Analysis of standard multiport versus single-site access for laparoscopic skills training
- 133 Downloads
Single-site-access (SSA) laparoscopy is more challenging to perform than multiport (MP) laparoscopy. This study examined the effect of MP versus SSA skills training on laparoscopic performance using surgically naive medical students.
For the study, 40 medical students at the end of their first year were randomized into two groups. Both groups were trained in four basic laparoscopic drills (peg, rope, bean drop, pattern cutting) using a standard MP setup (group 1) and an SSA approach (group 2). The time and number of repetitions required to attain proficiency were recorded. Each group then crossed over to the alternate approach and repeated the sequence. Data are presented as mean ± standard deviation, and statistical analysis was performed using the two-tailed, unpaired t test.
The total times required to attain proficiency for the SSA and MP approaches were not significantly different between the MP-trained group (234.0 ± 114.9 min) and the SSA-trained group (216.4 ± 106.5 min) (p = 0.67). The MP-trained group required less time to reach proficiency on the standard MP setup than the group using the SSA approach (119.1 ± 69.7 vs. 178.0 ± 93.4 min; p = 0.058) and significantly fewer repetitions (77.6 ± 42.6 vs. 118.8 ± 54.3; p = 0.027). The SSA-trained group required significantly less time to reach proficiency on the MP setup than the standard MP-trained group (38.4 ± 29.4 vs. 119.1 ± 69.7 min; p = 0.0013) and needed only a mean of 26.9 repetitions. When the standard MP trainees crossed over to the SSA setup, they required significantly less time to reach proficiency with the SSA approach than the SSA-trained group (114.8 ± 50.5 vs. 178.0 ± 93.4 min; p = 0.026) but required more repetitions than with the MP approach (86.2 ± 35.2 vs. 77.6 ± 42.6; nonsignificant difference).
Laparoscopic SSA skills training results in longer times and more repetitions to achieve proficiency than MP training, but the skills acquired transfer well to the MP approach.
KeywordsLaparoscopic skills training Multiport laparoscopy Single-site access
The authors acknowledge the Washington University Institute for Minimally Invasive Surgery for support of this study. Daniel Cox was supported by T35 DK074375.
Michael Brunt had educational grant support from Ethicon Endosurgery, Inc., educational grant support and equipment support from Karl Storz Endoscopy and Stryker Endoscopy, grant and research support from Lifecell Corp., and honoraria for speaking and teaching from Ethicon Endosurgery, Covidien, and Cook Medical. None of these disclosures are related to the content of this study, which was conducted in a completely independent manner and free of industry funding.
Conflict of interest
Daniel R. Cox, Wenjing Zeng, and Margaret M. Frisella have no conflicts of interest or financial ties to disclose.
- 2.Vidal O, Valentini M, Ginestà C, Martí J, Espert JJ, Benarroch G, García-Valdecasas JC (2009) Laparoendoscopic single-site surgery appendectomy. Surg Endosc [Epub ahead of print 19 August]Google Scholar
- 4.Nguyen NT, Slone J, Reavis K (2009) Comparison study of conventional laparoscopic gastric banding versus laparoendoscopic single site gastric banding. Surg Obes Relat Dis [Epub ahead of print 10 November]Google Scholar
- 5.Canes D, Berger A, Aron M, Brandina R, Goldfarb DA, Shoskes D, Desai MM, Gill IS (2009) Laparo endoscopic single site (LESS) versus standard laparoscopic left donor nephrectomy: matched-pair comparison. Eur Urol [Epub ahead of print 28 July]Google Scholar
- 7.Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons (2010) Fundamentals of laparoscopic surgery (FLS) program. Retrieved 7 March 2010, http://flsprogram.org
- 9.ACS/APDS Surgical Skills Curriculum for Residents, Phase 1: Module 17 Basic Laparoscopic Skills. Retrieved xxxx at http://elearning.facs.org/login/index.php
- 10.Mac Donald E, Pringle K, Ahmed I (2009) Single port laparoscopic repair of incarcerated ventral hernia. Hernia [Epub ahead of print]Google Scholar
- 11.Jacob BP, Tong W, Reiner M, Vine A, Katz LB (2009) Single-incision total extraperitoneal (one-site) laparoscopic inguinal hernia. Hernia 13:571–572Google Scholar
- 13.Rawlings A, Hodgett SE, Matthews BD, Strasberg SM, Quasebarth M, Brunt LM (2010) Single-incision laparoscopic cholecystectomy: initial experience with critical view of safety dissection and routine intraoperative cholangiography. JACSGoogle Scholar