainly between May and October (Sengupta and Sarkar 2006). The water table is typically only a few metres below ground level but deepens a few metres during the dry season (November–April) in response to natural drainage to rivers and abstraction for domestic use and irrigation. The water level locally may go temporarily below the level at which it can be raised by the suction pumps used for irrigation and domestic supply (typically < 7.5 m/25 feet). The shallow aquifers across the Bengal Basin (i.e. < 150 m depth) are fully recharged each year by monsoonal rain, with the water table rising above ground level in many areas during the monsoon to cause local inundation of lower ground with rainwater.
The present Bengal Basin comprises numerous major and minor river channels and the extensive interfluves that lie between them. A similar landscape would have existed around 125 ka, when sea level was around the level that it is today. In the interval 125 ka to the last glacial maximum at 18 ka (LGM), sea level fell by 120 m. In that period, weathering and erosion developed a late Pleistocene landscape at an elevation mostly lower than that of today composed of interfluves and river valleys (Umitsu 1993; DPHE 1999; Goodbred and Kuehl 1999, 2000), the most prominent of which remain today as the Barind and Madhupur Tracts. Long weathering of the palaeo-interfluves formed on them a capping laterite of red clay (Goodbred and Kuehl 1999, 2000; termed here the last glacial maximum palaeosol, or LGMP) over weathered and oxidised sands that are now commonly termed ‘brown sands’ (DPHE 1999 et seq.) and represent part of the ‘oxidised facies’ of Goodbred and Kuehl (2000).
The rise of sea level after the termination of the LGM created the accommodation space for the accumulation of newer sediment on top of the late Pleistocene landscape. First, the pre-LGM palaeo-channels, incised to a maximum depth of 120 m, were filled with mostly grey sands. Later sediments consisted of post-LGM floodplain silts, peats, and clays, incised by numerous later channel-fills of grey sands deposited as a result of channel avulsion. The channel-fills range in formational age from immediate post-LGM, in the base of main distributary channels, to modern deposits arising from modern river avulsion (DPHE 1999; Goodbred and Kuehl 1999, 2000; chapter 3, Ravenscroft 2003).
Within this sedimentological context, four sedimentological settings are recognised here (Fig. 1b) which have general meaning for As pollution. The channels present at the LGM, and infilled with grey sand as sea level rose, are termed here deep palaeo-channels (DPC). Shallow palaeo-channels (SPC), typically < 30 mbgl, contain grey sands which were formed by avulsion of Holocene rivers after most of the basin-fill had been deposited. Where the LGMP directly caps late Pleistocene brown sands and underlying Pleistocene grey sands, the term PI setting is used. The term truncated palaeo-interfluvial sequences (TPI) is used for the setting where shallow palaeo-channels have incised through the LGMP, depositing grey Holocene-to-modern sands directly onto brown, late Pleistocene sands.
The SPC aquifers are commonly exploited for water supply because they are the first aquifers to be encountered during drilling, usually at depths <30 mbgl. The grey sands of the SPC and DPC aquifers usually contain As-polluted groundwater because reduction of sedimentary iron oxyhydroxides, that sorb As, in the aquifer sediments has commonly gone to completion and released that As to groundwater (Gulens et al. 1979; Nickson et al. 1998; Welch et al. 2000; McArthur et al. 2004). Groundwaters in PI aquifers typically have concentrations of As that are <5 μg/L and commonly <1 μg/L because the environment is poised at the redox state of Mn-reduction, rather than the As-polluting stage of Fe-reduction (McArthur et al. 2011).
Brown PI sands and grey PC sands are in contact in TPI sequences and at the margins of palaeo-channels. In both environments, As-polluted groundwater in the PC sands can invade the brown sands of the PI aquifers. The brown sands have a higher Fe(III)/Fe(II) than grey sands (Horneman et al. 2004) because the brown sands contain more sedimentary iron oxyhydroxide. That iron oxyhydroxide strongly sorbs As (e.g. Stollenwerk et al. 2007). At such contacts, the concentrations of As in PI groundwaters are locally >5 μg/L because the sorption capacity of the brown sands is overwhelmed by As in the invading groundwater (McArthur et al. 2010).
