Recognition of six additional cystoviruses: Pseudomonas virus phi6 is no longer the sole species of the family Cystoviridae
- 1.1k Downloads
Cystoviridae is a family of bacterial viruses (bacteriophages) with a tri-segmented dsRNA genome. It includes a single genus Cystovirus, which has presently only one recognised virus species, Pseudomonas virus phi6. However, a large number of additional dsRNA phages have been isolated from various environmental samples, indicating that such viruses are more widespread and abundant than previously recognised. Six of the additional dsRNA phage isolates (Pseudomonas phages phi8, phi12, phi13, phi2954, phiNN and phiYY) have been fully sequenced. They all infect Pseudomonas species, primarily plant pathogenic Pseudomonas syringae strains. Due to the notable genetic and structural similarities with Pseudomonas phage phi6, we propose that these viruses should be included into the Cystovirus genus (and consequently into the Cystoviridae family). Here, we present an updated taxonomy of the family Cystoviridae and give a short overview of the properties of the type member phi6 as well as the putative new members of the family.
DsRNA viruses represent a remarkably diverse group of biological entities, infecting organisms in all three domains of life. Nine distinct dsRNA virus families (Amalgaviridae, Birnaviridae, Chrysoviridae, Cystoviridae, Endornaviridae, Partitiviridae, Picobirnaviridae, Reoviridae and Totiviridae) are currently recognised by the International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses (ICTV). These viruses vary in terms of host specificity (ranging from bacteria to humans), number of genome segments (one to twelve) and virion organization (varying numbers of capsid layers with different triangulation (T) numbers). However, the majority of the dsRNA viruses share certain fundamental structural and functional features. These similarities reflect the challenges viruses face replicating their dsRNA genomes, while simultaneously avoiding dsRNA-triggered antiviral defense mechanisms of their host organisms . DsRNA viruses overcome these challenges by delivering their genomes into the host cell within specialized icosahedral capsids, containing enzymatic activity for RNA metabolism. These multifunctional nanocompartments carry out replication and transcription as well as protect the dsRNA genome from antiviral responses . Probably due to these common functional requirements, the innermost capsids are highly conserved among most of the dsRNA viruses. They consist of 120 protein subunits arranged as 60 asymmetric dimers on a T=1 icosahedral lattice. Moreover, in most cases, the protein subunits in the capsid possess a similar fold, despite the lack of significant sequence similarity [3, 4]. This icosahedral protein shell encloses the segmented dsRNA genome and several copies of the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRP). Additional capsid shells, typically arranged on T=13 icosahedral lattice, may reside on top of the inner core particle. These external layers facilitate interaction with the host, and thereby show greater diversity between dsRNA virus families .
Proposed members of the revised Cystoviridae family
GenBank accession number (L, M and S segments)
Pseudomonas virus phi6 (type species)
M17461, M17462, M12921
P. syringae pv. phaseolicola HB10Y
Phaseolus vulgaris (bean)
Pseudomonas virus phi8
AF226851, AF226852, AF226853
P. syringae pv. phaseolicola LM2333
Pisum sativum (pea)
Pseudomonas virus phi12
AF408636, AY039807, AY034425
P. syringae pv. phaseolicola LM2333
Ocimum basilicum (bacil)
Pseudomonas virus phi13
AF261668, AF261667, AF261666
P. syringae pv. phaseolicola LM2333
Raphanus sativum (radish)
Pseudomonas virus phi2954
FJ608823, FJ608824, FJ608825
P. syringae pv. phaseolicola LM2489
Pseudomonas virus phiNN
KJ957164, KJ957165, KJ957166
P. sp. B314
Pseudomonas virus phiYY
KX074201, KX074202, KX074203
P. aeruginosa PAO38
Extended Cystoviridae family includes seven viruses
Since the late 1990’s, dsRNA phages have been readily isolated from environmental samples, indicating that the members of the Cystoviridae are far more widespread and abundant than has been previously acknowledged [6, 7, 8, 13, 14, 15]. The complete nucleotide sequences of six of these phage isolates (Pseudomonas phages phi8, phi12, phi13, phi2954, phiNN and phiYY) have been determined to date [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15]. Similarly to phi6, phages phi8, phi12, phi13 and phi2954 were isolated from bacteria-infested legumes in the USA [8, 13]. They all infect hosts belonging to genus Pseudomonas, most commonly plant pathogenic Pseudomonas syringae strains. However, this limited host range likely reflects the somewhat biased isolation method, in which the host strain of phi6, Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola HB10Y (or one of its mutants), was used in enrichment. Interestingly, a number of additional dsRNA virus isolates have been obtained by sampling from clovers and green beans at various locations in the USA [6, 7]. These virus isolates have been partially sequenced but not otherwise characterized. Nevertheless, the high frequency of dsRNA phages in these environmental samples suggests that this virus type is a common bacterial parasite in certain terrestrial habitats .
