Variability in use of cut-off scores and formats on the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale – implications for clinical and research practice
Original contribution First Online: 02 October 2006 Received: 30 August 2005 Accepted: 13 August 2006 Summary Objectives: i) To highlight the increasing use in the literature of unvalidated cut-off scores on the Edinburgh Depression Scale (EDS/EPDS), as well as different wording and formatting in the scale; ii) to investigate and discuss the possible impact of using an unvalidated cut-off score; iii) to highlight possible reasons for these ‘errors’; and iv) to make recommendations to clinicians and researchers who use the EDS/EPDS. Method: A convenience sample of studies that have used unvalidated cut-off scores, or different formatting, are cited as evidence that these types of ‘errors’ are occurring fairly frequently. Examination of previous data from one of the authors is undertaken to determine the effect of using an unvalidated cut-off score. Summary: Many studies report rates of high scorers on the EDS/EPDS using different cut-off scores to the validated ones. The effect of doing this on the overall rate can be substantial. The effect of using different formatting is not known, though excluding items from the EDS/EPDS must also make a substantial difference. Recommendations: We recommend that i) the validated score of 13 or more is used when reporting on probable major depression in postnatal English-speaking women, and 15 or more when reporting on antenatal English-speaking women; ii) that the wording used is “13 or more” (or equivalent), and not other terms that may cause confusion (e.g., ‘>12’; ‘more than 12’; ‘13’ etc), iii) if a different cut-off score to the validated one is used, a clear explanation is given as to why this has been done; and iv) that the scale should be worded and formatted as originally described by its authors. Keywords: Postnatal depression; screening; pregnancy; fathers; culture. References Adouard, F, Glangeaud-Freudenthal, NMC, Golse, B 2005 Validation of the Edinburgh postnatal depression scale (EPDS) in a sample of women with high-risk pregnancies in France Arch Womens Ment Health 8 89 95 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Alkar, OY, Gencoz, T 2005 Critical factors associated with early postpartum depression among Turkish women Contemp Fam Therapy 27 263 275 CrossRef Google Scholar Allen, H 1999 “How was it for you?” Debriefing for postnatal women: does it help? Prof Care Mother Child 9 77 79 Google Scholar Austerberry, H, Wiggins, M, Turner, H, Oakley, A 2004 Evaluating social support and health visiting Comm Pract 77 460 464 Google Scholar Barnett, B, Glossop, P, Matthey, S, Stewart, H 2005 Screening in the context of integrated perinatal care Henshaw, C Elliott, S eds. Screening for perinatal depression Jessica Kingsley Publishers London 68 82 Google Scholar Berle, JØ, Aarre, TF, Mykletun, A, Dahl, AA, Holsten, F 2003 Screening for postnatal depression. Validation of the Norwegian version of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale, and assessment of risk factors for postnatal depression J Affect Disord 76 151 156 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Boyce, P, Stubbs, J, Todd, A 1993 Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale: Validation for an Australian sample Aust N Z J Psychiatry 27 472 476 PubMed Google Scholar Buist, A, Milgrom, J, Morse, C, Durkin, S 2004 Metropolitan regional differences in primary health care of postnatal depression Aust J Adv Nurs 21 20 27 Google Scholar Condon, JT, Boyce, P, Corkindale, CJ 2004 The First-Time Fathers Study: a prospective study of the mental health and wellbeing of men during the transition to parenthood Aust N Z J Psychiatry 38 56 64 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Cox, J Holden, J eds. 1994Perinatal psychiatry: use and misuse of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale The Royal College of Psychiatrists Gaskell, London Google Scholar Cox, J, Holden, J 2003aPerinatal Mental Health: a guide to the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) The Royal College of Psychiatrists Gaskell, London Google Scholar Cox, J, Holden, J 2003b Letter to the Editor: Author’s reply to Matthey et al: The Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale Br J Psychiatry 182 368 CrossRef Google Scholar Cox, J, Holden, J, Sagovsky, R 1987 Detection of postnatal depression: development of the 10 item Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale Br J Psychiatry 150 782 786 PubMed Google Scholar Cubison, J, Munro, J 2005 Acceptability of using a postnatal questionnaire derived from the EPDS as a screening tool for postnatal depression Henshaw, C Elliott, S eds. Screening for perinatal depression Kingsley London 152 161 Google Scholar Davies, BR, Howells, S, Jenkins, M 2003 Early detection and treatment of postnatal depression in primary care J Adv Nurs 44 248 255 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Davis, L, Edwards, H, Mohay, H, Wollin, J 2003 The impact of very premature birth on the psychological health of mothers Early Hum Devel 73 61 70 CrossRef Google Scholar Davis, L, Edwards, H, Mohay, H, Wollin, J 2004 The course of depression in mothers of premature infants in hospital and at home Aust J Adv Nurs 21 20 25 Google Scholar de Tychey, C, Spitz, E, Briancon, S, Lighezzolo, J, Girvan, F, Rosati, A, Thockler, A, Vincent, S 2005 Pre- and postnatal depression and coping: a comparative approach J Affect Disord 85 323 326 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Elliott, SA, Rugg, AJ, Watson, JP, Brough, DI 1983 Mood changes during pregnancy and after the birth of a child Br J Clin Psychol 22 295 308 PubMed Google Scholar Evans, J Heron, J Francombe, H Oke, S Golding, J on behalf of the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children Study Team 2001 Cohort study of depressed mood during pregnancy and after childbirth Br Med J 323 257 260 CrossRef Google Scholar Felice, E, Saliba, J, Grech, V, Cox, J 2006 Validation of the Maltese version of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale Arch Womens Ment Health 9 75 80 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Freeman, MP, Wright, R, Watchman, M, Wahl, RA, Sisk, DJ, Fraleigh, L 2005 Postpartum depression assessments at Well-Baby visits: screening feasibility, prevalence, and risk factors J Womens Health 14 929 935 CrossRef Google Scholar Gerrard, J, Holden, JM, Elliott, SA, McKenzie, P, McKenzie, J, Cox, JL 1993 A trainer’s perspective of an innovative programme teaching health visitors about the detection, treatment and prevention of postnatal depression J Adv Nurs 18 1825 1832 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Gibbon, K 2004 Developments in perinatal mental health assessments Br J Midwifery 12 754 760 Google Scholar Green, JM, Murray, D 1994 The use of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale in research to explore the relationship between antenatal and postnatal dysphoria Cox, J Holden, J eds. Perinatal Psychiatry: use and misuse of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale The Royal College of Psychiatrists Gaskell, London 180 198 Google Scholar Grote, NK, Bledsoe, SE, Swartz, HA, Frank, E 2004 Feasibility of providing culturally relevant, brief interpersonal psychotherapy for antenatal depression in an obstetrics clinic: a pilot study Res Soc Work Pract 14 397 407 CrossRef Google Scholar Guedeney, N, Fermanian, J 1998 Validation study of the French version of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS): new results about use and psychometric properties Eur Psychiatry 13 83 89 CrossRef Google Scholar Harris, B, Huckle, P, Thomas, R, Johns, S, Fung, H 1989 The use of rating scales to identify post-natal depression Br J Psychiatry 154 813 817 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Heron, J O’Connor, TG Evans, J Golding, J Glover, V the ALSPAC Study Team 2004 The course of anxiety and depression through pregnancy and the postpartum in a community sample J Affect Disord 80 65 73 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Holden, J 1994 Using the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale in clinical practice Cox, J Holden, J eds. Perinatal Psychiatry: use and misuse of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale The Royal College of Psychiatrists Gaskell, London 125 144 Google Scholar Inandi, T, Elci, OC, Ozturk, A, Egri, M, Polat, A, Sahin, TK 2002 Risk factors for depression in postnatal first year in eastern Turkey Int J Epidem 31 1201 1207 CrossRef Google Scholar Lee, DTS, Yip, SK, Chiu, HFK, Leung, TYS, Chan, KPM, Chau, IOL, Leung, HCM, Chung, TKH 