To map the distribution of PI aquifers across Bangladesh, two methods were used. Firstly, the PI distribution was established using 1,580 rotary-drill logs made available by the DPHE, Government of Bangladesh DPHE/DFID/JICA (2006). Secondly, As, Fe, and Mn concentration of 2,387 well waters from the National Survey of Arsenic Contamination (DPHE 1999, 2001) were used as proxies for PI and PC settings (see the following section ‘Regional water composition’). All locations are reported here in the WGS 84 co-ordinate system.
The distribution of PI aquifers predicted by these methods were then tested by site investigation at 28 locations along an east–west traverse across 115 km of Bangladesh (Fig. 1). At each site, a borehole up to 91 mbgl was drilled to reveal subsurface sedimentology but without installing a well. Also, from existing domestic wells located around each drill site, groundwater samples were collected for chemical analysis of PI/PC proxies. Finally, for a few hundred metres around each site, the colour of stain on further well-completions and on domestic utensils was documented. This was done because such colour can distinguish between PI and PC settings of the well (McArthur et al. 2011) and help locate the boundary between PI and PC settings to an accuracy of a few metres (McArthur et al. 2011; Hoque et al. 2012).
DPHE rotary drilling logs
In none of the 1,580 DPHE logs was the distinction between PI and PC sequences recognised previously. It is the re-interpretation of these logs presented here that has allowed this distinction to be made. The key indicator of a PC sequence is the presence of sand at all depths, usually capped by surficial silt and/or clay typically only a few metres thick. The indicator of a PI sequence in the DPHE logs is the presence, at depths ranging from 26 to 34 mbgl depending on location, of a unit of clay+silt which, where present, was taken to be the LGMP. This is the depth range at which it has either been recognised and reported as such, or reported but not recognised as the LGMP and so re-interpreted here as such (see preceding citations). Further necessary conditions for recognition of the LGMP was a thickness >80 cm and that it was underlain by sands to the maximum depth examined. Where the LGMP was overlain by shallow palaeo-channel sands, identification of the clay between 26 and 34 mbgl as the LGMP is unequivocal as it was the only fine-grained unit reported. Where the putative LGMP is overlain by a sequence of floodplain clays, silts, and peats, the presence of the LGMP was inferred because all such sequences so far drilled by the authors have the LGMP at the base of the clay sequence, under which was a thick sand (McArthur et al. 2001, 2004, 2008; Pal et al. 2002).
The process of assignment was assisted by converting logs to a digital format and processing them using an algorithm that measured the proportions of sand, and silt+clay, present in successive 2 m-thick segments of core. The output of grain-size with depth was diagnostic of either a PI or a PC sequence. The number of logs that satisfy the algorithm was sensitive to the thickness set for that depth slice. That sensitivity analysis suggests that the results must be taken as reporting a minimum number of locations at which a PI sequence may be present. The analysis further under-reports the frequency of PI sequences because the DPHE drilling logs did not record sediment colour. The algorithm therefore classified as PC sequences all TPI sequences, in which grey sands directly overlie brown sands with no intervening LGMP, e.g. the sequences at piezometer site AP in the village of Moyna, West Bengal (McArthur et al. 2004).
A further bias towards under-reporting of the PI sequence occurs because rotary drilling seldom allows recognition of clay/silt units that are thinner than about 3 m in thickness, so the absence of such a unit from a rotary drill log does not indicate with certainty the absence of the LGMP. Despite these caveats, the analysis outlined in the preceding is useful in allowing quantification of the minimum extent of the PI sequences present at modest depth in the Bengal Basin.
Regional water composition
The hydrochemical search for PI aquifers examined water compositions from 2,387 of the 3,234 published analyses of groundwater available from the National Survey off Arsenic Contamination, of Bangladesh conducted in 1997/1998 (DPHE 1999, 2001). Following McArthur et al. (2011, 2012) and Hoque et al. (2012), concentrations of As, Fe and Mn in groundwater were used to differentiate between wells tapping PI sequences and those tapping PC sequences: PI groundwaters typically contain Mn, but no As or Fe; PC groundwaters typically contain As and Fe, but no Mn. Specifically, for wells between 20 and 90 m deep, the criteria set to identify PI groundwaters were: Mn ≥ 0.2 mg/L and Fe ≤0.9 mg/L and As ≤10 μg/L. For recognition of PC groundwater, criteria were: Mn ≤ 0.2 mg/L and Fe ≥ 0.9 mg/L and As ≥ 10 μg/L.
Excluded from consideration were wells screened at depths >90 or <20 m. Brown sands in the Bengal Basin have rarely been reported from depths >90 m, so wells screened below that depth are of limited usefulness in the search for PI brown sands. The shallow cut-off of ≤20 m depth is chosen because such wells must be screened in PC aquifers, as the minimum depth at which the PI brown sands have been found in the basin proper is around 25 mbgl. The top of the PI sequence trends to shallower depths as it approaches outcrop around the basin margin, and where it is close to the Barind and Madhupur Tracts, so the upper depth limit breaks down in such settings. Nevertheless, such settings form an insignificant part of the region studied and any anomalies they produce are unlikely to have a noticeable effect on the results or conclusions.
The extent of the PI sequences predicted by the two aforementioned methods were tested by drilling 28 boreholes up to 300 foot (91 m) depth along a 115 km traverse running from west to east across half of Bangladesh from its western border (Fig. 1). The traverse crossed much of the As-polluted part of Bangladesh. The boreholes were variably spaced about 3–6 km apart. The local hand-operated reverse-circulation method (Ali 2003) was used for drilling with plastic pipe, which can drill to 300 feet (91 m) rather than the 200 feet (61 m) attainable with iron pipe used in West Bengal. Water wells were not installed in the boreholes. Rather, at each borehole, cuttings were continuously collected and monitored, and were logged every 5 feet (1.52 m) or where a distinct lithological change occurred (see the electronic supplementary material (ESM), in which it should be noted that each 5 foot interval on the photographic logs gives an example only of the sediment(s) recovered in that 5 foot interval). The hand-operated method faithfully recovers clay units (see figure S2, ESM), and can distinguish fine sand from course sands, and both from silts. Comparison of the hand-operated method with percussion coring at the same site (J.M. McArthur, University College London, unpublished data, 2012) had shown that, at all depths, the lithological records were comparable, although sharp lithological contacts in sands, e.g. between brown and grey sands that occur over millimetres in sediment cores, are smeared over a few feet in hand-operated holes.
To test the match between sedimentology revealed by drilling, and that determined from groundwater composition, 176 unfiltered samples of well water were collected for laboratory analysis (see table S1, ESM) from domestic wells along the traverse, all but two screened at depth ≤90 mbgl. The wells were sited within a few hundred metres of the drill sites. Samples were not filtered because it has been shown that the As concentration of unfiltered and filtered waters are indistinguishable (Swartz et al. 2004; Zheng et al. 2005) and the major cation composition of filtered and unfiltered well waters have also proven indistinguishable unless the water is visibly turbid (J.M. McArthur, University College London, unpublished data, 2004); none of the samples were turbid. Samples analysed for U, V, Mo, Mn, Fe, and As were acidified in the field with 0.15 ml of 50 % AnalaR nitric acid. Analysis for Fe and Mn was by ICP-AES; analyses for As, Mo, U, and V, were done using a Bruker 90 ICP-MS.
A further 129 wells (see table S2, ESM) were tested in the field for concentrations of As using a digital Arsenator, because in wells between 20 and 90 m deep, the absence of As typically indicates that the well taps a PI sequence. At another 74 sites (see table S3, ESM), distributed mostly between drill sites, this field analysis was augmented by noting the colour of stain left by well water on well-completions and domestic utensils. This use of colour follows the demonstration (McArthur et al. 2011) that red stain is typical of wells <150 m deep that tap As-polluted PC groundwaters, whilst black stain is typical of wells that tap low-As groundwater from PI aquifers.
DPHE rotary drilling logs
The DPHE lithological logs that were categorised as PI or PC sequence are plotted on a map of the study area shown in Fig. 2. It is re-emphasised that the number of logs interpreted as representing a PI sequence is underestimated by the analysis of these DPHE logs presented here, so the distribution shown should be viewed as representing the minimum number of such sites.
Regional water composition
The depth to the top of the LGMP ranged between 29 and 37 mbgl and the thickness of the LGMP ranged from 0.5 to 5 m. The brown sands beneath the LGMP yielded groundwater containing <0.4 μg/L (median value, n = 77) of As. The minimum depth to the top of the brown sand was 29 mbgl and the thickness of the brown sands ranged from 4.6 to >55 m. Brown sand extended to the maximum depth drilled (91.4 m) at sites 22, 23, and 24. In other sites where brown sand was found, it passed downward into grey sand at depths between 55 and 86 mbgl. This basal colour transition marks the maximum depth of late Pleistocene weathering, and so approximate palaeo-base level, in past times (Hoque et al. 2012). These depths have not been corrected for subsidence that has occurred since deposition because local subsidence rates are unknown.
At nine sites (1–4, 16, 25–28), grey PC sands were found extending to the full depth drilled. At the ends of the traverse (sites 1–4 and 25–28), the grey sands infill deep and wide pre-LGM palaeo-channels. At site 16, grey sands to the depth drilled infill a channel of width 3–5 km that probably was a distributary river at the time of the LGM. This site may document an early equivalent of the modern-day Gorai River, which is located nearby (Fig. 1). The shallow PC sands overlying the buried PI sequences typically host As-polluted groundwater (McArthur et al. 2004), but of 14 samples collected in such shallow settings along the line of traverse, concentrations of As exceeded 57 μg/L in one outlier only of 384 μg/L. Within the main PI tract, two narrow palaeo-channels occur.
Using colour to explore the subsurface lithology around drill sites and along the line of traverse between the drill sites, it was found that 94 % of black wells (n = 79) confirmed the sedimentological setting for sites that had been deduced from drilling and water chemistry, and 81 % of black wells contained <10 μg/L of As (see table S1, ESM). The difference represents wells at the margins of palaeo-interfluves where local migration of As-polluted waters has brought As to marginal PI settings and is now polluting wells that previously were low in As, as has been documented elsewhere (McArthur et al. 2010).
The combined colour and chemical data allowed mapping in detail of the contact between the regions of palaeo-interfluve and palaeo-channel, which can be identified in the field to within a few metres by such means (e.g. Hoque et al. 2012). Along the central, PI, part of the traverse, local areas of red-stained wells in which well waters contains >10 μg/L of As (sites 8, 13, 15, 17, 21), and low concentrations of U, V, and Mn. The depth of these wells is within the range 30–90 mbgl at which PI brown sands would be found if they were present. The fact that PC signatures are seen locally in isolated small areas suggests they represent local incision of minor palaeo-channels through the LGMP, i.e. local scour to the depth of the brown sand. Such regions have proven to be uncommon in the mapping.
Extent of low-As PI aquifers
The analysis shows that low-As PI groundwaters that can be tapped from shallow depths accessible to local drilling methods are likely to be present under 45,000 km2 of the Bengal Basin, which is one third of its area (Fig. 4). These resources of low-As groundwater have not been much exploited by agencies responsible for potable-water supply. They have been overlooked by many owners of private wells who typically drill wells to the shallowest depth at which water may be obtained. That depth is often less than the depth to the local palaeo-interfluvial aquifer.
Along the line of traverse, the sediments revealed by drilling (Fig. 5) indicates that the middle portion of the traverse does indeed comprise a palaeo-interfluvial sequence, as predicted from water composition and DPHE logs. At both traverse ends, this central PI sequence is bounded by grey sands of As-polluted PC aquifers which occupy 40 km of the traverse. The post-LGM channels have not much truncated the PI sequence because their depth of incision has been mostly too shallow to do so, being imposed by decreased base-level gradients (Salter 1993) as sea level rose after 18 ka.
Fragmentation of low-As PI aquifers
The protection afforded by the LGMP, and the areal extent of PI aquifers, depends upon the degree of fragmentation of the late Pleistocene palaeo-interfluves. That fragmentation is governed by the initial distribution of rivers on that late Pleistocene landscape, and the degree to which subsequent channelling by post-LGM rivers has further fragmented those palaeo-interfluves. Such a large topic cannot be addressed fully here, but pointers exist that suggest such fragmentation is definitely not fractal in nature but instead has left many areas of PI aquifer that are tens of square kilometres in extent.
Whilst boreholes provide point-verification of subsurface lithology, the subsurface lithology between such tie-points can be reliably deduced from the composition of well water (McArthur et al. 2011; Hoque et al. 2012) and even from the colour of stain left by well water spilled on well completions (McArthur et al. 2011, 2012). Such investigations have shown that a borehole spacing of a few km (4–5 km in this study) reliably identifies major palaeo-channels. They have further shown that channelling at a finer scale has incised mostly to depths less than 30 m into the existing landscape, so preserving many of the buried PI sequences that mapped here. Where such incision has gone deeper, the fact is revealed by the presence of As-polluted wells that are screened at a depth greater than the depth to the local LGMP, which is typically at 25–30 m.
It can be observed that post-LGM channelling does not often incise to a depth greater than 30 mbgl, which suggests that much potential exists for PI sequences to have avoided erosion (Hoque et al. 2012). Nevertheless, sites 6 and 16 show that channelling at a scale of 1 km can incise through the LGMP and so fragment the areas of PI; an important future task will be to delineate just how dissected the regions of buried PI aquifer are because the buried PI aquifers can be recharged only by lateral flow from adjacent palaeo-channels (McArthur et al. 2011, 2012). Data show that the spacing between such palaeo-channels is between 6 and 10 km.
Protective nature of the LGMP
The value in the Bengal Basin of brown sand aquifers as low-As supplies of groundwater has been noted before (DPHE 1999; Pal et al. 2002; McArthur et al. 2004, 2008, 2011; Zheng et al. 2005; Stollenwerk et al. 2007; van Geen et al. 2007; von Brömssen et al. 2007; Pal and Mukherjee 2009; Burgess et al. 2010; Hoque et al. 2011, 2012). The local protection afforded to underlying aquifers in central Bangladesh by the residual clays (palaeosols) of the Madhupur and Barind Tracts was recognised by Davies and Exley (1992) and Davies (1995). The more widespread role of the subcrop of the LGMP palaeosol in protecting aquifers across the Bengal Basin from As pollution was not, however, appreciated until relatively recently, following their documentation widely in the subsurface of West Bengal (McArthur et al. 2008, 2011; Hoque et al. 2012). The extent of the brown sand and capping palaeosol noted so far, however, represent but a minute fraction of the total area of the basin under which the data presented here suggests that such a sequence might lie.
This paper further confirms the palaeosol model of As pollution of groundwater (McArthur et al. 2008) which states that PI aquifers will be protected from downward migration of As in groundwater from overlying As-polluted aquifers by the impermeable LGMP. Thus, PI aquifers are likely to prove a long-term source of low-As groundwater.
The PI aquifers delineated in this study are suitable for mitigation of the As-pollution seen in PC aquifers. In many areas where the shallower SPC aquifers are currently exploited, they are underlain by PI aquifers, so mitigation would involve no more than drilling an existing well deeper so that its well-screen is emplaced in the brown sand of the underlying palaeo-interfluve, and so beneath the protective LGMP. Indeed, this is already the default position in areas where the palaeo-interfluvial sequence is overlain not by sands, but by clays, silts, and peats, through which wells must be drilled to reach the first sands (e.g. sites 18 and 20; others in McArthur et al. 2011).
At the boundary of the PI and PC settings, the composition of well water can give confusing signals of sedimentology because of changing water composition caused by lateral migration of As-polluted groundwater from PC aquifers into PI aquifers in response to natural flow and pumping, especially pumping for irrigation. Changes can be marked over a period as little as 2 years (McArthur et al. 2010). Low-As wells become As-polluted and black well-stain becomes overprinted by red stain, making colour differentiation difficult. Wells in marginal PI settings a few metres to a few tens of metres downflow of such confusing well waters frequently have extremely high concentrations of Mn (typically > 2 mg/L), which imparts to the well and the well-completion an intense black stain that is unmistakable in the field (McArthur et al. 2011). This is the best marker of the proximity to the boundary between palaeo-channel and palaeo-interfluve settings of wells, and allows boundaries to be mapped at the spatial scale of metres if wells are sufficiently common (Hoque et al. 2012; McArthur et al. 2012).
At PI margins, protection against lateral (horizontal) migration of As into PI aquifers is provided by sorption to sedimentary iron oxyhydroxide in the brown sands (Stollenwerk et al. 2007). Model estimates by that author for sorption coefficients (K d) in Bangladesh sediments are around 30 L/kg. Measurements in Bangladesh at shallower levels (~6 mbgl), close to the zone of water-table fluctuation, indicate values of 7–8 L/kg (Jung et al. 2012). Push-pull, in situ, experiments in Bangladesh gave a value of 13 L/kg (Radloff et al. 2011). Assuming K d value of 13 L/kg, a retardation factor 70 can be estimated for the brown sand of the Bengal Basin (taking 30 % porosity, 1.6 g/cm3 bulk density), and this value is in the range of field-based estimates of a factor of > 30 by McArthur et al. (2010). Using this value in the Ogata-Banks solution (Ogata and Banks 1961), a well that is protected by a 50 m thickness of brown sand (e.g. one sited 50 m inside the margin of a PI sequence), would remain As free (<10 μg/L) for up to 525 years, assuming a groundwater velocity of 5 m/year, a hydrodynamic dispersion of 2e−7 m2/s, and an As concentration in invading water of 100 μg/L. These estimates are tentative, given the paucity of in-situ measurements of retardation factors for As and the degree of latitude on all and any of the governing parameters. It nevertheless allows an estimate to be made of the frequency with which wells in PI settings need to be tested, unless at the PI margins, and suggests a decadal timescale would suffice.
The deep aquifer
An increased use of deep aquifer water (from depths >150 m) is often invoked as an alternative source of water that can be substituted for the As-polluted water of the shallow aquifers. A major concern about this proposal is the possibility that increased abstraction from the deep aquifers of the Bengal Basin may draw down As from overlying aquifers. Because the brown sand of the PI sequences has the capacity to sorb As, it is often taken to be a barrier to the downward migration of As into the underlying deep aquifer (Stollenwerk et al. 2007; Radloff et al. 2011). Such invocations seldom recognise the limited thickness of the brown sand, which rarely exceeds 30 m, and so far have never recognised that the LGMP will limit downward migration of water through brown sands and so reduce their effectiveness as a protective sorber.
Along the traverse, the pre-LGM brown sand is often thin (35 % is <20 m in thickness), and so has a limited capacity to delay downward migration of As, even were it to occur. Such downward flow from grey to underlying brown sand, however, cannot be widespread because brown sand is usually overlain by the LGMP and/or pale blue-grey clay (Fig. 5; McArthur et al. 2004; Hoque et al. 2012), the effective impermeability of which makes irrelevant, in most places, the sorptive capacity for As of the brown sand in respect of downward (vertical) migration of As. The sorptive capacity of brown sand may therefore be of little regional importance when assessing the vulnerability of the deeper aquifers to the downward breakthrough of As-rich groundwater from overlying aquifers in palaeo-channel settings.