The most recent dsRNA phage isolations were reported in Europe and Asia from diverse environmental sources: Pseudomonas phage phiNN was isolated contemporarily with its host bacterial strain Pseudomonas sp. B314 from a fresh water sample in Finland , whereas the isolation source of Pseudomonas phage phiYY was hospital sewage in China . PhiYY was isolated together with Pseudomonas aeruginosa strain PAO38, and it also infects several other clinical strains of P. aeruginosa . P. aeruginosa is an opportunistic human pathogen, which causes serious infections in immune-compromised individuals. These recent discoveries demonstrate, that dsRNA phages have adapted to varying habitats in globally distant locations.
The dsRNA phages described above share genetic and structural characteristics (overall virion morphology, genome type and genome organization) with phage phi6, the prototype virus of the Cystoviridae. These features clearly distinguish them from other viruses and demonstrate their relatedness. Consequently, they should be included into the Cystoviridae family.
Cystoviruses have one or two icosahedral protein shells surrounded by an envelope
The virion organization of the proposed members of the Cystoviridae, if described, resembles that of the type species. The virions are enveloped and the tri-segmented genome is enclosed in one or two concentric, icosahedrally symmetric protein shells [16, 17]. Studies on phi6 have revealed that the innermost protein shell of the virion, also referred to as the polymerase complex (PC), is composed of the major capsid protein (MCP) P1, the RdRP P2, the packaging NTPase P4 and the minor protein P7 . The structural framework of the PC consists of 60 asymmetric dimers of the MCP P1 arranged into T=1 architecture, characteristic of dsRNA viruses [19, 20].
The second protein layer, or the nucleocapsid (NC) shell, of the phi6 virion is constituted by 200 trimers of protein P8 on a T=13 icosahedral lattice [18, 19, 20]. The near-atomic structure of the phi6 NC shell has been recently solved . Interestingly, phage phi8 is lacking this NC shell, and therefore has a single protein shell surrounding the genome .
The outermost layer of cystoviruses is a lipid envelope, containing host-derived phospholipids  and phage-encoded membrane proteins . Host binding spikes, composed of protein P3, protrude from the virion surface . Spike proteins differ between cystoviruses, resulting in varying host specificities [25, 26, 27].
Genome organizations of cystoviruses are highly similar
Nucleotide sequence similarities (%) between the cystoviral genome segments. Color code: > 95% = dark grey, > 75% = medium grey, > 50% = light grey
A moderate level of amino acid sequence similarity is seen among the proposed cystoviruses between the major structural proteins and essential enzymes, which are encoded by the L- and S-segments (Fig. 1). For instance, when comparing phages phi6 and phiNN, the protein products of the S- and L-segment are almost identical (89 – 99% amino acid sequence similarity; Fig. 1a,c), whereas more diversity is seen between the corresponding proteins of the M-segments (41 – 70% amino acid sequence similarity; Fig. 1b; ). This higher genetic flexibility in the M-segment, encoding the host recognition complex, may reflect the evolutionary pressure to broaden the host range and adapt to new habitats . Interestingly though, 36 – 85% amino acid sequence similarity can be detected between the corresponding putative host recognition proteins of phages phiYY, phi12 and phi13, despite their taxonomically distant host bacteria (phiYY infects human pathogen P. aeruginosa, whereas phi12 and phi13 infect plant pathogen P. syringae).
Cystoviruses have lytic life cycles
All the proposed members of the Cystoviridae are virulent viruses, which induce lysis of their bacterial host cells at the end of viral reproduction cycle. However, it has been shown, that phage phi6, the type member of the Cystoviridae, may also establish a carrier state in the host bacterium [31, 32, 33]. Different stages of the infection cycle have been described comprehensively for phi6. Upon infection, the phi6 virion adsorbs to type IV pilus on bacterial cell surface [34, 35]. As the pilus retracts, the virion is brought into contact with the bacterial outer membrane. Phages phiNN and phi2954 also use this type IV pilus-mediated infection strategy [13, 14], whereas phages phi8, phi12 and phi13 bind the host cell directly through rough LPS on the cell surface . In each case, P3 protein complex is required for the initial binding to the host bacterium [9, 10, 12, 13, 14, 29, 34]. It has been suggested, that the P3 protein complex consists of a single polypeptide or its multimer in phages phi6, phi2954 and phiNN [13, 14, 29], whereas in phages phi8, phi12, phi13 and phiYY the P3 complex is heteromeric, containing two or three different polypeptides (P3a, P3b, P3c) [9, 10, 12, 15]. The P3 protein of phi6 is anchored to the viral membrane via phage membrane protein P6. P6 protein mediates the fusion between the viral envelope and bacterial outer membrane, ultimately releasing the NC into the periplasmic space .