1998 Detecting postnatal depression in Chinese women Br J Psychiatry 172 433 437 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Letourneau, N 2001 Improving adolescent parent-infant interactions: a pilot study J Ped Nurs 16 53 62 CrossRef Google Scholar Leung, SSK, Martinson, IM, Arthur, D 2005 Postpartum depression and related psychosocial variables in Hong Kong Chinese women: findings from a prospective study Res Nurs Health 28 27 38 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Matthey, S, Barnett, B 1997 Translation and validation of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale into Vietnamese and Arabic Ferguson, B Barnes, D eds. Perspective on transcultural mental health Transcultural Mental Health Centre Sydney 77 84 Google Scholar Matthey, S, Barnett, B, Howie, P, Kavanagh, DJ 2003 Diagnosing postpartum depression in mothers and fathers: whatever happened to anxiety? J Affect Disord 74 139 147 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Matthey, S, Barnett, BEW, Kavanagh, DJ, Howie, P 2001 Validation of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale for men, and comparison of item endorsement with their partners J Affect Disord 64 175 183 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Matthey, S, Kavanagh, DJ, Howie, P, Barnett, B, Charles, M 2004 Prevention of postnatal distress or depression: an evaluation of an intervention at preparation for parenthood classes J Affect Disord 79 113 126 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Misri, S, Kostaras, X, Fox, D, Kostaras, D 2000 The impact of partner support in the treatment of postpartum depression Can J Psychiatry 45 554 558 PubMed Google Scholar Murray, D, Cox, JL 1990 Screening for depression during pregnancy with the Edinburgh Depression Scale (EPDS) J Reprod Infant Psychol 8 99 107 Google Scholar Murray, L, Carothers, AD 1990 The validation of the Edinburgh Post-natal Depression Scale on a community sample Br J Psychiatry 157 288 290 PubMed Google Scholar Muzik, M, Klier, CM, Rosenblum, KL, Holzinger, A, Umek, W, Katschnig, H 2000 Are commonly used self-report inventories suitable for screening postpartum depression and anxiety disorders? Acta Psychiatr Scand 102 71 73 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar O’Brien, LM, Heycock, EG, Hanna, M, Jones, PW, Cox, JL 2004 Postnatal depression and faltering growth: a community study Pediatrics 113 1242 1247 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar O’Hara, MW, Swain, AM 1996 Rates and risk of postpartum depression – a meta-analysis Int Rev Psychiatry 8 37 54 Google Scholar Onozawa, K, Kumar, RC, Adams, D, Dore, C, Glover, V 2003 High EPDS scores in women from ethnic minorities living in London Arch Womens Ment Health 6 s51 s55 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Ross, LE, Sellers, EM, Evans, SEG, Romach, MK 2004 Mood changes during pregnancy and the postpartum period: development of a biopsychosocial model Acta Psychiatr Scand 109 457 466 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar
Sanderson C (1995) Notes for Sheffield Health Visitors about screening for postnatal depression. Department of Community Paediatrics, Sheffield Children’s Hospital.
Google Scholar Sanderson, CA, Cowden, B, Hall, DMB, Taylor, EM, Carpenter, RG, Cox, JL 2002 “Is postnatal depression a risk factor for sudden infant death?” Br J Gen Pract 52 636 640 PubMed Google Scholar Small, R, Lumley, J, Yelland, J 2003 How useful is the concept of somatization in cross-cultural studies of maternal depression? A contribution from the Mothers in a New Country (MINC) study J Psychosom Obstet Gynecol 24 45 52 Google Scholar Suri, R, Burt, VK, Altshuler, LL, Zuckerbrow-Miller, J, Fairbanks, L 2001 Fluoxamine for postpartum depression (letter to the Editor) Am J Psychiatry 158 1739 1740 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Watt, S, Sword, W, Krueger, P, Sheehan, D 2002 A cross-sectional study of early identification of postpartum depression: implications for primary care providers from The Ontario Mother and Infant Survey BMC Family Practice 3 5 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Wickberg, B, Hwang, CP 1996 The Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale: validation on a Swedish community sample Acta Psychiatr Scand 94 181 184 PubMed Google Scholar