The work was supported by NERC grant NE/G/016879/1 to JMMcA and PKS. Charro and his drill team, and Talibun N. Molla, are thanked for assistance in the field, as are DPHE, and LGED, Bangladesh, for provision of data, and officials of the Government of Bangladesh for permission to stay in government guest-houses during the fieldwork. Roger Beckie and Martin Appold are thanked for their careful and constructive reviews.
- Ali M (2003) Groundwater resources and development in Bangladesh: background to the arsenic crisis, agricultural potential and the environment. In: Rahman AA, Ravenscroft P (eds) Bangladesh centre for advanced studies. University Press, Dhaka, BangladeshGoogle Scholar
- Argos M, Kalra T, Rathouz PJ, Chen Y, Pierce B, Parvez F, Islam T, Ahmed A, Rakibuz-Zaman M, Hasan R, Sarwar G, Slavkovich V, van Geen A, Graziano J, Ahsan H (2010) Arsenic exposure from drinking water, and all-cause and chronic-disease mortalities in Bangladesh (HEALS): a prospective cohort study. Lancet 376(9737):252–258CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- BADC/MMI/HTS (1992) Deep tubewell II project, esp. vol 2.1 natural resources. MMI and HTS for the Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation under the assignment to the Overseas Development Admin., Dhaka, BangladeshGoogle Scholar
- Davies J (1995) The hydrogeochemistry of alluvial aquifers in central Bangladesh, chap 1. In: Nash H, McCall GJH (eds) Groundwater quality. Chapman and Hall, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Davies J, Exley C (1992) Short term BGS pilot project to assess the “Hydrochemical character of the main aquifer units of central and north-eastern Bangladesh and possible toxicity of groundwater to fish and human”. Final report, Technical report WD/92/43R, British Geological Survey, Keyworth, UKGoogle Scholar
- Dhar RK, Biswas BK, Samanta G, Mandal BK, Chakraborti D, Roy S, Jafar A, Islam A, Ara G, Kabir S, Khan AW, Ahmed SA, Hadi SA (1997) Groundwater arsenic calamity in Bangladesh. Curr Sci 73:48–59Google Scholar
- DPHE (1999) Groundwater studies for arsenic contamination in Bangladesh, phase I: rapid investigation. Dept. of Public Health Eng., Bangladesh, British Geological Survey, Keyworth, UKGoogle Scholar
- DPHE (2001) Arsenic contamination of groundwater in Bangladesh. In: Kinniburgh DG, Smedley PL (eds) Dept. of Public Health Eng., Bangladesh, British Geological Survey, Keyworth, UK, 267 pp. http://www.bgs.ac.uk/research/groundwater/health/arsenic/Bangladesh/data.html. Accessed 20 June 2012
- DPHE/DFID/JICA (2006) Development of deep aquifer database and preliminary deep aquifer map, Final report of first phase, Department of Public Health Engineering (DPHE), UK Department for International Development (DFID) and Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), Ground Water Circle, DPHE, Dhaka, Bangladesh pp. 165; http://dphe.gov.bd/aquifer/index.php. Accessed 26 December 2010.