The removal of the viral membrane from the NC releases the lytic enzyme P5, which then digests the host peptidoglycan layer [37, 38]. The rupturing of the peptidoglycan layer enables the NC to reach the cytoplasmic membrane. The NC penetrates the cytoplasmic membrane using endocytic-like mechanism . The NC outer shell (formed by P8) dissociates in the cytoplasm, revealing the PC [40, 41]. This activates the virion-associated RdRP, which then launches viral transcription within the PC . Semi-conservative transcription produces full-length, polycistronic mRNA molecules of the genome segments . At the first phase of the infection, approximately equal amounts of transcripts are produced from each genome segment [44, 45]. However, only the transcripts of the L-segment are efficiently produced, which leads to the accumulation of PC proteins and, consequently, to the formation of empty PCs. The packaging NTPase P4 translocates one copy of each type of genome segment transcripts inside the newly synthesized empty PCs [46, 47]. The transcripts are packaged, based on the 5′ terminal packaging signals, in the order S, M and L. The packaging triggers the negative-strand synthesis within the PC, ultimately resulting in mature, double-stranded forms of all three genome segments . After the replication, the plus-strand synthesis is again switched on. During this late phase of infection, transcription of the S- and M-segments predominates [44, 45]. This leads to the production of proteins needed in virion assembly. The NC shell assembles around the PC [40, 48], after which viral membrane, derived from the host cytoplasmic membrane, encloses the NC . Finally P3 spikes are attached onto the virion surface resulting in mature virion structure. Lytic enzyme P5 and membrane protein P10 mediate the lysis of the host cell, ultimately releasing the newly synthesized virions into the environment [37, 38].
Taxonomic structure of the cystoviruses
Despite the fact, that the identified dsRNA phages commonly share a relatively low degree of nucleotide sequence identity (< 50%, except for phi6 and phiNN; Table 2), their overall virion structures (one or two icosahedral capsids, enclosed by a lipid envelope) and genome characteristics (genome type and size, GC content, genome organization and gene synteny) are strikingly similar. They undoubtedly belong to the Cystoviridae family. We have proposed 95% nucleotide sequence identity as the criterion for demarcation of species in the Cystoviridae family. This initial criterion may be adjusted when new cystovirus isolates are described. Based on the current criteria the members of each of the proposed species should differ from those of other species by more than 5% at the nucleotide sequence level. Consequently, Pseudomonas phages phi8, phi12, phi13, phi2954, phiNN and phiYY should be included into the Cystoviridae family as distinct species (Table 1).
The phylogenetic analyses indicate close relationship between the type member of the genus Cystovirus (Pseudomonas virus phi6) and one of the proposed new species, Pseudomonas virus phiNN, whereas the other proposed species are more distantly related (Fig. 2). Furthermore, the three genome segments of these isolates apparently have distinct evolutionary histories (due to frequent genome segment reassortments). These viruses clearly belong to the Cystoviridae family, but due to the low number of isolates it is difficult to clarify the taxonomic structure within the family. Therefore we propose that all the new species belong to the same genus, Cystovirus.
The authors acknowledge Professor Dennis Bamford who has contributed to the description of the Cystoviridae family in the previous ICTV Reports.
Compliance with ethical standards
The taxonomic changes suggested here have not been endorsed by the ICTV Executive Committee, may differ from any new taxonomy that is ultimately approved by the ICTV, and are presented for discussion only but have no official standing. This article is related to an ongoing taxonomic proposal (2017.016B.U.v1.Cystovirus_6sp.zip), submitted to the ICTV but not yet accepted at the time of submission. M.M.P is the Chair of the Cystoviridae Study Group of the ICTV Bacterial and Archaeal Viruses Subcommittee.
This study was funded by the Finnish Centre of Excellence Program of the Academy of Finland; the CoE in Biological Interactions 2012–2017 (#252411), Academy of Finland grants #272507 (M.M.P.) and #266879 (L-R.S.), Sigrid Juselius Foundation (M.M.P.) and by Jane and Aatos Erkko Foundation (L-R.S.).
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
The article does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors.
- 30.Mindich L, Nemhauser I, Gottlieb P, Romantschuk M, Carton J, Frucht S, Strassman J, Bamford DH, Kalkkinen N (1988) Nucleotide sequence of the large double-stranded RNA segment of bacteriophage phi6: genes specifying the viral replicase and transcriptase. J Virol 62:1180–1185PubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar