, Volume 22, Issue 3, pp 619–628 | Cite as

Grass-Shrub Competition in Arid Lands: An Overlooked Driver in Grassland–Shrubland State Transition?

  • Nathan A. PierceEmail author
  • Steven R. Archer
  • Brandon T. Bestelmeyer
  • Darren K. James


Traditional models of state transition in arid lands emphasize changes in disturbance regimes and abiotic feedbacks that promote the degradation of grassland into shrubland, whereas biotic interactions like competition and facilitation are often overlooked. Here, we conducted an experiment to determine whether shrubs have a positive, neutral, or negative effect on grasses and if these interactions may play a role in grassland–shrubland state transition. Prosopis glandulosa shrub neighbors within 5 m of Bouteloua eriopoda grass patches were left intact (controls) or killed with foliar herbicide, and metrics of grass performance were evaluated over 5 years. We saw no evidence of shrub facilitation of grasses. Instead, grass ANPP responded positively to shrub removal in all years, but more so in years with above-average rainfall. Grass allocation to vegetative reproduction and grass patch size also increased when shrub neighbors were removed. These results demonstrate that biotic interference by shrubs upon grasses reinforce and magnify grazing- and drought-induced abiotic feedbacks during grassland–shrubland transitions. Shrub effects on grass should therefore be considered a key process in desert grassland state transitions.


Bouteloua eriopoda Chihuahuan desert Competition Grassland Prosopis glandulosa Shrubland State transition Woody plant encroachment 



Support was provided, in part, by USDA-NRI Grant 2008-35320-18684, NSF-LTER Grant DEB-1235828, Arizona Agricultural Experiment Station Project ARZT-1360540-H12-199; and by fellowships from Science Foundation Arizona and the University of Arizona School of Natural Resources and the Environment. The constructive input of two anonymous reviewers is appreciated. Thanks also to John Anderson, JER HQ staff, the numerous USDA-ARS Jornada staff and students who assisted with field work, and the summertime residents of Jornada Acres.


  1. Archer SR, Predick KI. 2014. An ecosystem services perspective on brush management: research priorities for competing land-use objectives. J Ecol 102:1394–407.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Archer SR, Andersen EM, Predick KI, Schwinning S, Steidl RJ, Woods SR. 2017. Woody plant encroachment: causes and consequences. In: Briske DD, Ed. Rangeland systems: processes, management and challenges. New York: Springer. pp 25–48.Google Scholar
  3. Baez S, Collins SL, Pockman WT, Johnson JE, Small EE. 2013. Effects of experimental rainfall manipulations on Chihuahuan Desert grassland and shrubland plant communities. Oecologia 172:1117–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Barron-Gafford GA, Sanchez-Canete EP, Minor RL, Hendryx SM, Lee E, Sutter LF, Tran N, Parra E, Colella T, Murphy PC, Hamerlynck EP, Kumar P, Scott RL. 2017. Impacts of hydraulic redistribution on grass-tree competition vs facilitation in a semi-arid savanna. New Phytol 215:1451–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bestelmeyer BT, Goolsby DP, Archer SR. 2011. Spatial perspectives in state-and-transition models: a missing link to land management? J Appl Ecol 48:746–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bleby TM, McElrone AJ, Jackson RB. 2010. Water uptake and hydraulic redistribution across large woody root systems to 20 m depth. Plant Cell Environ 33:2132–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Brooker RW, Callaghan TV. 1998. The balance between positive and negative plant interactions and its relationship to environmental gradients: a model. Oikos 81:196–207.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Browning DM, Archer SR. 2011. Protection from livestock fails to deter shrub proliferation in a desert landscape with a history of heavy grazing. Ecol Appl 21:1629–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Callaway RM, Pennings SC, Richards CL. 2003. Phenotypic plasticity and interactions among plants. Ecology 84:1115–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Dakos V, Kefi S, Rietkerk M, van Nes EH, Scheffer M. 2011. Slowing down in spatially patterned ecosystems at the brink of collapse. Am Nat 177:E153–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Daniel A, Holechek J, Valdez R, Tembo A, Saiwana L, Fusco M, Cardenas M. 1993. Jackrabbit densities on fair and good condition Chihuahuan Desert range. J Range Manag 46:524–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Dohn J, Dembele F, Karembe M, Moustakas A, Amevor KA, Hanan NP. 2013. Tree effects on grass growth in savannas: competition, facilitation and the stress-gradient hypothesis. J Ecol 101:202–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Eldridge DJ, Bowker MA, Maestre FT, Roger E, Reynolds JF, Whitford WG. 2011. Impacts of shrub encroachment on ecosystem structure and functioning: towards a global synthesis. Ecol Lett 14:709–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Fredrickson E, Havstad KM, Estell R. 1998. Perspectives on desertification: south-western United States. J Arid Environ 39:191–207.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Gherardi LA, Sala OE. 2015. Enhanced precipitation variability decreases grass- and increases shrub-productivity. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 112:12735–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Gibbens RP, Lenz JM. 2001. Root systems of some Chihuahuan Desert plants. J Arid Environ 49:221–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Golluscio RA, Sala OE, Lauenroth WK. 1998. Differential use of large summer rainfall events by shrubs and grasses: a manipulative experiment in the Patagonian steppe. Oecologia 115:17–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Grime JP. 1977. Evidence for existence of three primary strategies in plants and its relevance to ecological and evolutionary theory. Am Nat 111:1169–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Havstad KM, Schlesinger WH. 2006. Introduction. In: Havstad KM, Huenneke LF, Schlesinger WH, Eds. Structure and function of a Chihuahuan Desert ecosystem. New York, NY, USA: Oxford University Press, pp 3–14.Google Scholar
  20. Higgins SI, Bond WJ, Trollope WSW. 2000. Fire, resprouting and variability: a recipe for grass-tree coexistence in savanna. J Ecol 88:213–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Higgins SI, Bond WJ, February EC, Bronn A, Euston-Brown DIW, Enslin B, Govender N, Rademan L, O’Regan S, Potgieter ALF, Scheiter S, Sowry R, Trollope L, Trollope WSW. 2007. Effects of four decades of fire manipulation on woody vegetation structure in savanna. Ecology 88:1119–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Howard KSC, Eldridge DJ, Soliveres S. 2012. Positive effects of shrubs on plant species diversity do not change along a gradient in grazing pressure in an arid shrubland. Basic Appl Ecol 13:159–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Jobaggy EG, Sala OE. 2000. Controls of grass and shrub aboveground production in the Patagonian steppe. Ecol Appl 10:541–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Kefi S, Rietkerk M, Alados CL, Pueyo Y, Papanastasis VP, ElAich A, de Ruiter PC. 2007. Spatial vegetation patterns and imminent desertification in Mediterranean arid ecosystems. Nature 449:U213–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Kerley GIH, Whitford WG. 2009. Can kangaroo rat graminivory contribute to the persistence of desertified shrublands? J Arid Environ 73:651–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Knapp AK, Briggs JM, Collins SL, Archer SR, Bret-Harte MS, Ewers BE, Peters DP, Young DR, Shaver GR, Pendall E, Cleary MB. 2008. Shrub encroachment in North American grasslands: shifts in growth form dominance rapidly alters control of ecosystem carbon inputs. Glob Change Biol 14:615–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Li J, Okin GS, Alvarez L, Epstein H. 2008. Effects of wind erosion on the spatial heterogeneity of soil nutrients in two desert grassland communities. Biogeochemistry 88:73–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Ludwig F, de Kroon H, Prins HHT, Berendse F. 2001. Effects of nutrients and shade on tree-grass interactions in an East African savanna. J Veg Sci 12:579–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Ludwig F, Dawson TE, Prins HHT, Berendse F, de Kroon H. 2004a. Below-ground competition between trees and grasses may overwhelm the facilitative effects of hydraulic lift. Ecol Lett 7:623–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Ludwig F, de Kroon H, Berendse F, Prins HHT. 2004b. The influence of savanna trees on nutrient, water and light availability and the understorey vegetation. Plant Ecol 170:93–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Maestre FT, Callaway RM, Valladares F, Lortie CJ. 2009. Refining the stress-gradient hypothesis for competition and facilitation in plant communities. J Ecol 97:199–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. O’Connor TG, Puttick JR, Hoffman MT. 2014. Bush encroachment in southern Africa: changes and causes. Afr J Range Forage Sci 31:67–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Okin GS, Gillette DA, Herrick JE. 2006. Multi-scale controls on and consequences of aeolian processes in landscape change in arid and semi-arid environments. J Arid Environ 65:253–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Okin GS, D’Odorico P, Archer SR. 2009. Impact of feedbacks on Chihuahuan Desert grasslands: transience and metastability. J Geophys Res Biogeosci 114:G01004.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Pockman WT, Small EE. 2010. The influence of spatial patterns of soil moisture on the grass and shrub responses to a summer rainstorm in a Chihuahuan Desert ecotone. Ecosystems 13:511–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Priyadarshini KVR, Prins HHT, de Bie S, Heitkonig IMA, Woodborne S, Gort G, Kirkman K, Ludwig F, Dawson TE, de Kroon H. 2016. Seasonality of hydraulic redistribution by trees to grasses and changes in their water-source use that change tree-grass interactions. Ecohydrology 9:218–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Ratajczak Z, Nippert JB, Collins SL. 2012. Woody encroachment decreases diversity across North American grasslands and savannas. Ecology 93:697–703.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Reichmann LG, Sala OE, Peters DPC. 2013. Precipitation legacies in desert grassland primary production occur through previous-year tiller density. Ecology 94:435–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Rudgers JA, Chung YA, Maurer GE, Moore DI, Muldavin EH, Litvak ME, Collins SL. 2018. Climate sensitivity functions and net primary production: a framework for incorporating climate mean and variability. Ecology 99:576–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Sala OE, Gherardi LA, Reichmann L, Jobbagy E, Peters D. 2012. Legacies of precipitation fluctuations on primary production: theory and data synthesis. Philos Trans R Soc B-Biol Sci 367:3135–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Schlesinger WH, Reynolds JF, Cunningham GL, Huenneke LF, Jarrell WM, Virginia RA, Whitford WG. 1990. Biological feedbacks in global desertification. Science 247:1043–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Schlesinger WH, Raikes JA, Hartley AE, Cross AE. 1996. On the spatial pattern of soil nutrients in desert ecosystems. Ecology 77:364–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Scholes RJ. 2003. Convex relationships in ecosystems containing mixtures of trees and grass. Environ Resour Econ 26:559–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Schwinning S, Davis K, Richardson L, Ehleringer JR. 2002. Deuterium enriched irrigation indicates different forms of rain use in shrub/grass species of the Colorado Plateau. Oecologia 130:345–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Soriano A, Sala O. 1984. Ecological strategies in a Patagonian arid steppe. Vegetatio 56:9–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Throop HL, Reichmann LG, Sala OE, Archer SR. 2012. Response of dominant grass and shrub species to water manipulation: an ecophysiological basis for shrub invasion in a Chihuahuan Desert Grassland. Oecologia 169:373–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Vander-Yacht AL, Barrioz SA, Keyser PD, Harper CA, Buckley DS, Buehler DA, Applegate RD. 2017. Vegetation response to canopy disturbance and season of burn during oak woodland and savanna restoration in Tennessee. For Ecol Manag 390:187–202.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Walker BH, Ludwig D, Holling CS, Peterman RM. 1981. Stability of semi-arid savanna grazing systems. J Ecol 69:473–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Walker BH, Noy-Meir I. 1982. Aspects of the stability and resilience of savanna ecosystems. Ecol Stud 42:556–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Ward D, Wiegand K, Getzin S. 2013. Walter’s two-layer hypothesis revisited: back to the roots!. Oecologia 172:617–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Welsh RG, Beck RF. 1976. Some ecological relationships between creosotebush and bush muhly. J Range Manag 29:472–5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Whitford WG. 1993. Animal feedbacks in desertification - an overview. Rev Chil Hist Nat 66:243–51.Google Scholar
  53. Zou CB, Barnes PW, Archer S, McMurtry CR. 2005. Soil moisture redistribution as a mechanism of facilitation in savanna tree-shrub clusters. Oecologia 145:32–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  • Nathan A. Pierce
    • 1
    Email author
  • Steven R. Archer
    • 1
  • Brandon T. Bestelmeyer
    • 2
  • Darren K. James
    • 2
  1. 1.School of Natural Resources and the EnvironmentUniversity of ArizonaTucsonUSA
  2. 2.United States Department of Agriculture-Agricultural Research Service Jornada Experimental Range, Jornada Basin Long Term Ecological Research ProgramNew Mexico State UniversityLas CrucesUSA

Personalised recommendations