- Gulens J, Champ DR, Jackson RE (1979) Influence of redox environments on the mobility of arsenic in groundwater. In: Jenne EA (ed) Chemical modeling in aqueous systems, ACS Symposium Series 93:81–95, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
- Horneman A, Van Geen A, Kent DV, Mathe PE, Zheng Y, Dhar RK, O’Connell S, Hoque MA, Aziz Z, Shamsudduha M, Seddiqu AA, Ahmed KA (2004) Decoupling of As and Fe release to Bangladesh groundwater under reducing conditions, part 1: evidence from sediment profiles. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 68:3459–3473CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- McArthur JM, Banerjee DM, Hudson-Edwards KA, Mishra R, Purohit R, Ravenscroft P, Cronin A, Howarth RJ, Chatterjee A, Talkdar T, Lowry D, Houghton S, Chadha DK (2004) Natural organic matter in sedimentary basins and its relation to arsenic in anoxic groundwater: the example of West Bengal and its worldwide implications. Appl Geochem 19:1255–1293CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- McArthur JM, Ravenscroft P, Banerjee DM, Milsom J, Hudson-Edwards KA, Sengupta S, Bristow C, Sarkar A, Tonkin S, Purohit R (2008) How paleosols influence groundwater flow and arsenic pollution: a model from the Bengal Basin and its worldwide implication. Water Resour Res 44:W11411Google Scholar
- Nickson R, Sengupta C, Mitra P, Dave SN, Banerjee AK, Bhattacharya A, Basu S, Kakoti N, Moorthy NS, Wasuja M, Kumar M, Mishra DS, Ghosh A, Vaish DP, Srivastava AK, Tripathi RM, Singh SN, Prasad R, Bhattacharya S, Deverill P (2007) Current knowledge on the distribution of arsenic in groundwater in five states of India. J Environ Sci Health Part A 42(12):1707–1718CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ogata A, Banks RB (1961) A solution of the differential equation of longitudinal dispersion in porous media. US Geol Surv Prof Pap 411-A, 9 ppGoogle Scholar
- Pate RD, Goodbred SL Jr, Khan SR (2009) Delta double-stack: juxtaposed Holocene and Pleistocene sequences from the Bengal Basin, Bangladesh. Sedimen Rec 7(3):4–9Google Scholar
- PHED (1991) National drinking water mission project on arsenic pollution in groundwater in West Bengal. Final report, Steering Committee, Arsenic Investigation Project, PHED, Govt. of West Bengal, Kolkata, India, 57 ppGoogle Scholar
- Ravenscroft P (2003) Overview of the hydrogeology of Bangladesh. In: Rahman AA, Ravenscroft P (eds) Groundwater resources and development in Bangladesh: background to the arsenic crisis, agricultural potential, and the environment. The University Press, Dhaka, BangladeshGoogle Scholar
- Smith AH, Lingas EO, Rahman M (2000) Contamination of drinking water by arsenic in Bangladesh: a public health emergency. Bull World Health Org 78(9):1093–1103Google Scholar
- Swartz CH, Blute NK, Badruzzman B, Ali A, Brabander D, Jay J, Besancon J, Islam S, Hemond HF, Harvey CF (2004) Mobility of arsenic in a Bangladesh aquifer: inferences from geochemical profiles, leaching data, and mineralogical characterization. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 68(22):4539–4557CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- van Geen A, Ahmed KM, Seddique AA, Shamsudduha M (2003a) Community wells to mitigate the current arsenic crisis in Bangladesh. Bull World Health Org 81:632–638Google Scholar
- van Geen A, Zheng Y, Versteeg R, Stute M, Horneman A, Dhar R, Steckler M, Gelman A, Small C, Ahsan H, Graziano J, Hussein I, Ahmed KM (2003b) Spatial variability of arsenic in 6000 tube wells in a 25 km2 area of Bangladesh. Water Resour Res 39(5):1140–1155Google Scholar
- Zheng Y, van Geen A, Stute M, Dhar RK, Mo Z, Cheng Z, Horneman A, Gavrieli I, Simpson HJ, Versteeg R, Steckler M, Grazioli-Venier A, Goodbred S, Shahnewaz M, Shamsudduha M, Hoque MA, Ahmed KM (2005) Geochemical and hydrogeological contrasts between shallow and deeper aquifers in the two villages of Araihazar, Bangladesh: implications for deeper aquifers as drinking water sources. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 69:5203–5218CrossRefGoogle Scholar